I was starving, and this was the first pizza place I saw with something truly rare, abundant…read moreparking. Destiny. Pizza was good. I had it cold because that's how I like it. No complaints there. Service was... philosophical. The place was empty, yet it took a while to be noticed. The staff seemed deeply committed to important discussions with friends. Once I finally received my pizza, I stood by the door, hanging like a lonely pepperoni, waiting for someone to remember I existed. Apparently there's another register somewhere in the back. So I took a small pilgrimage through the restaurant, paid, and escaped with my dignity and my slice. They do have a seating area to the left. I didn't explore it. At that point, my relationship with the establishment had run its course. Would I go back? If I'm starving and the parking lot calls to me again... nah...

I've been ordering from here for a few years now, and they're usually pretty good. Unfortunately,…read moremy last experience left a bad taste in my mouth -- literally and figuratively. I ordered a large plain pie around 8:45 p.m. and picked it up at 9. When I got home, it was obviously an old pizza that had been reheated! It was cold, hard, stale, and not fresh at all. I called the store to let them know, but instead of apologizing or offering to make it right, the person on the phone argued with me and insisted it was freshly made. It clearly wasn't. The lack of accountability and customer service was disappointing. They close at 9:30, and if they didn't want to make a fresh pizza that late, they should've just said so because I would have gladly taken my business elsewhere. After this experience, I won't be coming back.

I have been eating here my family for a few years now. I found the pizza here is excellent. Our…read morefavorite are the variety of sicilian slices they make daily. Very good under carriage with a nice smooth textura inside and great crunch on the outside. I recommend anyone in the neighbor give them a try if you are looking for traditional jersey pizza.

GOOD PIZZA. GO HERE Good tasty pizza. Meatball parm sub was…read morevery good as well. Definitely a go to place in this area. I'll be back.

The pizza comes out pipping hot. Delicious. Excellent service. Very busy for lunch in the weekend,…read moreand they handled the crowd efficiently and effectively.

I visited the Star Tavern on a Friday afternoon for a late lunch and enjoyed the food and service…read more My wife and I shared a garlic bread with mozzarella and a pizza (half 3 cheese/half white spinach) and even though the pizza is very thin it was more than enough food for us so keep that in mind if you go with multiple people and each one decides to order a pizza. Note that depending on the toppings you can order 2 different ones (half/half) but it's not available for all toppings. Pizza was tasty, I'd rate it a 8.5/10, I just wish it had a little more cheese. Garlic bread was also pretty good. I had 2 Coors light draft ($5.50 each) and my wife had a ginger ale ($3.00 and refill was free). They should offer some happy hour specials during weekdays. Service was good and waitresses were friendly. There are some tables and booths in addition to bar stools. There's a small parking lot so during peak hours you might need to find street parking.

Went here in a whim since we were in the area. Welcomed at…read morethe door and seated quickly. Ordered the thin shroom pizza with arugula. Wait was a bit long but the pizza was great.

Angeloni's calls themselves home of the famous "thinny thin," they're not kidding. If you're a fan…read moreof ultra-thin, crispy pizza, this is definitely the spot. The interior is nicely decorated with a cozy Italian vibe that makes it a great place to sit back and enjoy a few pies. If you follow Barstool, you might remember that Portnoy gave this place an 8.8 -- and it's well deserved. I can personally attest to that score. We started with a plain pizza, just like Portnoy did, and he absolutely nailed it. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with great flavor and not greasy at all. Next up was the Easy on the Pizzi -- vodka sauce base, crispy cup pepperoni, mozzarella, fresh burrata, basil, and a drizzle of Mike's Hot Honey. The combination of rich, savory, and slightly sweet flavors worked perfectly together. We also tried The Nicky Newarker, topped with thinly sliced sausage and onions on that signature thinny-thin crust. Another great choice. The pictures really don't do these pizzas justice, though they'll definitely make your mouth water. Our server was fantastic -- friendly, attentive, and made the experience even better. I'm already looking forward to going back to try more of their specialty pies. If you love thin-crust pizza and you're in the area, this spot is absolutely worth checking out.

We ordered dinner and had it delivered to our hotel. When I placed the order it stated utensils…read morewould be sent. Also, under special instructions I put send utensils please. Order came 15 minutes later than promised. I called the restaurant to say no utensils were sent. I was told "we ran out of utensils and that's why I didn't send any". I asked how we eat lasagna and veal parmesan with our fingers. She said I don't know that is your problem. We are out of utensils-that's it". Very poor customer service. Their sauce was also very bitter.

We have been regular customers at La Familia Ristorante and Pizzeria for many years and have always…read moreenjoyed bringing family and friends when they visit. For Christmas Eve, with my daughter and two granddaughters in town, we made a reservation for five and paid the required $200 deposit. The restaurant was busy due to the holiday, which we completely understood. Service was slow but expected, and we were enjoying the live music and conversation. After receiving our entrées, a frightening incident occurred: my 15-year-old granddaughter was drinking from her glass when it suddenly shattered in her mouth. I saw it happen. Glass shards landed in her mouth and in her plate of food. We immediately brought the broken glass and plate to the staff and asked if the entrée could be remade. A woman who identified herself as the owner came over. She did not ask if my granddaughter was okay, offered no apology, and stated that they would not remake the food, even after I offered to pay for a replacement. At that point, we asked for to-go boxes and our check. The check arrived without deducting the $200 deposit, requiring me to go to the desk to have it corrected, and a refund was needed since the total did not reach the deposit amount. What was most upsetting was not the accident itself, those things happen, but the owner's complete lack of concern, empathy, and professionalism. We were treated as though we were trying to take advantage of the restaurant, despite being frequent patrons who had already paid for the meal. The wait staff has always been kind and professional, which makes this experience even more disappointing. Unfortunately, after this incident, we will not be returning and will be taking our business elsewhere.

When you've been around greatness, you know it when you taste it…read more Tony D's Pizza in Caldwell is championship-level--no question. This is some of the best pizza in Essex County, period. From the crust to the sauce, everything is dialed in like a Super Bowl game plan. And trust me... they handled a "Giant" appetite with ease If you're in Jersey and you're serious about your pizza--this is the spot. #BigBlueApproved #EssexCountyEats

This place is always yummy. Cost is high up there tho and I think they made the pie smaller but…read morethe price went up lol they're very nice. Their pizza is always top notch tho. So I understand why it cost most than your usual place !!

I have been going here for 25 years, it's my g to work Pizza place…read more Pizza is very good as is the food and sandwiches. Always a friendly smile form the guys at the counter. AAA+++

Two of my most Excellent Yelp Brothers had good things to say, Capt Drew O. and Pat M. both…read moredescribed positive Pizza experiences here so I thought I'd add my two cents. Initially on my first visit to this old school type Pizzeria I went with a classic Mushroom Slice which had great thin crunchy texture and delicious flavor. To me the sauce and cheese mixture that they prepare here at La Pizza is super flavorful in every way possible. Next up was their old world Grandma Slice who must be working out cause she is looking good: Thin, Crispy, Beautiful and baked to perfection. Here again super flavorful Sauce combination that can be noticed in every tremendously tasty bite. Although I would've appreciated more Mozzarella than was provided but that superior crunch, Crunch, CRUNCH!! totally made up for that absence. Looks like we all can agree, Come And Get Your Munch On!!

Sicilian is dope - great pizza place. Chicken bacon ranch for lunch. Go to local spotread more

the the worst pizza that i ever ate when the original borinos was here it was different. i spent…read morefive dollars and a piece it was from two weeks old still no taste unbelievable

Old school store is still the best. Our cheese pizza, pizza with Italian sausage and mushroom, and…read morestromboli were so tasty tonight! Ordering online will get you 10% off. Highly recommend!

Livingston Pizza...Nice, quick, cost effective and quite tasty. Just ordered for the millionth…read moretime.

This was my first time ordering from here & I decided to have it delivered, since it was freezing…read moreout and I don't drive at night. Delivery would be 45-60 minutes, so I set my timer for 30 so I'd be ready to put the light on in the vestibule for the driver to see. Before I knew it, I got a call that the delivery driver, Joshua, was at the door! It wasn't even 30 minutes! He must have cooked my food on the way over! Joshua was very pleasant and the food was very hot! I ordered a large half sausage pizza with a side of fried mushrooms, which were both delicious. The pie had a nice thick crust, which is how I like it. I never eat the bottom crust, but break off the thick crust and scoop up the toppings. It was perfect! The fried mushrooms were tender with a very crispy & tasty coating. They were a nice size and there were plenty of them...even had some left over. Everything from placing the order with a very sweet lady to my last bite was great! I definitely recommend trying this eatery. FYI: There is parking in the lot behind it (same as where Stephanie's Italian restaurant is, since there is no parking allowed in front on Bloomfield Ave.).

I'm not sure why Cedar Grill & Pizza has 4.4 stars. The staff was friendly and we didn't wait that…read morelong for our food but nothing else about this place warrants that many stars. The pizza, the chicken Parm hero, and the chicken Caesar salad were all average at best. Frankly, not much different than Domino's or Pizza Hut. I can't say anything about Cedar Grill & Pizza was bad but considering there's a pizzeria every block or so in downtown Caldwell, I think you could do better elsewhere.