Some of the best pizza New York has to offer. Real service in a classic pizza shop ambiance. This is the pizza shoppe you think of when you think pizza in NYC. We ordered an entire cheese pie, kept it simple. Talk about an authentic crust, with high quality cheese and Italian tomato sauce. These guys know how do pizza! Every slice has the best cheese pull you can imagine. Their pepperoni is amazing, so is their grandma pie. But since I don't get authentic NY pizza in California, the simplicity of a delicious cheese pie is so satisfying and comforting. Every time I land, this is the first place I go. I can't wait to get back! read more

The Pizza Shoppe - Cheese Pizza is so delicious and comforting! The BEST!! - Pizza Near Me - East Patchogue, New York

I grew up within a 5 minute walk of the Pizza Shoppe, lived there 20+ years, and haven't been in the area in 10+ years, so I'm basing my review off of past experiences. First off, the owner (blonde haired, fair skinned guy) is very rude! No warmth, not inviting, very straightforward, resting (b)itch faced, doesn't care if you're a regular, "if you don't like my food then don't come here" kind of guy. Not aggressive, just cold. Was a regular customer for years, stopped coming when I had to go gluten-free for medical reasons, they don't carry gluten free pizza. (Maybe now they do? Not sure.) I knew of the previous owner back in the 90s, was so much nicer! The pizza was good, the prices were reasonable, the Italian ices they used to scoop out from the freezer were always smooth. I do have a lot of positive childhood memories from eating here as a kid. Stopped coming around 2011 due to the lack of gluten free options, and the owner's horrible attitude. Have no interest in coming back. Can't say whether or not I recommend the Pizza Shoppe based on the current quality of their food, but based on the past, don't recommend. read more

Took my friend Tyler here for a casual weekend lunch. We ordered a pizza to share and loved every single bite. Great crust, plenty of cheese, and a very comfortable environment. read more

Super nice people and garlic knots are pretty good too. Definitely preferred over the other Bellport pizza spot

This hidden gem is worth it. Food always fresh. Great italian meals and shareable portions.

As I've previously mentioned, the food here is great! It is consistently tasty and fresh. The owner and staff are very hard-working individuals. Inside, the restaurant is kept clean and neat. Overall it is my "go-to" place for good food at reasonable prices!! read more

One of the Best pizza places around . From the pizza to the Zeppoli. Pizza is always on point. Service is Excellent

The food is always fresh and tasty. The owner is great and knows his business His pizza is spot on read more

Food Great and personal okay Best . Have it delivered and was also beautiful hot and sauce was delicious

Great pizza and Italian food I recommend pizza shoppe. Very tasty dinners good assortment of pizza. Enjoy read more

ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS PIZZA!!! Just moved in around the block and have walked passed this pizza place multiple times now, always saying "we need to try this place sometime!" Well today was the day. We ordered online, which was super easy! I liked how you can select toppings on the left and right halves of the pizza. We got peppers & onions on one half, and eggplant on the other. The pizza was ready on time and still piping hot when we opened it up at home. My mom, my dad and I could not stop complimenting this pizza. I really liked the sauce on it. They were not at all skimpy on the toppings. Great price for a delicious slice! read more

The Pizza Shoppe - Grandma pizza with eggplant on half and peppers/onions on half! - Pizza Near Me - East Patchogue, New York

I absolutely love this place . This is the only place I will order my pizza from. Staff is always nice when I come in. The pizza is just how I like it . Perfect amount of sauce. Cheesy. Not over cooked or burnt . I hope they never close . read more

Great food, great and very kind staff. I am now a regular. Our go to is the baked ziti northern. Great price for a ton of food. Pizza is great as well. Love this place read more

We have ordered from this place many times for game night since our friend lives around the corner and it has never disappointed. They are always realistic with their time estimations, with all the food on their extensive menu coming out delicious each time! The garlic knots are the absolute best and I always have to stop there to grab a half dozen when I am in the area. Their pasta is also al dente every time, never overcooked like many other pizzerias. Among other things, their various pasta dishes and hot antipasto are some of the favorites among our group! Besides their amazing food, we also have had nothing but positive experiences with the management there. They are a mighty team of three that work tirelessly to ensure that orders come out perfect each time. Yesterday, we were ordering some garlic knots and zeppoli on our way home when we realized we had a flat tire. We ordered the food and then asked the owner if he had a can of WD-40 since the lug nuts were NOT coming off. Not only did he find a can, he brought it out to us, along with some gloves so that our hands didn't get covered in grease. Once we are out there for a bit (and clearly not getting very far), he came out to help us out and managed to get all the lug nuts loosened. The combination of amazing food and helpful spirit of this establishment is often hard to find. I encourage everyone to come to The Pizza Shoppe and support their business! read more

See all

Great food. Reasonable prices for quality. Fast delivery. Always satisfied with their service!

Love this place. Been coming here for years. Best pizza, best pizza pops. Buffalo chicken pop is my favorite. Caesar salad is perfect. The BEST zeppolis. They have cinnamon sugar zeppolis. Don't go here without trying them! read more

See all

Pizza and food is always fresh and tasty. Great choices. Kevin and his staff always make sure that your order right. Store is nicely decorated and clean. read more

This review is strictly for lack of customer service - their food is pretty good however the lady who works there is awful! My daughter ordered two gyros, a pasta and a salad to be delivered; I observed her place the order. The order was delivered and only 1 gyro was with the order; she called back and explained a gyro was missing and the woman began to yell at her that she only paid for one gyro; no apology for missing the gyro in the order. It got to the point where my daughter (17) was becoming upset on the phone at which point - I got involved explained she had ordered two and only 1 was delivered. The woman said we were not charge and I asked them for her to itemize the bill for me; she told me she doesn't know the prices off the top of her head she just pushes buttons on the register - but if I wanted it I needed to pay for it. She was very aggressive on the phone - I asked her if this is how she spoke to all customers and suggested that because she made the error she really should not charge us; especially since we would be delayed further. She told me I was the one arguing with her and the only way we were getting the gyro was if we paid for it... WOW! Won't be giving them our business ever again. read more

I cannot believe how incredibly rude the staff was to me when I called to make sure my order came in properly through the order app slice. I will never order from them again and will make it a goal that everyone knows what horrible service this place provides. I don't care how many Facebook post it takes I'll make sure that everyone knows how horrible this place is. read more

The first time I ordered from there, the delivery took over an hour and a half and the pizza arrived ice cold.. This time I ordered a pizza and I opted to pick it up and order it well done because it was slightly under my preference last time.. I picked it up and the pizza half raw when I got home.. The zeppolis were greasy, they looked like fried chicken read more

The Pizza Shoppe - Greasy zeppolis - Pizza Near Me - East Patchogue, New York

See all

Greatest pizza place on Long Island. Kevin is like family! Frequently going in here from one to three times a week.

The best meatball parmesan hero you will ever eat in your life. I strongly recommend ordering 2.

In the effort of maintaining full disclosure for all of my reviews (as few of them as I have at the moment...) I want to let everyone know that I have been ordering food here for approximately 20 years. I have done everything in my power to divorce my review from nostalgia in every way and I think that this is a fairly unbiased piece on this nice little local pizza joint. It's a small storefront that you can easily miss as you are careening down South Country Road at any speed, especially if you are like most people driving on that road and doing 60 mphs! There is a recently renovated interior with a few tables for a sit down and TV's on both ends of the aisle. I have eaten in maybe 4 times in the last 8 years, as I usually prefer to have my pizza at home. On the odd occasion I have eaten there, I have always mildly enjoyed watching the peoples coming in for their dinners and listening to the various conversations and cell phone calls people are on in a public place. The dining room area isn't anything more than what I have already described, except that you are always going to be aware of the weather as the front door is never too far away no matter where you sit. That said; let's get on to the food! It's a typical pizzeria that offers a selection of pastas and pizza, sides, and a few standard fare dishes like cheeseburgers and whatnot. I have personally tried almost every combination of pizza toppings that don't include vegetables (except for onions.) and always found their pizza to be crisp, cheesy, and with a decent sauce. They do a good job with the cheese/sauce/bread ratio and I have never come away from having two or three slices thinking that it was anything less than "good pizza." I adore their garlic knots and their mozzarella sticks. I don't care if they are purchased frozen and microwaved or however they prepare them, I will order one of those or the other whenever anyone in my place is ordering from there regardless if I am hungry or not. Case in point, my lady tried their Bacon and Bleu Cheese burger platter the other night and her sister got a Cheese Calzone. I had to throw in a small Mozzarella sticks even though I had eaten two hours prior. Those sticks lasted 22 minutes after they arrived even though I was trying to save them for the next day. The burger got two thumbs up from her and the calzone was given high marks for size, quantity, and taste. A good half of that did not get eaten that night! It's cool though, I'm still slicing off pieces of it two days later and tossing it into the toaster oven to snack on. In the hundreds of times I have had them deliver to me, I can honestly say they have made some kind of mistake or forgotten something less than three times and I have called once or twice in the last 7-8 years out of a hundred orders to ask how much longer will the order take. The reason for such a good percentage is honest appraisal of delivery times. They don't say "Thirty minutes" then have me calling them at the fifty minute mark and then again at the sixty minute mark. They give a good assessment on the time, and then they get there around that mark. Overall, this is a good local pizza place. Nothing overly pricey and the place does not try to be more than what it is. read more

Not as good as it used to be.. been a customer for years there's always that one guy with a really bad attitude.. there pizza now always taste uncooked read more

Without a doubt the best pizza in Patchogue. Ask them to put Sesame seeds on the crust, it's amazing. Always consistent, always the best.

This is our favorite pizza in town. We've lived in E Patchogue for 5 years and we have tried all the local pizzerias. They are generous with the toppings, the cheese is not greasy and they have sesame crust! We are regulars and have always been treated very courteously by the staff. The zeppolis are delicious, too. We are happy for them, but hate when they go on vacation and we have to try another shop. It never measures up. I make my own salad because theirs is just cucumbers, olives and tomatoes & I like a lot of veggies in my salad. We always order ahead, get extra sauce & reheat on our pizza stone! They are respectful of my food allergy. We highly recommend! read more

The pizza here is consistently good. The grandma vodka is lights out but all of their speciality pizzas are good. I think this is the best pizzeria in the area and I've been to them all numerous times read more

My husband and I started ordering from here when we moved to E. Patchogue and began trying multiple pizza places we have only had delivery as we only eat pizza on lazy nights. Though we have experienced some not so happy to take our order employees Majority if the time they are perfectly fine... I mean seriously who wants to take orders all day, I take no offense. The delivery men and women have always been super nice. They have great pizza though we ask for the crust well done. The pepperoni rolls are flipping delicious and the mozzarella stick YUM! TY PIzza Shoppe for making are lazy nights amazing! read more

Used to love going to this place It always had fresh food never had any problems this past year the times we have gone it has seriously gone downhill. Very disappointing sometimes they deliver sometimes they don't. The pizza never used to be soggy now it seems like it always is. read more

Great pizza, no a big chain that does not care about its customers, this is a owner who cares about the food

The pizza is delicious, the customer service definitely needs some help. It's a shame that the staff doesn't treat their customers well.

Best Pizza in town. Great Italian diners too. There honey mustard pizza is the best i have ever had. Nice staff and fair prices. Jeff read more

I absolutely love The Pizza Shoppe! For 10 years now I've driven past Papa Nicks in Bellport to have their food. The grandma pizza is the best around as well as their wings, salads and the gyros! I don't think I've ever had a bad meal there. Plus their prices are right! read more

The pizza was quite tasty, but the service was far mediocre. After arriving to the restaurant, the wait time was approximately three minutes. However, after waiting almost 20 minutes, it was still "one minute" after that. This would be understandable, however there were only two other customers in the restaurant (on a Monday night too). read more

The owner is really friendly but the staff is the most rude and pushy staff I've ever experienced. The delivery guy is a straight up jerk and takes forever and I live not even a block away. One time he forgot our garlic knots, we sent him back because he was so nasty taking our order, and then he gave them to us practically still dough (prob did it on purpose). Another time being physically in the shoppe a female worker put a customers slice on top of the oven before heating it up (prob is dusty, not where food should go, etc) after picking it up from the display tray with her bare hands. The guy saw and said "I'm outta here, thats disgusting." Manager if you're reading this the menu is great and the food is pretty good, but your staff could use some better customer service and friendliness! read more

I love the pizza Shoppe! Amazing food and the people that work here are the best. One of the best pizza spots on Long Island. Give it a shot you won't be disappointed read more

The Pizza Shoppe - a plate of food and drinks - Pizza Near Me - East Patchogue, New York

Mozzarella sticks are amongst the best I've had. They have a large selection of sandwiches and many different types of pizza to fit all tastes. They have a small dining room with big screen television where you can enjoy your meal. read more

Solid NY pizza. Good garlic knots and we love the white and buffalo chicken pizza.

This is our go to pizza place when we don't feel like driving.... I've always had a very pleasant experience. The pizza is always hot and tasty and the drivers are always polite and get here in the usual 45 minutes were told it will take. Thank you pizza shoppe, for delivering to our side of the tracks when your competitors down the road (closer to our house) say they don't go that far. read more

Giving them 4 stars for the amazing food and service they used to provide. Something has changed over the last two months; the food has been arriving cold, the taste of the pizza just isn't the same. I don't know if ingredients were changed, or distributors of said ingredients have changed, but it's not the same quality of food it used to be. Heartbroken that after 10 years of using them, I am now scouting other places for the same quality of pizza I once found here. read more