Outstanding ribeye! Excellent service. Don't know what else to say. If you're in Bainbridge, this is a must stop for evening meal. Quiet atmosphere with great music playing at a volume conducive to engaging conversation. Knowledgeable waiter who was attentive and efficient. Will definitely visit again on my next business trip anywhere near Bainbridge. read more

What an "American" experience! We came to this beautiful Georgian city because we evacuated for Hurricane Ian, and what a gracious city it is. We chose The American for dinner, which was stunning from the building, atmosphere, staff, and food! All of those mentioned above a 10+! Our server, Haley, went above and beyond helping us when she heard our story and helped us get a room at the Willis Park Hotel. We thank them for the kind hospitality, the comforting atmosphere, and the top of line service and food! All hail their kitchen!! read more

We stopped here on a recent trip from Atlanta to Tallahassee. What a cute little town with a wonderful holiday spirit. The restaurant was all that I had read about. Very warm and inviting atmosphere and excellent service. The food....yum! Started with the tomato pie, very good. Then we had the cornbread fried chicken, the filet and a cheese burger. Each of us was super happy with our meals. Only bad thing was very weak coffee after meal, I should have said something, probably a fluke! We look forward to returning, was really great!! read more

Wow. The food quality is exceptional. We went for a client dinner and so we tried many appetizers before the entrees. The barrel cut filet was wood fired and beautifully prepared. There's not much in Bainbridge, GA, but I would go out of my way to eat at The American again. Oh, and well done on the wine list. I love Orin Swift wines and you guys have a great selection! read more

Always enjoy eating at The American. Great food and wonderful atmosphere. My favorite is the steak salad as well as the cornbread

What a nice little stop in Bainbridge on our way back home from the beach! We were pleasantly surprised by this charming local restaurant. We ordered the iron skillet corn bread to start and it was amazing! Our family ordered burgers, steak salad & the crab cake... all were well seasoned and delicious! Look forward to our next drive through Bainbridge! read more

The American - View from our table out in the park! - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

What a surprise in downtown Bainbridge! I am in town for work & was invited to dinner by my clients. I wasn't expecting to find such a charming, delicious restaurant in Bainbridge! Service is exceptional, ambience is top notch- a true treasure in downtown Bainbridge! A MUST! read more

See all

Had a nice experience here on Friday night. Food was great and server was friendly. The space itself is very nice but a little stark feeling and would benefit from the touch of a traditional interior designer to "warm it up" a bit. There were issues with timing but the manager/owner was extremely gracious and came out at the end and apologized. The server was aware of the issues but rather than speak to us and acknowledge the problem he waited for the manager to do it at the very end. We were in suspense if actually anything was going to be acknowledged but we're very pleasantly surprised. They should have a more proactive approach when problems occur which I told them . I definitely recommend the American and think they are a spectacular addition to the new thriving downtown Bainbridge Town Square and hope they will use my comments constructively as they are intended. read more

We always love going to the American. The menu changes so it is not always the same thing. I love their mint sweet tea. Highly recommend.

A great lunch spot. An amazing date night place. The perfect place to host a small gathering. The atmosphere is awesome. The food even better. read more

The American surpassed our expectations! The service was fast and super friendly. The food was awesome! Fresh, hot, quick! We got the cornbread, Hawaiian ribeye, filet, & crab cakes. Everything was perfect! We ended with the banana cream pie.. oh my gosh!!!! Divine!!! Highly recommend!!! read more

See all

Amazingly friendly staff! One of (what I'm guessing was) the managers and our waiter offered us a dessert and drinks for my sister-in-law's bridal shower. The food is absolutely amazing and the aesthetic of the restaurant is beautiful. read more

The American - The Steak Salad - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

Atmosphere is absolutely amazing. It's a one of a kind, I've never been to a restaurant like it. It's like stepping back in time! The food is fresh and local. The staff is always so nice. The only thing that isn't my favorite is that the menu does rotate at times so what you get one visit you may not get another. I can't complain I'm sure that comes with being a restaurant that serves fresh and local which is much more commendable in my opinion. Will go EVERY time I'm in town. It's definitely a stop you HAVE to make if you're ever passing through. read more

Seriously the best dinner I've had in a minute. Salad was just a side salad, but it was interesting too 5. Their ranch is something special. Get the pork chops. Share them with someone. If you can eat them both, you're malnourished. Lol read more

An interesting find in a tiny little town in Georgia! It is obviously named "The American" for a reason, patriotic music, flags, hunting lodge fur and antlers, and imposing patriot portraits are hanging on the wall. It seems that this is where people go to eat when the average pizza/bar burger/bar food won't cut it. Mostly older couples, quiet families, no TVs, just food and company. Low light in the evening accompanied by table candlelight. A few awkward kids on their "Friday Date Night". The food was surprisingly good, again, was a great find in such a small town! The lasagna was OUTSTANDING. Really, I don't usually eat it as it can be embellished with peppers/spice/nonsense, but this was simple, decadent, not spicy, wonderful lasagna. The crab cake entree is SMALL, would not fill a hungry person up, so if you want a small meal, go for it. But if not, you will be left hungry. Fried green tomatoes, was my first experience eating them, not bad! All in all, given the choices, this is probably the only place I would eat at if I came through again! read more

Our first time eating here today. They are newly opened but you could not tell by the way everything was handled. This place is just what Bainbridge needs. Love the old classic building with old bricks. The booths have a high back on them and very comfortable. Very quiet and relaxing. The cornbread with honey on it was very good and southern. The buns that our Burger were on tested very fresh. If you want a classy date lunch or dinner, this is the place for you. We will be back for a dinner meal. I will post some pictures. read more

See all

Causal dinning with a American flair. Great menu and beverage selection. You want go wrong. read more

The American - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

See all

Came in from Atlanta today for a photoshoot and was recommended to eat here. Oh my goodness, this is the best southern food restaurant you will ever have the pleasure to eat at! Between the atmosphere, the cornbread, steak and lavender ice cream, you couldn't ask for a more amazing meal!! The service is outstanding and the waitress was super sweet. All of our food came out quickly. I highly recommend this restaurant and of course, the cornbread! read more

The American - Best cornbread ever!! - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

See all

What a gem! The American is still newly opened but your experience will tell you that they've been perfecting the experience for years. The menu is simple but elegant, everything from steak and chops to a small but relevant wine list. Don't let my use of the words simple and small fool you or keep you from dining here. Having had the privilege to dine at some amazing places across the country, few have the balance of quality and ambiance without pretentiousness that The American has. On my list of Best Steaks Ever, The American's filet is in my top 5, easily. Fork cutting tender and amazingly seasoned. To top it off, Payton (my server) was attentive and helpful without being overbearing. He was perfect and made the dinner so too. Don't miss the opportunity to enjoy this wonderful addition to Bainbridge's dining choices. You will not be disappointed. read more

Cornbread croutons were amazing Great fresh food, with exceptional presentation Great selection for everyone read more

Was passing thru Bainbridge and saw The American on Yelp. A friend of mine said is a great place. It TRULY is! The American decor is fun and tasteful. The menu looked great. I asked our waitress, Lindsey, if the chef could provide a plant-based meal for me. In a few moments he came out and spoke to me and offered to prepare something special for me. And HE DID! Thank you Tyler for your the attention to my needs. We will be back! read more

The American - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

Great start! The American recently opened and I couldn't wait to go and dig in. They have done a great job with the interior of their location on the square. Nice hand picked beer and wine list; great appetizers. I had the Hawaiian Ribeye which was done perfectly with the macque choux on the side. And the Key Lime Pie was out of sight. The owners Heather and Chef Tyler have put their hearts and souls into this, and it shows. read more

Number 2 in my top 5 restaurants of all time! Great atmosphere and great food! Must get a wedge salad because their homemade croutons are the best! read more

I drove through this town just to check this place out and I was not disappointed. I wish I could have tried more things on the menu, and the thing that really brought me in is the fresh tomato pie. I have made these before, and eaten them all over the south, but nothing beats this thing. It was light, buttery and the tomatoes were firm and sweet. I also have the heirloom tomato stack which was so fresh and the tomatoes were well chilled and firm. Even the side of kale salad was super yummy! No doubt I will stay here next time I work this region! read more

See all

I give it 4 stars because it was pretty tasty. But once seated the service was subpar. I ordered the filet, with potatoes and sweet tea. read more

The American - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

See all

When I think of Bainbridge I think of The American. The hint of peppers in their cheddar & jack cheese cornbread, juicy tenderloin on my wedge salad, creamy homemade blue cheese dressing, and a smooth glass of wine...Afterwards, I recommend taking an order of corn bread to go for the most amazing croutons you will ever put on a salad! read more

Visiting the area from the northeast. Had dinner at this outstanding restaurant upon friend's recommendation. An absolutely delightful comfortable upscale restaurant. The owner is highly visible and a terrific host. It was am epicurean delight Wonderful steaks, succulent pork, triggerfish was the special-incredible. All produce is locally grown. Scrumptious desserts...goat cheesecake was a smashing hit. Nice wine list and craft beers. It's a winner. Don't miss this one! read more

Did not have to think out a five star rating as a casual Saturday lunch encounter. Atmosphere is warm, inviting, charming and comfortable on the well refurbished downtown square buildings. Service was good to excellent, with our official server having the best personality. Tomato pie, crescent sandwich, and wedge salad were top notch. I don't think there are any fails with this establisment menu. Most of the lunch menu is $11-$12. Totally worth it. If nothing else, go for the Key lime pie. The best I have ever had, anywhere, including the Keys. Crust, filling and cream are independently unique, and perfect work perfectly together for this pie. One piece is rich enough to serve two. read more

Hmmm...Am here now and was just served laziest salad I have ever seen which consists of a quarter of a head of lettuce sliced off with 8 little cubes of tomato and a few croutons. WTF? No excuse. I was in the mood for a steak so I ordered the chipoltle ribeye since plain old unadulterated steak was not offered on the menu. The steak tasted too salty. Their seasoning squandered all the natural deliciousness of a ribeye cooked medium. The side of fries were good but a good baked potato would have been more satisfying. They do have some good local GA brews which helped dull the pain of my disappointment after such high hopes that I had after reading all the glowing reviews. read more

This was a great place. The food was fantastic. The tomato pie and cornbread appetizers were fantastic. Our entrees were all very good. This is just a lovely restaurant great food. read more

It has been quite some time since I've been here and it's just as fantastic as the first time! Service was great, food was great, atmosphere was great. Fantastic!!!! read more

This place is so darn cute, just like the town of Bainbridge in general. My husband and I had a wonderful brunch here. Service was great- good old southern hospitality. The atmosphere inside is really adorable, with old paintings of various historical figures and homey southern decor. I had a steak salad that was sooo delicious, and the staff was willing to alter some of the ingredients per my specific dietary request. I'll be back! read more

The American has got to be the best 5- star-ish restaurant in the south Georgia area! Super high quality food, made to order and very friendly staff. They have gone above and beyond each time we visit. They're a little pricey - but when you get what you pay for, that's just part of the deal. Well worth it!! read more

We completely and thoroughly enjoyed our lunch here today! From start to finish, the best food we have enjoyed in quite a while. We got the best server ever his name was Dylan. Service was exceptional! Definitely worth the drive from anywhere in the Southeast. read more

FANTASTIC!! We stopped here on a drive through Bainbridge after reading positive but older reviews on Yelp. Decor, service and food were all excellent! I had the grilled chicken sandwich with grilled asparagus and my husband had the Cajun shrimp/sausage/grits. We highly recommend eating here!! (don't forget the goat cheese and strawberry cheesecake-it's heaven on a plate ) read more

The food is amazing! This is great for a date night but not really for the kids my kids were too picky for stuff there because they were not into trying new thinks. Everything on their menu is from local farms and tastes amazing can't wait to go with my hasband again. read more

So me & my family went one night. Was very surprised at how pricey EVERYTHING was. The four of us just ordered hamburgers & fries. It was 60$!!! I mean..come on. Decatur County is about one of the poorest counties in the state of Ga & you have your prices like we are in Alpharetta or something.. The hamburgers were just ok. It definitely was not worth the price. I've had MUCH BETTER hamburgers at Beef O'Bradys or hell, even Red Robin. You really need to lower your prices. We won't be back. read more

I'm sure this has the potential and we were here on a busy Friday night but the service was terrible and the food was cold. Two of us ordered burgers. I will say the meat was delicious and cooked exactly as ordered. But the buns were ice cold as were the fries. We were very disappointed. read more

Yummy lunch ...Generous serving of tasty pimento cheese with pepper jelly; the tomato pie was flaky and tasty!

Delicious food great service. Try the tomato pie. Very charming and quaint but plenty of room.