I would give no stars if possible. My son broke his arm in two places, an uncomplicated break, we were told. Our pediatrician referred us to Suburban Orthopedics and were were supposed to see Dr. Chhadia, unfortunately that is not who entered the room to cast my 5 year old son. Instead, Dr. Freedberg is who we were seen by, something we regret deeply.
There is much to complain about, and it's a little hard to even know where to start. His entire demeanor is off-putting. He is abrupt, uncaring and rude. He should NEVER treat pediatric patients, as has none of the compassion one would hope for when treating a young patient.
Let's start with the casting. My 5 year old son is a bruiser. He is tough as nails and has always been that way. Therefore, when he complains about pain, we take him seriously. He is not jumpy or whiny by nature. After a sleepless night, because we were not able to keep him comfortable enough to rest while his arm remained un-casted, Dr. Freedberg entered the room. My son was terrified and in pain, Dr. Freedberg was unfeeling and never said a word of kindness or comfort. While they casted my son, he screamed in fear and pain, absolutely screamed at the top of his lungs. After the fiberglass was in place, Dr. Freedberg squeezed the cast to set it and I thought my son honestly might faint. All this was done with no pain management, no local anesthetic, nothing. I am not aware of the options that we may have had, if any, for pain management, because they were never discussed with us. My son's pain was entirely ignored and in fact, at one point during the casting, Dr. Freedberg actually looked down at my son and with the most disdain he could muster, said to him, "You are not helping yourself with all that screaming." It took everything to stay focused on consoling my son and setting a good example when I wanted to give the doctor a piece of my mind. Would it have been so hard to say something kind "I know this hurts buddy, I'm being as careful as I can and we are almost done." I mean, c'mon! How hard would it have been to say something like that?!
Fast-forward to cast removal -
Cast removal went well (Brandon was an absolute delight, thanks to him for being so sweet and kind during the actual removal process, he should give Dr. Freedberg lessons.)
The entire time that my son was in a cast (only 4 weeks), I kept telling people that I wouldn't care if Dr. Freedberg was a jerk to us, as long as he did his job and healed my son. Even still, as Dr Freedberg entered the room, I was hoping that, under a different light (more sleep, less pain), he might appear to be different that he was on our first encounter. I was disappointed, as he is still rude. He glances a cursory glance at the new x-rays, squeezes my son's arm (which is crooked, by the way), my son yelps and jumps in pain, and then Dr. Freedberg declares "It doesn't hurt. I can tell by looking at the x-rays that it is healed." Um... again, my son does not self-report pain unless he is FEELING pain. I request that the doctor explain the x-rays to me, considering my son reported pain and has a crooked arm with no forearm suppination, and he, very condescendingly and curtly, gives me a half-assed response about the bones being healed and the crook being something that will go away with time. I am very uneasy but I am not a doctor, so we leave and I try to muster up some sort of trust in this man.
After the shocked response at the appearance and function of my son's arm and also the quick removal from a cast that we got from several friends, family and finally, 2 physical therapists, we decided to get a second opinion.
Our new doctor was dismayed at the fact that our son was already out of a cast after only 4 weeks (he said 6 weeks is typical for this type of break and his age, 8 weeks is cautious but often better, especially for a child like mine who is "rough and tumble"). In addition, he said that the new x-rays are definitely not what he would like to see. He said that the bones are only about 75% healed (hence the reason he should still be in a cast) and that one of the bones is healing more crooked than is preferred, which is causing the limited motility. While he agreed that the crooked bone may self-correct, he said it will take a watchful eye to make sure that we are seeing the kind of progress that we should and he was disappointed that we were even in this situation. I believe Dr. Freedberg did a bad job and as a result, my son is going to have limited mobility of his dominant arm for a good amount of time (potentially years) and *may* eventually require invasive surgery to fix the bone alignment, if it does not self-correct enough. :( read more