I really wanted to like this place. Small-town pizza places often have a certain charm, but…read moreunfortunately, my experience here left me disappointed and honestly a little uncomfortable. The food itself was less than mediocre. The pizza lacked flavor and the crust was tough, like it had been sitting too long. It's hard to enjoy a meal when it doesn't even feel like it was made with care. I do want to give some grace to the younger guys working behind the counter--they seemed new, maybe still learning the ropes, and I don't want to fault them for that. Everyone has to start somewhere. But what really soured the whole experience was the man who brought out our pizzas. He was an Italian guy with a big black beard, and he was incredibly rude from the moment he walked up. He stared us down like we were inconveniencing him just by being there. When he brought out our food, he said, "Alright, where do you want these pizzas? Anywhere? I'll tell you what, I'll put them on this table," and just plopped them down without giving us a second to answer. It felt dismissive and almost hostile, and it left everyone at our table feeling uncomfortable. I don't usually leave negative reviews, but the combination of mediocre food and that kind of attitude just left a bad taste in my mouth--literally and figuratively. I hope this place can improve because Olivet could really use a great pizza spot, but I won't be coming back anytime soon.

Eh. Pizzas were large but still a little doughy, thick, and pricey. The pizza will fill your…read morestomach but I'm not sure if I will give it another go in future.

The most delicious super greasy pepperoni rolls. Dripping with cheese and grease. Find coupons…read more Cheap food. Pizza kind of sucks but hits the spot at midnight. Get extra sauce these people so cheap they don't hardly put sauce on pizza. Bootleg nasty pizza. 5 stars

Mediocre pizza. That's as complimentary as I can be. Over priced…read more For a so so product.

The service was prompt from placing the order to receiving my pizza. Although I said box it because…read moreI was taking most but eating a little before leaving - they offered plates and everything else I needed to dine in also. The topping were edge to edge and generous compared to what I have received at places in larger markets. Would return if in the area again. Slicing was party as opposed to wedge which worked out perfectly for eating small pieces.

Probably the most tasteless, dry pizza I've ever had. Cheese had absolutely no flavor, I'm…read morethinking perhaps imitation cheese. Breadsticks weren't much better unless you dipped them in the garlic oil that they were sitting on but that makes your stomach hurt afterwards!. Disappointed, used to be good pizza

Unique food menu with indoor and outdoor seating. Great service, quick kitchen during my recent…read morelunchtime trip.

Went for takeout, had a beer, declined another. Asked several more times if i wanted another,…read morefinally got frustrated and said no, for the fourth fucking time. Food was horrible, like cafeteria or military barracks food. $12 burger was shitty frozen patty worse than McDonalds, mac and cheese was not macaroni, the pizza was terrible, the spinach and artichoke dip advertisedto be served in a bread bowl was just poured on a sliced chabata roll, and the streetfighter chicken is just a shitty pad thai without the peanuts. The only thing halfway decent was the side with my burger, the waffle fries were ok... Bottom line, probably not going back there, even though we live in town..

Haven't had a bad pizza since I began ordering from them. I drive from Lansing or when I visit my…read morefamily in Tompkins twp.

Great pizza and subs. The place is a gem in onondaga breakfast pizza is best in lansingread more

Very disappointed and frustrated. We ordered two meat lasagna dinners on line with a pickup time…read moreof 6:13. I arrived at that time to find out they were just working on my order and it would be 5 more minutes. 15 minutes I'm still standing near the counter. They could have at least apologized and offer me a complimentary fountain drink and invite me to sit at a table in their nice dining area while waiting and bring my take out to me when it was ready. Very short on hospitality here. When we got back to the farm, the pieces of meat that they put on top of the lasagna were like hard pieces of charcoal. The garlic bread was missing the garlic and butter. Just toasted bread.

The best pizza - it's thin crust but still has great flavor, soft but also crunchy! The staff was…read moresuper helpful and they sell alcohol too. Definitely a place to stop for food!

What a nice little surprise. While out antiquing, we decided to stop for lunch. $9.99 Ayce pizza…read moreand salad bar. What a deal! Five different salads, all homemade along with a great selection of toppings for your lettuce salad. Five different pizzas to choose from and maple cinnamon bites for dessert. I highly recommend a stop when visiting Lake Odessa!

Excellent service and delicious pepperoni pizza! Our entire family loved it. We got it to go.read more

ordering online was easy, they had it prepared and delivered promptly…read more Over all the pizza was good, though they misread my 'special instructions" I feel. I requested 'extra crispy crust", and I got extra cheese instead.

Great sauce and lots of cheese. Toppings are fresh and they are generous. …read more . .....

The food was pretty good, I love the ranch, we got the everything pizza which like usually was…read moreYumm. The service was fast, we online ordered and picked up. The surrounding inside was filled with a nice vibe, overall a pretty good place to go

Ordering was easy. Fast service. Got 2 pizzas, 1 pepperoni…read moreand 1 Hawaiian. Both were extremely greasy. Dripping grease and your hands got covered just holding the crust. Grandkids took a few bites and refused to eat any more of it. 6 year old said it was disgusting. (and he is the big pizza lover) First time we got pizza from them, doubt we will go back. Pretty bad when you send a free pizza coupon to people who just moved in the area and you lose a potential customer.

We had the meatsa pizza . It was delicious. They notify you just about the time it is to come out…read moreof the oven. Personally, my wife and I like ours a cooked a bit longer. But that is a personal preference. A good value

Terrible service, and the owner was extremely rude. I asked about a gluten-free pizza and the owner…read moreproceeded to make fun and make rude comments while I waited for my food.