Amazing Authentic Buffalo faire Home town COSTANZOS Rolls - Subs were FANTASTIC ! Chicken Cordon Bleu Pizza - Crust to die for - Millers / Webers / Labatt Blue Beers - Everything serves quickly & Hot - Glad we took a chance on this FLORIDA GEM! read more

See all

Been here twice over the years they been open got my entire family sick both times owner has owned two different sals pizza and if you know how dirty they were then you shouldn't expect anything better here. (Edited review due to reply from the owner. Unsanitary and unprofessional truly the buffalo special.) read more

We drive from Orlando because my husband is from Buffalo. He has been following them on FB for a while, and we finally made the drive. What a nice dining area filled with everything Buffalo, plus many TV's mounted to watch your favorite teams play. They also have a fan shop, though small they have a wide variety of t-shirts. Jerseys, hoodies, hats and more. Now for the food. We wanted to try it all but opted for two slices of pepperoni pizza that came with a drink, a beef in a weck with fries and an order of 10 medium wings with the sauce on the side. The pizza had the crispy cups of pepperoni that we love, but there was too much cheese for our liking. I think it was because it was under the heat lamps that the cheese melted off the crust. Next time we'll order a small whole pizza--those looked amazing from other customers. The Beef on a Weck was good and the horseradish had a great bite to it. We took the wings home and reheated in our air fryer then tossed them in the sauce. Perfection! Go Bills read more

See all

My husband is from Buffalo, New York. That's as close as you'll get to their food. Beef on Weck was really good read more

Stopped by. They are closed. It's 3:45 on a Saturday. Came from Ocala area. Very disappointed. Several sites list several different times of opening and closing. One site says they are closed all day. One says they close at 3 and the other says 7. Was really looking forward to trying. 716 Burger and Brew here we come ! read more

So being from Buffalo I wanted to check this place out for a while but it's about an hour away. So I was driving home through the area and decided to go grab a few things for dinner. I got a large cheese and pepperoni , a chicken finger sub and a royal sub. Everything was delicious and reminded me of back home . The walls are covered in bills and Buffalo memorabilia , and the staff was great . I'll be back if I'm in the area . And I would definitely recommend trying them out if you live around there read more

That 716 Pizza Joint - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lakeland, Florida

See all

A great little place with Buffalo memorabilia. Ordered a small cheese, pepperoni and mushroom pizza. It was very good. Reminded me of buffalo food. The place is just a beautiful little place. If you wanna see Buffalo Bills and Sabres posters Jim Kelley, Josh Allen, and many others Sabres memorabilia the pizza was awesome. There is also a display with Buffalo type food. The service was great. I love the ambience the whole place with TVs and the Sabres and Bill stuff. Great price for the pizzas. read more

See all

The pizza was really good and hot and the decorations are pretty cool if you're a bills fan "GO BEARS" I've had the pizza three times now and I'll definitely come back. My kids really liked it as well. The service was good but then again we were the only ones there. read more

That 716 Pizza Joint - Meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Lakeland, Florida

See all

Pizza is the best in Lakeland. I'm a pizza guy from the northeast and I've tried every spot in Lakeland - nothing touches 716. Hours are a little odd and short - I've missed them several times coming out of work late but make it priority because it's very good. read more

If you like Buffalo style pizza this is for you. Small curled up pepperonis with melted fat rendered down on each pepperoni Buffalo style. Their pizza is very good. They have a small sit down area and you can even get a Genessee Light. They have Buffalo wings too. Their business truck is painted up with Buffalo Bills and Buffalo Sabres logo. You get the drift when you walk in the door. If you are from Batavia, Olean, Cheektowaga, Salamanca, Amheart, Jamestown or even Fredonia, you will love this place. read more

Im from bflo ny and moved to central florida and.this place is friggin legit when it comes to bflo food. Amazing. They also have a mini game room off to the side. read more

See all

Terrible, my husband came in to order pizza for his guys at work and was told he could not order 3 pizzas, what !!!! That is crazy he is trying to support a local business and was turned away. This does not make any sense and he was told they do not do any large orders. So explain this , he could order 2 pizzas and I could come right behind him and order 1 . Well that is 3 pizzas. I cannot believe a small business would not want our order, unfortunately you just lost a customer and believe me he would have ordered often for his guys. Do better ! read more

Great food, great service. Every time we have gone we have been treated great and quick. Tables are always clean and love to eat in and just enjoy the space. read more

Pizza is always outstanding! Location expanded and has a shopping area with many Buffalo favorites! Lots of TVs, definitely a great place to watch the games while enjoying a Labatt Blue and a slice! Order at counter, they bring you food. If you get wings ask for extra crispy, regular crispy didn't quite get there. read more

See all

Drove 55 miles there on valentine's day for lunch . No one there ! Waist of time i called Friday to inquire about the menu said I was stopping out sat. Ok see you then. Never again read more

as a buffalo native born aand raised on this foof it is as authentic to buffalo in flordia you will get !! the best in the south thus far !1

Pizza was soggy and made my kid sick this is the second time my family has given this place a chance and it's done nothing but underwhelm both times. Oh and go broncos read more

Okay WOW! MIC DROP! Their pizza is sooooooo good! Thicker crust, bold flavored sauce and cheesy deliciousness! I LOVE that their pepperoni is thicker. Only real downside is their garlic knots. Not much flavor and butter didn't have a garlic flavor at all! Hopefully it was just an off night . Very New York ambiance and I love it! read more

That 716 Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Lakeland, Florida

See all

Great representation of Buffalo pizza...Great crust and pepperoni...I give them a solid 8 out of 10...If you're from Buffalo check it out...Buffalo memorabilia everyone...One TV had a stream a Ray/Domi fights lol. read more

See all

Crazy big portions. The side salad alone was a meal. So if you got some hungry people this is the spot. read more

That 716 Pizza Joint - Sides salad - Pizza Near Me - Lakeland, Florida

Wonderful as always!! They have added a lot of wall decor since my last visit. Staff is welcoming and the vibe is incredible for Buffalo folk. They have even got a little "shop" with all things Buffalo for sale. read more

That 716 Pizza Joint - BOW - Pizza Near Me - Lakeland, Florida

See all

After hearing good comments about 716, we decided to give it a try. All i can say is after a $100.00 order we were VERY DISAPPOINTED!! The pizza was fair at best. The WINGS were OLD ,Tuff and DRY. The sub was not toasted, little meat. The salad was GOOD. So may daughter called and to our surprise the nice cordial people, turned into ASSHOLES !!! Never will go back !! read more

That 716 Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Lakeland, Florida

See all

When busy they can't handle the rush, under staffed. the owners fiancé takes the order and is getting all flustered when it's busy, and doesn't know her stuff when she doesn't even cook the food. ask for light baked and the food is undercooked. very small business but needs the help when busy. normally the food is good but the last few times was not read more

The restaurant is small but the food is delicious! Best sandwich I've had in a long time. Wings are full of flavor and pizza is just amazing. read more

See all

Let me start with the phone call I made to That 716 Pizza Joint. I called to ask what time they close. The person who answered the call said 7pm but they take the last phone order, I think it was 4pm or 4:30pm. I inquired about sitting down to eat. Her response was do not come in here at 2 minutes to 7pm expecting to sit and eat. I guess right then and there I should have known this was not going to be a good experience. Well, I took my wife there anyway because I had been meaning to try That 716 Pizza Joint for quite some time now. Mostly because I saw it had 4 1/2 stars on Yelp. Needless to say, my wife and I were very disappointed. Customer service was not there, and the quality of the pizza pie was not there. The pizza was too greasy, the pepperoni was burnt, and the dough was soggy from the grease. This had to be the worst pizza I have had in a long time. I was hoping for it to be good so I wouldn't have to continue driving to Winter Haven for some good New York style pizza. I know of at least 2 really good pizza places in Winter Haven. I will continue my journey there. That 716 Pizza Joint you can keep the food you serve and your customer care. This family will be going to Winter Haven for some good quality and tasty pizza. read more

WOW! FINALLY!!! One of the absolute BEST restaurants in the entire state of Florida! Great food really IS about the love that you out into making it. We met the "newish" owner , he really is such an all around wonderfully kind, friendly and caring super guy. You can tell his heart and soul are in making this place what it is. .He goes above to please all of his customers ~ and it truly shows with the food quality and his staff . I wish I would have taken pictures of our meals before we inhaled them. I swear we were on the verge of tears with gratitude lol. .So we ended up purchasing a small partially cooked AUTHENTIC!! " **cup n char**" pizza to take home with us (1.5 hours away ) to freeze and reheat ! . YOU HAVE TO CHECK OUT THE WNY themed dining / stadium area. Multiple tvs showing all the Buffalo Ny based teams ! read more

See all

The pizza was exceptional. Plenty of toppings. I got the supreme and was not disappointed

Went there a while back and was impressed. I'm from the chi so good pizza is hard to find. I asked for extra cheese and extra sauce like I normally do but with this pizza there is no need for extra cheese lol read more

This place did not disappoint. We got the pizza logs and wings and of course I forgot to take a pic of the rest and there were no leftovers. We also got beef on weck, royal sub, and kids tenders. We will def be back. read more

See all

I finally tried 716 Pizza Joint for our Saturday pizza night and am I glad I did. We got two small pizzas and we loved them. The wife's Vegetarian pie looked great and my Pepperoni was great. The price won't break the bank, the service was friendly and quick. This Pizza Parlor is truly a hidden gem that I will be back for more. read more

Royal sub... not enough sausage, more bread then meat. Garlic knots-huge & delish, sauce it came with was great! BOW , bottom of roll was soggy I asked for light on salt & kemmelweck hardly got anything, oh dear. The roast beef had a weird taste .the seasoning , didn't like. Yes, born & raised in Buffalo , never got a soggy roll & always had enough sausage on my sub. Will I return , probably not. Drove to far for this, no thank you. read more

That 716 Pizza Joint - Soggy bottom BOW - Pizza Near Me - Lakeland, Florida

Great pizza and wings. Super friendly staff. They might not be the cheapest option but I don't mind paying more for quality!

Love coming here for lunch. Always perfect western NY style pizza, you can never walk away hungry. I'm not a bills fan but if you are you better be eating and ordering from here! Awesome spot with amazing service and food every time. Recommend for anyone just looking for lunch or looking for a lot of pizzas for a Sunday watch party. read more

That 716 Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Lakeland, Florida

See all

OMG this is absolutely DELICIOUS!!!! Just like home!! 1-1/2 hour drive but well worth it! I highly recommend the chicken bacon ranch pizza and citrus explosion wings. Cooked just like Buffalo NY!! Love the sabres/bills/bandits decor read more

See all

Good authentic pizza from Buffalo.. They have that cup and char pepperoni, rolls from constanzo's and more. Worth the drive.

We moved from up north a few years ago, and since then, my bf has complained about how crappy the pizza is here because no one flavors their sauce. We found one place that we loved and then it closed. I have been on the search since! Found this place and reviews commented on how good the sauce was, so I figured we would try it. I'm so glad we did! The woman that answered the phone was so sweet and my bf said the two working were really friendly. I'm thinking one was the owner. We could smell the sauce on the way home! It was great pizza, and the slices were pretty filling. I could only eat one slice, and my bf could only eat two after we split the fries. We're the type of people that usually eat half a large pizza each and breadsticks then dessert (I know, bad habits we are trying to kick). We will definitely be back! read more

That 716 Pizza Joint - Meat lovers Large, half without ham - Pizza Near Me - Lakeland, Florida

See all

Pizza tastes just like a pie from Hoadley's Hut I had growing up in Salamanca. Go Bills! When traveling to Lakeland for biz it's not a must to stop in and support the home team. Had a beef on wick today that was perfect, right down to the horseradish buring my sinus. They have lots of WNY condiments for sale (Bison Dip!) and Buffalo Braves games playing on TV in the back (amazing!!!!). Only suggestion i'd make is with fries. Cook em up in different oil and saturate them with some seasoning, but I love this place and will eat here every time i'm in town. read more

The best of the best. Food is delicious and the prices are great. Great quality and the dining room people always seem like they are friends Nice store with Buffalo products. read more

Took an hour and 15 minute drive to try out that 716 Pizza joint I ordered a royal sub, which had more lettuce and tomato, than Mineo and Sapio sausage. Every other place I've ever had a royal sub, has at least two pieces of sausage, and that's from Western New York to Florida. The beef on weck was also kind of lacking on the meat, and the meat was kind of mealy. The weck was over saturated with au jus, which made handling the sandwich difficult. Maybe it's the weather, but several places I've eaten lately, claiming to use Costanzo rolls have been doughy, and dense NOT crispy or a little airy. The decor was definitely Bills Sabres Braves and Bisons, with plenty of seating for customers. The only thing missing I would have liked was Loganberry, which some people on the table in the corner, and brought their own! Although I did not order pizza, it looked legit. Plenty of toppings, not too thick, and a good sauce, which I sampled. Might be good for the locals here, but not worth driving over an hour for.... read more

I give this establishment 4 stars based on the staff and their friendliness! The food however was not my cup of tea. The garlic knots were the best thing I ordered, they lacked real garlic, made simply with garlic powder, but they were good. The chef salad was lack luster, lettuce was soggy, the pizza was not what I personally like, the crust was too thick and the sauce was too sweet for my liking. read more

See all