NOTE: This is a review for the Rudd Pond Area, not the much larger Copake Falls Area, which has a separate Yelp entry.
In order to properly explain the two-star rating, I'm going to go through all of the alleged "highlights" of this park, as-listed on the official website:
Beach - Forgive my naivety, but when a park advertises a beach, I picture a long stretch of sandy shores with volleyball nets and children running around kicking beach balls. What they actually have, is a little 20x40 ft. box of imported sand and a similarly sized swimming area. The rest of the pond is untouchable due to swamp-like conditions beneath the surface.
Biking - The actual bike rentals are apparently offered at a place in Millerton, which is a 2-minute drive from the park entrance, but you are more than welcome to bring your own. Where you are actually going to ride that bike is an issue addressed a few points down.
Boat Rentals - 4-person row boats are available for $7/hour or $25/day, but require the full $25 as a deposit regardless of how long you want to stay out there. A few canoes were also available, but we didn't try them out. Please bear in mind that these boats are probably older than most of the trees in this park. You are given heavy wooden oars that slip into a metal pin socket on the boat, which squeaks and squeals loudly every time you row. Luckily it only takes about an hour to do a lap around the entire pond, so you won't have to put up with it for too long.
Campsites - From the website: "Rudd Pond has 15 tent and 26 tent platform sites, each providing campers with grand views of the ridge, pond, and nearby countryside." If you plan on staying in campsites 1-5, as we did, this is just plain false. We were on a hilly back-road with the wooden platforms for the tents, and the only view was the trees in front or the service road to a gas tank in back.
Fishing - If you want to take a row boat out into the pond to fish, go for it, but a good 50% of the pond is filled with plants right up to the surface and I doubt you could drop a line in there without getting it tangled up in something.
Hiking - The Rudd Pond Area has a trail. Yes, one trail. It circles around the park area and is a few miles in length at most. You can try and make it around, but the DEET-resistant insects will eat you alive.
Showers - Possibly the best part of the park, they were fairly new and clean, and we never had any problems with hot water.
In addition to the above list, I would like to recommend that they add the following bullet point:
Insects - Based upon the results of our 5-person group, there is a 3/5 or 60% chance you will be devoured by no less than 200 mosquitoes during your stay. Be warned that our 25% DEET spray held them off for maybe an hour at most, after which time we didn't stand a chance. Also be warned that the mosquitoes in this area are trained and deadly ankle-biters: the three of us that were assaulted left the park with red, itchy ankles completely covered in bites that multiplied every night.
In summary, camp near a pond at your own risk. You are better off trying for the Copake Falls area, or any camp that has moving fresh water of some kind. Now if you'll excuse me, I have about a million bug-bites to scratch... read more