Enjoyed the chocolate milk ice cream with the chocolate sugar cone :) $7 something for 1 scoop.

Looked for upscale / unique ice cream experience and Theo's delivery. Servings are very big. the Cookie Monster is all the cookies in the Cookie Monster's tum-tum and is blue like his body. Very nice vanilla. read more

Super good Ice Cream. Always packed on the weekdays so it's best to find a good time that works for you. I personally enjoy swinging by here during the night time, looks really nice later in the day and the stuff are pretty cool. Very nice interior and they let you sample before you buy. read more

I have had a great couple visits to Theo's. The employees were patient with me asking for samples of the ice cream. The flavors are unique and fun. I also ordered a smoothie, and asked for it to be split into 2 cups, which the employee gladly did. The smoothie tasted great! The location is in a great area, too. There is seating inside, as well as courtyard seating next door. read more

Theo’s Microcreamery - Desserts Near Me - Normal, Illinois

See all

We've been to Theo's multiple times, and it never fails to disappoint! This visit, my friend and I got milkshakes- they can make them with any flavor of ice cream, and the flavors change often, so you have to try them before they're gone! The store wasn't too busy on Saturday afternoon, and we were offered samples, perfect! I like that the store is in the uptown Normal circle with so many businesses to look at nearby! The inside is a little small, but the outside seating area is nice, too, and they have a bathroom that was very clean! Thanks, Theo's, see you next time! read more

Theo’s Microcreamery - Honeycomb ice cream milkshake - Desserts Near Me - Normal, Illinois

Well if this isn't the cutest spot in Normal for you and your pup. My pup Lucy told me she knew a spot that had a puppy Sunday so we had to try it. They have the best small batch ice cream with an equally cute inside and outside. I also love the pup water station outside. Give it a try ! read more

See all

The location was adorable and the staff was super friendly. I loved how cute the lights were setup and the outdoor seating was so cute. My partner enjoyed a chocolate ice cream! points away for not many dairy free options. read more

Love it! The texture and taste of the ice cream is great, my favorite in Bloomington-Normal. It's so delicious. The workers are either really sweet and patient or really quite snotty but I don't mind it because the ice cream tastes really nice. read more

Good small local place for ice cream. If looking for non dairy options, they also have a few. Theo's Microcreamery sounds like a place that takes itself seriously. For sure it does. Prices are indicative that it's not a typical ice cream place. All the ice cream is made in small batches. It has a limited amount, so they can run out of a flavor. There's also a limited amount of seating, hard to find one inside. It was hopping the last time here. This must be a popular place. For a small place they sure have lots of ice cream. They have quite a few including a few that are vegan. It's about $5 for a small cup. The last time here they had the Vegan Peach Swirl. For sure it gets crowded. It has very limited seating inside. This is convenient to take to go outside and there's a few benches out there. read more

Theo’s Microcreamery - Vegan Peach Swirl - Desserts Near Me - Normal, Illinois

We had a lovely trip to Theo's on a busy Friday evening with our students on IHSA Journalism state weekend. All of our students found something that worked for them- including vegan and allergen friendly options. The inside is cute with a little seating, but they also had an outdoor area with more seating. All of the staff was very friendly and efficient, even with so many groups of teenagers visiting at the same time. I wish their summer flavors had been available already because blueberry crumble, key lime pie, and strawberry shortcake sound delicious. We were there in spring, so I got the cookie monster ice cream in a peanut butter sundae and it was incredible. If I lived in the area I would definitely go back, and if we are back for state next year this will be a must visit- highly recommend! read more

This is one of the best ice cream spots in Illinois. They have so many great flavors, and they always have fun small batch flavors. In the winter they have a hot chocolate ice cream which is the best ice cream I've ever had. It's in uptown normal and it's a great experience. read more

chocolate ice cream is great here, great texture! would love more chocolate based flavors.

Theo's is a wonderful, quaint ice cream and coffee shop in uptown Normal. Dog and family friendly with both indoor and outdoor sitting, my kids and I love visiting Theo's and have been doing so for many years. My only recommendation is that they rename their Espresso ice cream the Sabrina Carpenter for obvious reasons. That said, even if they don't, I'll still be coming back. read more

Variety was good. Ice cream was super tasty. Staff were a little sassy at first but we got everything we ordered quickly and correctly. If I found myself in this town again I would definitely stop in. read more

Cute shop. I got three scoops, mint cookie chip, strawberry and creme, and a seasonal flavor blueberry crumble. The strawberry was underwhelming. The mint was ok, the chips were a weird texture to me. The blueberry crumble was fantastic!! Will definitely go back. read more

Stopping for the night in Bloomington, I decided to stop here for some dessert. Even though it was 9pm on a Sunday, they were still open. I'm not usually a sundae person, but the one I got was quite tasty. The prices are about what you'd expect for any place dubbed a microcreamery. Not super cheap, but worth it for me. Cute interior as well read more

See all

Delicious small batch ice cream, good selection of flavors. Cute shop, and pretty busy. Has a nice area to sit outside with a smaller area inside. Busy area of town, but worth the wait. Side note: Great area for Pokemon Go players! Lots of stops and gyms. read more

See all

I'm not a strawberry person but this ice cream was so fresh and creamy .... Ughhh my mouth is watering just thinking about it. Don't make the mistake of getting a small ... get the large. You're welcome. read more

See all

ice cream was excellent, loved the coffee flavored one. the staff was so kind and allowed us extra time to choose what we wanted. got a big sundae to split with my husband and we downed it with delight. the ambiance is so cute. perfect for our date. i went back a couple days later with some friends. love theos!! price is average for nowadays; there is a tip feature that pops up if you use card. there's also a tip jar if you use cash. it's just an ice cream shop though, so you don't really need to tip, only if your wallets are feeling generous! going back soon to try more fun flavors. read more

Treats for pups and their hoomans. Great break from our walk on Constitution Trail. Doggie water fountain, outside window, and doggie Sunday. Little pricey at $5, but he loved it. Oh yeah, my chocolate icecream in a waffle cone was delicious, too. read more

Theo’s Microcreamery - Doggie Sunday - Desserts Near Me - Normal, Illinois

Great ice cream! Very creamy. The S'mores flavor and cookies n cream we're both really good. The interior of the store is also very cute. The reason I gave 4 stars instead of 5 is that it is a little pricey for such a small scoop of ice cream. But I don't mind the price too much knowing that I am supporting a small/local business. read more

Theo’s Microcreamery - Desserts Near Me - Normal, Illinois

This is ICE CREAM. It's impossible to mess up ice cream but somehow these folks do it. The chocolate ice cream taste more like... German chocolate? I'd like to compare it to some other flavor, but I am gluten-free and wasn't able to eat most of the flavors they offered. I got a sundae and it was missing a topping. The whipped cream and dusting of crumby nuts ruined it. Nothing tasted good. I stopped here based on all of the positive reviews but threw most of my $$$ sundae in the garbage and went to Carl's, which was no better but for different reasons. read more

This is our go to place for the Banana Chai Smoothie. Such a favorite on a warm day or when you are feeling like a little treat!

Ah, that hit the spot! Great service and fantastic ice cream. Perfect after some chicago dogs across the street read more

Theo’s Microcreamery - Desserts Near Me - Normal, Illinois

I had a chance to try their ice cream last week. They did not disappoint. I tried the brownie sundae and it was pure perfection. The browine was nice and warm, the vanilla ice cream was decadent, and the Carmel syrup was the perfect topping. My kids loved their chocolate dipped waffle cone with chocolate ice cream. We are already anticipating our next visit, and what we are going to try next time we visit Theo's. read more

It was standard nothing spectacular. It was nice and family friendly. It was loud and had close quarters.

Very clean upon entering. Fast, polite service. Small portions for the price. It tasted delicious though. My friend got a sundae but thought it was rather plain. No cherry or nuts on top, and they never asked if she wanted any. Would probably try again. read more

Theo’s Microcreamery - 1 scoop of pumpkin Oreo - Desserts Near Me - Normal, Illinois

It was a warm day and Theo's was very busy but the line moved quickly, the staff was friendly, and the ice cream was delicious!

Menu is small but fun - ice cream is good but nothing super special. Shop was busy when we went in but the staff handled the crowd well. We had a sundae, it was good but it was a little light on toppings. read more

This was our 1st time at Theo's and we were so impressed! What a wonderful experience! The shop is bright and clean and the patio is gorgeous. I tried the peach cobbler (flavor of the month for August) and my picky 5 year old son surprisingly ventured outside the box and ordered a scoop of cotton candy ice cream on top of his usual vanilla! He ate the ENTIRE cone! The staff (Alyssa) was so sweet and patient with him as he practiced his manners when ordering (we are working on saying "may I have" rather than just "vanilla cone, please." I also really appreciated the dog water bowl station on the patio. What a thoughtful touch! After this trip to a REAL ice cream shop my son has finally decided on his Halloween costume... He is going as an ICE CREAM MAN! So, the experience clearly made a huge impression on him! Thank you, Theo's for a wonderful experience today! We definitely will be back! read more

See all

Great place, I've gone twice & both times the items I ordered were delicious. Smoothie- "Purple Chill" perfect summer drink! Ice flavors I've tried: Espresso (Husbands favorite) My favorite is Cookie Monster And also tried the July flavor with cornbread/sweetcream based. DELICIOUS! Wish it contained more pieces of cornbread though. Definitely recommend, support local business! read more

Absolutely LOVE their ice cream! We live in Peoria and drive to Bloomington just to have it. The best in the area!

Always a joy to take the little ones here. They love this ice cream. It is excellent.

Enjoyed some mint chip in a waffle cone, the Theo's sundae and a scoop of raspberry sorbet. Super cute place ~ reasonable prices ~ great flavor ~ helpful staff. 5 stars all the way. read more

Great ice cream! Very cute place on the inside! Very modern feeling. We have tried the Cookie Dough, Hot Cocoa, and Puppy Chow (seasonal flavors) all very good but Cookie Dough is definitely my favorite. As well as the Cookie Monster and Strawberries and Cream two all the time flavors. The ice cream quality seems really good it's very thick almost sticky consistency. We would definitely go again for the Cookie Dough or Cookie Monster flavors if not to try new ones. read more

About a week ago my husband and I were in the mood for homemade ice cream. We decided to try Theo's Microcreamery. We bought Brownie Fudge and Caramel Sundaes. They were delicious! They had a lot of choices and the business was busy. We didn't wait long since they had sufficient help. There is both inside and outside seating available. read more

Delicious ice cream and helpful staff. Great flavors - inventive but quality and tasty. Good hot fudge too. And oreo shake was outstanding - tasted like liquid oreo! read more

Theo’s Microcreamery - 3 scoop sundae! Cookie monster, mint chocolate chip oreo, and cookies & cream with hot fudge! - Desserts Near Me - Normal, Illinois

One of my favorite icecream places in Bloomington! The staff is always very kind and work efficiently. I highly recommend their 309 Spark as it is one of mine and my partners favorite dessert! read more

Great ice cream. They have a nice variety of flavors. The ice cream is creamy and delicious.

This is the best ice cream by far in Bloomington-Normal! Unique flavors and perfect texture. Love!