I just want to update this review to share that we recently catered sandwiches and apps from the OG…read moreJohn's on Stilwell, and everything was just phenomenal! Did an OG Johnny Roast Beef 2 foot hero - and it was fantastic. They kept the onions and gravy on the side and people could add it at their leisure - it was perfect. Also did an Eric Murphy 3 foot hero - and it was soo good. Ari even gave us some balsamic and olive oil on the side it was a big hit! We also order potato croquettes which are always delicious, as well as mini rice balls. I was very impressed cause we shared our concerns about a nut allergy and they were sure to take every precaution making sure no pistachios made it near the order. It was so nice to know that our go to for sandwiches will now easily become our go to for catering large groups too! Big shout out to Ari, really went above and beyond on this one! Thank you!

Still as yummy as always :) love their sandwiches when I am in the area. The sesame bread is really…read moregood! And so is the assembly. Thank you!

Hands down the best sandwich I've eaten in New York, maybe the U.S. (hear me out). No long lines,…read moreno markups. They keep it real, from the Hot Italian to the potato salad, everything is deliciously prepared. Both Late Night Jimmys can't be wrong. Stop by, hear a story or two and get a great lunch.

Came to Jimmy's Famous Heroes for the first time after hearing about it online as a spot in…read moreSheepshead Bay to check out. Ordered the chicken cutlet hero to go as that was the most popular item on the menu. It was tasty and satisfying but a bit overhyped. If I'm being honest at $18 it's a bit pricey. You can get a better sandwich for more a bit more money at like Katz Deli with their pastrami in my opinion. My order was processed quickly. The place itself is a bit of an old school deli vibe to it and can feel like a time capsule. On the wall they have all the celebrities who have stopped by like Jimmy Fallon and Jimmy Kimmel.

The best bagel place ever! They were fast and courteous and the chicken salad and bagel were…read morefantastic!

WOW! The 2 two things I tried were oustanding! The fried ravioli was delicious & that marinara…read moresauce was to die for. The godfather sandwich was amaazzzing! It is definitely one of my top 5 sandwiches in NYC. The sandwich doesn't look anything special, but when you eat it you will be amazed! There was so much different delicious flavors at every bite: savory, sweet, spicy, tangy. It was a party in my mouth! I make happy sounds whenever I eat delicious foods & I was making too much of that. I also kept saying "jesus christ this is one delicious sandwich"! The cool thing is that u can tell them how to season the sandwich. I asked for the red pepper tomato concoction, pesto, basil, mayo, black pepper, frated parmesan cheese, white vinegar, balsamic glaze. That combo seasoning made that sandwich even more delicious! I have passed by this shop many times & I regret not trying it earlier. I can't wait to try their other sandwiches. I highly highly recommend this shop!

I've lived in the area for many many years and never tried John's deli. Decided to come here and…read morepick up some sandwiches. They have a big menu so it's overwhelming. I ordered The Godfather and a hot roast beef sandwich (forgot the name). The Godfather wasn't bad but nothing special about it. The roast beef sandwich was really bland, this could just be a normal thing because I've had other roast beef where it's also bland. If I ever make it back here again I'd love to try their hot foods instead of another sandwich.

Cropsey Bagels is a nice place and a lot of people like it. Only one thing is not right - there are…read moretags 'Hazelnut' and 'Franch Vanila', in fact, there are the same ordinary coffee.

Great everything bagel - incredible lox - solid cream cheese. Friendly service and classic bagel…read moredeli vibes. Good selection of cold drinks too

First off I want to say this place is a neighborhood gem and if it ever went away I'd be…read moredevastated. I come here almost every day for breakfast, coffee, and maybe a sweet treat. If any of the owners are reading this, I just have one suggestion! I know y'all are a bakery, but it would be amazing if you had a breakfast option that wasn't bread related, like a yogurt parfait. You have the cups, fruits, nuts and maybe even the yogurt already! Think about it, I'd buy one every day ;) Love you guys!

Extremely disappointing experience, both with the quality of the cake and the customer service…read more We purchased a seven-layer chocolate cake two days ago for my mother-in-law's birthday, expecting a fresh, delicious cake for a special family celebration. Unfortunately, the cake was incredibly stale and tasted like it had been sitting around for days. It was embarrassing and disappointing to serve something of such poor quality at a birthday celebration. Rather than making a scene or publicly complaining, we went back to the bakery and discreetly brought the issue to an employee's attention, hoping for some understanding and a reasonable resolution. Instead, we were met with a completely dismissive and unaccommodating attitude. The only solution offered was a $10 store credit, which honestly felt insulting given the circumstances. Mistakes happen, and we understand that, but how a business handles those mistakes speaks volumes. We weren't looking for anything unreasonable, just accountability and decent customer service. Unfortunately, we received neither. lol to respond to the chat gbt response from owner Vinny boombatz, none of your un trained workers admitted that you have a stale cake frozen section where you put week old cakes and sell them as " frozen fresh " nice try. Just linked up with one of your old employees though who confirmed you have a freezer filled with stale garbage you're too cheap to throw out. Whoever loves this bakery please ask prior to what you're buying if it's fresh, apparently that's not something you should just assume with this dump.

First time ordering from them. I've been dying to try this place for months! We got one Ray romano…read morehero which is absolutely delicious, a loaf of bread we will have with dinner tonight and the rice and prosciutto balls which were will have tonight but the sandwich is one of the best heros I've ever had and it's HUGE!!!!!!!!!!! I could only eat half of a half and I was starving. I can't wait to try more from this place!!!!

I've been to the Staten Island location so it was time to…read moretry this original spot. It is a tremendous menu so you need to take your time or you can always make your own sandwich. The service is good, efficient and the heroes easily feed 4 people each imo. So the prices are worth it . I was a little disappointed in my eggplant hero bc it looked a bit burned but overall we were all happy and felt it was worth it.

I love this place. G & S has a nice assortment of freshly butchered meat and chicken…read more I'm always trying something from their selection of prepared hot food and the hero sandwiches are made to order. The whole crew is awesome and very informative with food preparation. Did I say I love this place? You will too.

Sandwich was big and filling but waiting for it in a dusty, grimy grocery store was not on my list…read moreof expectations. The man serving me was friendly, I even tipped him. He made the sandwich per my request as best he could. But y he dirt in the front of the shop, plus all the dust and grime accumulated throughout the shelves and cans/non perishables is the ONLY reason I wouldn't come back. If the front of shop looks this bad, how clean is the kitchen?

Wow! I am glad I found this spot on Yelp. The restaurant is at the corner of the block and it has 2…read moresides to order from which is weird, one has Mexican and the other side has more Americanized food. I ordered a steak Cemitas, steak quesadilla and chorizo taco. The steak Cemitas was my favorite, it was huge with stuffed toppings. The quesadilla was tasty and different from the usual quesadillas, it was so crispy with the toppings on top. The taco was my least favorite, it was plain with just cilantro and onions. The service was pleasant and helpful. It was also a really nice day to enjoy authentic Mexican food sitting outside.

My experience at this establishment was mixed, and it started with confusion before I even placed…read morean order. The cashier informed me that I could not order through her, yet there was no visible signage indicating where customers were supposed to order. For a business operating in a busy beach environment, clear direction and customer flow are essential, and that aspect was noticeably lacking. The seating situation was equally puzzling. After receiving my food, I noticed many people occupying the tables while eating food from completely different establishments. Throughout my visit, groups carrying various meals from around the beach sat freely without being informed otherwise. This gave the impression that the seating area functions more as a public beach dining space than as seating reserved for paying customers. Management may want to evaluate this arrangement, as it can diminish the experience for patrons who purchased food from the restaurant. As for the food itself, the sandwich was undeniably large and offered a generous portion for the price. However, much of the value seemed tied to its size rather than its flavor. The chicken breast was substantial but lacked seasoning and depth of taste. The agua de horchata was even more disappointing, with a flavor that tasted artificial and more reminiscent of a powdered mix than a traditional homemade recipe. Overall, this is not a place that stands out for its atmosphere, food quality, or customer experience. While the portions are impressive, the flavors fail to match the presentation, leaving the impression that you're primarily paying for quantity rather than quality. With improvements to customer service, clearer organization, and more attention to flavor, the experience could be significantly better in the future. Rating: 3/5 stars. Decent portions, but the overall experience and food quality leave plenty of room for improvement.

The Mefuneket sandwich may be simple, but is so so delicious! I love that it comes with some many…read morefresh veggies. Moti the owner is so sweet. He's always checking in on everyone and making each customer feel like they're one of his friends. If you want more pepper, no problem! Moti will give you extra banana peppers or jalapeños if you ask. The store itself isn't the prettiest to look at, but the service and food more than make up for that. I highly suggest you come to Think Sweet for breakfast or lunch if you're in the neighborhood.

5/29/24 My brother introduced me to this "hole in the wall…read morewith great Shakshuka". The cozy restaurant is tiny with 2 tables on the ground floor but there is also seating upstairs. We had the freshly toasted sliced baguette with Zatar spiced cream cheese, pickled jalapenos, and pickled banana peppers. Then each of our Shakshuka was brought out individually by the owner. It was in a skillet, covered to stay hot. My shakshuka was fresh, flavorful, and prepared exactly the way I requested (eggs over hard instead of the typical over easy). The owner kept coming to check on all the customers and make sure they had everything they wanted. Before leaving the owner ran to the kitchen to prepare a Nite Toast for us to sample. It was so delicious. I may start with that next time. This was a wonderful homey experience with warmth, hospitality, and excellent food.