Great Pizza! I had the "Popper" pizza and it was delicious. However, I would've liked to have had a…read morelittle more meat on it. There is vey limited seating inside, but you feel almost as though you are sitting in the kitchen which is kind of cool. The service was friendly and accommodating.

They are super nice and polite, the food is amazing and tastes homemade; and the place has a calm…read morelively environment.

Greasy gross pizza, rude staff, sometime is always outside smoking. Trash is over filled and on the…read moreground. The kitchen worker liked over worked as there at only 1 person trying to keep up with the demand. Yet they were stocking sodas rather than focusing on their kitchen. The cashiers have no idea what foods is being prepared or what their specials area. But lack of communication within the staff. I will not go back to any Caseys general store, ever. The entire franchise lost my business.

So I order 2 pizzas they say it will take 20-25 min well I waited for 40-45 min so if I could I…read morewould rate this a half a star

Just passing through town, took a room and ordered pizza…read more Friendly people on phone and delivery. Pizza topping were top notch (Italian sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms)Sauced correctly, but only gave 4 stars due to underdone crust. Still if you are in town you'll find this pizza good.

Food is amazing and the staff are super nice and a great location to over all super amazing very…read morecool place

There were hairs, and worms in the pizzas. The wings were cold, and raw I do not recommend this…read morepizza plus! The waiter was super rude she told me to eat the damn food and to not be a brat. I will speak with my father about this Pizza Plus it is the worse! Do not recommend at all 1 star!!

Hands down the best pizza I've ever had. Not greasy at all and so much flavor. They have so much…read moremore than just pizza as well.

I love good pizza and this meets the requirements so good flavoring kicks Pizza Hut out of the…read morecompetition that thin crust squares of pizza are so gooooooood Collin out!

we ordered a whole hour before they closed. order was in "quality check" for at least 30 min and it…read moreended up getting canceled. sounds like laziness to me.

Great Pizza service is great definetly 5 star worthy the raviolis are pretty great too salad bar is…read morepeak.

I ordered from door dash so I didn't go in the store. But the meat balls were VERY salty. That was…read moreterrible. The rest of the food I got though was good. Though the price ? Should be lower.

The ambience of this place is slightly nicer than a gas station. We were from out of town and the…read morereviews were good, and when we asked if we could sit and eat they said yes. But all the chairs were in stacks against the wall and we had to get our own chairs and put them next to the table. The specials list was old and torn. The server who helped us seemed shocked that we were there at all... Had almost no customer service skills. The pizza tasted like it came from an easy bake oven cooked by a lightbulb. Cracker-like crust that was not as good as something you'd get at a Casey's. Plastic plates and styrofoam cups for our drinks. Outdoor seating is a picnic table in the parking lot of a busy street. This is not a place to go if you want good ambience, good pizza, or good service.

Been wanting to try this place. Super excited they offer gluten free in all different sizes. Got a…read morelarge regular signature pizza which my kids loved which came with a liter of cola. On my small gluten free pie, I ordered the German. It was okay but I was disappointed the " sauerkraut" was basically just chopped up cabbage. Not sure what kind they're using but if it's homemade, they didn't put near enough vinegar on it. (Maybe they're trying to tailor it to Midwestern taste buds?) Perhaps a mustard sauce with extra cheese would've been a nice touch, especially if the sauerkraut wasn't actually sour.

We've been Arthur's pizza several times. Great pizzas great service people are really friendly…read more It's a great place to go and have a pizza.

The pizza has great flavor. The waitress was very nice. Building is charming. All a perfect…read morecombination after tonight's polar express train ride.