Stone Craft Pizza

Consistently one of the better choices in the area. Love their dough and sauce...deep dish is my…read morego to!

Donte's is my go-to. Everything is great. A nice dining room. The Sunday special is hard to…read morebeat. A large pizza, 10 wings, breadsticks, and a 2 liter for about $30. I've probably eaten there 100 times, and I've never had a bad meal. The lunch specials are crazy too, especially the pepperoni minis. I order the pizza well-done or they don't cook it enough.

Salad with tons of cheese

Large pepperoni & green pepper

See all

Italian hoagie on a Pitt plate

The Pizza Company

3.5(20 reviews)

2.0 mi

I order pretty often from the West Mifflin location, sometimes the owner delivers and sometimes my…read moreneighbor, pizza is great but more importantly it's consistent quality. I like knowing what I'm getting every time.

The young lady who answers the phone & takes the orders is…read moreincredibly rude! I hate how everytime I call to make an order she's really hostile & rushing me off of the phone before I can even say I'm finished...

Half mushroom pepperoni half onion and sausage

Raw Chicken from The Pizza Company In West Mifflin PA 3/29/14

See all

Steak salad

Fiori's Pizzaria

4.4(614 reviews)

5.3 mi•Beechview

Best in southills 30yrs customer Great service great slice…read moreof pie Good price Must try

Tip: if you want to leave a tip, bring cash - you can pay with a card, but you can't leave a tip…read more I was excited to try Fiori's. Old school dive-style pizza place (they also do sandwiches, calzones, etc). I got a nice greasy slice with mushroom and pepperoni. Pizza was not bad at all, just didn't live up to the hype. I enjoyed the sauce, but a little seasoning would have made this good slice of pizza, a great one. The crust was a nice mixture of crunchy and fluffy. The salad was ok - had a little too much dressing. The garlic bread that came with it was the best part of the whole meal. The soft, flaky bread, gently toasted with butter garlic on the inside was fantastic. No problem with the service.

Inside Vibe

Fiori's Cheese Pizza

See all

Fellinis Pizzeria

3.3(32 reviews)

2.6 mi

I'm surprised the place is so poorly rated. Yes, the seating isn't that great, and the atmosphere…read moreisn't either. But the food itself is quite good. Nothing amazing, but certainly not bad. I tried their plain cheese calzone and a brownie with caramel. The calzone was quite interesting. It's probably the greasiest calzone I've had in a while, but surprisingly, it was still really good. Most of the grease had already spilled out of the calzone by the time I bit in. It's topped with a ton of garlic, so the bread part tasted like garlic bread. It was really good. Plus, the calzone was stuffed with an adequate amount of cheese (mozzarella mostly, and a little bit of ricotta as well). Quite good. Portion size was great for the small, and price was around $14 so not too bad. Sauce on the side was sweet but cold when served. The brownie was really good. It was super fudgey and had large chunks of chocolate scattered throughout it. Very soft. It's absolutely delicious and honestly one of the best brownies I've had in a while. And, it's huge! It's like four brownies in one order for $5. All in all, I think this place is underrated. Atmosphere isn't the best, but the people are kind (they came out with my food while I was waiting in the car and were courteous). The calzone tasted like a garlic bread with cheese filling and brownie was amazing.

I've had a great experience ordering take out here! Pizza is always hot when I come to pick it up…read moreand tastes delicious every time. It's great to support a local business too! I love ordering from here.

Cheese calzone

14" pizza with garlic white sauce and chicken

See all

I like Fellinis this is not a slice it's almost criminal. What is this??

Italian Village Pizza

1.8(19 reviews)

1.1 mi

Breaks my heart that the quality and service of IVP has degraded so bad - it was a staple of my…read morechildhood. Just arrived for pickup only to find they had forgotten to make my order, then lied about it. When I finally got it, the pizza was half cooked. Huge disappointment.

Awful overpriced pizza. Worst Italian hoagie ever with very little meat on it. Place is absolutely…read moreFILTHY. Never ordering from this dump ever again.

See all

Pizza boat

Mm! Mm! Pizza

4.1(21 reviews)

1.6 mi

Oh my goodness! I do not know why we have been ordering from the national chain pizza joints when…read moreMm Mm is in our neighborhood! We decided to give them a shot because there was a coupon on their website that was tempting, and I drive past there pretty often and wonder if it's any good. Welllllllll, I can now report that it is DELICIOUS! The crust has just enough crunch to it, and the toppings are well proportioned. We called in our order and the person who answered was pleasant and accommodating. I'm sure they were rushed so I made sure to have my requests ready. The pickup place itself is small but clean. There's plenty of parking (but be careful there are a few potholes!) We WILL order again.

While our pizza was totally fine, it couldn't compare to the Mm Mm Pizza in Bethel Park which is…read moreour go-to pizza spot. The pizza was done on time and it was easy to pick up, with plenty of parking and polite staff. But, the pizza itself left a bit to be desired and was a bit chewy, and the breadsticks were thinner and a little more crisp on the bottom than others we've had. While I don't think we'll select this location again, I wouldn't complain if someone brought this pizza home for dinner.

See all

Yoli's Cucina and Crafthouse

4.0(122 reviews)

3.4 mi

I love their Sunday red sauce! Great family atmosphere. It feels like the kind of place you'd take…read morea big group when you have family in from out of town. Everything we ordered tasted great!

I made my first-ever visit to Yoli's on 885 this past fall. Growing up in the area, I have had…read moreYoli's several times at different events or by take-out, but this was my first time dining in at the restaurant. Yoli's Cucina and Crafthouse is located at the intersection of State Route 885 and Payne Hill Road. The building has been other restaurants in the past, but Yoli's has occupied the space for nearly a decade. It is very easy to locate from the road. There is a private parking lot as well. This is not a heavy business/commercial area, so it's very easy to park and navigate into the restaurant. My visit was on a Friday night this past August. We chose to come after seeing a Facebook post about "Friday Night Lights," which was extended hours on select Friday nights when the TJ High School Football Team was playing at home. My family and I attended the game, and usually will try to find a pizza place to go to afterwards. Since we saw the post for this, we decided to give it a try. We left the football game a little early, and arrived to the restaurant around 9:15 PM. Since the game was barely over, we were one of the first few groups in. The longer we were there, the more people filtered in from the game. It was not completely full though, so no problem getting a seat at a table or the bar. There are plenty of seating options. The dining room has many four-top tables, some booths, and bar-height four-tops surrounding the bar. Of course, there are bar seats. In the back, there are also several longer tables. I assume this room can be rented out and/or reserved, but on this night they had it open for dine-in. As advertised on Facebook, there was a special menu for this after-hours time. It was a limited menu with $10 Pizzas, $10 Yoli Rolis, and $3 White Claws and Domestic Bottles, plus other items. We were not given regular menus, but instead papers that had the limited menu printed. It listed all of the different items, however, it had no descriptions. This was an issue for us, since we were not regulars of the restaurant. Our server acted really strange about this honestly, and would not give us a regular menu to look at when we requested it for the descriptions specifically. So instead, we had to literally ask her what was in every single sandwich, what all of the toppings available for the pizzas were, and any other specifics about any items. I understand in theory why they made the menu like this, but it should have included item descriptions. It makes sense that they do not want customers trying to order off of the regular menu, since they are not serving everything. But, eliminating descriptions is an issue. This was the first "Friday Night Lights" of the season, so it is possible that this improved for other ones moving forward. Following that confusion about the menu, we placed our orders. Our food was ready in about 25 minutes. My mom and I split an 8-Cut Mushroom Pizza. My fiancé ordered The Baller, which was a half-size meatball hoagie with marinara sauce and melted provonello cheese. My dad ordered The Drunk Fish, which was a half-size Yuengling battered haddock with melted provonello cheese, house greens, and house tartar. Both sandwiches came with fries. We each enjoyed our food. The pizza was more than enough for the two of us, and we even had some leftover to enjoy the next day. It is not super thick, but it is not a New York slice, either. A good in-between. Both of the sandwiches were okay, but the portions with the fries were generous. I personally liked the fries. Overall, we had no real complaints about the meal. Everything came out in a timely manner and prepared well. The value of our meal on this night was great. Some of us got some drinks, but for the food it was only $30 before tax. Hard to beat that, especially considering it was four adults. I appreciate them having these specials! The staff here was average, all considering. As detailed, not being able to see the descriptions for the menu items was really bizarre, and unhelpful from a customer service perspective. Otherwise, we had no issues with the service or our waitress. I am glad I got the chance to dine in at Yoli's! As stated, I have had their pizza many times, but never dined in. We had a positive experience overall, but as detailed there are some areas for improvement, specifically relating to the limited menu/after hours events. I hope they continue to have success with these, and improve on them for the future. In an area with very few locally-owned restaurants, it is nice that Yoli's is around and continues to be successful. I hope to come back to try more of their menu on a typical business day, especially the Yoli's Rolis. I believe the "Friday Night Lights" is an incredible idea, and promotes a better community. If you find yourself in the Century III/South Hills area, definitely give this restaurant a try!

Back Room

Dessert trays

See all

Conti’s Pizzeria & Pit

4.1(55 reviews)

3.2 mi

great food ! Thank you ! Ingredients were fresh and well prepared…read more Pizza made with quality and pride

This place treats you like family. The sauce and crust complement each other very well. I'm kind of…read moresick of sauceless pizzas at most places. Dry and pizza are two words that don't complement each other much. Here you will get the salty and glorious taste of pizza done well. Just wait until you check out the party rooms upstairs. The service is up at the counter and they are accommodating. I usually drink fountain drinks, but they do carry tea by the carton. Conti's has been my favorite for a while now. A+

Inside seating

Pepperoni rolls at Conti's!!!

See all

Parking for Seton LaSalle Bowling party.

Vocelli Pizza - Pleasant Hills

3.1(32 reviews)

1.4 mi

We ordered pizza from Vocelli while visiting my parents in Pleasant Hills. We got delivery. It…read morewas on time and the driver was friendly and even helped make sure my parents dogs did not go to the street when they got out. The pizza was pretty standard, but that is what we were looking for. We did one plain pizza and one pepperoni.

I was sold cardboard basically. The driest pizza I've ever seen. I fully believe they reheated a…read morepizza from hours before I called because it looked 2 days old.

Pizza

See all

Tuscan Chicken Salad

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

George Z.

6 months ago

Tried Stone Craft Pizza in Pleasant Hills on Saturday night and came away impressed. Went with a 12-inch New York style pizza, half pepperoni, half sausage, with mushrooms. The sauce really stood out, well balanced and flavorful without being too sweet or too acidic. The crust had that perfect New York feel, thin, slightly crisp on the outside, but still soft enough to fold like a true NY slice. Everything tasted fresh, and the toppings were cooked just right. What really made the visit even better was the crew. Super friendly, welcoming, and you can tell they take pride in what they're doing. We even had the pleasure of meeting future employee baby Charlotte, already part of the team and stealing the show. Definitely a spot I'd go back to. I wish they delivered. read more

Frank S.

4 years ago

Great, quality pizza. Always on time when you arrive on time for pick up. Great customer service.

Stone Craft Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Stone Craft Pizza also viewed

Jimmy Z’s

4.2

(29 reviews)

After stopping for a 4cut 1 top pizza special with 20 oz drink i was pleasantly surprised by the…read morecrispy sicilian crust. The friendliness and service was spot on just like the pizza. I definitely recommend Jimmys after my first visit and I'll be bakk. *Arnold*

trying to order on line but could not find the list of toppings, called the store and was told they…read morewere closed. The web site said open and the time of closing was 9:30. I called at 8:45 and when I mentioned that I thought they were open until 9:30 I was told no we are closed. I really wanted to try this pizza I will try again in future hoping their web site was not correct giving them the benefit of the doubt .

Ya Ya's Pizza

4.3

(44 reviews)

Ordered was done quick. Everything tasted amazing especially the cinnamon sticks only request next…read moretime would be for more sauce on the wings but other than that very satisfied and will be back!

First time trying Ya Ya. Pizza was excellent and sauce was very good. You can definitely tell a…read moregood pizza shop by the amount of customers and the phone ringing nonstop.

The Pizza

3.9

(30 reviews)

If I could give this place 6 stars and a kidney, I would…read more We drive an hour--yes, ONE WHOLE HOUR--just to "see our friend." But let's be honest, we're only pretending to care about her. We're here for the pizza. The pizza with the adorably tiny pepperonis that curl up into little meat chalices of joy. Like, who authorized this level of cuteness on a pizza? I want to scoop them off and put googly eyes on them. But I won't. Because I eat them too fast. And then there's the ranch. Ohhhh the ranch. If this ranch were a person, I'd propose under a sunset. I could BATHE in it. If my bathtub ever mysteriously smells like garlic and dreams, don't ask questions. Just know I'm happy. Our friend always tries to make conversation like "how's life?" and "how's the family?" Meanwhile I'm 8 slices deep, covered in ranch, nodding like a feral goblin. She could tell me she moving to Peru and I'd just ask if she could grab me another slice before she goes. Please. Try this pizza.

Best meat eaters pizza ever! Nice people and food always ready on time. Plus they have Pepsi…read moreproducts.

Pizza Shack

4.1

(51 reviews)

Delicious pizza! Their sauce is top notch. It is a sweet sauce so just be aware before you get it…read more Walking inside is like walking into a Time Machine. Really cool spot with really nice workers!

Have been eating this pizza since the 70s. I will say that…read moreit's not everyone's favorite, but if you grew up in (or around) B-wood it probably holds a place in your heart. Not expensive, no frills, but delicious.

R & B's Pizza Place

3.9

(59 reviews)

Ordered takeout from here when we had a few people over. Not really any seating inside (it's a…read moretakeout place). The pizza is always solid from here. Service is great - My order came out perfect. Large pepperoni and cheese pizzas and an Italian wedgie. The small wedgie was HUGE.. We split it 4 ways. They have decent deals on their website for family night etc.

Excellent pizza. The service is nice, and friendly. I have only ordered food for delivery so I'm…read morenot sure what the inside is like.

Carol of Casey's Pizza

3.2

(44 reviews)

Located in Penn Hills Shopping Center. A "Sister" store of Casey's Pizza in Turtle Creek, along…read morePenn Ave. Great quality and always consistent quality of food. Delicious pizza, oven baked hoagies, calzones, wings, tenders, salads, pasta, and more. A few tables inside for Dine-in but mostly a takeout and delivery location. Delivery available. Always timely delivery and good drivers. Food is still hot when it arrives. The drivers are always courteous and friendly. The dough is homemade and always consistent. The sauce is flavorful with the perfect amount of tang and flavor. The bread comes from Mancini's Bakery in Pittsburgh. A highly popular and well known bakery with a delicious bread recipe. Highly recommended! A must try! Cheers!!

Great pizza. Great chicken parm. Meatball sub was okay. Too much sauce. Excellent customer service…read moreon both the phone and by the delivery person.

Luciano's Pizza & Six Pack To Go

3.3

(61 reviews)

My family has been visiting Luciano's for a long time now, and we always have a good experience…read more This particular visit, we came on a rainy Friday evening in May. Luciano's is located in Bethel Park in the middle of a quiet neighborhood. There is indoor seating, as well as carry out available. It is not huge on the inside, but there are probably at least 10 tables. On this day, it was not too crowded and we got a table right away. Our server was attentive to us and did a good job at taking our special request order correctly. Whenever we needed something, she provided it quickly. There were four of us total, so we decided to order the two Large 16" Pizzas special for $36.50. We were able to order one of those as a Traditional Pizza Half Plain and Half Pepperoni, and then a White Pizza, with a special request of putting the tomatoes on top of the cheese instead of underneath. We also got the Zucchini Planks to share as an appetizer. We enjoyed the zucchini before the pizzas came out. Some of them were sort of small, but there was definitely enough for the four of us to share. It came with a marinara sauce to dip. Our pizzas came out relatively quickly. We have always loved their pizza, and this time was no different. Both the White Pizza and the Traditional were hot and cooked perfectly. The pizza is not Thu. crust, but also not extremely bread-heavy, either. A perfect medium that will satisfy most parties. There was plenty for all of us to eat, and we had some leftovers to take home. I thought the value for what we got was great. With the pizza deal, the bill came to less than $50 for the four of us to eat. And we all had enough to eat with plenty left for leftovers. As usual, we had a great experience at Luciano's. We will definitely be back, as this is one of our go-to pizza spots in the South Hills!

Solid sandwiches and pizza as well. Always good service. Reasonably priced. We take out from here…read moreoften.

Pizza Al's

4.2

(64 reviews)

We have been searching for good pizza since we moved to the McMurray/Peters area and have been…read moredisappointed. Pizza Al's was a wonderful surprise. Thin crust, good toppings, good cheese, and a good price point. We ordered Cari out, so looking forward to eating in the next time and checking out the atmosphere. To be transparent, we played pizza "roulette" with friends, and ordered pizza from two different places to be able to compare, and the comparison was also very good (look for Frankie's review).

The simplicity of Pizza Al's is very welcoming. They have a nice, understated dining area right in…read morefront of the pizza counter with a big screen TV on the wall. No frills whatsoever, and it is actually a nice vibe allowing you to watch the football game with enough room for kids with lots of energy to stand at the table and eat some pizza then run around - all without bothering you whatsoever. Really nice low-key atmosphere. The pizza also is very good in flavor and in its simplicity. If you're looking for a quick in and out pizza dining experience, this is the place!

Mary Jo's Pizzeria

5.0

(14 reviews)

A Turtle Creek staple. Terrific pizza prepared by great friendly folks. Very reasonably priced for…read morethe size and quality you receive. This place takes Domino'sand Pizza Hut straight off the map. Deserves 10 stars.

Wow! This truly is my kind of place. An incredibly simple concept, with a truly great product…read more I actually learned of this place via an Instagram reel. Being from the area, I cannot believe I have never heard of this place before. I put it on my short list of places to try, and one day when out in the Monroeville area, I was finally able to stop. Like I said, the concept is simple. This place serves pizza. There is one size, and some toppings to choose from. At the time of writing this, pizzas are $8 and it is cash only. The price includes any toppings you want to put on. They are open Thursday through Sunday from 4 until 7:30. Orders are placed over the phone, and then picked up through the side/basement door of a normal residential house. We placed an order for three pizzas, and they were to be ready for pickup in about 30 minutes. We got one Pepperoni, one Mushroom and Onion, and one with Sausage and Extra Cheese. When we arrived, there was another person picking up, but our pies were hot and ready. The ladies working were quick and kind. The pizzas are truly so good! The crust is not too thick or too thin, and the sauce is a sweeter one. All of the pies we got we liked, but the sausage was a true winner for us personally. One pizza could easily feed two or three people, and they are cut into 8 slices. I cannot wait to have this place again. The pizza was great, the ambiance and entire operation give off everything that classic Pittsburgh is about - no frills, but a great product. Plus, you cannot beat the value. Will definitely be back soon!

Mama Pepino's

3.0

(35 reviews)