Great stop after a walk around downtown Bentonville! There are standard favorites like cookies and cream and chocolate, but they have some unique treasures to try as well- like lemon poppyseed and smoked road. Cute shop, fair prices for "downtown," and nice people! read more

See all

We were the only customers on a cold night (we refuse to let temperatures limit our ice cream consumption). Ice cream was simple (in a good way), seemingly devoid (I didn't look it up) of a lot of additives and colorings. Flavor-wise, they have both standard and creative varieties. Friendly service, good stuff. read more

Really sweet! Met the owner, Allie, and ordered the mint chocolate and mocha toffee ice cream in a cup. It was delicious! I can tell it's homeade.. in a good way! Highly recommend and it's very colorful inside! read more

First of all, the decor in here is so cool. It is brightly colored and top-to-bottom a fun vibe. It matches with the bright ice cream flavors. I had two different flavored scoops in a cup for $6.25. The flavors I got were Lemon Poppyseed and Sweet Strawberry. Both were SOOOO insanely delicious and that was maybe the fastest I've ever finished my ice cream. Sweet Strawberry was different than your typical strawberry ice cream-- it tasted more fruity and a little bit tart-- just perfect. Lemon poppyseed had chunks of lemon bar in it and is so refreshing. I can't decide which I love more, so I will always want to get the two together. On a separate visit, I got the salty caramel and chocolate brownie. I would definitely say the lemon poppyseed and sweet strawberry were more standout and the chocolate brownie was very average and almost a little starchy in texture. The menu of flavors isn't very extensive but it looks like they focused on quality of each flavor they do offer, rather than quantity of flavors, which is fine for me. However, I'd be reluctant to bring my boyfriend here, as he always goes for s'mores, chocolate chip cookie dough, or mint chocolate chip and this place doesn't have any of these flavors. Why 4 stars? Well, the ice cream flavors and texture were 5 stars minus the mediocre-tasting chocolate brownie flavor. The hardness to softness ratio and creaminess were so perfect on all of them. The decor and ambiance were also 5 stars. The small list of flavors is a bit difficult for some. However, the price was the real turn-off. At $6.25 for two flavors, it felt like big city prices for a small town ice cream shop. Its $5 for one flavor, which feels super overpriced. After I finished my ice cream, I felt like I wanted way more of it. Also, there is no option for no-surcharge cones. You can pay $1.25 extra to get a waffle cone in either cup or cone form, but I think that is also a little too steep in price. Also, if you want to add toppings, it's also pretty expensive at $1 per topping-- really?!! I definitely would come back again, but the prices are just hard for me to feel good about repeated visits. read more

See all

Went for dairy free ice cream and was not disappointed. It was definitely coconutty but amazing with the crushed Oreos. I truly enjoyed my experience here. read more

SOOO GOOD. My husband met the owner while he was working and the owner said to come check it out because it had clean ingredients (or at least cleanER). We were like yeah, okay. Fancy downtown ice cream isn't really my thing. But uhhhh I wanna come back like tomorrow and the next day and the next day. I got the honey peanut butter ice cream (I was not expecting the honey ice cream to be that good since I like honey a little, but not a lot. It was incredible. And they let you try it first) and my husband got cookies and cream. The waffle cones were only a dollar and definitely the best waffle cone I've ever had. They are somewhat oily though so wipe your hands after eating. 5/5 stars. We drove by Trash on our way home and it was packed and I felt like I needed to yell out the window to tell everyone to go to Superfine instead! read more

Superfine Sweets Shoppe - Honey pb & cookies and cream on waffle cones - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

Superfine is conveniently located in the Bentonville town square so it makes for a good place to grab desert after having dinner in the square. The ice cream is good which is the most important quality in an ice cream shop. The interior has this overwhelming yellow/orange hue to it which is a bit much for me and the interior had a bare feeling to it. They have the counter with the ice cream then tables and chairs and not much else making the space feel open but also a little vacant. Next time I go, I'll likely eat my ice cream outside on a bench in the square. read more

Stopped in for some after dinner ice cream treats! Tried strawberry, cookie dough and chocolate infused with peanut butter. All were pretty good, favorite was cookie dough for sure. read more

Superfine Sweets Shoppe - Strawberry! Yum! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

Really cool vibe! The freshly made cones were the best we have ever had. Definitely a great spot to try out

Brought the kids here today and they really loved the mint chocolate chip ice cream, great little atmosphere, very friendly staff, decent pricing read more

Superfine Sweets Shoppe - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

This place is awesome! You walk in and it's so trendy! The pink columns with bananas, is my favorite part! I love that they have a variety of ice cream flavors and type. The dairy free flavors are amazing! I got the cookie dough which was dairy free and is coconut based! They also have cookies and other sweets for sale. I did not try them, but I heard from a friend they are very good! Make sure to go check the owner's other delicious creations at Oven + Tap. If you like pink and you like ice cream you will love this place! read more

See all

Unique & fresh flavors! Loved that they had a smaller sized kiddie cup for our toddler. Small space for seating! Conveniently located!

Good, not great. They let you sample the flavors which I appreciate. I tried popcorn pb&j which had no peanut butter flavor so I ordered a scoop of mocha toffee with magic shell chocolate. The texture of the ice cream is great, but again the mocha toffee had little to no coffee flavor. On top of that, I found 2 toffee chunks in my entire cup. If it hadn't been for the chocolate magic shell it would have been very bland. read more

My husband and I have a love for all desserts. We were excited to try this cute new sweets shop in downtown. The staff was friendly and allowed us to taste each ice cream. The strawberry and mint chocolate chip were both delicious but we ended up getting the mocha toffee and cookies and cream. The ice cream was creamy and fresh. They also have unique flavors like lemon pop and golden milk that we will have to try next time. I also want try some of their cookies, brownies, and pies! read more

Superfine Sweets Shoppe - Love the vibrant vibe of this shop! The staff was delightful. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

Very cute place. Wonderful variety of ice creams, delicious cookies, and more. Love the decore and atmosphire. Stop by if you are in the area. read more

Superfine Sweets Shoppe - Sweet Strawberry Ice Cream and Lemon Sugar Cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

Overpriced. $5 for a small scoop? No thanks. Go to the Spark Cafe or Braums. Just as good and a fraction of the price.

We stumbled upon this place in downtown Bentonville and are so glad we did! The interior decor drew us into the shop. We tried salted caramel and chocolate brownie and both were delicious. The texture was soft and the flavors felt gourmet. Customer service could have been a tiny bit better, as I have a severe peanut allergy and more care could have been taken to properly clean the scoop, but other than that everything was great! read more

Best ice cream in Bentonville! So happy to have a really great homemade ice cream shop. I appreciate that they let you try options before ordering. I had the mint chocolate chip and loved it! read more

This was my favorite ice cream when it first opened, it was compared to italian ice cream but now it has changed completely, I can find better ice cream at the grocery store. I only received two smalls scoops for $7, flavorless and icy not creamy as it used to be, not worth it. read more

Beautiful atmosphere and some really great ice cream! The flavors sound very interesting (peanut butter and jelly popcorn) but I promise they're delicious! read more