I have been to Coterie Market a couple of times and have enjoyed everything I've tried. While I'm…read morenot into speciality coffees, I know a lot of people who frequent this place love their unique creations. I have really only tried their baked goods. The shop is quant, with a lot of rotating items--both drinks and baked goods. They have a little gift shop inside with a variety of trinkets and such too. The atmosphere is cute and unique, there is nothing like it in midtown for sure. They do have indoor seating and I can see this being a good study spot. Their hours are also decent as they close at 5, which is later than some spots in the area. The service is good and the workers are really friendly. They offer great suggestions and are really pleasant.
I have tried a couple of items including their chocolate chip cookies, banana bread, and other seasonal treats. The can say the banana bread is easily the best I've ever had. Super moist with a cinnamon streusel-like topping, with ample amounts of chocolate chunks, and bananas--DIVINE. If this is available when you go, don't hesitate, just order it. Their chocolate chip cookies are good, but nothing too special. I think they use an all-white sugar base, whereas I prefer more of a brown butter type of cookie. They are thin, with crispy edges, and a good amount go chocolate chunks. While all the baked goods are great here--they are on the pricier side...especially considering how big they are. While the banana bread is a larger portion, it comes in around $5 for a slice. The cookies are almost $4 per cookie. I think their baked goods are really great, but I honestly can't justify the price...
Overall, I think Coterie Market is great little shop in Midtown. They offer an eclectic, fun menu that caters to the college town. They host a lot of events and will collab with other businesses as well. I really want to check some of these events out at some point. The baked good are of good quality, but are pricey. But I definitely think the banana bread is a highlight here and shouldn't be missed. I will probably come back at some point and check out there new items. Worth a try if you haven't been!