Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sibylicious Cupcake Cafe

    2.0 (1 review)
    Closed Closed

    Sibylicious Cupcake Cafe Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sibylicious Cupcake Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Cupcakes 149 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Designer Desserts - Clockwise from the top: Key Lime Pie, Creme Brûlée, New Yorker Cheesecake, Mocha Java, New Yorker Cheesecake, Cotton Candy in center!

    Designer Desserts

    3.7(62 reviews)
    5.5 mi
    $$

    Today was my first time coming here. I had a coupon for a free cupcake. I really wanted to try…read moreeither cherry chip or cotton candy, but I did not see those. I asked the girl what she recommended and she said the top shelf was the best sellers. I got the crème brûlée and pink champagne. The pink champagne was really delicious. It has like a raspberry buttercream and raspberry cake flavor. I did really like that one. The crème brûlée was also good. It was filled inside as well. My only complaint is be careful when you are eating the decorations (sprinkle balls) on top of the pink champagne cupcake. One of them actually cut my gums a little when I bit down. Service was great, it was clean inside .

    Odd location out of the way, but I was going to the pizza place in the same strip so we gave it a…read moretry. It's a small basic shop with 2 display cases of cupcakes. My husband went with the brownie which was coated in a thin layer of chocolate. It was quite rich but not too sweet which was nice. The 2 girls working the counter were courteous and pleasant. Prices were decent, maybe $6/ea. OG Chocolate Chocolate cupcake: chocolate cake with chocolate frosting cake was moist, frosting was fine, just too much of it Dark Chocolate Raspberry cupcake: the frosting was coated in chocolate and topped with a raspberry, a little light on the raspberry flavor but not bad My favorite was the Lemon cupcake, filled with a lemon curd it was sweet and tart and the perfect ending to a meal. While I won't necessarily go out of my way to go here, I'll stop in the next time I'm grabbing a pizza next door.

    Photos
    Designer Desserts - Greeted with a giant cupcake on the floor as you walk in.

    Greeted with a giant cupcake on the floor as you walk in.

    Designer Desserts - Current menu prices 07/07/17, comparable to the area for the size of the cupcakes

    Current menu prices 07/07/17, comparable to the area for the size of the cupcakes

    Designer Desserts - Selections in the case

    See all

    Selections in the case

    Cute As A Cupcake - Cake Pops

    Cute As A Cupcake

    4.1(64 reviews)
    10.3 mi
    $$

    Don't blink or you will miss out! Thank goodness they have a truck with their logo on it. It's on…read morean access road in an outdoor strip mall so you will have to turn into that to get there. Another place I have been meaning to get to but I don't come down this far often. But I will now! I have tried my fair share of cupcakeries and this ranks #1. I got the last caramel banana pudding (there was regular and I believe another flavor) Fantastic!! Between my husband and I this didn't last the night. I narrowed my cupcake choice to 3- toffee caramel, butterfinger and Dutch apple. Moist and delicious and creamy frosting OMG. It tasted as the title described and not too sweet or fake flavored in the least. I was stunned when I walked in as I wasn't expecting what was before my eyes. The owner was friendly and gave me the run down. They also have minimal ice cream flavors for winter but she said more in the warmer months. I will be back sooner than later and it is worth the extra gas I will use!

    This area isn't a vegan mecca, so just short of driving up to Chitown, you pretty much have to take…read morewhat you can get. This cute little bakery offered one soy based ice cream and several vegan cupcakes. Cupcakes were ok and satisfied my sweet tooth. If you're vegan and in this area, show 'em a little love so they can keep offering these treats for us.

    Photos
    Cute As A Cupcake
    Cute As A Cupcake - Vanilla Cupcake Chocolate Cupcake Strawberry Cupcake

    Vanilla Cupcake Chocolate Cupcake Strawberry Cupcake

    Cute As A Cupcake - Inside

    See all

    Inside

    Butterfingers - Not as expected, I got three mini cupcakes and to be completely honest they tasted like refrigerator

    Butterfingers

    3.7(60 reviews)
    1.5 mi
    $$

    The cookies from Butterfingers bakery are a seasonal highlight. I volunteer with an organization…read morethat hosts a holiday appreciation open-house each year featuring THE BEST cookie platter from this family-run bakery. From traditional Christmas cookies to new twists on the classics (sugar cookie with crushed peppermint pieces) these cookies are not overly sweet, crisp, and delectably melt-in-the mouth with the perfect proportion of textured-add ins. I have even been known to take a couple in a plastic bag to savor later. In the last few years, cookie chains have sprung up, bringing with them cult followings for their elaborate, often hubcap-sized tricked out confections and rotating flavors. Against this backdrop, Butterfingers stays true to the classics, turning out quality products, year after year, that stir nostalgia and evoke positive emotions, much like you-know-who's madeleines. (Sorry...I swore I could make it through a cookie discussion without mentioning Proust, but I couldn't.)

    I tried the vanilla buttercream cupcakes and both were just ok. The frosting tasted like cream…read morecheese frosting, it tasted nothing like buttercream at all. I actually hate cream cheese frosting, so I did not like it. I was kind of bummed out. Especially for $4.50 a cupcake The ham salad was good. The lady working was friendly and helpful.

    Photos
    Butterfingers
    Butterfingers - M&M Chocolate chip cookies

    M&M Chocolate chip cookies

    Butterfingers - Banana cupcake and butterscotch cookie with marble cupcake and peanut butter chunk cookie in background

    See all

    Banana cupcake and butterscotch cookie with marble cupcake and peanut butter chunk cookie in background

    Sibylicious Cupcake Cafe - cupcakes - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...