The staff (Dan and Toby) were very kind, and helpful on suggestions. This is the kind of staff you could speak with for hours. We loved our experience here and can't wait to return. The food was just as amazing as the staff. read more

See all

Excellent restaurant, from the very attentive service to the delicious food, all is top notch. The steak was cooked to perfection and the demi glace was fantastic. We also tried their pineapple creme brulee, which was another yummy dish - sweet with a hint of rum and fresh pineapple. Cocktails are strong and priced right, I wish we had another night in town to try some other dishes. We made a reservation, which was not needed on a mid week evening, but the host said to definitely reserve a table Friday and Saturday during main dinner hours. Parking is only available outside on the road and the public lots. read more

Snitches - Steak - New American Near Me - Deadwood, South Dakota

See all

Everything about the experience was fantastic. Mason was an awesome waiter. Very knowledgeable about the menu, how items were prepared and he was very attentive. For an appetizer we had an order of steak tips which were amazingly tender, but made even more delicious by the sauce. I highly recommend it. For the entrée, I had the wagyu New York and my wife had the line-caught salmon. Both were outstanding. I hesitate to leave this review because it seems like a little secret tucked away in the Tin Lizzy casino. It's not inexpensive, but very well priced and a great value. It made for a great beginning to a wonderful evening. read more

This was our first time eating at this wonderful restaurant. The food was excellent. I ordered the special halibut. My husband ordered Alfredo pasta with lobster. The Wedge salad and prosciutto, melon salad was very good. Also the bruschetta was excellent. We had great service with Daisy, our server. The only issue was parking, give yourself a little extra time. read more

Food was mediocre Service was adequate Ambiance was not good. Load and rather harsh. Personally, we will not be returning. There are much better options to choose from in Deadwood read more

The Alfredo costed $28 and tasted like the Stouffer's freezer meals. The server was great and drinks were great but we were very disappointed with the food:( read more

You guys! This place is worth the drive. Make reservations and enjoy an amazing dinner! I was super impressed by the scallops and everything was delish!! Ask for Toby ... he gives great recommendations. read more

See all

After reading the reviews we decided to have dinner tonight at Snitches inside of Tin Lizzies. It's safe to say whoever the chefs were that actually earned the 5 star reviews are long gone and the kitchen is not any where up to their level. We asked what their medium rare steaks looked liked (warm red, lots of pink, Halie didn't know) and we decided to order 2 medium rare ribeyes. They can always cook it a bit more. It was all downhill from here. So, here's what we got. My steak was crunchy on the outside. Seriously. It crunched on the first bite. It was so over done and chewy I had to send it back. My husband's steak looked pretty good however as he got into it it became super rare. Ok, raw where the while line around the meat is so stringy you can't cut it with the steak knife. Unbelievable. My steak was sent back as was husband's when he got to the raw parts. My second steak comes out and again, it's a little crunchy on the outside and I kid you not it is ice cold in the center on the 2nd bite. My husband looks at me and says how is that even possible? I cut a bite and give it to him and sure as shoot ice cold when your tongue touches the center of the piece of meat. How do you even do that? At this point I don't even want a 3rd steak, just take that off the bill. I've have a 1/2 a salad, some bread, and mashed potatoes. Now they send out the "manager" Alexandria, who is actually the cook in back, who then proceeds to actually argue that the steaks were cooked property and the same and I'm wrong. R E A L L Y??? Instead of getting that meal comp'd we get two 25% off coupons. Ah, we won't need those we won't be back. Halie (waitress) explains that's in place of taking my meal off our ticket. Well, I do math for a living and I can already see where this is going. I step away from the table and the other diners so they don't overhear our conversation and ask to speak with "the manager" again. She is just as defensive swearing those steaks were cooked perfect. I pointed out then why was my husband's rare and mine so over cooked? They were the same she says. She took a picture and sent them to the actually manager who supposedly agreed with her. Then she tells me she only eats her meat well done and my steak was too rare for her to eat. Ah ha! You know that point when you know you're not getting anywhere fast? Well, we were there so I ask her "is this the hill you want to die on? Because if that's the case I'll give you the opportunity to cook that steak correctly a 3rd time to go and I'd be more than happy to pay full price for my meal." After waiting a longer period of time for the 3rd steak, which I took as a good sign, the gentleman behind the bar comes out to discuss this conundrum. I explained to him that I'm paying $15 for mashed potatoes according to this bill and if that's going to be the case I'll take the entire meal a 3rd time to see if she can figure out how to cook it correctly. In the end they removed my dinner from the bill completely, which by the way was $15 less than the "deal" she was giving me. I did get the 3rd steak with mashed potatoes by a much more pleasant Alexandria. Will I eat that 3rd steak, hell no. How does it look see for yourself. How can the middle of the steak on one side never touch the heat? Honestly it has a huge light brown streak. How do you do that? Go have a fabulous meal at The RedWater Kitchen in Spearfish or Jacobs Brewhouse in Deadwood run the heck away from this place. read more

See all

AMAZING EXPERIENCE! 6+ stars! From the time we arrived (a few minutes late) to Tin Lizzie's, we had an awesome experience. We ordered the $42/person all you can eat and that was the most amazing choice EVER, especially because we like our steaks medium rare. I think the last time we had anything so tasty was at a restaurant that doesn't exist anymore (where if you needed a serrated steak knife, something was wrong). What did we like best? The filet!!! (All the filets!) STARTERS: We had the Filet Mignon whiskey tips appetizer ... a few times, because it was AWESOME!!! We also had the grilled shrimp cocktail and the antipasto skewer appetizers. MAIN: We had a few of the Petit Filet in a cherry demi glaze, which was delicious with a little cherry. CUTE! We had a few of the Petit Bison Filet with a heart of palm and arugula salad that was the best bison we've had ... ever. We also had the sesame chicken. SIDES: The ginger wasabi mashed potatoes had just a hint of ginger and wasabi, which was pretty amazing. We also had the tomato pesto pasta and the grilled asparagus. DESSERT: We had it all!!! We had a tiramisu and banana gelato (like a bananas foster gelato). Thank you to our amazing waitress Alexandria (who likes Pokemon)! We chose the restaurant partially because of the OpenTable reservations and partially because there were so many 5-star reviews! Despite being busy when we arrived, she took care of us with a wonderful smile and some great recommendations! It was our first time in Deadwood and at the end of the night, she gave us a quick tour of the beautiful private dining room and let us say hi to the chefs. She also told us to take our paid check to the casino for $10 each which ... err ... we promptly lost, but WHEE! Free fun money! For Pokemon Go, there definitely was a Pokestop, but I think there was a gym also ... eep! A testament to what a great time we had that I didn't make a note of that. read more

Snitches - Having a party? This is a small private dining room. I wanted to run home and put on my 20's little black dress and hat combo! - New American Near Me - Deadwood, South Dakota

See all

Wow. What a terrific find in Deadwood. The food was terrific. We tried the all you can eat menu and were delighted with the flavors. We will definitely be back. My favorite,hands down, was the salmon followed by the sirloin. They were out of the scampi so I can't rate that. They say the all you can eat menu was small portions but I they were larger than I expected. We will be back! Try it. I think you will love it too. read more

See all

After a late lunch and snacks late afternoon, we visited with the plan of checking out the new menu and trying the Wedge Salad ($6) and a couple appetizers. We were not disappointed! We each had a Wedge. The iceberg lettuce was crisp and fresh complimented with blue cheese crumbles, sweet tomatoes, ranch dressing and prosciutto. Our request for some additional dressing was quickly fulfilled. We went with the Charcuterie Board ($15) and Hummus ($10). The Board was an amazing spread of deliciousness. It only had two meat choices but the ample cheese selections in addition to a wonderful array of gourmet crackers, fresh fruit and nuts made up for it completely. The dipping oil with fresh roasted garlic was a notable finishing touch. If you've ever ordered Hummus to find there was no where near enough Hummus for the pita they provide, no worries! It is not the case here. There is the perfect amount of hummus and the Olive Salsa offers delectable flavors to balance the hummus. A delightful surprise were the Meringue Mints with a hint of cinnamon they deliver with the check which is tucked away in a lovely little wooden box--memorable touches. We will return and would not hesitate to order the same items again. read more

See all

***MICHELIN STAR*** High class, high quality, amazing all around! Best Scallops I have ever had in my life. Tried the veal cheeks for the first time and it was so tender. All courses looked amazing and tasted even better. Braised rabbit pasta was to die for. This chef is highly skillful. Will come back as often as we can. Many praises and highest compliments!! "Everything was so delicious!!!" --My Wife She had the waygu, medium rare of course. I stole a bite. We have tried many of the high quality restaurants in Vegas and this chef matches all we have tried. Highly recommend his tasting menu so you get a piece of heaven from all four courses! ***MICHELIN STAR*** read more

Snitches - New American Near Me - Deadwood, South Dakota

Great ambience and over the top service but one of the worst ribeye steaks I have had. I ended up with about a cup of grizzle. The bartender must've been a chemistry major because she measured out my cocktail in cubic centimeters. If you want a truly exquisite dining experience with wonderful atmosphere, great service and delicious food go to Legends, downtown Deadwood in the Franklin Hotel, just a few blocks away. They don't take reservations, but if you get there around 4:30 the half hour wait is worth it. You can designate someone to wait in line while the rest of your party can enjoy the view and a drink upstairs overlooking Main Street. read more

Food was better than expected and service was excellent. There was a ladybug on one of the tomatoes in the salad but they took off 10% from the entire bill. Seems to be one of the best restaurants around Deadwood despite it being a gambling town. Definitely tucked away inside the casino/lodge but very fancy aesthetically with things like gold silverware with a luxury theme overall. read more

Disappointed to say the least. Charcuterie board was $22 of waste. Fruit was overripe at best, moldy at worst. All the cheese was so hard we had to break it because you couldn't get a knife through it. Steaks were ok, but not worth the price. read more

Great food! The crab cakes and bacon wrapped shrimp were stupendous! I highly recommend the surf and turf. Probably the best lobster you can get in South Dakota. read more

Excellent restaurant, best meal we had in Deadwood. Ribeye was perfect as were the scallops. Very attentive service in this secluded intimate restaurant. Great drinks too! read more

A true small gem with wonderful nostalgic ambience, exquisite service, and really great food. Toby was an amazing "dinner guide" and was the proverbial icing on the cake! When we return to Deadwood, we will most definitely return to Snitches!! read more

Not great. Didn't seem like there were a lot of good options for food nearby. Snitches' menu seemed the best option. We got the charcuterie board, it was mostly packaged crackers and stale pita bread. The fruit was not good either, and should have been tossed. Very disappointing. The other food we got was pretty bland and neither of us finished our meals. I got the wedge salad which was good, and the Mac n cheese which was penne pasta tossed in truffle oil. Super oily and greasy. Husband got the salmon which he ate a few bites of and didn't finish. read more

The vibe of the restaurant was jazz baby. The cocktail I ordered was beautiful it tasted of burnt brown sugar in the best possible way. It had nice notes of fig and was very smooth going down. The service was kind and thoughtful. I would go again just for the cocktail. The 1920s was the influence here. The restaurants decor is beautiful and inviting! read more

Wow ! We drove up from Rapid City to check out this new restaurant . We will be back . There were 9 of us I the party which is hard to coordinate service and courses . All of us were blown away with our meals . Fabulous new addition for locals or vacationers in the black hills . read more

Blown away. Exceptional fine dining in what feels like the back corner of a casino. Don't let the location fool you though, this place is legit. The Chef here and his team are taking what they are putting out seriously. There's clearly a lot of thought put into each dish on the menu and the wine list is outstanding. A chef's tasting menu with wine pairings for each course is available. There's also quite the list of unique and delicious cocktails on offer. Possibly the best meal I've had in the Black Hills. Definitely the best restaurant in Deadwood by miles. Would return to Deadwood just to eat here again. Had the scallops starter, the lobster pasta, salmon main, and pistachio cake dessert. All had wonderful and complex flavors. Each course was equally impressive and outstanding. Describing them wouldn't do them justice. My best suggestion is that you go try them for yourself. read more

Shockingly good. My family and I visited Deadwood as part of a two-week trek through the Dakotas, which meant a steady diet of bar food plus some decent but unspectacular stabs at more elevated cooking in Rapid City. Looking for something interesting but not holding out too much hope, we decided to give Snitches a try upon our return from Devils Tower. I was surprised and delighted by it. The art deco setting is unlike anything else in cowboys-and-casinos Deadwood; the hostess and manager, Xanthe Dewolf, was lovely and welcoming; and the food is miles better than anything else we ate, before or after (so from Rapid City to Medora to Bismarck and most points in between). With four family members dining, we were able to try both the tasting menu (including astute and creative wine pairings) plus most of the other dishes on the plank. All were excellent. I live in the S.F. Bay Area, have traveled through 47 states and 70+ foreign countries, and have eaten at multiple Michelin-starred restaurants in here and abroad. If a Michelin taster were to visit Snitches, I think there's a pretty good chance that chef Tucker Walton would get his star. (And I note that I'm not the only one who thinks so -- another poster down below said the same thing.) As far as I can tell, this is the best restaurant in the Dakotas. read more

Probably one of the best new restaurants in the United States. Impeccably curated and mindblowingly good. The food easily constituted the best meal I've had in 2020. The menu is quite limited and I gather it changes frequently so I recommend getting as many items as you can afford and sharing it all. Wine list is amazing, cocktails innovative, service is welcoming and knowledgeable. For the reasonable price this is destination dining. In most major US cities this level of restaurant would be insanely expensive and reservations would be hard to get. The place is in the back of a small casino. It's dark and small but uses the odd location and unusual vibe to its advantage. I've been to a lot of places. This is something special. Without a doubt the top culinary experience of my six week great plains pandemic vacation. The best meal I've had in 2020 thus far. read more

The food is above average, the service is prompt, the decor is sort of cheesy. The salmon was excellent, the chili/lime shrimp skewers we ok. I think the price was a little higher than it should have been, but they did give us each $10 in casino credit for dining there. read more

Best Steak and crab cakes ever!!! Love the atmosphere, Service was great! Will be back!

The food was excellent and the variety was good. Service was fun & good. I would definitely go back.

We picked this spot during our stay in Deadwood and were so happy we did. The food was delicious. We had the scallops and shrimp scampi with squid ink pasta. The service, excellent! The staff friendly. Right down to the well crafted cocktails. It's a quiet gem just steps away from the action. read more

If we are ever out that way again, we will definitely eat here. Our food and service was excellent. I should have taken pictures of our food. It was all delicious and plated beautifully! I absolutely recommend eating here! I wish I could rate this higher! read more

This is a hidden gem. Go there and support a humble and incredible chef, and one of the best all-around meals I've had in the USA. The rabbit pasta, bison meatballs, and pistachio cake were inexplicably good. It's a small operation where every detail is finely tuned and has a purpose. I wish we lived here so we could dine here every month! The wine list is so well curated a standard dessert wine paired impeccably with the pistachio cake. The decor is striking and unique. It's a bit hard to find but when you do you won't want to leave! read more

First weekend back in Deadwood!! I was happy that Snitches was still open by the time I sauntered in and the staff was so welcoming. Alexandria is an awesome server and has a beautiful name :) Everything was great and I'm glad I got to kick off my Deadwood weekend eating such tasty food and having the best sauv blanc of my life! The revival is happening and this is a good spot to celebrate! read more

In a word: unbelievable! This was one of the best dining experiences we've ever had. We heard this place just opened a month or so ago, and had to give it a try after returning from a week in Jackson, WY. Everything we experienced at Snitches was as good or better than the fine dining we had in Jackson. Hands down the best food in Deadwood, possibly including Rapid City (haven't been back to Juniper yet with them re-opening soon). Amazing chef creates the most well-crafted dishes and drink menus, friendly and knowledgeable staff, absolutely delightful cocktails, and as well-crafted wine list as you can find. We had four courses, half of the cocktail menu and a bottle of wine, and everything surpassed expectations. Will definitely be back as the chef indicated he plans to change the menu with the seasons. Really hope this place has the opportunity to grow and develop; it is beyond the space it is in. read more

I was too late to get food here, but they did make me a couple of drinks before they closed. The drinks were incredible! The manager was so nice and explained all of the ingredients, and taught me a bit about mixology. I would highly recommend this place for the drinks! I can't wait to go back and try the food :) read more

Salmon dinner w/ potatoes mediocre and served barely warm. Beef tips better. Missable.

My husband and I celebrated our 10 year anniversary here and it blew our minds! The four course tasting menu was absolutely perfect! Every dish was so good we couldn't possibly choose just one favorite. The waygu was delicious and the chicken was the best chicken we have ever had! The cocktails were as good as the food! The staff was so friendly and made our night very special. The chef even came out and spoke with us. We cannot wait to come back! read more

This was just an awful experience. I know service is difficult to hire right now, but the restaurant only had 5 tables occupied. We asked our server for recommendations on what to order and he replied "I don't know the menu, so I have nothing to offer." We then ordered cocktails after seeing some great pictures online. The cocktails were great but they took 40 MINUTES to serve. It was painful to watch how slow the bartender moved to make each drink. We regretted not ordering something simple like beer or wine. Our dinner was served about 1hr 15 minutes after we sat down. This was quite baffling again, given how there were 12 people max in the restaurant at any given time. They were out of filets so the men ordered ribeyes. Both were served so rare that they were almost blue. They had to be sent back. We ordered the lobster and scallops. The scallops were overdone and served cold. The lobster was okay but definitely nothing fancy. I didn't taste any garlic butter as it was advertised. The asparagus on the side was soggy and the potatoes were undercooked. The enter experience took us nearly 2 hours. It was a terrible experience which is too bad because it looked much better online. Deadwood needs more great options. read more

The best prepared mushroom themed pasta and all locally organically grown ingredients that I ever had! The staff was delightful and a joy to talk with Tucker, Xanthe and Rachel. Tucker meticulously discussed details about the locally sourced ingredients and we enjoyed listening to his vast knowledge and his world travels and global knowledge of fine cuisine. I highly recommend Snitches and sharing meaningful conversation along with great food imprinted and lasting fond memory. Thank you for a great dining experience! read more

Such amazing service and Chef Tucker really personalizes your experience. Nice wine list and knowledgeable suggestions for pairings. Everything was fabulous. read more

Incredible food and amazing flavor profiles. The scallops were perfect. The wagyu second to none. The drinks were mind blowing!

This is a well deserved 5 star review. This place was sketchy from the outside, questionable on the inside but what a gem when you get to the actual restaurant.  Our server was  Halie and she was Amazing.  With her bright personality, bubbly southern accent and happy nature, she sure added to our overall experience.  Her recommendations we're on point, we had the charcuterie board for starter, and it is Large!  Then we had the Kalabi short ribs for me and scallops for my husband.  But the part that took everything over the top was the dessert I judged as not very good because I don't like restaurant cheesecake.  My husband wanted to try the blueberry cobbler cheesecake because it was blueberry.  He took one bite, looked at me and said, "you have to try this and I'm not kidding." He knows I have a texture issue with my cheesecakes so I took a very small bite.  It was the smoothest, creamiest most flavorful cheesecake I've ever had.  Sorry mom but this was the Best ever!  From start to finish this dinner was a 5 star dinner... and it's a farm to table restaurant in Deadwood, South Dakota! Who knew!! read more

Snitches - Charcuterie Board - New American Near Me - Deadwood, South Dakota