Two parts to this review: Waldorf in general, and Shining Mountain in particular. I'm a parent of two boys, one in 8th grade at Shining Mountain (there for 3 years, previously in LA), one in 5th grade at the local public elementary (went to Shining Mountain for 3rd grade).
In short, we looked at Waldorf because we met kids who had graduated, and they were incredibly impressive as people. Not just being smart and accomplished, but being solid. Mature, well-rounded, able to hold conversations with adults, and NOT focused on the shallow. One example comes to mind: Thanksgiving dinner with 8 nieces and nephews, of which 5 were basically the same age. The 3 who were at regular schools -- and are great kids in so many ways -- were completely occupied texting their friends about the next party that night, etc., and couldn't engage with others in any meaningful way, being totally distracted.
The two Waldorf kids, on the other hand, were present in the moment, interested and interesting. The marked contrast was palpable, but it's hard to convey here. But, overall, these kids were comfortable in their own skins and were real people. It left a deep impression. So, what that said to us was, we don't know how they got there, but the end results are so good, we have to check this out.
The Waldorf approach is quite different than others with which I'm familiar. It is heavy on deep exploration of topics, music, art, performance, and integration across disciplines.
Deep exploration of topics is in contrast to "teaching to the test" and "learning by rote". That is a really big one, and takes getting used to for parents, and kids, who have been in public (or almost all private) schools. It's partly based on the idea that kids will truly learn when material is presented multiple times, with deep explanation of why it works the way it works. Learning about Alexander the Great, astronomy, even algebra is decidedly different under Waldorf. Much more observational rather than just accepting what someone tells you. Not perfect, because it seems to take longer than I'd like, but the kids definitely know a lot about the subject this way.
Art, music and performance are serious. There is real time dedicated to stuff that public schools have had to largely jettison or do only once in a while. You give up the rapid-fire progress on other topics, obviously, but if it's a trade-off, at least you get something in trade! Every kid plays an instrument -- a lot -- and creates art in many media, performs in the class play, sings at assemblies, etc. I can't believe the art my sons have done. That skill is inherent in some people, but at Waldorf everybody spends time becoming good at it. It's amazing, I would not have expected it actually works!
Waldorf is not for everyone. If your kid loves taking tests, is really competitive, or if you as a parent get freaked out by the pace and the wider array of topics or the non-denominational spirituality, it can be a challenge. My younger son and Waldorf are a great match in many ways, but he wanted much more academic pace, and -- and this can happen at any school, it's not just Waldorf or Shining Mountain -- wanted more structure and order in class than the other kids were able to deal with. So he's at public, and loves the academics, the structure and the larger pool of kids. But he definitely misses out on the art, music, etc., and gets loaded with all kinds of tedious make-work homework that is almost a complete waste of time. He may go back to Waldorf and Shining Mountain at some point, we'll see, I would be a strong advocate for that given the outcomes I've seen.
Shining Mountain is a great Waldorf school. It's big enough to have enough kids to find variety, it goes K-12, the faculty and staff are great, the facilities are pretty good (although the high school could use a refresh, which it will get soon), and the kids and parents are pretty great. One thing I've learned is that the fit with the kids and teachers are most important; it's wonderful to have cool parents, which we do in our class, but your kid is there 8 hours a day, not you. So if your kid finds a fit, that's the place. read more