Banana cream pie with whipped cream was Amazing!! Always try to find Banana cream for my mom and my mom is very picky about her pie. We have found her birthday pie from now on! read more

Arrived there 1 week ago last Tuesday at 5:50pm. The store closes at 6. Was so excited to purchase a Lemon Pie at due to my Son and his wife bought one for me for my birthday. I loved the taste. I purchased a $17.00 key Lime, Lemon was out. I also bought a Lemon Slice, was not as good. The young lady with the noise piercing finished my sale. Within ear shot, I heard the lady behind me order a Chocolate Pie. The young lady says $8.00. I leave out the store confused as to why the person behind me charged only 1/2 of what I paid. I looked for a sale announcement, nothing indicating such. Went back in to inquire how this could happen at 6pm. She explained; because the pie was a day old....I asked her was this advertised anywhere as an I option? She looked at me like her hand was caught in the cookie jar and says "no". I left the store with the pie I paid full price; which I had no problem paying for, just wanted fairness. As a retired black elder, I just wanted to believe things could change. I guess Indiana just hasn't caught up yet. I probably will not spend my money there any longer. read more

We stopped at Marilyn's after coming up empty handed for baked goods at Remus Farmer's Market just down the street. We were greeted by a friendly person behind the counter and found lots of goodies to choose from. Their pies look great, and are bargain-priced compared to what we are used to in Chicago. They had a holiday table with toffee and other goodies. It wasn't until we left and I read the reviews that I knew that they are famous for their toffee. Something we missed out on. We ended up buying two blueberry muffins and a nut-laden banana bread. When decided between their zucchini bread and banana bread, we asked the counter person which one was better. Her answer was that she had never eaten either of them. Not a great help, and my suggestion is that employees should sample and be familiar with the product they are selling. That said, we went with the banana bread and was absolutely delicious--moist, flavorful and with a generous coating of nuts. Marilyn's banana bread was much better than the banana coffee cake that we had given our La Porte friends from a fancy-schmancy Chicago bakery--and it was a third of the price. The blueberry muffins were good, too. Not sure when we will ever be back in Hobart, Indiana, but Marilyn's is worth a stop if you're in the area. read more

Best pies ever. Nice size with delicious crust and fillings. Would definitely buy again read more

Looks like Marilyn's has beginners decorating their cakes now. I always get my cakes from them for special occasions and this time the frosting is so uneven. Hopefully the taste makes up for how ugly it is. read more

Marilyn's Bakery - I think Marilyn's has beginners decorating cakes now. Will not be getting my cakes from them anymore. - Bakeries Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

Their pies are always fresh & delicious. I stop in anytime I go to visit friends in Miller Beach. read more

Marilyn's Bakery - the front of the building - Bakeries Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

I always try to support local. I ordered 48 cupcakes two weeks prior to a Bridal Shower. Confirmed the order the day before. Arrived for picked up and they only had 24 cupcakes. They just missed out on a 200 person wedding order. read more

We always stop in on our way from ohio to Chicago. Very clean, nice, friendly bakery. Bought shortcakes, macadamia white chocolate cookies, and muffins. Went next door to the fruit and vegetable store for amazing fresh strawberries and we had delicious strawberry shortcake dessert. read more

I called 48hrs ahead of time to reserve two pies for thanksgiving to be picked up today, waited an hour and a half in line only to be told when I reached the counter they were SOLD OUT of the ones I ordered. Which this tells me they sold the ones I ordered to other people! Why couldn't they have called, had a note on the window, really have done anything to inform all the people in line of this, instead of making them waste their time only to be informed their preordered pies weren't available and to "come back in the morning," I've used Marilyn's bakery every year but this is the absolute last time! That is completely rude and bad business. read more

This is the best bakery in Northwest Indiana!!! We've gotten the cheesecake, fresh strawberry pie and chocolate pudding pie and all were so fresh and delicious!!! They are not too sweet, they are perfect! Definitely don't pass this place up if you have a taste for a good dessert! read more

Strawberry season After picking next door - stopped in for Strawberry donuts n Angel food cake n pound cake read more

See all

Bought cupcakes for birthday party on short notice. They made 3 dozen for me in two days. Ordered red velvet, carrot cake, and yellow cake with salted carmel ocing. They eere awesome, the hit of the party! Recomend them highky for any of your needs. Thank you for delicious cupcakes, great service, and meeting my short schedule. read more

I have bought their toffee during the Christmas season for years. I have accounts that can't wait to get it. I bought a container for my own family. I ate a piece and thought...this is not quite the same. I had another piece and it was the same as the first piece. . My husband ate a piece and made the comment, "this is not as good as it used to be". I don't know if we just got a bad batch, or what. Very disappointed!! read more

Only purchase one thing and it was the blueberry gluten free pie. Let me tell you this did not taste gluten free at all (if you know you know), it was delicious! read more

I think I can honestly say this is the best bakery I've been to. It's a cute little cafe with an adjacent farm that you can walk around and see flowers, veggies, herbs etc. The employees were very kind and the pastries are AMAZING. I would Definitely recommend. read more

Love their bakery it reminds me of my grandma's. Only downside is they need a bigger space.

Best pies in the area but they absolutely blew it for thanksgiving. I and many others had prepaid preordered weeks ago with a specified time to pick up only the get there and have to wait in line for literally 1.5 hrs. Many people I was with waited in line only to reach the counter to find out they were out of the pie they ordered. I personally ordered 3 which they did have but one of them looked as if it was dropped and the filling was knocked out they could not replace it because they didn't have another but did refund me for it. The whole time I was in line inside the building the manager made at least 3 announcements about how they have been working 16 hrs shifts and we're tired so don't complain more less. I can understand them being tired but it is absolutely there issue that they took way to many orders they should only accept orders for what they can handly in a timely manner instead of make people wait 1.5 hrs and then complain to them absolutely ridiculous. I have ordered on holidays many times and had to wait maybe 20 min max someone deffinately droped the ball do better read more

Some of the best desserts around. Friendly and helpful customer service. Neat and clean.

A little late for a review, but I like to tell you my story. Back in July 6th of 2022, I needed to pick up a cake for my son's birthday on July 7th as always I procrastinate. I start looking for locations in where I can get a cake and everyone was saying it would be ready the day after my son's birthday. I called Marilyn's and they told me it will be ready in a couple hours. They saved me as well as my son's birthday and the cost and taste has exceeded my exceeded my expectations. I will be shopping at Marilyn's Bakery for now on. read more

Went to pick up my cake order and sat for over 45 minutes with no explanation as to why! They bring the cake out and it is sliding over to one side. They take it back to "fix" it and bring it back taped up. I start heading home and decide to check the cake and it was sliding off even more. I take it back and they ask me if there is something wrong with the cake. I open the box and show them and I get. "Im sorry " They knew when they sent that cake out it was not going to be stable. They had a better reputation than this. Truly disappointed. Im sorry that I wasted over an hour of my time for your mistakes and now I don't have a Birthday cake for my daughter read more

The Very Berrie pie is as good as Buried Treasure from. The Elegant Farmer.Mucwanago Wisconsin

A little pricey, but definitely worth it! Best pies around!! They won me over when their strawberry rhubarb pie was delicious... and I hate rhubarb pie! Can't wait to pick up one of their chicken pot pies, I hear those are amazing! read more

Great food, wonderful homemade pies! We love supporting local businesses when possible. Some items a little pricey but I do recommend them.

Amazing pies, great service and wish you were closer to us in IL. Thankful you come to farmers market in Frankfort, IL

Stopped by Johnson's for the first time, to pickup some fruit. Never heard of Marilyn's Bakery before and decided to stop in. I picked up one of their strawberry pies. It was the best pie I've ever had!!! The crust was amazing, the strawberry were amazing! Will be a regular customer now read more

Our family ordered two pies for Thanksgiving. Pumpkin pie and the crumble apple pie! Outstanding!

Phenomenal experience here. Had the ultimate grilled cheese, homemade pumpkin soup, and French silk individual dessert. Everything was amazing, and all together total was only $9.00 What a deal!!! read more

Marilyn's Bakery - Ultimate grilled cheese, homemade pumpkin soup, and French silk dessert. All for only $9.00 bucks!!! Amazing!! - Bakeries Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

Chelsea was fantastic! Told us the entire story of the bakery, offered amazing suggestions and was charismatic! The pricing is great for the quality of the pies! I will be coming back to try the lunch options and pick up more desserts! She is super passionate and even told us the upcoming seasonal harvests that were her favorite and when we could get them! read more

Marilyn's Bakery - a pie and a pie with whipped cream - Bakeries Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

Saw this place on yelp and wanted a coffee so decided to give it a try. We drove from miller beach and while they didn't have the coffee we were hoping for (only had whole milk), I did try the cinnamon roll which was delicious. We got some apple cakes to go and would absolutely return. they had a cute little store next to the bakery. read more

Disappointed to give this place 3 stars. I was so excited to eat lunch here after our trip to Johnson's and was let down. First, it seemed to be understaffed. It was Labor Day so not sure if that's why. We ordered lunch and it took a while which was fine. Tons of people were coming in to pick up baked goods. We got our food and then had to wait another 5 minutes for the iced tea. We had a chicken salad croissant which had maybe 3 tbsp of chicken salad on it. I actually spotted someone else who ordered one and theirs was fine so I think this is an isolated incident but disappointing. We also had the bacon panini which was wonderful. They came with a tablespoon (seriously I'm not exaggerating) of potato salad on the side. It was bizarre, like why bother? The biggest disappointment was my kids meals. Ok the menu all they offer is a cheese or peanut butter and banana flatbread which I thought ok that's fine. We got it and it was a cold pita which they had melted a tiny sprinkle of cheese on, and the PB one was basically a swipe of PB with a few bananas on the same cold pita. it is nice it comes with fruit and a cookie. I actually felt bad for my kids that that was their lunch. On the bright side they did give us an extra free cupcake because of the wait, and the baked goods were awesome! I may try it again but not with my kids unless the menu is improved. I was so excited for them to open in St John since it's so much closer, I hope someone sees this and develops a better kids menu for that location! read more

Marilyn's Bakery - See the TINY potato salad?! - Bakeries Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

See all

the pies are excellent . they have steadily increased prices and are no longer reasonable . i think they are taking advantage of their success to gouge customers . yes I know the cost of ingredients has increased, but their increases are disproportionate. A nut roll shouldn't suddenly double in price. Certainly stopped me from going there . read more

Everytime I stop in they always have new delicious treats to devour and I make sure to grab a glass of their homemade lemonade read more

See all

I ordered a chocolate orange cake for my husbands birthday. The cake was silky and flavorful. The chocolate frosting was airy and delicious. read more

Marilyn's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

Well was there bright and early this morning looking for a plain vanilla cheese cake. Went there yesterday afternoon and they had only the "fancy" fruit topped ones. I was told there would be some this morning. Which of course, WAS A LIE. This makes several attempts on my part to get a plain cheese cake from there. I won't be making any more. I was told they get them from the St John Marilyns. Are they the only shop baking for both? Questions and no answers. I am not going to travel all the way from Portage to St John with gas prices what they are. And this in my opinion is NOT a good way to run a business. Close the Hobart store if you can't make your goods there. Plain and simple. read more

Came here for some blueberry picking and stopped by the cafe. Was expecting a small assortment, but boy was I wrong! So many choices! I went with the corn soup, panini, and blueberry cheesecake lunchbox, which was a great value . I'm not one for corn flavored anything, but OH MY GOODNESS that soup was delicious. The panini and the cheesecake were tasty too! Would recommend anyone driving by the area to stop here to grab a bite to eat! read more

Marilyn's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

See all

Amazing cup cakes and always friendly staff. Always a go to spot. German chocolate and orange and definitely the best.

Yes, this is a follow-up review. If I could have figured out a way to edit the first one, then I would have done so. The poor service that we encountered yesterday picking up the cake became even worse today when we served it. The cake WAS NOT their "daily signature" mandarin orange cake with pineapple whipped frosting ... it was a plain old yellow cake with the pineapple whipped frosting. Further, of the 3 layers, only the bottom layer was an actual round cake (8 inch, I think) ... the other two layers were pieced together parts. This made cutting and serving quite a challenge. Bottom line, if you read my other review, we were indeed hoodwinked just like the caller who tried to place an order. Funny thing - I had read a review from someone who posted about a wedding cake disaster. My first thought about that review was "not possible" ... well, I was completely wrong and should have taken that review seriously. read more

The product when you get is good but the service is the worst. Pre-ordered our holiday pies and rolls. Mind you paid for weeks ago and assigned an order number and pickup time. Arrived at pickup time only to be told they are short handed and need to come back at 2:30. Arrived only to find order was not complete because someone sold one of our items. This is twice we have had bad experience with service. They basically said sorry here you money back and you can have a very berry pie. Sorry not good enough if I wanted a very berry pie I would have ordered. Thanks for screwing up our order and not caring. read more

Small local bakery. Awesome red velvet cupcakes. Good selection if pies and breads. Creates wedding cakes. Laura is very easy and friendly to work with. Good prices. Constantly changing menu. Cozy place to sit in or outside to eat. read more

Marilyn's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Hobart, Indiana

I came to try the Strawberry doughnuts, not bad nothing spectacular or anything. I also tried a few other items the favorite was the lemon cake that was really good. read more

See all