We went in to do a tasting and wound up using them for our wedding favors in 2015. Amazing service…read moreand amazing product. I'm glad I found them on line. I will be browsing for another purchase soon.

Seriously, the most delicious handmade chocolate truffles I've ever had! There are 40+ flavors and…read morewe tasted about 10 of them. The cookie dough, cookies & creme, bay caramel, and port wine truffles were my favorites, but I don't think you could go wrong with and of their confections. We also tried the chocolate covered pretzels and they madeleines which were so yummy. The owners were so friendly and helpful that I decided to order truffles for my wedding favors. It's nice to support a small business where the owners really have a passion for what they do.

Coming to IT'SUGAR on 02/12 was a treat. Lol, no pun intended. It makes you reflect! It made me…read morereflect! Walking inside, I see all the gummy bears, all the sweet and sour worms, all the chocolate. I'm freshly reminded of my first toy candy which is PEZ. I went to the zoo on a class field trip in Frankfurt Germany. Elementary! Mom gave me and my brother money. This guy goes and buy mom a plaque with a monkey on it. I go and buy the PEZ candy toy for myself. We get home and she yells at me saying that I was selfish. I was so made. A moment of reflection and feeling nastalgic. So I think I'm not the only one that purchased the candy cigarettes and pretended to smoke. I'm just happy that I wasn't influenced by that act. But IT'SUGAR has a lot of sweet stuff (lol no pun) for you to try. I was treated to a pack of stogies and I had to be the gentleman and lite a cigarette. Smh! Feeling amused and longing to return here when it's warmer weather, this was fun... Inspire more, Yelp more!

Great selection of sweets both chocolate, hard candies, gummies and licorice. There's something for…read moreeveryone They also have additional merchandise on the sides. The interior of the store is very well kept There is different pricing depending on how much you want. We went with the half pound bag, and filled it up with our favorite gummies Decent pricing for its value, made for a good visit within the outlet mall

This is the kind of business that makes you really appreciative of Babylon in general. Let me start…read moreby saying I work for a high-end chocolate company and really appreciate the good stuff. This particular company, located in a stunning location in a house by the docks, manages to combine high-end and accessible chocolate into a delicious, well-presented and affordable product. I first tried Morgan's Bay truffles when my cousin brought some to Christmas the year before last. They were perfect- every one is equally delicious, individually wrapped and packed in reasonably priced sizes. When you go into the shop, Nyna is so friendly and informative, and you can't help but feel welcome and excited to buy things. No hard-sell here- I was shopping for V-Day chocolates for my kids and she recommended I start with a smaller box rather than the large one. While I waited, she gave me samples to try of something chocolate (I can't recall what right now) as well as what was unequivocally the best caramel I've ever tasted, soft and not over sweet, with just enough sea salt to bring out the caramel flavor. It was really unbelievable. I worry enough people might not realize what an amazing chocolate and homemade candy resource exists right in the village, due to the lack of foot traffic on Post Place. If you need a thoughtful gift or just want some really good chocolate for yourself, you should definitely check out Morgan's Bay. I'm really excited to see their new website when it comes up, and I am definitely going back for chocolates the next time I need to get a present for someone. I really can't underscore what an overall excellent customer experience Morgan's Bay provides. Really top notch!

One of the most wonderful things about living in a non-industrialized, less suburban area is…read morediscoveries like Chocolate by Morgan's Bay. Down meandering roads of elegant New England-style homes and built-up Cape Cods in the village of Babylon is a blue waterfront house that serves as a chocolatier's studio. Right on top of the docks is Nina's passion project, a chocolate shop unlike any other. There are no artful displays of mass-produced truffles and treats. Rather, Victorian dessert plates grace a table up front with packaging displays, with one lone refrigerator gracing the waiting area by the register. The buying experience is also different from any other. The owner, Nina, believes that it's hard to convey a taste or sensation with words. So she describes her treats by offering sample tasting plates -- for free! Be prepared to buy after you try, though. She has no set flavor list, preferring to make custom orders or go where imagination takes her. The rich Belgian chocolate truffles are hearty and full-flavored, whether the centers are liqueur-spiked ganache or Oreo cookies in the consistency of a dense chocolate cake. Also part of the sampler platter are candied orange peels--fragrant, sweet, and addicting. However, the showstopper for me was her most easily made confection -- the almond butter brittle. Buttery and rich without being overly sweet, this is a praline-style treat that delivers satisfaction without the toothache. Also offered are chocolate-covered strawberries, peanut butter patties covered in chocolate, and hand-dipped chocolate-covered cherries. The prices are reasonable, and actually less expensive than many other chocolatiers, since Nina seems to weigh lightly. Generally, $2 a piece is the norm, but here, $2 will buy you roughly two and a half pieces, creating a packed half pound for $12.50. The only shortcoming would be that the white chocolate selection is nearly nonexistent and that the bon-bons aren't of perfect uniformity. But that's if you're being really picky (which I sometimes am, since I was spoiled in New Orleans by Sucré). But in conclusion, wrapped up in a festive red bow, Chocolates by Morgan's Bay is a great gift idea or special treat. Truly a hidden gem in a waterfront community.

This store is Amazing! if you want down a walk down the candy memory lane or shopping for a…read moreparticular kind of treat, look no further! this place has every type of candy you can think of. the store is easy to navigate and the staff couldn't be more friendly or helpful. very reasonable prices as well! I will be taking my grandkids there next week. We are all literally and figuratively kids in a candy store once entering this place!

I purchased 2 bags of Coffee Rio candy from Long Island. They canceled 1 bag and shipped the other…read more I called and wrote them to ask why the bag was canceled and never got a response. I received the other bag and the entire bag the candy is stale and a large number are stuck together and out of any wrapper. Normally, I don't leave a negative review for any company and consider it a fluke, but I did write a negative review on their own website. I saw the review was posted and the next day when I happen to check again the review was gone from their website. That is what motivated me to write here on Yelp. I am sorry but don't sell candy that is stale and accept any negativity that comes your way.

The best ice cream truck ever, Heidi comes around in her ice cream truck about the same time…read moreeveryday, I make sure I buy a cone or ice cream sandwich, I will support Heidi's soft ice cream truck through the spring, her truck brings back some normalcy to the neighborhood and to me. She always has a smile, she's clean, friendly and polite, thank you Heidi for the professional showcase you are. I just saw you today, I just brought another delicious ice cream and I will buy another one tomorrow for sure. Sign: P.S.E

From the owner: Soft and hard ice cream read more

Such a cute shop, everything is pink which is right up my alley. They have gummy candy as well, not…read moresure if it's considered Swedish candy as I was only there for an iced latte. Went with the banana bread iced latte which was good, I think I was more excited about the heart shaped cup and heart shaped straw that it comes with.

This is one of the cutest tea spots on Long Island! The décor and ambiance are absolutely adorable,…read morecreating a fun, vacation-like atmosphere that's perfect for both adults and kids.They offer a great variety of drinks, including boba tea, candy-inspired beverages, and plenty of other delicious options. Everything we tried was really good! As an added bonus, there's a charming boutique right next door where you can browse jewelry and other cute accessories. It's the perfect place to enjoy a refreshing drink and do a little shopping. Definitely worth a visit!

This place is just so awesome! Anytime I need a good cheese it's my goto. The staff and owner are…read morefabulous - this last time I took my daughter (who recently discover cheese) to find out which one she liked most. They let us sample a range of awesome blue's, and then we grabbed her a wedge of her own "nibbling cheese" that I'm not allowed to touch. Make sure to try their sandwiches, mac and cheese, or charcuterie boards (or supplies for them). They are all fantastic!

Cute little shop! The staff is always very kind and knows what they're talking about but not…read moreoverbearing which I appreciate! Tons of different cheese to try and other things here and there. They're also always more than happy to let you sample the cheese. The parking could be better, but it's not usually super crowded. I'm definitely going to try some of their food next time I go!

I had ordered an arrangement for Mother's Day and I even paid 20 extra dollars for an hour delivery…read moreas well, I wanted to give it to my aunt whose done a lot for me and I'm on my first job now and it makes it exciting I can buy nice things but four hours later it said delivered and it didn't come so I emailed and called and no answer and the next day Monday I called and emailed and no answer at all and today I called and said they would tell corporate and never answered me back it was 120 dollars for that arrangement

First let me say "Super Fantanstik" goes above and beyond, great communication. I live on NJ and…read morehad no idea relatives moved 1 yr ago,Sent a beautiful arrangement to their address and had no way of locating a new address. Atiff the owner waiting patiently for a new address for hours. Finally I asked him to deliver to the funeral home on the other side of town which he graciously did. SUPER TERRIFIC CUSTOMER SERVICE! The fruit arrangement was wonderful too.