Cancel

Open app

Search

Sheridan House

4.4 (16 reviews)
ModerateHotels

Services - Sheridan House

Hotels

Sheridan House Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Sheridan House

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

14 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Nick D.
43
10
1

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Beautiful, clean, and cozy rooms. Also a very quiet neighborhood. If I'm ever in the area again I will definitely stay here!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Classic, comfortable place to eat. We ate at the bar rather than a table. Great service..Very tasty food, good atmosphere.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

The final fish fry of lent was awesome! I had the beer batter cod! With potato pancakes! Just delightful!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Great location near parks and lake, beautifully appointed, unfriendly management, wonderful staff otherwise. I loved my stay there.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Sheridan House

Review Highlights - Sheridan House

The rooms are luxurious and always super clean.

Mentioned in 3 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Hotels 3,407 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Homewood Suites by Hilton Oak Creek Milwaukee - Hotel

Homewood Suites by Hilton Oak Creek Milwaukee

(13 reviews)

The desk receptionist was very nice and friendly! He saw that I was an out of towner and gave my…read morerecommendation as to what to do in the city while visiting. Checking in was also a smooth process and a quick one if I don't say so. The room was clean and spacious like most suites. I didn't have any issues or complaints with anything. The breakfast spread could have been a little better in the morning but I won't complain too much as it was better than nothing at all. I'd definitely stay here again no problem.

I travel for work. Not a little bit, a lot! I am in the field 12 days, home 2 days, rinse, repeat…read more I always stay at Hilton properties when I can. Well I recently changed companies and there was a gap between the last job and this one. Money was tight due to some personal issues that had to do with me leaving the last job and having a gap. I was checking in on a Monday to start work at my new company the following day so I did not have a company card yet. The hotel was booked and paid for by my new employer and my reservation was for 12 days. As I mentioned I'm a loyal Hilton customer and I use the Hilton Honors app. The day before check-in I used the app to select my room. I think this is where the problem started. I had a personal card as my payment method on the app and I think that when I checked in it switched from using the payment method my employer provided and switched it to my personal card, which did not have a large enough balance to cover the 12 days I would be staying. So my check-in did not go through. I calmly tried to explain this issue to the front desk attendant and she was absolutely uncaring, I think her primary concern was that she did not know how to resolve the issue so she just wanted it to go away. She insisted that the only card they had for this reservation was my personal card. I offered to get some info and call some people and stepped aside because there was another woman who needed help. Turns out the other woman was trying to sort out an issue with personal vs corporate payments but hers was a bit different than mine. I tried to step back up when that woman went back to sit in the nearby chairs but the receptionist told me she was still working on that woman's issue. She eventually called a manager and after dealing with the other issue asked about my issue and the solution was simple and something I had politely suggested earlier. The entire time she was uncaring, responded with blank stares and made pretty clear she didn't care if I slept on the street that night. I've been in Homewood Suites several times before. This one is new but it's not well designed. In the king suite there is one table and chairs that are taller than dining table chairs but shorter than bar height chairs. I am using the bags of supplemental blankets as a foot rest so that blood flow isn't being cut off as I sit to do work at the table. Other locations have also had a small work desk with a suitable chair. There is a built-in nightlight at the bathroom sink that can't be turned off. I covered mine with a band-aid. In the shower room and toilet there is a door and a motion sensor light. In the middle of the night it's like a flashbang grenade. I had to put two band-aids on that one. I don't really like the shower but it's a 3/5. The AC is like so many now. It lies. It turns off in the middle of the night. The breakfast is pretty average. There is usually a sausage, then they have had Chicken Tinga or Chorizo and Potatoes. Yukon Gold potatoes and scrambled eggs. Waffles, yogurt, oats, sweet baked goods, bagels. A condiment bar with a green and red salsa, jalapenos. Only one dispenser for regular coffee so it is often empty. Their OJ is in a pitcher and the cups for it are extra small, plus it has a chemical taste. I'm not a fan of hotel breakfast in general and this is no different than most. Oh, the dish washing machine is extra loud, like crazy extra loud. You can also hear every footstep from the room above, so I'd opt for a 4th floor room. Even thought this hotel is new the laundry is coin-op. EDIT: After the owners response I want to say that I have had exceptional experiences with the shuttle drivers. All of them. I should have mentioned that. Also, besides the person I dealt with at check-in I have had positive experiences with the front desk staff. However, the chair issue is too much for me. I will be looking for an alternative when I'm in the area and I will be back often. I need a foot rest and my makeshift solution is not cutting it. I cannot comfortably work at the table because the chairs are too high. I appreciate the response. Thank you!

The Iron Horse Hotel - The lobby area

The Iron Horse Hotel

(463 reviews)

$$$

Walker's Point

This place is just COOOOOOOOL. You will NOT regret your stay!! My boss took a bunch of us here for…read morea team building. It has been my favorite hotel stay to date. Make the reservation!

My stay at The Iron Horse Hotel was extremely disappointing, especially for a property that markets…read moreitself as a boutique experience. From the moment I walked in, the lobby was overwhelmed with a heavy, Axe body spray-like scent--so strong it felt like walking through a middle school locker room. I assumed it was temporary and that my room would be a relief, but unfortunately, it was worse. The room smelled musty, like a house that hasn't been aired out in years. To make matters worse, the wallpaper was peeling off the walls, which is unacceptable for a hotel at this level. Beyond that, the overall cleanliness of the hotel was lacking. For a boutique property, I expected a much higher standard, but the space felt worn and not well-maintained. The bed was hard and uncomfortable, and the towels were rough--far from the soft, high-end feel you'd expect. The most concerning part of my stay, though, was waking up at 1:45 AM struggling to breathe. It genuinely felt like a reaction to something in the room--possibly mold or poor air quality. I initially thought I was getting sick, but after spending a few hours away the next day, I felt completely normal again, which makes it hard to ignore the room as the cause. If you have any respiratory sensitivities, be cautious. I contacted the front desk to explain the situation and was told checking out early without being charged for another night wouldn't be an issue. I even offered to return around noon so they could turn the room, but was told not to worry since they weren't sold out. When I returned later that day, there was no note, and the staff refused to honor what I had been told, citing the late checkout time. While I understand policies, the inconsistency and lack of follow-through were frustrating. I also dined at the hotel restaurant, which didn't help the experience. The food was overpriced for the quality--my salad was warm, fries were room temperature, and clearly sat out too long. Dessert was equally disappointing; the lemon tart was buried under an excessive amount of powdered sugar, making it unpleasant to eat. It's honestly a sad day when I transferred to a basic airport hotel--Hyatt Place Milwaukee Airport--and had a significantly better experience. The bed was more comfortable, the towels were actually soft, and even the shampoo and conditioner were noticeably better quality. On top of that, the Hyatt was spotless, which only made the lack of cleanliness at Iron Horse stand out even more. Overall, this stay fell far below expectations. Between the condition of the room, air quality concerns, cleanliness issues, and poor service recovery, I won't be returning.

Sheridan's Bed & Breakfast - Amazing breakfast

Sheridan's Bed & Breakfast

(151 reviews)

Sheridan's brunch and food is great. I've never gone wrong with the Oatmeal-Blueberry Pancakes or…read moreEggs Sheridan or the Pulled Pork Benedict. It's a nicely decorated place, with comfortable seating, and a fireplace in the back dining room. And while I like visiting, service has always seemed to be lacking, from taking that first order, to refilling the coffee, to getting the check, and I see others have pointed that out. They serve Valentine Coffee, which I love, but get bigger cups (and Splenda)! Tea cups don't do us coffee drinkers justice if the coffee service is slow. Yelper Cliches: Can we stop calling restaurants that have been on Yelp for a full decade with over 100 reviews a "hidden gem"? Sheridan's is in plain view on Lake Drive (four lane highway 32), and everyone in the area knows about Sheridan's. Sheridan's is not bad, could be better, A-Okay 3-stars.

They have an electronic keycard for the building and your room, and no reception. They give you a…read morecode for the lock box the first day and leave your key in there (along with everyone else's). On the second day, they apparently decided to change our keys without telling us. We were stuck outside in the rain with no way to get into the building, and no one to buzz us in. They said "we changed your keys and slipped your new keys under the door." Big help that is when we are stuck outside in the rain. What a ridiculous thing to do. The walls and floors are paper thin. There is no water to drink.

The Pfister Hotel - The Pfister Lobby

The Pfister Hotel

(454 reviews)

$$$

Downtown, East Town

We love it here. Very spacious and relaxing. Rooms are so clean and the pool has a beautiful view…read more Everyone here is so nice and accommodating. The lounge is perfect for snacks and breakfast. I would definitely upgrade to that package and the people working in the lounge were so sweet and kind to our whole family. Again the views are amazing. Really kid friendly.

I'm somewhat torn on this review. I think the hotel is beautiful - especially the rooms in the…read moreolder part which scream history (and have huge corridors - very European feel!). I thought our room size was decent - a suite with a separate bedroom and sitting area. However, it was very pricey and I think for the price, we shouldn't have had hair in the shower, a discarded tissue by the nightstand and .. something gooey on the phone. I know it's hard to find every nook and crannie of these rooms, but it is very expensive and compared to other hotels of this caliber/price, this was unusual. Hopefully an anomoly. I also thought we booked 2 queen beds but these beds were certainly only doubles - not so large when you've got 4 people staying in a room. Service was good when we were there, though I tried to contact them my email ahead of my visit (no reply) and also by phone where I wasn't greeted super warmly. However, upon arrival, we were welcomed with a glass of sparkling wine to check in and the staff at the front desk was very helpful and friendly. The pool is nice but not that large and depending on how many people are there, it can be tight. It's also near the upstairs restaurant, so you might get to wait at the elevator with half of the people in dressy attire and half in bathing suits. The artwork in the conference/event area is lovely and throughout the old part of the hotel is really interesting. I love quirky and this had a mix of historic and quirky which was nice. Parking was attached (just a different elevator if you're staying in the historic part of the hotel).

Sheridan House - hotels - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...