This fun local coffee shop offers a variety of drinks, including teas. The Sellersburg location has a drive-thru, which is super convenient! Inside is also adorable and they were all decorated for the holidays. I tried the Pumpkin Patch latte, which I offered all year round! So when all those other coffee shops ditch their fall flavors, you can still get your pumpkin and coffee fix here. The coffee was super smooth and the flavors blended nicely together. A quick stop off the interstate as you are headed to Louisville and definitely worth popping in. read more

Starlight Coffee Co. - Pumpkin Patch Latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

The best coffee we have had in our road trip so far. It's a lovely little shop. I followed another reviewer and tried the banana latte. One pump banana and 1 pump white mocha and it was divine! And the customer service was so nice. Everyone was smiling and sweet. Scones were pretty good. read more

Starlight Coffee Co. - Blueberry lemon and cheddar and chive scones and blueberry muffin. Also thin mint latte. And iced banana white mocha. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

Good coffee, nice staff. Breakfast pastries were very good too. Even bought a pound of coffee that I liked.

We popped in to this cozy little shop on our way to Louisville on a little day trip from Bloomington. The place was clean and inviting with ample seating and some comfortable chairs toward the back. My Americano was just right, as was the toasted bagel with cream cheese. My wife also enjoyed her chai tea latte. Service was quick and friendly and our order was ready in no time. Definitely fit the bill and eased my caffeine fix in a relaxing space. I'd stop in again if I get back to the area. Nice place. read more

Starlight Coffee Co. - Americano and toasted Everything bagel. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

The service was great! They helped my kids decide what to get and offered to make it kids temp so it wasn't too hot. They were also very patient while I was deciding. They also had a lot of sugar free syrup flavors which is hard to find. All of our drinks were delicious! The environment was also very cozy and cute! It's definitely a place I could hang out with friends, read a book, or get work done on my laptop. read more

Starlight Coffee Co. - White mocha latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

Great tasting fresh roasted coffee!!!!!!!!! Support local businesses!!! Not great customer service, but basically what you get at coffee shops everywhere read more

Always stellar service. The girls are always so sweet and the coffee is hands down my favorite. 1000/10 every time! read more

Starlight Coffee Co. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

The coffee is good and the pastries are tasty. Getting your right isn't so easy for them. They made 3 mistakes on one order. Not sure what the problem is read more

While passing through the area I stopped into Starlight coffee for a latte. The interior was very inviting with several areas for sitting and a comfy chairs. I ordered the Starlight Latter and Cinnamon roll. My latte was delicious! I was also very impressed with the design on their coffee sleeve. I collect these and this was the most creative one I have seen. If I am passing this area again I am going to make a point to stop. read more

See all

Always love getting my coffee fix at Starlight Coffee. Service is always great. The baristas are always very attentive and friendly to us. I have tried their caramel latte, white mocha latte and iced chai tea latte and they have all become my favorites. Their cinnamon rolls are also a must try if you have a sweet tooth! When warmed up, the rolls have the right amount of sweetness and chewiness. The ambiance of the shop is really cozy and inviting. The space layout is open and is surrounded by lots of pothos. This is such a cute, calming and stylish local coffee shop. So if you are in the area, definitely visit Starlight! read more

See all

Love this coffee! I have a hard time finding coffees I like while out because I like more coffee than creamer in my drink but this is perfect. Medium iced mocha with and extra espresso shot was only $5.51 which in the coffee world I thought was a good price! I feel like you can always tell when shops roast their own coffee beans. It just adds something extra to it The service was also fast and friendly! I'll be coming back for sure. read more

Starlight Coffee Co. - Medium Iced Mocha with an extra espresso shot - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

I've driven by this location of Starlight Coffee Co. so many times, but had never stopped in until recently. I had an early nail appointment and decided to grab a coffee on the way. This spot is really cute! The service was fast and friendly. I opted for the Starlight Latte, which is honey and cinnamon flavored. It was delicious! I also selected a cinnamon roll, and took the server up on her offer to warm it for me. It was delicious! The only issue was that I took my order to go, and the packaging for the cinnamon roll completely stuck to the top and removed most of the tasty glaze. Other than that, everything was great! If you're looking for a quick easy spot to grab a coffee and/or snack, this location of Starlight Coffee is a good spot! read more

See all

The coffee was amazing, the decorations were pretty, the place was clean, and the staff was nice. Definitely stop by if you pass! read more

Starlight Coffee Co. - Iced coffee laté - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

Very nice drive thru, local coffee shop! I ordered my usual latte with oat milk and flavored syrup and this was an excellent cup if coffee. The coffee is bold amd smooth (not bitter at all), the oat milk and syrup was really good as well. I got it iced and a large which has three shots, so I am ready to go! Friendly and fast service, clean exterior and good pricing for a local specialty coffee shop. Will be back! read more

Good customer service and the drinks and beagles are to die for. Raven and Morgan are excellent. The music is excellent too. Great vibes all around read more

Starlight Coffee Co. - Birthday cake blended - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

First item at this coffee shop and figured I'd stick to my basic iced mocha with oat milk. Though it was a little pricey (which is becoming usual for coffee shops), the drink is delicious. A nice place to get a sweet treat and take a break. read more

Starlight Coffee Co. - Iced mocha with oat milk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

Wow, great experience. The only thing better than the coffee are the talented baristas. Polite, friendly, smiles, and great attitudes only enhance the fresh brewed coffee bean aroma. Ask for "The Rob" or the UFO Blend - it's the best!! read more

Starlight Coffee Co. - Special blend coffee - ingredients are classified "Top Secret". - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

The best coffee in So. Indiana. They treat EVERYONE with respect. The shop is large and very nice inside.

Great latte. Super friendly service. We hit the drive through on our way out of town and it was quick, friendly and delicious. Looking for a great cup of coffee? Stop by. read more

Starlight Coffee Co. - Caramel white mocha latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

Love the ambiance. Quiet, quaint and friendly. Coffee was exceptional and love the pastries. Especially the lemon blueberry scone, but all their pastries are top shelf. They read more

I love their newest location! It has cool vibes, bright and airy feel to it. Wonderful furnitures, soothing music and the huge plants in the back are a plus! So far I had their herbal raspberry tea (teabag) and cappuccino w/ almond milk! The kids love their pastries and I enjoyed the vegan and gluten-free cookie. The roastery is also in this location which has a unique and cool look to it. read more

See all

"Big Jim" roast some darn good coffee. The Kenya AA, Guatemala Huehue, Ethiopian Yirgacheffe make a wonderful pour over cup. But the best kept secret (have only seen one time) is the "Snowball Blend". As far as drinks, can't go wrong with either the Starlight latte or the Log Cabin latte. One of them is made with REAL MAPLE SYRUP (I just can't ever remember which one). I get them iced but I am sure they would be great either way you have them! read more

I very much enjoy the service here. The coffee is sweet and the lemonade is country but the syrup makes it doable. The music is fire and the lights are brighter. 10/10 business. Shoutout to Sydney and Morgan. Fabulous and quick service for very tasty drinks. Many options to choose from as well, love the variety and cleanliness. read more

They have such a large selection of syrups and a couple seasonal drinks. Highly recommend the gingerbread man with espresso. The staff is also very welcoming and helpful. Support local with this gem of a coffee shop. read more

I really like this place! The white mocha is amazing. The prices are a little expensive, but I live a minute from here so I make that up in gas haha. I wish they would stock some 12 ounce cups for frozen coffee as the board says they offer it, but they don't actually (it is only available in 16 & 20oz). The employees are friendly and I haven't had anything but good experiences with them. read more

I have never written a review on a business or have even been on Yelp, however today I made this account just to leave one. My husband and I were traveling by today and stopped to get a coffee. It's unfortunate that they had such flavorful drinks yet such bad service. I ordered their Log Cabin latte and it was phenomenal , and my husband ordered a Bold coffee. While we were waiting in line, the workers were yelling loudly about how they "got that b- word fired!" (excuse my language) and were complaining about their pay and the lack of tips made, and discussing the money in the drawer right in front of us. My husband and I felt uncomfortable, but decided to give the benefit of the doubt because food service isn't always easy. We took a seat on their comfortable chairs that they have, to relax before heading back out on the road. While sitting there, they were loudly talking badly about people who have worked there, and were complaining about every customer that came through the line, cracking jokes about their appearance based on the size of drinks they purchased. We just decided to get up and leave. I have never felt that uncomfortable before! read more

Asked for a cappuccino and was handed a milkier version than a latte. Inconsistent experience for the 2 times been there.

This was the most positive coffee experience I have ever had! The cafe was warm and decorated for Christmas, the bathrooms were clean and the water hot. Not to mention the AMAZING chai tea latte they made. Kind staff and cool background I would go to Indiana just to visit this again read more