I was in town (Curtis NE) visiting my mom for the week and 3/14 (PI Day) rolled around and my daughter insisted on a pie to celebrate the occasion. Where to get a pie in Curtis? I don't even like pie. So we did a Google search and found The Village Pie Maker. We didn't have the time to make the jaunt over to Eustis so we settled for a trip to the grocery store in Curtis. So many great choices; which one to choose? I asked a couple of nice ladies in the store if they were to buy a pie, which one would they buy. They both said they'd buy The Village Pie Maker. I had already forgotten it was in my search results. Hmmmm what flavor? One said cherry, the other rhubarb/strawberry or mix berry. I settled on peach as peaches always remind me of my grandmother, Marian Davis. She always made peaches with real cream for us kids when we were growing up and Grandma was coming to dinner. I purchased this pie uncooked and frozen, followed the directions to a T and for the first time in my life I love pie. It was pretty, perfectly golden across the top. We didn't even wrap the edges. This is the perfect pie. I'm stopping in the morning to pick up two more to take back to Kansas City with me. I don't know why I didn't like pie before! =) Thank you Village Pie Maker! Four generations of ladies sat around a table sharing your pie and our memories. read more

Worst service ever. Ripped us by over charging for a 3 cut rate pies stuffed full a gel like sugar. Its diabetic pie. Much better options. Don't fall for hype like we did. read more

These pie crusts shrank so much after cooking that I had to throw them away. Horrible product! read more

The Village PieMaker - Desserts Near Me - Eustis, Nebraska

have purchased 4 of these cherry apple and pecan. All had the same issue. Never cooked properly (oven temp is correct.) crust is always soggy when cool enough to serve. next day you throw it out if not sooner. filling doesnt set. 50% off is still too much for crap read more

The strawberry rhubarb is spectacular totally recommend I would have never expected it to Be so delicious read more

The Village PieMaker - The best ever pie - Desserts Near Me - Eustis, Nebraska

See all

Grew up enjoying homemade pies and village pie maker's Strawberry Rubarb is just like having a slice of grandmother's pie made from garden to stove. I'm impressed having grown up with foodies ... I'm not understanding any negative comments because that certainly hasn't been the case.... Try it! Thank you for such a good product with real fruit and no fillers. read more

The Village PieMaker - Desserts Near Me - Eustis, Nebraska

Literally taste rancid. Must use lard?! Ewww and I think they used rancid lard it was not edible went right into trash.

I've bought many of their pies over the years. This year I bought a Pumpkin for our Christmas family dinner. It was defiantly the 'Worst' pumpkin pie I've ever ate! There was more than 1/2 the pie left after a gathering of 20+ people! So it went into the trash! It had absolutely NO FLAVOR, very bland. Cost $16.66 + tax. I will not buy anymore. Really disappointed that the Quality is not there anymore! A Hall read more

Crust was flaky and really good pie crust. That's where the good ends. Purchased an apple pie from local grocer. Very few apples and mostly sugary gel filling. Way to sweet for my taste and I could not taste any apple. All I tasted was sugar and spices. This was supposed to be a premium like homemade pie for $17. It was more like one of those mass produced commercial pies for under $5. The small $1.25 individual pies I purchase are better than this pie. read more

The Village PieMaker - Filling taste like it came from can. - Desserts Near Me - Eustis, Nebraska

This is the worst apple pie I have ever bought, they should call it Applesauce Pie , I couldn't locate any slices or chunks of apple , it was apple mush within a pie crust , big let down since the packaging and presentation was nice . read more

We got the apple.pie for Christmas and while it looked really beautiful, only the filling was any good. The pie crust had a decidedly lardy taste that was so bad and strong, one little bit stuck in my teeth was enough to leave a terrible, terrible taste behind. I will not be buying pies from this company again. Disgusting, disgusting, disgusting. read more

We bought a village pie maker coconut cream pie at hyvee- it was the worst pie we ever tasted. After looking at ingredients we knew why-it was full of chemical concoctions including gums- no real food ingredients. We threw it in the trash. In years past we had some of the Village Pies Maker good fruit pies when the pies were made in Eustis, Nebraska. But now the father of our Nebraska governor bought the Village Pie Maker moving its operation to Omaha - and their pies are trash fillers. Very disappointing. Bad representation for Nebraska. read more

If I could give this 0 stars I would. I went to Costco yesterday to get their apple pie, only to be told they no longer sell them. Shocking at best! Called Costco Customer Service today and they had no idea what I was talking about....thank you Call Center. So I googled around and found some mixed reviews of Village Pie Maker, drove to Safeway, paid $20.00 for this apple pie and it is the pits. Doesn't taste like apple pie to me. I tried, but it's just gross, so in the trash it went. Save your money......this is a loser. read more

I purchased the large apple pie but I haven't baked it yet, will post when I've eaten it and it cost $14.00. This review is for the small two pack cherry pie. No way should those very small pies cost $7.00, for the size they should only cost $4.00 or less. Well, I will not be buying them again and they weren't that great in taste. read more

While the quality of the dough and flavor was good, I was very disappointed to see when I opened the packaging that the dough was pieced together rather than being a single uniform layer, and as a result, when pre-baked for my pie, it separated and gapped. I don't believe I would buy this brand again. read more

Friends told me about these pies, I did not believe them. No person alive an make a pit as good as my mom did. Wow, I'm stunned the cherry, the apple taste like mom's. It goes from the freezer into the oven, takes about 90 minutes, the crust is flaky, tender, not soggy. I'd never have thought this freezer pie could be good. A convection oven did best to lightly brown to top. Excellent and much to easy for me to buy. read more

Best mass produced pies ever! My aunt used to make several pies when apricots were in season and freeze them. These are the closest any company has ever come to my aunts homemade pies. Also the best crust I've ever tasted from a company. Would love to try a huckleberry one!! read more

We love these pies. They're absolutely delicious. We just bought two for Christmas, and this one isn't going to make it! If I could give them 6 stars I would. Glad to have two grocery stores in Northern Colorado that sell them:)) read more

The Village PieMaker - Peach pie - Desserts Near Me - Eustis, Nebraska

I'm not 100% sure where these people are getting their pies? But in the last few months I have had a cherry pie a peach pie and Apple pie. And they're all fantastic. As a matter of fact it went on sale in my local grocery store and I bought three or four more I can't remember . They're full of fruit . And there is no gelatin in them. That's why I like them. read more

The Village Pie Maker frozen pie crust is the worst I have ever tried. I had to throw the first one out as it shriveled up in the tin and was unusable. After double checking the instructions (which I followed correctly the first time) I had to throw the second one out for the same reason! I won't be using this brand or any of their products again. read more

Crust taste like greasy flour. Filling is gelatinous. I recommend the company try the Willamette Pie to see how they can improve.

Exceptional! The best crust I've had since moms. Plenty of real fruit Will definitely buy again!!'

I paid $17 for a Blackberry pie a couple days ago Lot #0-12920-BB, baked it, took about 3 bites and threw it in the trash. VERY strong chemical taste in the blackberries. NOT RECOMMENDED; it made me feel sick. Please refund! read more

We've always loved Village Pie Maker pies, but had a cherry pie yesterday and the quality is not what it was before the business sold! There were fewer cherries and the cherries were tiny. We were disappointed and will not be buying these again. read more

I bought a cherry, because my neighbor shared one this summer it was wonderful. But this one the crust was awful, just like the poster it had this weird lard taste that just ruined it. Since they were bought out something has changed. Never again. Yuk. read more

Worst ever!! Filling awful, price outrageous,crust nothing like advertised. Marie Calenders is half the price & well worth it. This is a sham. The pie went in the trash, hard lesson. Beware what you read is not what you get. read more

Discovered your pies at our local Walmart. Cherry was the first we tried. Delicious! I make a great homemade cherry pie, but yours is better. The crust is flaky and the sugar sprinkled on top adds to the delectable delight. Wish our other grocery stores carried your pies. I am in the process of ordering raspberry-peach and berry medley since Walmart carries only cherry, apple, peach, and strawberry-rhubarb. Thank you for these yummy pies! read more

I beg you to find a fresher and better tasting pie than what these guys make... And then I'll tell you you're a liar. These are available at many meat shops around Omaha and the NE area. A family member brings them to family functions and we ended up having to look up the company and find out where we could get them. These are fresh fruit pies, not any of that canned pie filling. I know most people think, well how different can it be? That's what I thought too. Grandma ain't got nothing on these things. Check out their site to find out where you can get them. They run about $12 each but well worth it. read more

OMG I think I've died and went pie Heaven!!! This is the best pie hands down and I'm not a pie lover because I don't like the wet soggy bottom of most pies but this is the real deal the crust just melts in your mouth and I love the sweet tangy taste of the filling. The best part is it's made with real(less than 8) ingredients that you can pronounce. read more

The Village PieMaker - OMG I think I've died and went pie Heaven!!! - Desserts Near Me - Eustis, Nebraska

Excellent pie! I don't like pie, but my husband does so I bought a gooseberry pie for him. It was delicious! It wasn't overly sweet and the crust was delectable! I have made many pies trying to please the pie lovers in my life, and this pie even takes the cake! I wish they didn't use soybean oil in the crust and there ingredients were organic, but maybe they will sway to this persuasion. (Or at least offer an organic option?) Regardless, we will try the rhubarb pie next time we want a (non-chocolate) treat in the house. read more

Had the cherry pie, good taste to the filling, crust to thin, burned where bottom met side of the pan. Stuck to the pan like glue.Marie Callender's is far and away a better pie. read more

I'm from Virginia, where berries are a-plenty and pies are a way of life. Everyone's granny, mawmaw, mother, sister and daddy can throw a pie together in less than 20 minutes. THIS pie is about as CLOSE as you will get to homemade without purchasing all the ingredients and making it yourself. My family enjoyed it, and we are still enjoying it down to the last! First time we've ever purchased a $20 frozen pie - and we are NOT sorry we did! read more

I bought their cherry pie in Littleton, CO for my hubby. He is a cherry pie connoisseur as his mom used to bake them for him. GREAT cherry pie! Not too sweet, not too tart, and the crust is fantastic. Better than Village Inn, Marie Callenders'...we will buy more! Yummm read more

We continue to enjoy these pies. They are as good as any I can remember from my childhood. My personal favorite is Cherry. The crust is light and flakey the way it is suppose to be. They are priced higher than store bought pies but you get what you pay for. We get them at LuLu's which is a farmers market outside of Brighton Colorado read more

I bought a cherry and blueberry in Boyd, TX a few weeks ago. I was surprised they had blueberry there, but they did. I think blueberry is the best. The only improvement I would suggest is to make the cruist a little thicker. The crust itself is delicious, so why not give us more of it please? read more

See all

Just bought our 1st strawberry-rhubarb pie at Hy-Vee in Omaha. This is what pie USED to taste like! Same price as Costco but they are a world apart. Keep on baking - you've got a winner! read more