Walked in off of the street and ordered a Pizza, thought it would take a while so I waited on a bench out front. They brought the pizza out front to me when it was ready. Not only that, it was really, really good. read more

Do not overlook this small, hidden gem for a great pizza. The service was also excellent. The place is small and simple- but don't judge a book by its cover! We ordered a half meatlovers/half the works pizza and it was great! read more

Ordered pizza door dash style on July 2nd. I'm not going to say I'm some sort of pizza expert or anything, but this pizza was just "Mid". The crust was just not that great to me. Several of the pizzas we got the crust edges were like a rock and you couldn't even eat it. The toppings, sauce, and cheese all tasted great. The one pizza that wasn't overcooked the crust was decent. Still on a search for a good pizza place in the Myrtle Beach/surfside area. This wasn't "it" read more

See all

It had been a while since I've ben here and I heard that there might be new owners. I ordered pizza over the holiday weekend and it was not too long of a wait. The size of the pizzas is great, but they really lacked toppings, and the crust really lacked flavor. Maybe it was just an off day, but it did not live up to the previous pizza I tried here. read more

Delicious and great customer service Our pizza slid and the toppings shifted for a to go order. They gave it to us and another for free. Very appreciative of us and just kind. read more

The pizza here is better now than it was with the previous owners!!! Highly recommended!! read more

Great legit pizza! Superb crust sauce cheese ratio at a great price. Popular with locals and tourists.

We got there late but they were still happy to sit us at a table. Ordered the large Meat Pizza with mushrooms and a side order of meatballs . I still say they have the best pizza!!!! read more

Good food service they got order done on time we picked it up they were very friendly and had a good attitude. Parking was a little tricky but got a spot. read more

Tasty and delicious. They have really good fettuccine Alfredo and I like that they offer a cauliflower crust option with their pizza.

One of my favorite places to get food when visiting family. Food is always on point and the waitresses are always welcoming and friendly. Pizza is always yummy. Highly recommend if you are looking for great pizza or Italian food. Will definitely be back!!! read more

I had an extremely disturbing experience at Surf Side Pizza. I arrived around 12:30 PM with my daughter, only to find the door locked despite the "OPEN" sign being clearly lit. We knocked and waited -- no one responded. However, we soon noticed that the staff were selectively opening the door and allowing white customers inside while continuing to ignore us. As a Black father with my Black daughter, this felt like blatant discrimination. There is no excuse for a business to treat people differently based on race. If you believe in equality and human decency, do not support places that treat some people as welcome and others as invisible. Racism has no place in any community -- including the restaurant business. read more

We ordered takeout on vacation this past weekend. My mom is not a pizza lover but my 5 year old is. I will say after a few bites of Surfside Beach Pizza, my mom is a pizza lover. The crust was great as was the sauce. My parents swapped out sausage for hamburger on their works pizza. It was a hit! We would recommend. read more

Surfside pizza is good pizza. I have only been here twice and I feel they have a pretty good pizza. The staff is very friendly and helpful. The restaurant is clean and inviting. It's not a large area so if you have a large party I would get it to go. I do recommend this place. read more

"Don't trust anyone who sells you spaghetti for 10$" Pizzas real good and they're good old italians. Menu on yelp is a lil old as of 2025 your pay $18 for spaghetti and meatballs but what do you want for nothing? The girl with the cornicello is friendly and funny as hell. Shes got great bits. Really added to the whole affair. If you're that one girl hit me up I think we're supposed to get married. read more

Best pizza I've had in Garden City! We've ordered the pepperoni pie and garlic cheesy bread. Everything was very good. I'm from NYC and this pizza reminded me of back home. It's off street parking and the sign it's a little hidden. Give this place a try. read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - Pepperoni slice - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

I'm sorry but I can't believe the reviews are so high. My husband just said if you could get the pastry into squares, you could make boxes. Toppings - like the sausage, mushrooms were CANNED and lack of everything else were also disappointing. We are locals, but our fav pizza place -Aromas - must be on vacation, so we had seen all the great reviews, and thought we would try...now the people there are very nice and as a local I feel bad calling them out, but come on now, this pizza is horrible! We spent $50 and are throwing it in the trash. BE WARNED. read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - Look at the tiny piece of sausage and the disgusting canned mushrooms. - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

This is the second weekend in a row where the phone is nonstop busy. Decided to go the restaurant to make our order. The lady at the front explained that they are just "always on the phone" When we tried to order the lady kept walking away to answer the phone that kept ringing and acted surprised we wanted to order more, because hello, you should ask if there's anything else. When we ordered more her response was "sorry you just looked depressed and sad and that's not in my pay grade" Completely unprofessional, especially to customers who pretty much order every single weekend. There is no need to be nasty, even when you are busy. read more

Good variety on menu. Have tried a seafood pizza and a supreme so far, and both were excellent. Will definitely be back.

Pizza and sausage hoagie were very good. The restaurant is not big....we will do carry out next time. I thought it was a little pricey for pizza place, but we had enough leftovers for 2-3 more meals. Staff was friendly. Service is needed for their air conditioning---dripping condensation on customers is not good. But otherwise I would recommend ( I already did recommend to other family members) read more

Good service everything was very nice food was great my room was very comfortable! Lots of places to dine! Shopping was great! Did have a little problem with parking but worked out fine!my plans are to come again In august . read more

Meatballs great. Sauce awesome! Pizza awesome! Antipasto awesome! Servers were friendly.

Ala Vodka sauce was delicious. Pizzas are great, true to the New York style. Loved the crust as well. Lots of options on the menu as well. It's a local favorite, and a must stop for all vacationer. read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - Menu - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

Great pizza find in Surfside Beach. Staff was very friendly and helpful. We got the Hawaiian pizza with garlic bread and mussels, we wanted the garlic knots but they sold out, everything was delicious. We ordered takeout but there is seating inside that looked like a cozy pizza joint. Great pizza and great location. Looking forward to our next visit. read more

We absolutely love this place! Whether we eat in or take back to the ocean front condo, this place is a must for us each trip! read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - Two meat lasagna's, salad & bread! - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

Ordered delivery tonight. The delivery driver Shelly was super sweet. She came all the way in so my dog didn't escape. She reminded me of what good service used to be. We just ordered the basics, Pepperoni Pizza, Italian salad, garlic knots and the cannolis. It was hot and fresh tasting. The pizza was New York style. Salad was crisp and the pickled vegetables were a nice surprise. The cannolis were a big hit with my husband. The prices were unbeatable. It is also family owned. read more

See all

Sad.... Hadn't been here for about 1 yr. Used to be the best extra thin crust. Stopped tonight for a pie and some wings. Prices horrible food awful, won't return read more

Little place fitted between Borgatta and Advanced Custom Flooring. I came because one of my lyft Passengers was raving about this place so I had to give it a go. As pictured below, the chicken parm Sammy was good. Bread was fresh, had a nice crisp to it. I also got a canoli for dessert. Even though shipped from elsewhere...was a decent cannoli. read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - Chicken parm sammy - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

Being from Syracuse we know Italian and this place fits the bill! Great food, great service, great atmosphere! read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - a snow shovel hanging on the wall - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

Ordered for pickup. Pizzas and Stromboli were excellent and as ordered. !

Pizza slice is rather small. No glop and a little greasy. Reminds me of bowling alley pizza. Service was quick.

Our 1st time visiting and we truly enjoyed our meal! The pizza is reminiscent of NY style but smaller slices to me. The buffalo wings were delicious! They were nice, plump and fried just right! The sauce was really good! I forgot to take pics as we dived right in. The service was excellent and the prices were reasonable! I recommend giving them a try! read more

This is a great local Italian restaurant.. We ate here for dinner and had a great meal.. I ordered the mussels marinara which came with bread and salad. The house dressing is really good and and I also liked the bread is the bread. The muscle's marinara was very tasty. My son loved his spaghetti and meatballs. read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

Pizza is fantastic, the chicken parm is yummy, and the homemade meatballs were huge! We really enjoy eating here, quality food!

I can't believe that I didn't review this place. I've had pizza and a veal sandwich from here and they were both excellent. read more

See all

Living only one block away, why did it take so long for me to try this place? Really surprised me! Great New York style pizza! Glad I finally went! Now I moved and need to find a new restaurant . read more

I'm from Boston area New England, visit the area regularly as family lives down here. Have never, ever had pizza that was edible in the area until today. Very good pizza, sauce had a great flavor, right amount of cheese and thin perfectly cooked crust. Greasy..but that's my preferred way! Garlic knots outstanding and Alfredo pasta also excellent. Impressed! read more

We walked in on a Saturday night at 9:00, Yelp said they close at 10. No one was in the place & the owner said the kitchen actually closes at 9:00...what??? I have never heard of such a thing, we had to leave, his brother the chef said they would not cook for us! We will never come back, VERY poor customer service!!! read more

Great NY pizza! Would recommend sausage and pepperoni yum! Great combination. Staff has always been welcoming.

Amazing food and service. We talk about this place every time we go to the beach!!! We recommend this place to everyone. We ordered via phone and the place was packed when we went to pick it up but the service was super friendly and efficient and the pizza was perfect. read more