Very popular...usually a line to enter. Noisy, casual, fun atmosphere, very friendly staff. Food is abundantly sized but not particularly special or delicious. Best for burgers, salads. read more

I don't really get all the buzz about this place. The atmosphere is borderline and uninspiring. The food is good but not extraordinary in a couple of times I've been there. There's always a wait so it's really kind of lost on me. I live at Reynolds Lake Oconee, and much prefer the restaurants inside the gates. read more

Best food at the lake no doubt! And the staff is the best! Get the strawberry shortcake!

My husband and I decided to dine at The Silver Moon after it had been recommended to us by several people. There was a wait when we arrived, so he added our name to the list on the board and we chose to enjoy the outside sitting area while we waited. I sipped on a sangria while hubby ordered a pomegranate martini. My sangria did not lack in the alcohol department, but it was a little weak in the flavor department. Hubby's pomegranate martini was a better choice...a subtle sweetness with a nice alcohol content. Other customers commented about how strong their cosmos were. A few had to ask for more cranberry juice to make them palatable. Conversations with other guests and the bartender for the outside bar prompted numerous appetizer and entree recommendations once they learned we were visiting for the first time. From bbq shrimp and Philly Cheesesteak Spring Rolls appetizers to fish-n-chips, fried shrimp, and chicken tenders entrées to peanut butter pie, strawberry shortcake, and bread pudding desserts, everyone shared so many options that were "sooo good". Hubby and I ordered the bbq shrimp appetizer. It did not disappoint. Now this wasn't the same type of bbq that would be on ribs or chicken from the grill. This was a scrumptious butter, worcestershire, spicy sauce that was worthy of being licked off of our fingers and sopped up with the delicious crusty exterior, pillowy soft interior bread that was served with it. Definitely 10/10 would recommend. For our entrées, we both selected the option recommended to us by our fantastic waiter, Cody...fish and chips with fried shrimp. We both opted to swap the chips (fries) out for the parmesan cheese grits as recommended by a guest in one of those previous conversations. Again, all recommendations were fabulous! The fish and shrimp were seasoned and fried perfectly with a crispy but not over battered exterior. It was served with cocktail and tartar sauces and a coleslaw that was unique in that it had an onion flavor. It was edible, but it wasn't my favorite. I would likely swap it out with another side next time...and based on tonight's experience, there will definitely be a next time. The only down side was that hubby and I ordered bread pudding desserts to go. When we opened them later, they were drastically different. One was lighter in color and was delicious while the other was much darker and seemed like it may have been overcooked. The flavors differed between the two as well. After such a great meal and experience, it was a bit disappointing to have it all end this way. If possible, I would have taken off half a star because everything and everyone else was great. read more

The Silver Moon - Two bread puddings. Was one overcooked? - Bars Near Me - Eatonton, Georgia

Just went for the first time, best me and the family went to eat at silver moon for the first time, I have to tell you that was the best, savory meal I've had in a long time. The filet was cooked to perfection, it was like eating cotton candy, it just melted in my mouth. My wife had the same thing. My son in law had the 44burger, couldn't stop eating until it was all gone, then wanted another, my daughter had chicken fingers with fries. Our server was the best, friendly treated us new comers with happiness, and a great big ol' smile. Appetizers came out pretty quick, then came the that great tasting meal. It may not look like one of those fancy restaurants on the inside or outside, but it makes up for it with the great food and service. read more

Great food and generous portions for the price. The service is professional and friendly. We try and go every week.

My Husband golf team comes there annually to play golf in Greensboro ga! We had dinner here at this restaurant on last night, but rest assumed it was our last time eating at this establishment. The Food was terrible and cold like the people! The hostess was very racist! It was evident that they weren't use to eating with black folks in those sticks! They felt at home having those black waitress service them though. Also, It was evident that they have a black section for sitting in this restaurant as well. read more

Best steak of my life best steak sauce of my life waiter was really nice drinks were good fast service

I was at Lake Oconee for a wedding and my group was looking for a dinner spot on Friday night when we arrived. This spot seemed like a cute local spot so we decided to check it out! There's plenty of parking in the lot and there was a bit of a wait but not too bad (we were able to get drinks at the bar while waiting). The inside is very cozy and has murals painted and plenty of TVs. Our server was awesome, very welcoming and had great recommendations for us! I had the 44 South Burger but our table also tried the chicken tenders, fish and chips, bacon cheeseburger and steak frites. Everything was super delicious and well cooked. We also had a few beers and the house made cocktails were great. For dessert, our server recommended the Mud Pie which WOW!!! Desserts are homemade by the owner and this pie had a fantastic homemade Oreo crust, silky mocha ice cream, and whipped cream on top. I also had a Chocolate Kiss Martini and man, I love a chocolate martini and this one impressed! Overall,Silver Moon is a great spot on Lake Oconee and really brings the welcoming, homey vibes. Would visit again if I'm in the area! read more

The Silver Moon - Chocolate Kiss Martini - Bars Near Me - Eatonton, Georgia

See all

Great food and service. Tuesday steak night is pricey but delicious and the onion strings are worth the trip.

Love the Friday nite shrimp. Large shrimp fried to perfection served with French fries, cocktail sauce and Cole slaw. Pair with sweet tea and you've got a real winner. read more

The Silver Moon was the highest rated restaurant on Yelp for this area and it did not disappoint!!! We had a party of 6 and we were seated within 20 minutes on a busy Friday evening for dinner Once seated, we ordered a couple beers around the table and our waitress was absolutely fantastic with a great personality! For my main, I got the bistro steak fries and for the price this entree was amazing!!! The steak was cooked to my liking, the shoestring French fries were great AND it came with a small side of coleslaw which was also delicious. And because we could not get enough and our waitress was raving about all the homemade desserts we shared a portion of the mud pie and wow!!!!! Everything here was homemade and delicious and you could definitely taste it. Would love to try more things on the menu 10/10 read more

The Silver Moon - Mud pie - Bars Near Me - Eatonton, Georgia

See all

This is hands down the best food establishment in the Lake Oconee area. What's the first giveaway? So many people know about it that it is hard to get seated on the weekends. The service is exceptional. The food is 10/10. The ambience is so positive. Everyone is happy because they are enjoying all the great food and drinks. This is my go-to whenever I take my wife and family out for a special occasion or just because I want to have a great experience after a hard day. read more

The Silver Moon - Wine - Bars Near Me - Eatonton, Georgia

See all

Food was excellent as always. Service at the bar was amazing, too. We also really like the ambiance - where other diners chat with us. It is always worth the wait to be seated. read more

A really cool environment especially at the bar. The other general seating feels like a Cracker Barrel. If you're not familiar with this place, there is always a wait starting at 5:00pm and theres a waiting list that you have to write your name on the chalkboard for. If you prefer a bar table or even bar seating, you must specify a bar table versus bar seating to the hostess. There is a separate chalkboard for bar seating for just two people max. (Def recommend for date night!) What is really convenient is a nice outdoor bar area so that you can have drinks while you wait. The food is hit or miss, but the ribs, and fried shrimp are always a hit. Being from Atlanta and traveling often, I wouldn't recommend having a steak at this place. It feels very amateur and like something you could make at home on your stove with just a little bit of salt. They also only have one type of oysters, so don't expect smaller size or a choice in Brineyness. They are huge. Otherwise, it is a staple in the neighborhood and a must visit. read more

The food and service here are always great! I've been in the lake area for quite a while now and I cannot recall a bad time here! Of course it gets busy and packed and there is a wait but when you have a great place like this it's expected. It's cozy and relaxing. Ophelia and Cody are amazing servers. Everyone is here really! Give it a try if you have not been. Also. If you happen to have room for dessert the strawberry shortcake is AMAZING! read more

The Silver Moon - Bistro Steak & frites. Cooked medium rare - Bars Near Me - Eatonton, Georgia

Food and service is wonderful! After 6:30 can be busy with a wait but it goes fast and is worth the wait

This was our first time going here and what a pleasant surprise!! The food was very good - it was steak night - 3 in our party had steaks all very pleased and 1 had fish and chips also very happy. The wine list was EXCELLENT- all by the glass and better then any restaurant in town including the country club! We will return read more

I currently live in Nashville visit where I grew up about twice a year. I am extremely disappointed. As a true native to Lake Oconee and someone who ACTUALLY grew up With the lake and has so many great memories here I will never be back. Sorry Gregg & Ginger. Nor will John Ruark. read more

The chicken tenders are delicious! The steaks are amazing! Customer service brings us back every time!

SHHHHHHHH...don't tell everyone..... It's the fabulous little secret at Lake Oconee. Great , great food...local spot...food is incredible. They do a spicy shrimp appetizer with fresh bread for dipping...yum... I love their Halibut, but hubby gets the steak... Love this Hidden Gem.. Get their early, they don't take reservations.... but grab a drink and get to know the Lake Oconee neighbors read more

Great restaurant. If you get dessert, get the strawberry shortcake! It is the best ever!!

After struggling to find a good restaurant in Lake Okonee The Silver Moon was a hit. Or server Sherrell was awesome, knew the entire menu made great recommendations. The food was great, the drinks also. Would definitely go back. read more

The food at Silver Moon in Eatonton, Georgia is very delicious! One of our Favorite Meals is a Dozen Oysters On the Half Shell with a Wedge Salad. We sometime order a Meal but we first have the Oysters on the Half Shell as an Appitizer. Oysters on the Half Shell are only served on the weekends, so that is when we go. We will be going there soon to enjoy thier delicious food! But guess what else we will definitely have when we go there? The Service is Always Top Notch! The Atmosphere while you are there enjoying a Fabulous meal is one of the better of any Restaraunt we have ever been to! read more

We absolutely love coming here. Great spot with good food and great cocktails. Dine in or take out, you won't be disappointed.

Always fabulous food, great cocktails and great service. Definitely recommend giving Silver Moon a try

Food is consistently good, no surprises. Staff is very efficient and prices are fair. There's a reason they have stayed in business all these years! read more

Good food. Bad wait. At this price point , it fees weird to write your name on a chalk board.

Key Lime Pie This restaurant is truly A GEM in the Lake Oconee area. Ginger the owner / Chef and Shirelle our waitress were the nicest most hospitable people I have met in a long time. The food was amazing ! We got a ton of the apps and then spoilt a burger & the salmon ( was so good !) !!! If You are in this area DO NOT miss this gem ! read more

The Silver Moon - Key Lime Pie - Bars Near Me - Eatonton, Georgia

Five plus stars for the food - it was devine and really, exceptionally tasty. We have driven by multiple times, but there is no sign, so we didn't know what it was - we actually thought it was a bar. A bar that happened to be always packed! We had heard great things about The Silver Moon, and saw its great reviews on Yelp. We'll, lo and behold, they are the same place. We arrived at 4:15pm when they first opened, after hearing and seeing how popular Silver Moon is. By 5pm, the place was really crowded. Jessica was an awesome, friendly, prompt and efficient server. I highly recommend the bacon wrapped shrimp - it was perfect and delicious. The 10 ounce burgers was a real treat, as was the salmon. Perfect fries, excellent cheese grits, and wonderful broccoli rounded out the meal. The prices are very reasonable. My one complaint: the swinging kitchen door squeaks so badly it sounds like you are on a ship at sea. I would love for it to not squeak on my next visit! read more

See all

Best food on Lake Oconee! Steaks, fresh fish, great cocktails & wine list! Never fails to deliver the best food & drinks no matter what time of the year read more

We have never had a bad meal here. Always good food. Go early. 4 PM or be prepared to wait. Put your name and number in your party on the chalkboard. It is a little loud at times as there is little to no soundproofing. Food is great. Service is great. This is Lake Oconee's 4+ star restaurant. There is No sign out front of the building. As I remember is is between Agee Lawn & Garden & the Sherwin Williams Paint store. They have some specials and a regular printed menu. Casual dress is fine. Lake rules apply. read more

You will not be disappointed it's a great place with great service and the steaks are out of this world. Cool place been around for ever. You will not be disappointed. It's very popular so get there early no reservations walk on put your name on a chalkboard. Highly Recommended!! read more

We have a group of about 12 that are in a weekly supper club. Last week it was our opportunity to go to the Silver Moon . We had been there one other time, but this was a different and larger crowd. The table was ready when we arrived and our guest enjoyed excellent service by Cody. he knew the menu he knew the process. He knew how to treat customers with respect and I will always ask for him when I go back. The food was excellent a lot of different choices and everybody had a great time. read more

Stumbled on this place as I noticed parking lot was full with all GA. Plates which told me it was a local favorite! Well it was Saturday and a croud were waiting out front and inside but being a single, I got seated at the bar relatively fast. The fact that so many wanted to wait for dinner was a strong indication that I was in the right place for dinner. Bar staff were super friendly, and I was considered a called a "newbie" after conversation and I introduced to the entire bar patrons, including the owner, who looked through the kitchen bar window to wave and say hello. Several couples on either side of me at the bar recommended several items on the menu and I went with the fish and chips (shoestring fries). Food was served fresh hot and in short order. As an Out-of-Towner traveling through, I recommend this place as it must be "THE" local Wateringhole as well as friendly people & service. I wasn't disappointed! My dinner was great! read more

A great bar and good food! Get there early if you would like to sit at the bar! A popular place.

Me, my wife, and my in-laws who were visiting from out of town had the pleasure of trying this place out for the first time. The service 2as wonderful - our server was both attentive and well-versed on the menu. The crab stuffed swai on a bed of creamy grits was excellent. My wife - a veritable burger connoisseur- exclaimed that her burger was one of the best she has ever eaten. read more

The Silver Moon - Today's specials - Bars Near Me - Eatonton, Georgia

Great food, portions, service! The chicken tenders are massive! Tuesday is steak night and they didn't disappoint with the 20 oz ribeye. Salmon BLT and tuna poke bowl were tasty. We are going again tonight. This is where the locals eat. Go early or be prepared to wait. read more

Our friends recommended Silver Moon when we stayed close by for the week. We are so glad they did! Best meal we had. Our sever was so nice and helpful (as were all other staff we encountered). Our onion straws were delicious. The steaks were perfectly cooked. The strawberry shortcake was a chef's kiss! Thanks Silver Moon. We'll be back. read more

My band and I were in town for a show and we're always looking for a great local place to eat at that is not some typical chain type of place. Boy, does the Silver Moon fit the bill. Friendly local southern hospitality type service, great food and atmosphere. We liked it so much we ate their twice, once the night before our show and the next night after the show courtesy of the Sliver Moon's Ginger helping us to get our order in before the kitchen closed. We had everything from steak, Ahi tuna sandwiches, Halibut and more. All delicious. Be sure to save room for the house made desserts! They are all off the richter scale! Enjoy this local treasure. read more