The rating-meter above says that 2 is what corresponds to "meh," and "meh" is how I feel.
Peter Haley was our DJ for our wedding a couple of weeks ago. He seemed nice enough when we first met with him, and we were originally really happy with our choice. He also told us at the time that he would get in touch with us a couple of weeks before the wedding so that we could meet and go over any last minute requirements/changes of plans. This didn't happen, but that's OK since we were pretty busy anyway, and the email communication seemed OK (although a couple of times we had to ask him the same question more than once since if there was more than one question in an email... he wouldn't answer them all).
On the day of the wedding, Peter arrived on time and set everything up well in advance, so definitely some props for that. Nobody wants to be running around on the day of their wedding looking for their DJ.
Another positive point: He definitely is not the kind of DJ that has you play stupid party games. No beach ball throwing or any similarly dumb stuff. He plays the music, and does the required minimum of MC-ing. Good stuff.
However, the rest of the experience is fairly blah. During dinner my dad asked him to play a fairly sad Hebrew song (and as a compromise, since I didn't want him to play it) my dad asked Peter to only play half of it. He played the whole thing. Not really a big deal.
My (music snob) sister asked me during dinner if I asked him to play muzak. When I stared at her in confusion, she made some comments about how this jazz he was playing was terrible. I took it with a grain of salt since she really is a big music snob, so not that huge a deal either.
For the first dance, he started the song before we were ready. We had to stop him and ask him to restart it once we were ready. Not really that big a deal either.
And, unfortunately, after the first few songs, he really couldn't keep a lot of people on the dance floor. Part of that might be the fact that it was a late-ish evening wedding, part of that might be that we had several very disparate groups of people (Indians who only danced to Indian music, Russians, and mid-20s Americans), and maybe it was hard to kind of unite everyone and get everyone on the floor? However, during the Indian numbers a LOT of people danced, and then when Peter switched to some other stuff, there was a mass floor exodus that he didn't really react to. This was pretty blah.
All in all, I'm a tad bummed out with this vendor choice. I hired a DJ because I thought that he could get a feel for the crowd and do what was necessary to get them on the dance floor, but that's not really what happened. Maybe if your group is more uniform in their cultures, ages and tastes, Peter would be a great choice, but I was disappointed. A lot of the things I wasn't thrilled about were not big issues, and if he had kept the dancing going throughout the night I would have ignored those and given a 5 star rating, but that's not what happened. read more