Appetizer we had their baked Bri which was new in their menu. Wasn't big, max 2 people could share. Unique flavor. If you are looking for something different this is it. Cesar salads are big! My husband and I could have shared. Very good though. Would love some large chunks for Parmesan on here, would add to it. Entrees we ordered their boneless ribeye with broccolini and Cabernet sauce. The sauce I could drink, was so good! My husband ordered their dry aged large bone ribeye, was a bit too tender for either of us. He did like the lobster Mac which he ordered for the side Dessert was their lemon cake. Not to sweet but had a zing to it. Was okay. read more

See all

We visit Three Fires Steakhouse for special occasions. We were celebrating our anniversary and looking forward to fine dining. Arrived at 6pm, ordered cocktails and reviewed the menu. Placed our order by 6:10pm, then waited 45 minutes for our main entrees. My husband's 12 oz NY strip steak, which included shallot for $54, was room temperature when served. There was no shallot on his plate. He mentioned the temperature to the waitstaff. At least the side of mashed potatoes for $9 was warm. Because I didn't like the non-beef choices on the menu, I ordered a Sunflower salad, the jumbo shrimp cocktail and crab cakes which are listed as starters but I asked for them as my main entree. I received my salad within a reasonable amount of time, but waited the 45 minutes for my main entree to be delivered. I always laugh when Kansas menus say "jumbo" in their description of a shrimp cocktail, but the shrimp on this cocktail were indeed jumbo. They were large enough to make any shrimper, from the south Texas coastline, proud. The crabcakes were tasty and served hot. My guess is that my husband's steak sat for a long time before my crabcakes were cooked. We believe the issue of delayed service was due to a very large group being served in the dining room to the east of the Three Fires main dining room. Our waitstaff was also waitstaff for the group in this dining room. Consequently, all of the attention went to this group and only occasionally to our table. We watched as food was carried from the open kitchen into the secondary dining room. We waited for our food to be served and never received an offer to replenish our water glasses. My husband requested coffee, but it was never served. We finished our meals and waited 25+ minutes for anyone to notice. When the waitress brought the bill she remembered the coffee. My husband told her to forget the coffee and asked for boxes for our leftovers. When my husband requested the to-go boxes, our waitress remembered that I had said I would be ordering dessert when she first greeted us at our table. She asked me what dessert I wanted. I told her to forget it, we were ready to leave. When she returned with the boxes, she offered warm bread pudding to-go "since it was our anniversary." We said sure, but I am fairly certain that it was her attempt to minimize the lackluster service. She left our bill at the table before bringing the to-go boxes or our "complimentary" bread pudding. There was no itemized coffee or dessert on the bill which obviously had been printed before she remembered the coffee or to ask for the dessert. We won't be back ~ at least for quite a long time. Food quality was poor in comparison to previous visits. The smell of cigarette smoke permeated the dining room. Service was good but unacceptable slow for a great dining experience. They were unprepared for serving the main restaurant along with the large group in the second dining room. For a Friday evening between 6pm and 7:30pm, there were many empty tables. Perhaps now we know why. read more

Little man loves it! The complimentary bread was delicious. He loved the Caesar salad so much that he didn't want to share! He loved the lobster tail and asparagus. I loved my boneless ribeye and the asparagus. It was so much food that we saved the loaded potato for a different day. The Creme Brûlée was a big hit! read more

Three Fires Steakhouse - Crème Brûlée - Steakhouses Near Me - Mayetta, Kansas

See all

We had steaks! Service by our server Sienna was wonderful and she helped us with recommendations that were exactly what we wanted. Hubby had a NY strip steak and I had a filet mignon - we split the bacon blue cheese salad and split the lobster Mac and cheese side dish. Ended with crème brûlée which was also delish. read more

As mentioned in the Resort Review - the diner choices at the Three Fires Steakhouse was very good. The service staff was so courteous - and the warm bread delivered to the table was so good we could not finish our food. Very standard decorations for a steakhouse good selection of cocktails and wines for my winos. We will most certainly return. Thanks to Madi/Rey and everyone in the kitchen staff. read more

See all

Reducing my rating today. We waited 20 minutes for food and it was NOT busy. The tacos were cold. There was a kid taking all of the sauce bottles from tAbles and so as king the lids. While I appreciate the need to clean, we still want to have sauce in the table. This is the second time this has happened. So am starting to see trend here. Customers are not a priority here anymore. Hope management sees this and fixes things. By the way - even cold the tacos are still delicious read more

Three Fires Steakhouse - Stuffed mushrooms - Steakhouses Near Me - Mayetta, Kansas

Returned for our second Valentine's Day visit. My husband and I split the prime rib, a baked potato, roasted wild mushrooms, and calamari with shishito peppers. The prime rib was decent in size but under seasoned, which is fixable with a little table salt. Mushrooms were delicious, cooked in plenty of garlic and butter. The baked potato came fully loaded and was MASSIVE. And finally, the calamari was the star of the show. Perfectly fried and light, the shishitos seemed to be brined and had a nice little vinegary kick that cuts through the grease. The batter was also well seasoned and did not over power the squid. Great dinner, we plan on returning again read more

Three Fires Steakhouse - Slow Roasted Prime Rib -Roasted Wild Mushrooms, Fried Calamari, Loaded Baked Potato - Steakhouses Near Me - Mayetta, Kansas

Amazing Valentines meal at Three Fires steakhouse. The sea bass was amazing, service was very good. Fantastic special menu with a lot of goodies read more

Three Fires Steakhouse - Desert sampler very yummy - Steakhouses Near Me - Mayetta, Kansas

Let me start by saying the food was good, not great but it was good. Now, the service was less than desirable, everyone was very nice but our waitress only checked on us twice during our whole meal. We had to wave someone down to get drink refills. Someone else brought out our food. We felt ignored most of the evening. Our bread in the bread basket looked like someone had squeezed it with their hand and threw it in the basket. We tried to find someone to let them know we didn't have very good service but no one ever came (we got tired of waiting). We will not be back. read more

We happen to be here the night this restaurant finally reopened from Covid. It is pricey, but the food is DELICIOUS! The manager greeted us with a wine suggestion (which was fabulous), before I ordered the chef came to our table to see if we had any questions or concerns, and our server was super sweet & friendly. I got the scallops which just melted in my mouth- My husband got the roasted lamb, which was really rich but tasty! Can't wait to try something else because we will definitely go back before we leave the area. read more

I took some of my coworkers out here for dinner I ordered the four course menu. The calamari that was my appetizer was cold and it was chewy so it was overcooked. The French onion soup was OK not much better than I would do it like Applebee's. The states were average at best part of the 24 hours right corner house and it was OK it was too much of the blue cheese butter put on it. The lobster mac & cheese was really good as a side, the risotto was overcooked average a fast way too salty. The bread putting that came out of the desert was flavorless the caramel was overcooked it looks like something that came out of a can just not good at all. It was definitely overpriced for what you get. read more

We've eaten here on a few occasions, and have always had a good experience. We shared a large KC Strip steak that was very good and so was the bread! Be sure to try the sunflower side salads as we did...the taste and presentation was great! Also, the staff/servers were excellent! Always a great atmosphere and look forward to coming back again soon! read more

There needs to be an adult in charge here but there isn't. They shouldn't even have lobster on the menu. This is a frozen lobster that is under cooked for the second time! I'm so happy I didn't order ithe crab cakes!!!!! The steak tastes good but it isn't hot.. Everyone else seemed fine with their food. I don't know what else to tell you. $111.00 gratuity. So not worth it read more

If you have not been to Three Fires Steakhouse you are missing out. Everything our table ordered was perfectly prepared. The calamari was excellent and the Wagyu Filet was decadent. Don't forget dessert. The Creme Brûlée is delicious. Portion sizes are more than generous and we had excellent service from Paula. read more

Great ambiance, appetizers and wine selection. Food was fresh and service was top notch. Hope to try a full course next trip. Try the portobello fries! read more

Three Fires Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Mayetta, Kansas

We have visited this restaurant 3 times now and each time, I would have to say that the food has been very good. We've ordered the steak and seafood choices and even dessert on occasion. This last time though, we were very disappointed in the fact that the restaurant (who was supposedly voted to have the best wine list in Topeka) did not have any nice wine glasses for us to use. Knowing we were going to be at a steakhouse, we brought along some very nice wine to share with our friends and were told that the restaurant had used their last 8 wine glasses at another table and the rest of the glasses had broken. Seems odd and very strange that if that were the case, you wouldn't have just replaced them and made sure your customers could enjoy their nice wine in real wine glasses. That being said, their food is really good, but if you are planning on wine, you might want to call ahead and reserve some nice glasses. read more

Glad to have snagged a reservation when someone cancelled last minute. Loved it all from cocktails to the appetizers and bread pudding to finish. Our waiter, Blake, was helpful, attentive, professional. Great spot! Didn't see any of the "3fires" though & it was COLD in there that evening! We'll be back read more

Use to be a favorite place for dinner when visiting the area... most complaints about service and quality unfortunately are now true. Our experience was very disappointing especially when we gambled enough to justify a better class of service. Won't be going back. read more

Best food, good service, gets busy on Fridays and Saturdays. Call ahead to make a reservation.

I read the prior reviews and confirmed them. The service is lacking and the food was not that good. My medium well steak was medium rare. Not a problem to send back but the server never came back. This was their New Year's Eve special and they were busy. However this was ridiculous. I don't plan on going there again. I'll go to the buffet next time. Fail! read more

This was the WORST steak that I have had in my life, it was RARE and was tough, how in the he'll do you cook a rare tough steak, on top of that they wouldn't let me take the unused portion of the steak for my dog, I have never paid $36 for a steak and they wouldn't let me take the unused portion, I do not recommend the Prairie Band Casino and will let everyone know that I know how bad of experience I had! read more

Nice atmosphere. Quiet and laid back. By no means was the food terrible. It all tasted pretty good. I ordered steak and risotto, both were nice, but not exceptional. Nowhere close. Compared to what I can get in Kansas City, this place falls short. In fairness, anything smacking of bbq or grilling, when compared to what you can get in K.C., may fall short. read more

We were working close to the Prairie Band Casino and resort and since we had missed our anniversary, we thought we would have a nice dinner at the Three Fires Steakhouse. We got seated quickly( which was amazing as there was a BBQ contest that day and the place was packed). We had a very polite and friendly server named Vincent. He took great care of us and the prime rib was awesome, topped off by the amazing orange cheesecake. We had a meal to remember and now look forward to our next trip! read more

I wanted to give this place a good review. Unfortunately I sat at my table for over 30 minutes without being acknowledged for a drink order, which I then had to repeat 3 times before I got it. Our party ordered pre-meal drinks, which sat empty for 25 minutes before our appetizers arrived, without a opportunity to order another. The calamari was disappointing to say the least. Then the entrees: risotto so overdone it could be used as stucco and a steak oscar style, which apparently means a la mode here given the icy nature of the toppings. The service was sub-par to say the least. The only redemption was the scallops....and I never got my mashed potatoes... read more

Food was way to expensive for what you get to eat, and my husbands steak was not cooked all the and was very gristly.

Great food, great service. The yelp menu isn't necessarily up to date as they change based on what cuts are available. Ribeye has amazing flavor, scallops and risotto are also great. Reasonable wine bottle prices. Worth the trip!! read more

The decor, the staff, the food - everything about this steak house is spot-on. If you're looking for a romantic spot to take your honey, this is it, even if it is located inside the casino. It's as if you step into another world when you enter the doors. Their menu is online and everything is delicious and gourmet level of quality. read more

I love this restaurant! Food it great, the decor is classy and the staff is friendly. This is where I go for special occasions.

Steak was cooked perfectly, my wife had a great chicken parm...but the problems were. They were out of ribeyes. What? Isn't this a steakhouse. We had to wait fifteen minutes after sitting at our table before our waitress took our drink order. Fifteen minutes later I was told they were out of a juice to make my drink and had to run to store. This was one of their specialty drinks. What? Really? At least food was good. Would not go back. read more

I went here for my birthday with my family. We waited 1 1/2 hours and never got our order. We did get the bread and our drinks in that 1 1/2 hours. The waitress kept telling us that our order was next to be cooked. She did mention that she would talk to the Manager but I doubt that ever happened because the Manager never came to our table. We left without our dinner because the place was closing in 20 minutes. Never got acknowledged by the Manager or any apologies. Very bad service for the price of the dinners. Will not go back. Ended up at an excellent steakhouse in Kansas City the next day and our steak meals were great with knowledgable wait staff and excellent service. read more

This was certainly not the restaurant I was anticipating in the middle of a Kansas casino! We were here producing a show in the ballroom, and I enjoyed a delicious salmon filet, sautéed spinach, and the Sunflower salad. Trying not to eat flour or sugar, I could NOT resist the amazing dinner rolls, with some kind of honey butter. Om nom nom nom! read more

Great Food, Better Service Lobster Mac & Cheese, was the bomb. Filet was excellent, desserts were terrific

Awesome ribeye! It was a pleasant surprise, very tasty, just cooked in butter! I wasn't expecting much from a casino steakhouse but it was one the better steaks that I've had. I will definitely hit this place up on my next golf outing to Firekeepers. read more

Admittedly we drove up there (25 miles north of Topeka on 75) because we wanted to see where our daughter worked (she's in a different part of the food service ), but no regrets! As a rule I hate to pay restaurants steak prices since I can buy the best beef in town and cook it myself for half that money. But prime rib... I've never taken the hours it takes to cook restaurant quality prime rib. Their's was superb and I've eaten at NYC and Chicago and Omaha and Denver and Ft Worth steak houses! And it's way bigger than the 14 oz. they posted in menu, at least 16 oz. Daughters strip steak reported as excellent.Vegetable sides - asparagus, spinach, and mushrooms- also delicious. Highly recommend this place. We have no interest in gambling but if you like that, it's all there. Dessert was exceptional (my daughter does some of that) and service friendly and excellent. 5 of us with 5 cocktails and two glasses of wine, 20% tip, 210 bucks. Very reasonable for the quality. Only gripe: very noisy. Be pleased to return. read more

Great food, great service, great atmosphere. Wish I could find a recipe for their sweet sunflower vinaigrette salad dressing! Does anyone have any information on it? Best salad dressing I've have in a loooooooong time!!! read more

I can cook a better steak for a lot cheaper than that. It was like eating burned wood I don't know if the good cooks work Monday through Friday but dam!!! read more

The appetizers were phenomenal, but they overcooked my husband's steak. No big deal, it happens. What WAS a big deal, was when the Assistant Manager, Antonio, brought the steak back and treated us like idiots. He pulled the steak apart with his bare hands, insisting that the brown steak was "Their" medium rare, and asked if we would like to take it to go. What happened to "The Customer's Always Right?" We eventually did get another steak out of him, it was purple inside. He ate it. Because it's better than burnt. I don't see the restaurant keeping this jerk around long, but I won't ever be back. read more

Ate there last Friday night. 7:30 reservation. Not very busy. Took 15-20 min. for our drinks to come. My wife had a filet which was OK. I had a lobster tail. It smelled like fish bait it tasted like fish bait. I called the waiter over. He asked if I would like something else. Said he would take the lobster off my bill and picked up my plate. I had a few bites of my wife's steak and we prepared to leave. When we received the bill the waiter had taken off the lobster tail but left on the $8 baked potato (which he had picked up). Called the waiter back over and he removed the potato from the bill. Overall crappy dining experience. Won't be back. read more

This place doesn't even deserve one star .... Server suggested prime rib and since I was in the mood that's what I ordered med rare... It came out within seconds before my salad.... Half our later sever asked if it was good... I literally had two bites cause it is way over cooked and awe full !!!! This place is pricey and I expected way better food and service !!! Did not even comp it wow !!!!! read more

Has came a little way since my last visit in December of last year. food isn't as pricy and is good. we went in with a $20 off coupon each we ended up paying 12 dollars with drinks and everything and was pleased. wouldn't go there often as it is pricy. read more