Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Teatime Bakery

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed 10:00 am - 3:00 pm
    Updated a few days ago

    Order Teatime Bakery Takeout or Delivery

    Teatime Bakery Photos

    Business Info

    Recommended Reviews - Teatime Bakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    I have eaten here twice and really enjoyed the sandwiches. I would love to go back for one of their full teas with sandwiches and desserts.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Teatime Bakery

    Amish Cheese House - Blueberry cheesecake waffle cone!

    Amish Cheese House

    4.4(94 reviews)
    17.4 mi
    $

    When you step into a cheese shop, they eagerly recommend flavors, passion spilling from their…read morewords, as if each cheese holds a story yearning to be shared. At a fish house, the same heartfelt enthusiasm fuels their suggestions, their pride illuminating every dish they serve. But why is it, when we reach out about their pies--those tender, comforting slices--their response is silence? No advice, no hints, no warmth--just a cold, dismissive "I don't eat pie. It's been six years since I had pie. It's just not something I eat." Those are the words from the very people who work here, strangers to the simple joy that a good pie can bring. No effort to tempt, no desire to share a slice of happiness or to welcome us back. It's as if they've given up entirely on creating an experience, on making us feel valued, on making us crave more. And even as signs invite us to indulge--"Try our butter, cheese, fudge"--we walk away empty-handed, denied even a sample to taste the passion behind their products. This place, with its dusty buggies parking spot out front, presents itself as an Amish-inspired haven, yet it feels hollow--more of a tourist trap than a genuine slice of heritage. It's a place that seems to have forgotten the soul of community, the warmth of tradition, and the simple act of sharing something truly special. And I can't help but wonder--why settle for empty gestures and sterile responses? Why not open your hearts, embrace the spirit of true hospitality, and let us taste the love you claim to carry? I'll look forward to March 14.

    Christmas shopping made simple!!! Something for everyone on…read moreyour list. I buy the local jams, spreads and cheeses.Whipped honey. Taffy. Candy. And lots more!!!!

    Photos
    Amish Cheese House - The hallway between the bakery and the Amish cheese house

    The hallway between the bakery and the Amish cheese house

    Amish Cheese House - Make your own sandwich combo

    Make your own sandwich combo

    Amish Cheese House

    See all

    Ludger's Bavarian Cakery

    Ludger's Bavarian Cakery

    4.4(171 reviews)
    26.0 mi
    $$

    I recently ordered a custom party cake (funfetti) with traditional buttercream from Ludger's, and…read moreit absolutely exceeded my expectations. From the beautiful presentation to the delicious flavor and outstanding customer service, the entire experience was wonderful. After submitting an online quote request, I was contacted quickly with detailed information, and the ordering process was seamless when I called to finalize. The cake was thoughtfully and beautifully crafted with realistic bark texture along with detailed greenery; it was the perfect forest-style centerpiece for my son's Gravity Falls party. When guests saw the cake and learned it was from Ludger's, several of them raved about how amazing their cakes are. This was the first birthday party we've had where nearly the entire cake was eaten! Thank you Ludger's!

    So the business owner reached out to me about my previous review and offered to refund me for my…read morelemon bar that I was not able to enjoy. So I went in today to do this and not only were the staff yet again amazing and friendly and helpful, but they offered to let me try something else and the manager told me they're known for their cakes. since I have never tried their cake before I decided to go for that. I tried the strawberry lemon cake and I am not a cake person, usually because they have tons of icing which is just not my thing. However, this cake does not have icing instead it has this lemon strawberry cream in the middle of the cake with some whipped cream and it is the best thing. This is now the only way that I want someone to give me cake is like this. My next birthday, I'm gonna be asking for a cake like this and I officially will be back to this place. I'm just been blown away by the customer service but also I'm thrilled that they corrected their lemon bars and now I found a place where I can actually like cake.

    Photos
    Ludger's Bavarian Cakery
    Ludger's Bavarian Cakery - Blue bird (turkey and swiss on blueberry bread)

    Blue bird (turkey and swiss on blueberry bread)

    Ludger's Bavarian Cakery

    See all

    Prairie Lane Bakery - Thanksgiving-Style Dinner.

    Prairie Lane Bakery

    4.5(2 reviews)
    20.0 mi

    This was such a special and wonderful experience! The service was like nothing I've experienced…read morebefore. The entire family working there were kind and I felt as though I had been welcomed into their home for a feast. They served us an "eat until you're full" style meal including but not limited to... - Coleslaw - Green Beans - Mashed Potatoes & Gravy - Bread Rolls with Butter & Apple Butter - Brisket - 7-Up Chicken - Stuffing - Amish Noodles For drinks we were offered either ice water, or iced black tea. For dessert we were served both a Chocolate Pie, as well as a Banana Cream Pie, along with coffee. It was such an inviting experience and definitely made me feel as though I was a part of their family's dinner. It was truly special! I'd absolutely recommend trying this at some point! Do note that this is a cash only operation, and you do need to make a reservation well in advance via phone.

    Prairie Lane Bakery is a family-owned Amish eatery about a mile east of Highway 69 just outside…read moreChouteau, OK. A dirt road leads to its blink-and-you'll-miss-it door. No signs declare its existence. My wife and I found ourselves there for a meeting with her coworkers, one of whom has been a longtime frequenter of this establishment and recommended it as the site for the group's monthly dinner. She had made the reservation (required, for parties of at least 15) and had also been the one to choose our meal. I'm told the business can accommodate for many different allergies or diets and that they have a wide selection of meats, vegetables/sides, and desserts from which you can take your pick. The dining hall is in a nondescript white building across from the main house. It is far from fancy in keeping with the lifestyle of its proprietors. As in tin-metal walls, concrete floor, and gas-powered lights/heat. Metal folding chairs flank two long rows of folding tables covered in plastic tablecloths; our party of 12 sat in one row with a few seats to spare. The atmosphere is that of having a Sunday supper after church with kinfolk at grandma's. The (rather adorable) children of the (hardworking) women preparing and serving our food played along the borders of the room and ran through the doors, the air ringing with their laughter. Drinks (water or unsweetened tea only) were served as we arrived. Once everyone was present the food came out family-style - one large platter or bowl at a time, passed from one person to another. And now what you've all been waiting for: the food! The coleslaw wasn't very good; then again, I'm not a coleslaw fan and so might not be a good judge of it. The green beans could've come from a can for all the good they tasted. And the roast was dry, tasteless. That's where the negatives end. The baked chicken was tender/moist/juicy, all those words that make some people uncomfortable when talking period, let alone about food. The mashed potatoes were creamy, the white gravy perfectly rich, the country noodles expertly flavored, and the turkey dressing pure cheesy goodness. I can't forget the rolls, too, which when paired with homemade apple butter were the best I've ever had. After a brief rest to digest, we were served one kind of coffee and two kinds of pie - cherry and coconut cream. The cherry pie filling reminded me of a Pop-Tart but more intense, which wasn't a bad thing at all. Typically I don't like even the word coconut unless it's followed by "rum and pineapple juice", but that particular pie was delicious. It may have made me a convert. I haven't mentioned the service, but it was fantastic. Glasses never more than half-empty before being refilled. Constant questions of whether we needed anything else. Smiling faces and good conversation. We ate until we were stuffed and several people took home heaping to-go boxes, yet there was still a ton left of each food item. On the way out I picked up a loaf of banana but bread from the bakery side. The damage to my wallet for all of this? $27.59! Yep. All-you-can-eat comfort food for two in a place that feels like home for under $30. I'm definitely going back. Just as soon as I can round up 10-12 likeminded foodies so I can make a reservation.

    Photos
    Prairie Lane Bakery - Clockwise right: rolls w/apple butter, roast, baked chicken, noodles, green beans, coleslaw, dressing, mashed potatoes & gravy

    See all

    Clockwise right: rolls w/apple butter, roast, baked chicken, noodles, green beans, coleslaw, dressing, mashed potatoes & gravy

    Teatime Bakery - bakeries - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...