This was my second time eating at Smithville Bakery and I would definitely come back again. This restaurant is the cutest and they have a wide variety of breakfast and bakery menu items. The pancakes and french toast are both great! The loss of the one star was due to our waitress being rude on this second visit. Other than her, everyone else was very polite and friendly! read more

Had a delicious breakfast today. My wife had the banana cinnamon pancakes. I had the farmer's breakfast. Both were top notch. I would recommend you give this business a try. read more

Smithville Bakery - Banana Cinnamon Pancakes - Bakeries Near Me - Galloway, New Jersey

See all

I wanted some cupcakes. I went in, and it said take a number. It was 92. They weren't going by them. There were customers all over the place. No line, and one person behind the counter waiting on customers the other counting receipts. If you have all day to wait, this is the place for you.​ I left and went to Shop Rite read more

Got up a little late this morning and it was one of those cold and rainy winter days where it really takes an effort to get out of the house. However, it was later in the AM and thought why not try Smithville for a breakfast, that I would not have to clean up after. Went to the Bakery which is about 5 miles straight up the road from our house located in the Historic Towne of Smithville near the Smithville Inn. Really a nice small older fashioned bakery/breakfast place which can get crowded on really nice days. Not crowded today. Really nice and homey in here. Have that barcode thing you can take a picture of and get menu on your phone. Waitress noticed I was a novice at this and offered two menus which was fine with me. Ordered the Omelet that has everything in it and wife got Western Omelet. Both came out hot and in a very reasonable time. Plenty of coffee so we were in, as we say here in South Jersey, Pig Heaven. This branch of the family is actually referred to as the SJ Pig Farmers by our more gentile Philadelphia relatives. Food great and potatoes cooked crisp just perfect. Service very good. A great place to visit on that slow day when you want to relax. Careful on weekends since they tend to get very busy. They do have a takeout Bakery section that has a very good selection of baked goods for the grab and dash customers. read more

We were really excited to come check out Smithville but unfortunately it wasn't exactly what I had envisioned. To start out I realize it's Covid but the place was by exactly inviting. The pastries we got here were stale. My 10 year old will practically eat anything that's a sugary dessert but he couldn't even pretend to enjoy this. Coffee was burnt and bad. All went into the trash. Was not money well spent. read more

Had a fantastic omelette with kielbasa, mushrooms, asparagus and cheese. Along with rye toast, potatoes and a watermelon slice. Small outside seating area. Waited a very long time to be seated even though there were tables available. Two servers and a busboy working the area should have been sufficient but they seemed flustered. Get a table under an umbrella because there are birds in the trees overhead. Went in to pay and everything looked and smelled delicious. Will be back. read more

Smithville Bakery - Outdoor seating area - Bakeries Near Me - Galloway, New Jersey

Fantastic breakfasts and very nice homemade bakery products. Decorated in old Smithville area ephemera. read more

Nice little no-frills breakfast/brunch spot. Large portion sizes with good rustic home style food. Friendly service. They have an awesome array of baked goods and cookies! read more

This is going to be a short one, we are at the smithville Oktoberfest and decided to go into the smithville bakery. Of course without a doubt the decor is country and beautiful. The staff behind the counter were extremely pleasant. We ordered a Boston creme cupcake for $4.95. Very disappointing the cake was crumbly and there was barely any Boston creme inside. I mean it was scarce. Definitely not worth the money. I can not speak for the other products or breakfast but do not purchase the Boston creme cupcake read more

Service is awesome! Good far exceeded expectations. I'll be back whenever business takes me up that way.

So yummy. Not a huge place but worth the wait. Cinnamon raisin French toast, breakfast croissants, pancakes everything was amazing. The pastries and pies not only look good they are delicious. Very friendly service. read more

See all

This is my favorite place to eat when I'm visiting family. I always get the blueberry pancakes. They give you the option to choose from 1 pancake to 3 pancakes. I think 1 pancake is filling enough. It's HUGE. It's fluffy and the blueberries are fresh. Perfect texture with the right amount of Bite & fluffiness to it. I suggest that you order 1 pancake first, because the air conditioning will cool your pancakes pretty fast. By the time you make your way to the second pancake it's already cold (if you're a slow eater, but the pancake is so big, I'm pretty sure Most People will not get to the second pancake fast enough before it cools. So I suggest that you start with 1 pancake and have the waiter bring you the second one when you're ready for it or just get 1 and order another one later). I have been here a handful of times over the years, and every time, I am pleased with the food. Friendly service, good food and upbeat atmosphere with the homely mom n pop feel. I'll always choose to support a small family owned business like this restaurant over a commercialized chain restaurant. You just don't Get this kind of quality and friendly neighborhood feel from a commercial chain restaurant. read more

Smithville Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Galloway, New Jersey

I like the spinach feta croissant especially. We bought bread with apple, nuts, and cheese. The bread was soft. There is a dining area for breakfast and brunch in this place. Don't miss this mini restaurant when you visit Smithville. read more

See all

Great breakfast and service all in one! Quick preparation, high quality and friendly atmosphere.

Great place for a home style breakfast and amazing bakery products. Always got the cherry popovers to go after breakfast

Natalie answered the phone and guided us to a most amazing breakfast. Fluffy omelettes and light as air pastry's. The cheese danish gets a special mention as it is as good as it gets. read more

Stopped here on the way hone from vacation and I honestly wish we would've visited this place sooner as we were only staying down the road. The breakfast was AMAZING and everything was so fresh. My children loved the food and so did my mother. If we ever come back to the area we will make sure to visit the bakery again. read more

This place is a hidden gem in the Historic Shopping Village of Smithville. Freshly made pastries and pies, and there is a nice dining room to sit at where they serve breakfast. Old fashioned comfy vibe here at this quaint bakery. We dropped in here last weekend to pick up a few eats for the ride home. Cookies, pies, croissants, a vaiety of sweet buns, fruit filled sticks, and assorted other pastries. Coffee, tea, and hot drinks too. Good prices and friendly service at the counter. We devoured a soft jumbo peanut butter cookie and a few raspberry sticks while driving. It was a gluttonous mess as I wore a rainbow of crumbs on my shirt and crotch but I didn't care as both were delicious. Nothing like fresh baked pastries all over my body. read more

Great breakfast with good quantity of food. Bakery has many excellent treats, especially their blueberry scones and cheese Danish.

I would say this is my favorite brunch place in this area. The omelette everytime I get it - is like heaven in my mouth. It is the cooked to perfection and the oil/butter on it seems so fresh and organic. The portion size is huge! The place is very homey. I usually will get a dessert to go, when I leave. The pastries and all are ok but the food here is amazing!!! I sometimes crave the omelette in my sleep. hehehe. read more

Maybe pass on this bakery. I was dealing with some of my awesome chronic back pain (seriously, I'm 90) so my mom stood in line for the both of us while I waited in one of their high chairs. The line itself was disorganized and a young girl ended up jumping in front of my mom, who had been waiting much longer. I only requested a blueberry donut, but my mom ordered a bunch of baked goods. She told me her items were overall average, aside from a cookie that she ended up tossing because the icing was ungodly sweet. I ate my donut early the next morning and it was already hard as a rock. Not exactly the most enjoyable breakfast. This bakery is good in theory (right in the middle of a cutesy old-time village) but just didn't delivery on quality. read more

Great place for a breakfast! The vibe of the town is a cherry on top! Definitely check it out if you're in town.

This is one of those places that when you find it you feel like you found a well kept secret. They are open from 7am to 1pm for food, and they only serve breakfast. I'm not sure what time the bakery stays open until. The Smithville Bakery is set in "Historic Smithville", which is a group of old houses that were moved from their original location, set around a lake and turned into a very unique shopping center. There are paddle boats, ducks, chickens, antiques, clothing, food, etc.. It's all kinds of corny, but I kinda like it. The Smithville Bakery is a rustic old fashion bakery and a restaurant. You won't find Flour-less Chocolate Cake, Tiramisu, an Egg white Omelet or Cafe Lattes here. What you will find are pies, apple, peach, etc. Sticky cinnamon buns, cherry cheese buns, blueberry cheese buns, cookies, breads and so many other delights. Their pies are among the best I've tasted. For breakfast I usually get the French toast. You have to order a half portion unless you are 300+ lbs and need two canes to walk. Then you'll be fine. This is thick slices of fresh bread dipped and grilled to perfection. This morning while dining there with my parents I changed it up and ordered the "Breakfast on a Bun" with pork roll, and a cherry cheese bun. The cherry cheese bun was unbearably delicious. The bun itself was soft, easy to pull apart and crisp on top. A light dusting of powdered sugar perfected the artists work. The center was a thick, rich layer of sweet cheese on top of a layer of what appeared to be fresh whole pitted cherries cooked into a pie like filling. The "Breakfast on a Bun" with pork roll starts with their freshly made kaiser roll, topped with egg, cheese, home fries and the optional Pork Roll. You can also choose bacon or ham. This bulging breakfast sandwich is equally as good as the cherry cheese bun a savory sense, though, a cardiologist may disagree. I also tried my father's Western Omelet. I never order western omelets because I don't like them. Next time I'm down there I'm going to order it because it's one of the best breakfast foods I've tasted. If you are anywhere in the area, like Atlantic City, it's worth the excursion to experience the Smithville Bakery, a piece of America that's hard to come by these days. read more

See all

Smithville Bakery! Sort of a let down... I came her around noon on a Friday to grab some of their once amazing pastries to find myself with stale and really not edible pastires/cookies. Bummer. If you're here on a busy day though you must try the cherry cheese bun. Very yummy! read more

The line was long but moved quickly... a wait well worth it. Located just outside of AC, my boyfriend and I enjoyed a tasty and unique breakfast here that was very reasonably priced! The decor was very old fashioned/hometown feeling so the atmosphere was very cozy. Again, unique breakfast entrees. I had the apple french toast which was a bit too sweet for me but all of the other dishes were yummy. Also, the baked goods served separately are delicious! Get there early as they run out, quick. read more

Smithville Bakery - Apple French Toast - Bakeries Near Me - Galloway, New Jersey

See all

I went here for breakfast and was actually served BURNT EGGS!!! Seriously???? Disgraceful that it was actually served to me! You would think the chef would not allow this to be served, but the server should not have brought it out either. I will NOT be back! Unbelievable! read more

Excellent bakery with a true homemade taste. Everything must be made in small batches! The coffee was delicious too!

After coming back up from the shore, my boyfriend and I were just looking for an early, good breakfast without hitting any traffic. We tried to find a town we never even heard of...and we came upon Smithville. The Smithville Bakery was everything we wished for and more. The food was amazing, the bakery items were killer, and the people made you feel like you were right at home. The atmosphere is one you don't find at many places. Definitely a place for the books!!! read more

I wonder how this place gets four and five stars. People who are giving it such high rate must not have opportunities to eat real food or they have not had real baked goods. I tried supporting this business with the hopes that they would improve or improvise the quality of their baked goods. Nothing has changed for at least six years. This past weekend, they had seasonal pumpkin spice donuts which that were very dry and I suspect they had used food coloring. The donuts did not taste like pumpkins or pumpkin spice. I also bought Boston cream donuts which were supposed to have custard fillings. Their donuts were filled with some white sugar cream that tasted like bottom cream. They had apple turnovers that clearly used canned apples. They charge so much money for such low quality, food coloring decorated and canned fruit containing pastries. I guess, if people are happy giving them five stars why would they strive to improve or use better quality products. Well, I will take my business somewhere else. read more

Can I give negative stars? This was by far the worst bakery I have ever been to in my life. The cupcake and cake was so dry and terrible. I bit into a peanut butter cookie and thought it was for the dogs. Absolutely no taste. Do not go here if you want good baked goods. I had to slap ( kidding) the hotel clerk in OCNJ for recommending this place to us when we drove over for the day to the village of stores. read more

This is a hidden gem. The tiny cafe was perfect for a nice breakfast on our way out of town. The eggs were fresh. The service was pleasant and the chef was fast. It was very peaceful sitting outside and watching the world go by there. Definitely a from me. My only hesitation in giving 5 stars was the quality of the sugar cookies we picked up on the way out.. maybe it was just a bad batch but they seemed stale. read more

I only made a very quick, small purchase so I can't say much. I just needed something sweet to keep up my energy for shopping. Everything in the case looked good and I really wanted to leave this review just to say that prices seemed very reasonable. I talked myself out of everything and went to the 1/2 price, day old shelf and got a giant chocolate chip cookie. That ended up doing the trick so I could keep shopping. The next time I visit Smithville I will check out something on the menu. read more

Always good food with excellent service for the staff. Always get plenty of smiles with good morning form all the staff. Prices are fair as always portions are good. read more

Coming from California you find diners a lot that are overrated but this organization gives you the grandparents kitchen vibes. The food cooked from scratch and the bakery full of constantly cooked breads. This place is packed a lot but this organization is worth the wait and you know what the coffee isn't half ba read more

Smithville Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Galloway, New Jersey

Nice place to grab breakfast in Smithville. They have tasty baked goods. Donuts and bagels go quick. read more

The Smithville bakery is one of the best bakery's I've ever been to and one of my favorite treats there where the chocolate cookies

They make the best stuff. If you want breakfast or just a cookie to go, they have you covered. The staff is friendly and funny, and I also just like the whole atmosphere. read more

Went here for brunch in a girls trip and I got the Eggs Benedict Florentine. The were really just average. The other ladies got omelets and one got a breakfast plate. They were a bit happier with their choices. Smithville was adorable I have to say. read more

Smithville Bakery - Eggs Benedict Florentine - Bakeries Near Me - Galloway, New Jersey

Went here for breakfast since the place down the street was closed. It was my first time here. The baked goods in the front are appealing to the eye and obviously made in house. We took some for snacks later. We sat down to breakfast- the place was full by 8:30am with a line of people waiting- and had pancakes, eggs, bacon, potatoes, etc. We all had a bit of everything. There was nothing special or bad about any of it, just nothing great either. The bacon was cooked well and a large portion, but the pancakes, though quite large, were rubbery, The dining room has fake trusses and som old tools on the walls. Service by Kim was poor - didn't get a refill on my $2 coffee- and the table was not wiped clean of the crumbs from the previous diners. Early in the morning it seemed filled by lots of senior citizens. The pastries are fresh but the rolls are all made from the same yeast dough so there is some lack of variety here. I would return for the bakery and try more things but not the cafe. read more

We got wonderful large oatmeal raisin cookies , a cheese danish multiple people could have ate , wonderful brownies and cinnamon sticks. Wonderful staff and food. read more

Smithville Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Galloway, New Jersey

See all