A family member of mine brought cookies from this bakery, and I was absolutely blown away at how…read moretheir raspberry jam filling in their sprinkle dipped cookies was so potent and delicious. Their cookies have a beautiful zest and kick to it, unlike other bakeries where you get cookies and you really just don't taste much. I would definitely come back here and ask them to make a cake for me. It was delicious!

This bakery was a staple in the area. Since the new owners took over, quality is way down. The…read morehazelnut cookies (formerly my fave) are now inedible. I asked for certain Italian pastries. The Chinese girl working the counter did not know what I was talking about. Won't be back.

Delicious desserts...every one of them. Not your ordinary! Love their merengue Success Cake!…read more Have been going to them for years and never disappointed. Also, extremely accomadating!

Absolutely fabulous bakery!!! Delicious cakes and brownies and apple tarts and cookies. So fresh…read moreand tasty! Jennifer is the most lovely person and was completely helpful and so incredibly nice. We will be back for sure- best bakery and it's worth the drive from Port Washington.

Love the new aesthetic after they updated the place. Love their almond croissants and a few of…read moretheir drinks! I live 40 minutes away and would drive out here sometimes for them. If you like sweet drinks, the iced Tres Lattes latte is one of the best drinks I ever had ( though it is made differently by different workers and will change if I like the drink or not). The summer coconut cold foam latte and Nutella hot Chocolate are delicious too!

We ordered a Tres Leches cake for my mom's birthday as she requested. Everyone really enjoyed the…read morecake! However, I was a bit disappointed because I expected fruit on top, but it was only included inside the cake. The pickup service was fast, though the ordering process was a bit difficult. I called on Thursday to place the order, but the woman who answered told me she couldn't take it and that I had to speak specifically to Diego on Friday. Diego took my order. I assumed all tres leches cake have fruit at the top. Diego didn't ask either so it could have just been a miscommunication The store itself was very clean. Compramos un pastel de tres leches para mi mamá porque ella lo pidió. A todos les gustó mucho el pastel, sin embargo, pensé que tendría fruta por fuera (encima); solo traía fruta por dentro. El servicio fue rápido cuando fui a recogerlo. Llamé el jueves para hacer el pedido, pero la señora que me atendió dijo que no podía tomarlo y que tenía que hablar con Diego el viernes. Diego no me preguntó nada de la Fruita encima del pastel. Yo pensé que todos los pasteles de tres leches eran así. La tienda estaba limpia.

Need to start this off with the staff... Phenomenal. The two…read moreladies that were there yesterday were so kind and helpful. Ambiance was super chill. Loved the lighting & decor. We stayed and had some delicious gelato. Our son had a yummy piece of cake. We will definitely come back here & I highly recommend you checking it out. I'm thinking of buying my son's bday cake from them in August. Two thumbs all the way up!

I go here to get the Chocolate Mousse Cake for all parties and events that I go to. Everyone that…read moretastes this cake loves it. Been going here for long time, I just never wrote this review. I'd definitely recommend this place for their good cakes.

I made a stop at this bakeshop after doing my shopping at this neighborhood. Cute little spot. It…read morehas a small dining area. I believe it is more popular for take outs, I see in and out traffic. I enjoyed looking on its displays specially of their fruit designed pastries. A unique presentation of each flavor. It's quite a pricey item but worth the try. Cakes on display cabinet has better pricing than my regular bakeshop. I may try to get one on my next visit and make a comparison if worth getting. So far, I enjoyed my visit here.

What a beautiful array of holiday pastries. These things look amazing and the taste was pretty…read moregood. These Mango one had little bits of mango in the center and that was a surprise and a pleasant one for some. The staff here is friendly and know their pastries so they can help you with any questions. The place itself is nice and cozy as well.

I tried this place for the first time and their cannoli was amazing!…read more They had so much varieties of pastries that it was hard to decide, but I decided to try their chocolate covered cannoli and their mini cream puffs (tiramisu and regular cream). All tasted really good, especially the cannoli! Their cannoli cream is not too sweet, just perfect! The cream puffs were good too! I definitely want to try other ones as well! They also had cakes, cookies and more and the price was great too! The large cannoli was $5 and the cream puffs were $16 per pound (I paid around $2 for two cream puffs). This place is small so you can take out and try! I'll definitely come back for cannoli and other pastries!!

I bought a Cannoli cake. It was specially made to exclude rum for religious reasons. They were very…read moreaccommodating and the cake still tasted amazing! It has a unique nutty and lemon zesty flavor that perfectly balanced out the creaminess so that the sweetness wasn't too overwhelming.

Quality has gone down while prices have gone up. Polito Bakery had been my go-to local bakery for…read moremany years. I try to support local businesses over retail chains, but I believe the quality of their food has declined since the pandemic while their prices have risen significantly. Today is the first time I felt uncomfortable after eating one of their apple turnovers. It was large but over fried, tasting more like a treat you would find at a carnival food truck rather than a reputable local bakery. The ambiance has always been quaint. When I came here to purchase a cookie gift basket for a recent holiday, however, it was half the size from previous years and double the price. I'm also not pleased that you can't use a credit card unless you're making a $10 purchase, and they still charge a fee unless you pay cash. With the high prices they're now charging, over $20 for a pound of butter cookies, management would be wise to ensure their baked goods are cooked to perfection rather than expediently to fill up the display case. Not happy with this recent visit. I may return, but only in a pinch.

Thank you for making my son's grad cake! His favorite...red velvet. It was moist and delicious…read more Everyone loved it!! Thanks again!

The other day I had a total cake catastrophe. It was my 4-year-old's birthday, and the original…read morecake didn't survive the car ride home. With only one hour until the party started, I was in a total panic. I called Sapienza to see if there was any way to save the day. Even though the original couldn't be fixed, their incredible team completely jumped into action. They managed to put together a beautiful new cake similar to the original design just in time. They truly made the best out of a stressful situation and saved my son's birthday!

6/21/26. I snagged the last small cheesecake early in the morning ($33.60). The girls at the…read morecounter were friendly enough. Unfortunately, I was disappointed with the cake. It was dry, crumbly and oddly tasted like lemon. One and done. FYI- If you pay cash, you get a 5% discount.