Very frustrating experience. I came from New York and took a detour on my way to Newark Airport specifically to visit this pickle shop because of the great reviews. I arrived about an hour after they were supposed to be open, but the store was closed with no sign on the door and no one there. I drove back again around noon after noticing the lights were on. I went inside and asked if they were open, and the gentleman said yes. Then a woman from a U-Haul vehicle yelled that they were not open and said that, because they are kosher, they could not sell anything until 1:00 p.m. I completely understand that businesses may have religious observances or adjusted hours, but those hours should be clearly posted online and on the door. After making two trips and receiving conflicting information, I was extremely frustrated. Unfortunately, I will not be trying to visit this location again. read more

A local, cozy pickle place in Teaneck/Bogota ... We can taste all of them !!!! We did try about 10 of them and made the final decision of getting 4 selections. Mediterranean mix Kalamata Jerken pickle Pickled mushrooms Love them all !!!! read more

See all

The pickles were absolutely amazing! The person who assisted me was very knowledgeable.

Some of the products are very good and some are meh. Highly overpriced! You will find them at farmer s'markets.

I have lived in Texas for 30 yrs but grew up in up on the east coast. There are some things you just can't get in Texas. A very well done sour pickle is hard to find. My online order was a gift from heaven. I bought the horseradish and traditional full sour and both are amazing. Their sun dried tomatoes and olives are worth an order. No longer do I need to miss out. Thanks. read more

This place is overall unbelievable. It's a one of a kind noshing store right in Teaneck. They keep coming up with new recipes as far as the Pickles, Pickled Condiments, Olives and there killer product " KRELISH". It's everything you want in one. And love that they totally expanded there candy line. They now have a full line of jelly belly, fine chocolates from Ashers, Koppers chocolate & many varieties of Halvah. Let's talk Platters: they do anything from Pickles, olives & Candy. I always pre order, my platters cause on Friday it's like Platter Heaven!!!! And Leslie is always a pleasure on the phone or in person, actually all the staff is especially the guys there always with a joke and such great salesman.... I walked in for a pint of New Pickles and walked out with two big bags full of goodies. Right on Pickle Licious. Please Never Leave!!!! read more

The Pickle Shoppe - Specialty Food Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

The best pickles in the world!!! The staff is very nice and helpful, and their selection is huge.

Be careful what you order. I ordered Sweet horseradish chip. and was given something else which was wicked hot. Unfortunately, I didn't find out till I got home., I don't live locally. When you call no one answer the phone and message are not returned when left. Also, they sold the business, not original owners. read more

Cute place in Teaneck Super friendly and knowledgeable staff who offer rhelp with just about everything. THey treat everyone like family and genuinely want to please every customer. They have pickles and pickles and pickles. ThEy also have organic flavored olive oils and a selection of homemade chocolates. Cute idea and most definitely unique. read more

I must say I also got pickles from Harlem at the farmers market and in the Peekskill farmers market. Same treatment! It was a younger guy in Harlem, a guy in Peekskill also, not friendly and picked out the smallest pickles against me asking for bigger ones. Again I traveled from the Bronx hoping g for a better experience. I must say I miss Guss pickles, I was treated very nicely! Also tasting wasn't an issue. The pickle guys were extremely nice and great salespeople. Also the Hospitals Farmers market on Pelham pkwy very nice... my last time trying picklicious. I will still to who is nice to me and grabbing a few quarts from Katz Deli... which are Gus's Pickles.. read more

So I originally came across this place through an outdoor event in Ridgewood. The guy was super friendly and let us try different pickles. I ended up buying some and loved them. I cut some up for an event I had and everyone raves about them. I went to the store in teaneck to buy more. The new pickle and hot/spicy are my favorite! The store is cute and the lady is nice there. They offer a lot more than just pickles! Chocolates which were surprisingly fresh. I bought a small bag just in case and they were not old at all! The jelly rings and creamy peanut butter are my favorites and i love how they have chocolate espresso. They also offer olives and have a little olive bar, they have a pickle bar to for sliced pickles, olive oil, hummus, and more! I will keep coming back! Always delicious!!!!!!! read more

See all

I love visiting Pickle Licious at the Montclair Farmer's Market on Saturdays. The dill pickles are delicious! There are so many varieties of pickles and the staff is excellent at helping me decide which to purchase. read more

Wow.. What a disappointing shopping experience. If you want to walk out feeling angry and treated like garbage run to this store when this lady is here. I have ordered from here before online but noticed they were in driving distance in Teaneck. I thought to myself well I'm running low and I can pick up my kids from school and make it before 4PM and re-stock on some kosher dills which my kids love. As soon as we walk in the lady at the store says she'll be right with us - cool. She comes over after a very short wait and I ask if we can have samples? She says they don't do samples anymore. I kind of get it but also I've never been told no samples if I were buying - I mean even if the charged for a sample so I can try something before buying it would be better than being treated like some sort of sub human beggar. I say "Okay but I want to buy a gallon and I really don't want to buy a gallon if I can't try it". Her response is - we only allow samples of chips. Me..... Okay but I really can't have 1 sample? I really want to buy a gallon. Her - okay fine but it has to be a small one - (she proceeds to dig into the barrel to ensure she finds the smallest pickle she can find) I try it and I ask for a gallon. I look over at the hot and spicy and ask about sampling more - again she says chips are okay but.. At this point I'm pretty annoyed so I ask my daughter if she wants to try the sweet chips. She does - and I ask for a quart of those. Honestly - just why? It's not even what she said but how she said it. I felt completely uninvited in this store and will never go back again. The two places I buy from are here and Doc Pickle. I'll be exclusively Doc Pickle going forward. Unfortunately we really needed pickles since my kids love them so I sucked it up and paid for it and walked up. To the rude lady - According to some other reviews it seems like this is just how it is for some of us. read more

The Pickle Shoppe - Gallon of Kosher Dill & Quart of Sweet Chips - Specialty Food Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

Ok - I NEVER thought I'd walk into a store who sells pickles! I've always been the one to just buy em at my local deli or grocery store, but I'm so glad I ran across this spot! You can taste the difference in the pickles that they sell and the quality in every bite! Plus checking in with yelp can get you a "pickle on a stick" ... while compared to a regular grocery store, they're more expensive, they are worth every ounce of the bite! Go check em out and don't forget to check in on yelp! read more

The Pickle Shoppe - Free pickle on a stick for checking in! - Specialty Food Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

Great place that meets all of your pickle needs. When you approach the door, the glorious scent of pickles wafts through before you open it. For a pickle lover like myself, this is purely paradise. They have such a wide variety to choose from that you can't help but want to buy everything. They also have olives, chips, candy, etc. The staff is helpful with getting you what you need and they're always courteous. Their sampling area is useful for when you're not sure what you want. read more

I'm conflicted about this review. To start off I loved the way that they were packaged while it took me awhile to open they ensured that no spills would occur during transport. Now for the review... I feel that the pickles tasted that way they were supposed but I am not a fan of the horseradish ones. I expected crispy, crunchy, sour and then a kick of spicy. I got the salty not sour, a small crunch but none of the spicy and I didn't enjoy the after taste. I can see why some people enjoy this item but it just wasn't for me. But I will definitely try another flavor in due time. read more

Not only are the pickles fantastic. Not only do they have more varieties than one ever could have imagined existed. They are also really good and nice people! I thought I had lost my wallet at their stand at the Montclair Farmer's market and Carla helped me for THREE DAYS looking for it!! She called, emailed, and texted the owner of the farmer's market, followed up with me multiple times, went out of her way to be helpful and empathetic. I haven't experienced such friendly, helpful-when-you-don't-have-to-be, genuine kindness in so long. The guys at the farmer's market in Montclair are also so nice. Everyone should try to be more like the people at Pickle Licious. read more

Love this place. Yea their pickles are amazing, but they have such a great selection of other pickled foods as well. I can eat pounds of their pickles, all of their brines are awesome. The women that was there when I went was very helpful, answering all my questions, and giving me tons of free samples. I will be back for more! read more

Best pickles around. Large selection of pickles, olives, papers etc. We love the sweet chili chips. Everyone that works there is really nice and helpful. They usually have samples of all the items so you can taste them. read more

Pickle Licious is definitely an equal to, in some ways better, than any NYC pickle like Guss'. Whatever style (whole, chips or spears) or flavor profile (sour, 3/4, 1/2, new, kosher, sweet, etc.), we have not tasted any pickles that were not worthy with right amount of crunch. Our favorites are the whole 3/4 sour and full sour, but that's just a taste preference. Pickle Licious has excellent cured olives which we also love. Sweet tooth? They have great handmade chocolates and other sweets. We were offered samples of whatever we asked for and the staff seemed quite helpful. The Pickle Lady might seem a bit grumpy, but not unfriendly. read more

These pickles are like the old days of barrel pickles, when you got a pickle for a nickel. The price has changed, but the taste and flavor is still the same. I buy the sour pickles buy the gallon. They're great. Thank you! read more

The management of this place is just awesome. I ran into an issue with a gift certificate I got from a friend for Father's Day but even though the business took days to solve it, at the end they fixed it. They will go far and beyond to solve any issue you may bump in. Can't wait to place my online order. read more

This place was a pleasant surprise when I friend and I ventured to NJ from some burgers at White Manna down the road. Robyn talked to us for a while about pickles, and the whole place definitely smells like all kinds of pickles and olives and stuff, but it was really really cool. They also sell all kinds of penny candy and honey sticks and neat things like that. Robyn gave us both a pickle-on-a-stick for dropping by and they were delicious :D read more

See all

These guys came to 23rd street in New York and had a stand open and they had all the pickles in buckets and smaller containers lined up in front of them enabling potential customers to give each a try. The first one I tried was the Sweet Chili Chips and it was absolutely delicious. It is a little spicy but not too overwhelming. I ended up buying a $5 container. Besides pickles they also have olives, roasted pepper, horse radish and some other pickles snacks. read more

The Pickle Shoppe - Pickleeeeees! - Specialty Food Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

If you are a pickle lover, this is your paradise. Used to see these guys at the Montclair farmer's market and they were super friendly, let you try samples, and I became obsessed with their horseradish pickles. Finally went to the actual store. I lost that special feeling for the horseradish pickles but fell in love with the 'new' or half-sour pickles. SO GOOD. They also have a bunch of other pickled items there as welll as snacks! I ended up getting a mix of various olives for my dad because he is a huge olive lover. I can't stand olives but he loved 'em, particularly the garlic stuffed olives. Cute little store. Friendly staff. They just have weird hours so it's not super convenient to get there. read more

Totally awesome in every way The best pickles ever !! Reminds me of Gus on the lower east side Staff super friendly and helpful Lots of delicious and creative condiments ( olive pastes, tapenade, humus, roasted garlic, sundried tomato) list goes on and on and each one is more delicious than the other Candy section very cute with both old time and new varieties Specialty oils and salts are amazing to cook with Just an all around fun place and I always walk out with a smile read more

Seems like a place like Pickle Licious can only exist in this part of the country. I love pickles but I never knew that you could have a selection of pickles like this. My first trip was somewhat intimidating. Luckily there were other customers in the shop and I got to observe the process. The cashier/salesperson helps you get whatever you want. So don't even think about helping yourself. They have barrels of pickles near the door and I got a sample of a few: Kosher, Half Sour, Spicy. The spicy was good, though more sour than I expected. The 100% winner for me was the Half Sour and I've been back multiple times for them. These remind me of the way you get them in Japan: from a food stall on the street, served on a stick. They're slightly pickled with salt but not all the way so they retain some fresh crunch and are more clearly cucumber than pickle. They are perfection. Speaking of on a stick, they will serve you a pickle on a stick if you just want a small treat and you're in the area. Note that they have a $10 min credit charge so if you want a pickle on a stick then bring cash (or check in on Yelp!). In addition to pickles they have pickled tomatoes, sauerkraut, a variety of olives, and bulk candy. I loved Pickle Licious and their offerings so much I got my dad a 3 month subscription where they send different pickles and olives to his home in Las Vegas. Highly recommend checking this place out! read more

Their Full Sour Pickles are the hands down best pickles I have ever had. Outstanding!!!

Surprised I missed rating Pickle Licious! What an absolute charming place for goodies and treats! I have a huge place in my heart for pickles and olives... if you do too, I advise you to check this place out. and WAIT UNTIL YOU DO. Your mind will be blown away by the array of products they have to offer. I love eating Pickle Licious olives, hummus, mushrooms, pickles, jellies (and more!) as movie snacks and my everyday items. I go there to buy pickings for parties, and I even go there to purchase gifts for people. Once you try their homemade...UM ANYTHING, you'll fall in love. They have options for all types of pallets. The service is always incredibly homey and knowledgeable and the product is always pickleLICIOUS! The productions are pricier than a jar at your local supermarket, and rightfully so. You cant get their flavor anywhere else. I'm headed to stop by this week to get my pickle fix in. New pickles, I'm coming for you...! read more

Every once in a while a business presents, for itself, an entirely appropriate name; something that sums them up and accurately describes what they do or sell. Pickle Licious is one of these businesses. They sell pickles that are simply delicious. Other stuff that would all pretty much fall into the same category, too. I guess that Pickle And Olive Licious would be rather tedious to pronounce as well as create a difficulty with signage but, rest assure, they are the real deal. I HIGHLY recommend their horse radish pickles as my fav but no matter what you buy here, they simply cannot be beat. Kudos. read more

Finally had a chance to checkout Pickle Licious and I was not disappointed! This is a great local business with quality products. My sister found a sweet groupon and we were able to use that for our purchase. They have a wide variety of pickles, spreads, and olives which are almost all available to try. The service was excellent, the woman at the counter was so welcoming and helpful. I personally loved the classic sour pickles and the lemon mediterranean olive mix. Wasn't a huge fan of the sun dried tomato hummus, just didn't taste right but A for effort! Overall it is a little pricier than I imagined but it is local and homemade so worth the price for me. Check in on Yelp and get a free pickle on a stick! read more

The Pickle Shoppe - Yummy pickles! Couldn't wait to get home to eat them! - Specialty Food Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

Pickle heaven - if you're near the GW bridge, it's worth a stop. I've loved their pickles since they were at the Morristown Farmer's Market, getting a gallon of pickles every month. The half sour, 3/4 sour, and kosher dills were always good as hell, and at reasonable prices. Here, much more inventory, with lots of other great food options. This time, I got some roasted garlic as well - damn good. For people who love the old style barreled pickles, anything picked, and want a true pickle experience, this is a must visit. It costs more than generic grocery pickles, because it's a much better product - it's like comparing a beautiful aged ribeye steak with a $2lb loin cut - quality is worth the price. If you love pickles, you'll love Pickle Licious. Everything is sampleable as well, so yes you should come here. read more

I always buy multiple pints of everything at the Pleasantville farmers market. My absolute favorite is the green olives stuffed with garlic. Great flavor right amount of saltiness. I like a little heat. The mixed hot olives and the whole Hot pickles are amazing. To combined spicy hot and flavor is majestic. Wine, a wedge of Parmesan cheese and those hot pickles and olives are a great combo. I have not traveled to jersey to visit but I see them every week at the farmers market. read more

The Pickle Shoppe - Pleasantville Farmers Market - Specialty Food Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

See all

Picklesicle. A pickle on a popsicle stick. BEST IDEA, EVER. And the nice pickle man gave it to me for free to celebrate their first day at the farmer's market-- they're selling at various farmer's markets throughout NY and NJ till September. Find me every Saturday with a picklesicle. You can smell these babies (and me, consequently) from a mile away. read more

A little pricey but worth the splurge. Very friendly staff any time I've gone and always helpful. Re-use your pickle container and get a dollar of the next fill. read more

The Pickle Shoppe - When I feel a bit daring I'll try this - Specialty Food Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

I loved this place, so homey and comfortable. My girlfriend took me here for a valentines day present and I was impressed with there selections, from the full dills to the spicy butter tips, it gets an extra plus for there tasty gourmet popcorn and honey suckers. read more

Store was closed. We had a pickle emergency. The shop keeper opened up just for us. **GOOD SERVICE** She helped us pick out the perfect pickles. We got a pint of sweet Horseradish pickles. Life changing. Sweet like gherkins, dry like half sour, but with a kick from the horseradish. Pickle-licious also has delicious eclectic jams, pastes, candies and nuts. Plus they have some side salads. Prices are higher than jarred, but you're getting crisp gourmet pickles and supporting a local business. I'll gladly pay a couple extra bucks for that. read more

Pickles to honey to mushrooms to hummus...all of that and more can be found in pickle licious. All of it is home made, or from local businesses. If theres something you want to try, dont be afraid to ask. everything is fresh, reasonably priced, and packed with intense flavors. Anything from sweet to jalepeno to sour. They even have various sizes of containers to take home and catering trays! suich a great spot, with very helpful and polite people whom work here. read more

Anticipating the Jewish holidays, I was just planning the "when" of my annual pilgrimage to Pickle Licious when I received the unexpected yet magical email offering garlic junkies like me up to two 2-for-1 $25 coupons at PL... OMG - bliss! I must confess that I am a "PL" groupie from way back. I have followed them now through three locations and many a near-weekly farmers' market (not to mention the soon closing DePiero's...). In short, my extended family goes crazy over PL's sour tomatoes and full sours (memories of very sweet RH's past...!) Anyway, I want to report that the owner did a most generous thing in allowing me to use my two coupons at once. I realize that the point of offering the discount while requiring multiple visits is to encourage separate visit/spending opportunities - and I can only assure the owner that her purpose was achieved. I will be back. I'm a regular (whether in the store or elsewhere). I love PL's quality products and I tell everyone I meet. So while I am not proposing that others take advantage of the owner's generosity of spirit (and my breach of the clear terms of the coupons), I do want to acknowledge her kindness and share the goodwill it generated in me. I'd like to publicly say "thank you" for making my pre-Rosh Hashanah week just that much easier. One more thing...the coupon gave me an unexpected treat in that it encouraged me to purchase products I have not historically tried...I usually just stick with the aforesaid sours/sour tomatoes. But today I also bought horseradish sweet pickles, some pitted kalamatas and the sliced banana peppers. While you can sample them there, it's just not the same. They are simply delish. Thanks PL for a wonderful (and much appreciated) deal! read more

Stopped in here on a Sunday afternoon in search of the full sour pickles of my youth. I have been buying them from the vendor at the local farmers markets but they were never quite the same. After reading some of the reviews on Google and here on Yelp I decided to give this place a try. I must say I was not disappointed. Not only did I find the pickles that I was looking for but I picked up the song peppers and garlic for the wife. Wow I saw on the website that they do a number to farmers markets around the state , oddly enough they don't appear to go to any of the ones locally here in South Bergen. But that's okay , Teaneck is not that far for a ride on a Sunday afternoon. The woman who owns the place was extremely helpful and pleasant. The prices were in line with those I pay at the flea market so I have to say that they are good. Bottom line , I'll be back. read more