I hate writing this because Supreme Pizza in Cumberland has been my go-to spot for the last 2 years. Usually, two pizzas disappear instantly when we order from here. Tonight? Totally different story. Honestly, I'm hoping the business was sold or something changed behind the scenes because there's no excuse for how bad it was. The crust tasted like it was cooked in a pan -- thick, soft, and absolutely no crunch at all. It didn't even resemble the pizza I've been ordering for years. Even the cheese looked strange... it had this weird melted orange color that just seemed off. Normally everyone goes back for seconds. Tonight most people stopped at two slices, and I honestly think that was just because they were hungry. I'm going to take a short break and give them another shot down the road because this place has always been one of my favorites. But whoever is making the pizzas right now... please get it together. read more

Ordered an Italian sub. I have really been a long time customer. All the ingredients were fresh. Their bread is soft and delicious. Their staff is courteous. Couldn't ask for more. read more

This has to be under new ownership. I've been a customer for the last 15 years and this is not the same food. Supreme had a Greek style pizza that was crunchy. Just got plain cheese pizza and it was more like Chucky cheese than Supreme. Almost felt like a frozen pizza. Also all new faces. Didn't recognize anybody. Last couple visits the same experience. Disappointing if the real Supreme is gone. read more

I go to Supreme Pizza fairly frequently for lunch during the work day. I typically order a chicken Caesar wrap or salad. I find their chicken to be well seasoned and not dry at all! I love the Caesar dressing that they use. We have also ordered a large number of pizzas for work lunches. The food is always ready on time and the pizza gets compliments from our employees. The restaurant itself is small. There are only a few booths and tables. I typically order take out so this isn't a problem for me. They also have online ordering which is really simple - They have never gotten my order wrong from an online order. Overall, I would recommend Supreme Pizza to those in the area for a quick, casual bite or take out. read more

I got mozz sticks and a steak and cheese w grilled onions, peppers, and American cheese with mustard and ketchup. This was one of the best subs I've ever had. So delicious! Staff was super friendly and the wait was super reasonable, especially considering they were slammed. read more

Supreme Pizza - Steak and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Cumberland, Rhode Island

See all

Best Chicken Alfredo in town, might say in Rhode Island. Amazing pizza and great people. Quiet dine in experience if you aren't about the big crowds. Definitely recommend if your in the area read more

Mixed review here and here is why: 1st visit: Had something to attend close by and had a small window to have lunch. My husband and I pulled in and split a Bacon, chicken, ranch wrap and an order of buffalo wings. I can tell you the wrap was very flavorful and I have thought about it a few times. I want another but I found a hair on a chicken wing. In fairness to Supreme we didn't have time to bring it to their attention to wait while they cooked another order for us. We finished the wrap and left. 2nd visit: (being fair again- during Covid-19 and supporting local) We order a large half cheese/half pepperoni pizza and a small bacon pizza. We were told 20 minutes. We arrived 30 minutes later and still had to wait in the parking lot for 10/15 minutes. They were busy and I am sure with trying to figure out a new way to do business t was stressful. Kudos again to another business for getting it together during the outbreak. Staff were wearing gloves and they did not allow anyone inside (locking the door after deliveries to cars were made.) They are having people re-pay (good idea) but then you cannot leave a tip on a card- cash only. Wish I could write that the pizza was great but it wasn't hot when we got it and barely warm once it got home. The pizza was lacking sauce but I can say... they have the good blue cheese and pepperoni! The pepperoni curled up while cooking, that kind! The blue cheese was chunky and creamy just the way I like it (I dip my crust in it.) I can share the pizza is much better as leftovers the next day with a little garlic salt. read more

See all

Calzones are amazing but pizza is just average. Customer service is excellent as they are very well staffed especially on busy nights. Very solid food all around if you stay with subs, calzones, salads. read more

I use to love this place. Recently my husband picked up a large pepperoni pizza with extra pepperoni. They said 20 minutes it would be ready but it actually took 40 minutes. That's ok- it happens but when he got the pizza home it definitely wasn't extra pepperoni. It happens! Maybe new employees. But I got my bank statement in and I was charged twice. I called and explain I was charged twice. They told me to call back in 15 min. I did and the manager wasn't there so someone took my name and number down and I was told I would get a call back. It's been almost a week and no call. I guess they're not interested in my business. Too bad because we ordered there a lot. read more

Great comfort food! Never a bad experience! It's the place to go to if you're craving something simple but good!

Three times now I have called to order some food - and they answer with " sorry we're closed" - 9 pm on a Saturday night.... Add and menu say 10pm... another time I called they were closed at 8:30pm... I give up! Manville Palace is open to 4 am - just down the street... read more

Typically their Pizza is very good. However, I ordered a Pizza with a Greek Salad. The Greek Salad, was heavy on the Lettuce and Feta cheese. Very little olives, cucumbers, onions, tomatoes, etc.. It was basically a Lettuce & Feta cheese salad and not very good at that. read more

I ordered wings for lunch, and bit into them to find out they were raw inside. I opened up a few other wings, thinking maybe it was just that one? ALL RAW. I called back and was advised that they were so sorry and going to bring a new order of wings WELL DONE. This is what I got...... read more

Supreme Pizza - Chicken Wings - Pizza Near Me - Cumberland, Rhode Island

OH MY GOD. There was a frigging staple in my veggie burrito! I was just chewing my very mediocre tasting burrito when all of a sudden my teeth crunched down on something way too sharp and hard to be rice or beans. At first I thought "hmm, this burrito really sucks, so maybe it's just under cooked rice," but thankfully I decided to check. I spit out a staple! A STAPLE. Don't eat from this place. I don't care if you're on your lunch break and they're the only place delivering to you. I don't care if you're wasted and just really need a burrito, trust me, you don't need it that bad. Wish I could get my money back. My husband and I bought two of these wretched things. Such a waste of money. read more

Supreme Pizza - Yum. Rice, Beans, and STAPLES in your veggie burrito. - Pizza Near Me - Cumberland, Rhode Island

Driver came up to the door and just smoked a cig seconds before coming to the door. The manager argued with my husband about this over the phone. The manager was rude, inexperienced in customer service, and completely out-of-line. He asked my husband if he had been drinking tonight!! What?! Not to mention the steak tip salad was pretty pathetic for $9.00. What happened to the Supreme we used to love? Update: I met with the owner after the rude manager called to tell me the delivery driver was coming by to offer an apology and a $10 gift card. I thought this was really cool until the manager preceded to argue with me again. I hung up the phone and drove to Supreme to talk to the owner. The owner was a nice guy with a lot of pride for his business but I did not feel like he actually listened to me. He made a comment about my husband "cooling off." He kept cutting me off to tell me about how hard his employees work and vented to me about how difficult it is "being in this business." He said he thinks of his business as the NE Patriots. If they have a winning season everyone is on board but if they lose, stadiums aren't filled, etc. Thats probably the worst analogy he could have made considering if you have a losing game (bad customer service and food that's missed its mark), you will lose fans. I left there with a new menu and no gift card. There was no real effort to understand my problem with the rude manager. It was just an owner sticking up for his young, inexperienced manager who was sticking up for his delivery driver. We weren't looking to get anything free, just wanted to relay a less-than-par experience. We won't be back. read more

It's taken me some time to write a review for this restaurant because I wanted to give them a second chance. We used to order from them all the time. Then tried a few other local places and ended going back to supreme. However, first time we ordered from them again - it took about 2 hours to arrive! The food arrived cold and we had a hard time reaching the restaurant as it was past the closing time. The next day, I received a call from the owner. He was extremely apologetic. Explained the situation and refunded our money. He asked for us to give them another chance. Since then, we've ordered from them three times. Every time, the food has arrived on time and hot. Always good! My go to for chicken tenders (real chicken and very well flavored), wraps, clubs. My daughter loves their wings and husband loves their pizza. Moral of the story - give a restaurant (especially local) another chance if they mess up. Sometimes, its well worth it! read more

Love supreme! This is our go to pizza place! The calzones are also amazing! Honey bbq chicken and the white pizza with grilled chicken added is the best! read more

Great food!!! We were in the area for kids haircuts and decided to try this place while waiting. Definitely worth it. They have amazing pizza. I would say one of the best tasting around. Also had a honey bbq wrap and chicken finger sub. Both also excellent. I would give them a try. Glad we did. Will definitely be back. read more

we receive an half cooked Pizza last night , disappointing to say the least ... non bueno when prices go up ^ so should service ... we have to cook it some more to finish the process read more

tried finding a healthy option on the menu, ended up getting the mozzarella salad. Came with more croutons than salad. The lettuce was the crap quality kind that's more white than green. I gave the whole thing away, couldn't even stand to look at it. Very low quality food made without love and consideration to the person whos going to eat it. Probably fits well for the neighborhood, but isn't for anyone who only wants to eat quality food. Think Mcdonalds, just more expensive. read more

I frequent here for lunch and the food is always pretty good. I usually call ahead and pick up on arrival. Most recently I got the buffalo chicken wrap with French fries and it was very filling. The tenders had adequate buffalo sauce. When I requested bbq sauce for my fries they did add an extra charge, about .50. I was a little surprised it wouldn't be complimentary. I also have had their pizza before which is really good. The service always seems rushed but that doesn't bother me since I'm just picking up. read more

We ordered pizzas and they tasted amazing. Not super greasy and very great. Nothing was bad and they came quickly. Prices were very reasonable. read more

Uggh - if I could give a zero star rating, that's what this joint deserves for the "sandwich" they served me. On my way up to Boston, I met a friend who works locally in the area for lunch at Supreme. This same friend told me that the sandwiches at Supreme are excellent. So taking his advice, I ordered a chicken parmigiana grinder. When it arrived, the "chicken" was comprised of two previously frozen foodservice breaded patties that are made up of indescribable chicken cast offs and makes Chicken McNuggests seem premium. The sauce? Out of a big foodservice can from Sysco or Perkins probably - at least it tasted that way. No Italian flavor at all. Isn't this supposed to be an Italian food place? Vote with your feet and your hard earned dollars fellow Yelpsters. Go elsewhere for quality food. No customer deserves to be served crap food like I was. I took one for the team so that you don't have to. read more

The absolute BEST pizza in Cumberland. Delicious wings with great flavor options. Their sandwiches are incredible as well.

When I lived closer I'd go here before any other spot. I remember when there was Castle Pizza before in the same spot. What a dump. Unfortunately, while tasty, CHOPS is closer. read more

We have been eating at Supreme for years. I previously rated them a 4, but the past few months, the pizza has started to get greasier and the ingredients less generous. The prices have also gone up as the quality has gone down. Overall, decent food with nice delivery guys, but not something I would rush to buy for company (unless it's the high schoolers). read more

Better than corporate pizza, but it's pretty typical and nothing special. You'll be okay, but I didn't find it to be the best pizza or worth the effort. There's better out there. This one is here for the convenience factor. I will recommend the garlic-onion combo, and while it smells super strong, it tastes quite good. Regardless, I just can't say too much positive things about this one. Just okay and a little bland. You won't be disappointed, but you also won't be glad with your investment. Service is all right. Not much atmosphere. Parking is easy. read more

Poor customer service and staff isnt aware of menu options. Paid for meal and received no receipt to support being shortchanged on meal options. read more

Stopped in on a whim driving home from a day trip. The price was just right but didn't match the flavor. The pizza and steak and cheese sub we got were outstading. The pizza, good crust, great flavor, cheese was of quality, everyone raved about it. The steak and cheese was perfect and the steak had a great flavor. We also had cheese fries the kids like them but i wasnt a fan. Not my liking for my style of fries and it was a cheap cheese sauce. read more

Here's another review where I wish we could give 1/2 stars. I would love to give supreme 3.5 stars, but they really don't deserve 4 stars and I wouldn't give them 3 stars usually, but they forgot to deliver my sauces today, so I'm going with 3. My office is in the area, so we order from Supreme quite often. I have had a few of their items but I've come to settle on the marinated grilled chicken tips with a side of their Spanish rice. The chicken is nice and tender with a fantastic flavor from the marinade. Other than today, I usually order and receive bbq sauce and hot wing sauce and mix those together for a dip. Obviously I'm still a little bitter about receiving honey mustard in stead...yeah a little petty. They have a really good cheese steak and chicken parm. I usually order the chicken parm with grilled chicken instead of the fried (see above statement about the marinade). The delivery times can vary. Usually they're within 10 minutes of delivery time however they have been 20 minutes late before and 10 minutes early. Kind of a crap shoot, so be sure to allow enough time. Like I said, this is a 3.5 star place. read more

My go to sub shop in the cumberland hill area. Excellent menu, good prices, fast service, delivery. Everything CHOPS isn't! Parking can be tough during busy times. read more

They suck. I ordered two SMALL calzones. It came to $27. And the girl showed me that it was correct. DONT GO HERE. SAVE YOUR MONEY. ITS A RIP OFF. read more

Supreme has all of the standard pizza delivery food. Huge pizzas, an assortment of chicken wings, cheese fries and most importantly jalapeno poppers. I am picky about my poppers and Supreme's passes the test. Delivery is always fast (I might be biased because I live less than 10 minutes away) and service is consistently friendly. They remember you by name and will always call if they have a question on your order. Plus being able to order online is great. read more

Good pizza, excellent eggplant parm sub. A great value for something quick and easy for the family after work.

Calzones and pizza have always been pretty good. There is a vegetarian burrito option on the menu, but I would seriously love if you would have one solid vegan option on your menu that's not a salad, perhaps a veggie burger that doesn't have any meat eggs or dairy in it! read more

Today I ordered a small onion rings and large chicken parmigiana sandwich to stay. I was pleasantly surprise by the service even during a busy lunch shift. The onion rings were brought right to my table and were hot and crispy. Then a few minutes later my chicken parmigiana was delivered to my table. The sandwich was hot and the chicken was juicy. One of the best chicken parmigiana sandwiches I've had in a long time. read more

VERY DISAPPOINTED! --! I am new to this area -- and this is only my second attempt at Supreme and both have been not good, but this was a terrible experience! I ordered a Turkey Club, which was cut wrong (never seen a club cut in half), bacon was mostly in the middle not in the sandwich, bread was soggy and cold, and I asked for pickles and I got not even a whole (but half a pickle!). And was charged for the pickles, and also for "Xtra Onion Rings" and I received 7" -- with one packet of ketchup. Everything was cold! I also had a calzone and one half was perfect, other half look like it was stabbed or something...wide open, I removed the other piece to show. We are all struggling and need a job...but this is a horrible experience and I am really disappointed on the owners to allow this. The delivery guy was awesome, and the manager was great --- but I am out 30+ bucks and still trying to find out what to eat tonight. A true let down...I will not recommend this restaurant at all based on this second poor experience! read more

Good fresh food here.pretty typical pizza place.friendly staff. What I like here is the lunch specials.you can get 2 big slices of cheese pizza and a fountain soda with free refills for $3. Can't beat that! Pepperoni and daily specialty slices are available for 75 cents more. Only downside to coming here is the major lack of seating.only 6-7 booths and a couple tables in the middle.really small place.there's been times I've tried to go for lunch and with no place to sit down I go next door for Chinese.ive seen lots of people walk in and right back out due to no place to sit down.wonder how much money they are losing? I'll continue to come here. read more

Supreme pizza is a go to favorite for my family once a week. The pizza is always exactly how I want it, which does tend toward the greasier side, but that's the style I like. Their ricotta calzones are delicious, it's hard to find a place in RI that has ricotta as an option, and that's how I thought all calzones were made growing up in CT! The staff deserves a lot of credit for operating so well in such a small space-there's a rhythm they have to consistently meet the expectations of their customers even when the place is slammed with orders, and always with courtesy and friendliness. read more

Thin crust, fresh toppings of mushrooms bacon n pepperoni n peppers, awesome Greek salad cut thin on feta n heaping veg