As someone who has been reviewing for Yelp for a long time, this has to be the absolute worst dining experience I've ever had. I mean that very seriously. On Saturday, 2/28, I came into the restaurant at 6:15pm with a group of 6. Looking around the restaurant, there were only 3 tables taken. The Hostess wanted to put us a table, but it wouldn't fit us all. We asked her where to sit and she told us to decide on seating. We had to suggest to put a table together and started to move it ourselves, then she helped. Just odd because we had no idea if they had a table to seat us. While waiting for the server, the table in front of us asked for to-go boxes and was told they only have the bottoms, no lids. She brought plastic wrap to cover their leftovers. They were not happy and left without a lot of their leftovers. Our service came out and was very sweet. She honestly was the nicest person at that restaurant and she deserves to go somewhere that she can make better money. She told us they only had beer and wine, but only a few on the wine list. Sometimes if it was asked for, they said they didn't have it. I stuck to a Coke. We ordered as follows: Me: Loaded Baked Potato (yes that's it.) Person 2: wedge salad Person 3: cornbread skillet Person 4 and 5 had burgers. One had cheddar cheese with everything on it. The other had everything BUT pickles. We waited about an hour for our food. Person 5's burger came out and the fries were cold. I'm not meaning lukewarm, I mean COLD. Like out a fridge. They hadn't even been cooked all the way. Person 4's burger came out without cheese. Both of those were sent back to get that fixed. Person 4's burger came back with a piece of half melted (what looked like) American cheese on the bottom of the burger and the burger was BURNT. I mean, hockey puck burnt. When the fries were sent back, we could hear the cook SCREAMING AND THROWING THINGS, yelling that we "weren't right" and he "had just took those up". The server even felt them and agreed with us. My baked potato came out hard. I couldn't really even eat it. It was hard, bland and it was covered in sour cream, even the outside. A runner came over to bring some salt and pepper and I asked her if she wouldn't mind letting us talk to a manager. Everyone there said I was polite in asking, as we just wanted to tell her what was going on, not trying to get anything free. When I asked, she threw her hands up in the air, slapped her hips, rolled her eyes and stomped away. The people around us even looked at her. They also could hear the cook yelling. We did see another couple send their food back as well while we were waiting. The manager comes over and when we tell her everything, she tells us she agrees and that she's working on getting better help, as we could see what she was working with there. We just asked her for the check and asked to go. We hear the manager try to talk to the team and the cook begins to scream and talk down to her. Then, he came out and stared at our table. If looks could kill, we would all be dead. The thing is- burgers there are $18. We didn't get anything hard to make but only the salad and the cornbread were fit to eat. They did comp our meal, but we continued to ask them to let us pay. Instead, we ended up giving the money to the server. She can only do what she can and she was so sweet. I do have multiple people who will attest to everything that happened. That was the whole experience. We walked outside and immediately went to get something else to eat. We came to the American because this was our first time in town and we had heard great things about it! Of course, we had seen it on TV as well, so we were very excited. The next night, another couple we knew went there and had the same experience. She was the only table in there and they still took over an hour and her food was terrible. This is absolutely so disappointing. The American used to be THE destination down here but now, it's the one everyone is telling people NOT to go to. We talked to our hotel host and they said they wished we would have asked because they would have told us to stay away. It's a shame. I really hope they can get some new people in there who care about food and making it good! I'd love to come back if they're able to improve and change my review. I do have 5 other people who are willing to attest to this, so as much as I wish it was an exaggeration, it's not. read more

See all

THis restaurant is leading the restoration of downtown Bainbrige. We had a very pleasant dinner here with a dozen of my wife's family members. The space was beautiful and open. Good drink selections with both local and more faraway craft options for beer. Elevated Southern/Georgia fare on the menu. For appetizers, try the cornbread and heirloom tomato pie. You can get quality fried chicken, pork chop, and grits here. I had the Pecan Crusted Idaho Trout. The sauce was bit cloying but the fish was tasty. Service was quick and competent, especially with a large group. Definitely one of the best dining options in downtown, and right next door to the brewery. read more

We had a reservation for 6:30 for prom and we got there at 6:20 and all the chairs were up and no one was there

Beautiful location and atmosphere, good service and very clean , very good food. A very special place. read more

See all

The food was excellent! Anyone that comes here has got to try the Tomato Pie! Wow! Every meal here was amazing! Cooked to perfection by a great chef we met. Our service was great, thank you Paulette! Situated right downtown in the square, just beautiful. read more

See all

The quality of food has declined significantly! Canned soup and bland pasta...my first experience with this restaurant in 2024, was very positive. Went yesterday, and its a shell! Don't go!! read more

Love this place. Great service. Great food. We love visiting Bainbridge and shopping after

The American was recommended to us by everyone when arriving in town. Another prime location, located right on the square downtown. The hostess stand seemed slow and unorganized but we eventually had a table. The place wasn't too busy when we arrived at 6pm but it took the 3 hostesses about 5-10min looking at their seating chart to make a decision. By the time we left around 8pm, there was a line out the door. Our server, Dustin, was fantastic. His knowledge of the menu and southern hospitality truly showed. He made a ton of recommendations before we made a decision. We started with a bottle of wine before we both ordered the Hawaiian Ribeye. They let the meat marinate in pineapple, garlic, and ginger for 48 hours before cooking and it truly showed. The flavor was sweet but not overpowering and we both loved it. I had a side of brussel sprouts and mashed potatoes and both of those were good but nothing special. I'm not sure if I'm a fan of the brussel sprouts being chopped up. Overall, a cool historic building revitalized as an inviting restaurant. There isn't a bar to sit at but they had a drink list. The wine list is nothing special as the only cab options were crazy expensive or on their limited list that weren't anything out of the ordinary. Our server was great and the food was delicious. read more

The American - Hawaiian Ribeye, Brussel Sprouts, and Mashed Potatoes - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

See all

Took my son to lunch. We were greeted by a hostess with a frown. Limited menu for lunch. Ordered the pimento cheese which was very ordinary. The tomato pie was nothing more than gloppy cheese in a greasy pie crust with "2" tomato slices on top. My son ordered a pricey steak that looked good, cooked nicely but had the flavor of old meat. Definitely did not live up to the hype. The upside was the attentive and pleasant waitress and the iced tea. Would I make the drive from Tallahassee to Bainbridge just to eat at The American again? Probably not. read more

New ownership! Beware!!! Service was practically nonexistent. We waited an hour for a wedge salad, pork sirloin and a baked potato. The chicken for the wedge salad was burnt and inedible. The pork was undercooked in the center but burnt around the edges. The baked potato was uncooked and hard. I will never return. This restaurant used to be the best in the area. read more

My bride and I have been there several times. It's always clean. The service in the food is top drawer. We will be back again and again.

We've eaten here twice. This place is an oasis in the middle of nowhere for the serious foodie. The interior brick is really cool as are the chandeliers and wood trim. The tables are set very nice with candlelight and most importantly the food is out of this world, both lunch AND dinner. The food is really good!! We've had the burgers, the pasta as well as the cornbread, goat salad, and charcuterie board. The goat cheese on the goat salad is fried. Don't miss it. We have loved everything we've ordered and the service is always good too. This is not just a local favorite, people from Florida drive up here as well. Olevia and Bailee were terrific hosts. This is one of the coolest places in a small town I've ever been to. It's very clear to me, someone cares about what happens here. Thank you "The American" for being AWESOME. My family and I will be back. Although we're 600 miles away, this was our second time here. read more

The American - The pimento cheese was my favorite! - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

See all

The food was actually worse than the service. I wouldn't have thought that possible. It was simply inedible.

Second time here --- still wonderful! The food and atmosphere will not disappoint! The staff are all very pleasant and attentive. My turkey and pimento was simply delicious. The hubby's grilled chicken literally melted in your mouth. In conclusion - this place is a must stop every time when head south for the beach!! read more

The American - Smoked Turkey and Pimento Lunch with wedge salad. Hubby got grilled chicken and fries. So so so yummy guys!! - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

If you're looking for a meal that will make your taste buds do a happy dance, look no further. We just had an unforgettable experience and let's just say, this meal left us speechless (in the best way possible). The tomato pie--oh my word. This was not your average slice. Imagine a buttery, crispy crust holding together the juiciest, most flavorful tomatoes, all topped with a delicate cheese blend that was simply out of this world. Next up was the showstopper: the jalapeno butter ribeye. First of all, they torch the butter right at your table, filling the air with the intoxicating aroma of sizzling jalapenos. It was like a smoky, spicy love letter to our senses. The ribeye itself? Perfectly cooked, ridiculously tender, and packed with flavor that made each bite better than the last. If you like a bit of heat, this one is a must. The crab cakes were a dream. These weren't those sad, filler-heavy patties you sometimes get--no, these were pure crab, all meat, no fluff. They had just the right amount of seasoning and were golden on the outside, tender and succulent inside. they were some of the best crab cakes I've ever had. And then... the banana cream pie. We're still thinking about it. The custard was impossibly creamy, with the perfect balance of sweet and rich. The the buttery wafer crust was the ideal foundation for this masterpiece. Every bite was a glorious reminder of how dessert should taste. I wish I remembered our waitresses name because she was so delightful. She stated she had worked there 6 years and we could tell she enjoyed her job and the customers she served. As we left a gentlemen offered to open the door for us and it turned out to be the owner. We had a nice conversation with him about his restaraunt and his car parked out front. Just good people all the way around. If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and get to this place ASAP. We can't wait to go back! read more

If you're looking for that perfect combination of culinary, expertise and down home wholesome delicious food, the American hits it on every level. From the delicious heirloom tomatoes, avocado, basil and mozzarella salad to the burger that is so fresh and perfectly cooked when you take a bite, steam literally pours out of the burger. This is a five star all around place to eat! Also, the decor is lovely! I would definitely recommend this restaurant. I look forward to returning soon. read more

See all

We visited The American on a Friday evening (we had reservations). This resturant is in downtown Bainbridge, GA. It has all the southern charm you would expect with large oak trees and Spanish moss. The restaurant is on the "square". The menu changes (mainly the main courses) based on what the chef can find in the area fresh. We had the scallops and filet steaks, and wedge salads. All were excellent, and you can tell the ingredients are fresh. The owners are doing this right! If you are in the area, give them a try. You will have a great meal, and be immersed in Southwest Georgia Deep South southern charm. read more

Our second time at this great restaurant. We were seated promptly and our server was quick. I had the strip sirloin and my wife had the burger. Both were cooked to perfection and delicious. We will return. read more

Dined a few times and always a wonderful experience! The fried green tomatoes and the tomato pie are delicious appetizers. Every entree is amazing! And the atmosphere has rich southern charm. read more

Corn bread appetizer 100/10 Filet was wonderful. Don't necessarily recommend mac n cheese read more

The American - filet with mac and cheese - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

See all

The atmosphere at this restaurant is great. Beautiful spot with good service. The menu changes daily but you can look on their Facebook story to check it out. Food was overall very good! Banana cream pie was my favorite part so delicious! Also best cheese grits I've had anywhere. read more

See all

Very busy place. Food is a bit pricy, (about $50.00 per). Filet was cooked to perfection as well as the wood seared salmon. However, the porkchops ,were tougher than shoe leather . Manager removed it from the bill. Beer and wine only. read more

My Aunt and I (really her idea) decided to dine here for lunch yesterday while in town for our family reunion. Our waitress, Abigail was so delightful and very attentive to all of our needs. We both ordered the Grateful Goat Salads one with grilled chicken and one with grilled shrimp. This has to be one of the BEST salads that I have ever had!!! The flavor was AMAZING, the little bites of toasted cornbread BEST ever! I would highly recommend trying this place if you live here or are in town! read more

See all

We arrived before noon on a Thursday and were not warmly greeted by either hostess. The waitress, was equally as cool. We ordered ice tea and it was delicious with a hint of mint. We also ordered for appetizers the skillet cornbread and the Heirloom tomato and avocado caprese salad. The tomatoes were a bit crunchy and the avocado was not quite ripe. The tomato pie was delicious! The cornbread, for all of its hype, was very, very sweet. I ordered the pork loin with smoked Gouda grits. The pork was delicious but the grits were cold so unfortunately, I had to send the grits back. My friend ordered the pull pork sandwich which came out cold and the French fries would have been delicious if they'd been warmer. She asked for BBQ sauce and it was being made. This should have been prepared in the morning before opening. My other friend ordered a hamburger and I am going to blame the chef's bad day for this. The bottom of the burger was charcoal. There was no excuse for this burger to have gone out of the kitchen like this. He sent it back and it was so long in getting a new one that the others had finished their lunch so he cancelled the order. I was embarrassed for bragging about this place. The waitress never really warmed up but did take the caprese salad and pulled pork off the bill. I will give them another chance but perhaps management can step up the training. Hostesses could have menus ready with a smile when people come in (especially when they are not busy). The kitchen should not send out any thing that they would not eat. Don't ever serve cold grits. Prep items beforehand that can be prepared. If management had been on duty, they should have been at our table. We were looking forward to desserts but not after our experience. read more

See all

Love this place! The service is almost always spot on. Atmosphere is lovely. Unique touch with the checks in old books. The food is to die for and will melt in your mouth. Cool name and way to be a patriot. I do wish there were more organic ingredients on the menu. read more

This is a wonderful spot in the downtown Bainbridge square. Plenty of scenery and absolutely delicious food! Their menu is quaint, which is always a good sign. On my first visit in I got the crab crake. Y'all, this was one of the best crab cakes I've had in my LIFE! In Bainbridge Georgia!!! Everyone in my party enjoyed what they got and I would definitely come back when in town again. The owner/chef came out to check on us twice and was very accommodating. Easily 5 stars given the location of this gem. read more

The American - One of the best crab cakes I've ever had! $13 - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

Food was wonderful. We had the steak chicken and an appetizer. All were good. The desserts were awesome. Cheesecake and banana cream pie. The restaurant is clean friendly and easy to find seats. Bathroom was clean. Service was fast. read more

I found this great restaurant on Yelp while I was in Bainbridge for the evening. The restaurant had a good rating and I was not disappointed. I had the wedge salad, a filet, red mashed potatoes and a piece of banana cream pie. I was not disappointed. Great service, great atmosphere, great food and a fair price. What more could I ask for. read more

The American - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

I have always had a great experience at The American until tonight. We came with a larger party to celebrate my Moms birthday. The restaurant was not very busy, so we assumed service would be good per usual. Unfortunately, another server accidentally dropped a plate of ketchup which then splatterd all over our clothing, bags, chairs, and the floor surrounding our table. The employees acted like it was an inconvenience for them to clean it up. Any other restaurant would have been apologetic and offered some sort of compensation or atleast a sense of urgency to make their guests feel comfortable. After the spill the employees were dismissive and slow to continue to serve us. We had to ask multiple times to have the ketchup cleaned off of the floor and to be offered more napkins for the table. I enjoyed the food but the experience was awful. Hundreds of dollars of clothing were stained. Not to mention the hundreds of dollars spent at the restaurant tonight with a hefty added gratuity. I understand that accidents happen, but I am disappointed in the service by the employees and their attitudes towards us. read more

Wonderful food, fabulous service, great location. This was the first high-end restaurant that helped transform downtown Bainbridge.

So let me start this by saying Bainbridge, GA is a very cute/quaint little town that we decided to stay in on our way to Florida because my other half's last name is....you guessed it, Bainbridge! So we asked for a good dinner recommendation and came to the American for dinner. Had to make a reservation but it was no big deal, 30 min wait...WELL worth it! The food was AMAZING!!! The pic doesn't do it justice, we had their cornbread appetizer which was fantastic, fluffy and wonderful with honey! Then we also had to try the heirloom tomato appetizer...WOW! So for dinner, we had the Tuna two way (Ahi!), the Hawaiian Ribeye, and the special beet ravioli and lobster in cream sauce....there are no words, but I will try....all three were out of this world!!! And then we had the Key Lime pie for dessert, soooo good!!!! If you ever roll through Bainbridge, I highly recommend the American!!!!! read more

The American - Tuna two way, Hawaiian ribeye, lobster ravioli in cream sauce - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

This restaurant always serves up incredible food. I love that, when possible, local produce is used. The service is fantastic and the vibe of the place is great for hanging out or a business meeting. This restaurant and its owners are the anchors to the downtown restoration efforts. My favorite: any soup of the day. Also love the Grateful Goat salad at lunch. read more

The American - New American Near Me - Bainbridge, Georgia

See all

The best food in Bainbridge hands down. Service is always fantastic and the menu offers a new item each day. Tyler has a true talent and we are so thankful he chose Bainbridge to reside in. My personal favorite menu item is the heirloom tomato pie. read more

See all

Really top notch food and service. Our group of 5 were all pleased with our food. Ample portions tasty and well plated. read more

See all

Nothing special for very high prices. Bland. Chicken salad has no taste and way too expensive for what you got. Croissant was not toasted as advertised and no garnish. Disappointing. read more

This place brought their A-game last Friday night, we loved everything!!!! There were 8 of us for my father's birthday and the service and food were out of this world! I'm still dreaming about the tomato pie , DELISH! Portions were perfect size and the price was on par with the quality of the food. I will return every time I find myself back in Bainbridge:-) read more

See all

Food was delicious! Loved the tomato pie! Everything we ate was so amazing. Great service and such a cute place to eat.

An excellent meal last evening ! The ambiance, the waitstaff, the food - all top-notch !

The best restaurant in town, by far! Family owned and the owner greets you at the door or your table! Great service and delicious menu of locally sourced items. Chef rotates out specials to spice up the menu, while keeping some of the classic favorites. A few of my favs: fried green tomatoes, Hawaiian ribeye, southern key lime pie. I look forward to eating here every time I'm in town. Go visit The American, you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

This place was incredible! The smoked salmon dip was amazing and the Hawaiian Rib was totally INSANE!! The flavor on that steak was too die for. The waitress Leanne (RHYMES) was by far the best waitress I have ever been served by. Great food and even better staff. A must go to if you are ever the the HUGE METROPOLIS of Bainbridge, GA. read more

See all