Cancel

Open app

Search

Shakin' Shellfish

4.3 (7 reviews)
Closed • 5:00 pm - 8:00 PM

SHAKIN' SHELLFISH · YELP ASSISTANT

Ask Yelp Assistant

Shakin' Shellfish Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Shakin' Shellfish

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

2 months ago

This place has gone out of business. Please update your listing. We drove there and it was closed

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Hollie S.

Hollie S.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

100 percent recommend this to everyone looking for seafood in the Ottumwa area, the owner and service was top notch !!! We will be back!!!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Randy C.
58
33
10

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Awesome seafood,best in town,just like a taste of New Orleans it's my #1 spot in Ottumwa.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of R D.
0
21
17

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Shakin' Shellfish

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Shiki Hibachi And Sushi - Shiko Tako - Octopus (9/10)

Shiki Hibachi And Sushi

4.1(14 reviews)
1.6 mi

My friend brought us here and started the table with spicy Edamame 10/10 , Pork Gyoza (6 Pieces)…read more10/10, Crab Rangoons 9/10 and not pictured Crab Puff 100/10 - only came with 4 but we wish there was so much more. Every roll we tried was delicious. They definitely put their own spin on the mixed fish with adding panko into it. Overall amazing service and very clean restaurant.

My wife and I love sushi. We won't be back. That's the synopsis. However, if you'd like details…read moreplease read on. I will be thorough so all may be spared the horrors of this place. In hindsight, this whole experience reads like a horrible relationship. There were signs along the way that we should have left, but for some reason we stayed. Red flag number one; The front door. The filthy hand prints on the glass and non descript smears of god only knows what should have prompted a quick "nope" & return to vehicle. Yet we pressed on. I must say the first impressions were on par with the front door. We walked in & noticed the place was virtually empty, we figured it was about 3:00pm so it was probably an odd time and shrugged it off. Before sitting down I went to the bathroom to wash my hands from the filthy front door touching and figured I'd use it while in there. That should have been red flag number two. I won't go into detail since you're looking for a food place to dine at. Let's just say this place made the front door look palatable. I had to use soap in order to use the soap. No joke, nightmare fuel. As I escaped the panic room, I walked passed the hostess/server sitting in a booth eating some sort of soup with mussels, watching her soaps on her phone. As she sat at the table she spat something into her hand and placed it onto the pile that was on a napkin on the table in front of her. This was a practice she had clearly been doing a while as the pile in front of her indicated it was habitual. I got back to the table and this same woman quickly approached with two menus & rudely said "do you know what you want to drink?". The menu was ripped & sticky, the wallpaper around the table was pealing off the walls. This place is unclean & felt dated & uncared for. She walked away & a returned with two sprites & again rudely asked "Do you know what you want?". The answer should have been "yes, to not eat here" yet again we pressed on foolishly thinking, "maybe the food is good". We ordered some pork gyoza (grilled dumplings) to share, an Ottumwa Roll, Ninja Roll, & a Philadelphia Roll. Each of these seeming safe choices given the description in the sticky torn menu. The waitress had gone outside & returned walking passed us. The smell of smoke was so strong it was as if she blew smoke directly at us. She then sat back down in her booth where she spent the next ten minutes or more hacking a wet cough out into the room without seeming to care to cover her mouth. Again, why didn't we run? We had already ordered. Rather than be rude we waited to partake of sushi, which as I stated in the first sentence of this sad saga, we love. We should have been rude. The food arrived. Even though I asked for no cilantro on my Ottumwa Roll, it still came with it right on top like a visible middle finger to my request. I simply removed it & moved on. My wife noticed her roll was in fact deep fried. Interesting given that the menu read "deep-fried salmon, white tuna..." which to us read that the salmon was deep fried, not the whole roll. We chalked this up to an unfortunate grammatic error in the menu & "our bad". As we prepped our dipping plates we poured the "soy sauce" & noticed it was a pale brown color almost akin to beef broth. Soy sauce is traditionally very dark, almost black. It was clear this was watered down but it could work. I'm saddened to say the watery soy sauce was the highlight of this meal. The deep fried ring on the outside of the Ninja roll was so hard it could not be eaten. It was as if someone wrapped room temperature dried-out fish inside of cardboard. My wife had to dissect the roll just to eat the part that was manageable. It was as if this roll was made yesterday then refrigerated and brought out today. The Ottumwa roll should be re-named as it is offensive to the city of Ottumwa. It should be renamed Barstow as it is dry, unpleasant, & not really a good representation of California. This roll was exactly that, only mildly resemblant of sushi. The dryness of the "spicy tuna" inside this roll was as if they had made it with sawdust. This roll tasted stale like yesterday's gas station sushi. In fact, I've eaten sushi from grocery store deli refrigerators that was more fresh & flavorful than this atrocity. The Philadelphia Roll should come with a size clause. If a standard sushi roll is the size of a silver dollar/fifty cent piece, this was the size of a nickel. I thought I was being punked. It too overly dry. Then $54 later, we left feeling violated as if leaving a bad relationship that we should have left years ago. We left & went to Menards to use their restroom to avoid any more humiliation from this place. In truth, this was all our fault, we should have run. Now our trauma is your guide. Avoid this place. It's not good. I'm not even sure it's sushi. Frankly it's a miracle we didn't both have food poisoning, though I waited to post this until I was sure we were safe. Zero Stars.

Photos
Shiki Hibachi And Sushi - Nice

Nice

Shiki Hibachi And Sushi - Scorpion Roll (2 Roll)

Scorpion Roll (2 Roll)

Shiki Hibachi And Sushi - Tuna Tataki (10/10)

See all

Tuna Tataki (10/10)

Sebree's Restaurant

Sebree's Restaurant

4.2(41 reviews)
47.1 mi
•$$$

What an unexpected surprise. This place is in the absolute middle of nowhere but nonetheless…read moreprovides an excellent fine dining experience. What a find! Presuming our son ends up going to Truman, we will be back. To start, the rolls are fresh baked every day and served with local honey butter. They are amazing! Easily the best bread I have ever had. They are a cross between a yeast roll and a biscuit with a hint of sweetness...incredible! My son had the chicken piccata which, though the portion was a bit small, was extremely flavorful. He ate every bit. I had the prime rib sandwich. The portion was large with plenty of provel cheese, onions and mushrooms. It was also delicious. My wife got a giant pile of roast pork served with warm apples and a sweet glaze. The pork was fall apart tender and the glaze added a punch of flavor. All 3 of us had the home fries as the side. These were the crispiest potatoes I have ever had in my life. 10/10. Out waitress/hostess had plenty to do (I think she may have bend doing kitchen prep as well) but she was friendly, welcoming and accommodating. A few tips: the restaurant is very small with few staff (like one person who is the hostess and waitress for the entire place). Reservations strongly recommend. And maybe don't come here if you're in a hurry. Service was not fast but it's clearly because they are taking great care with the food and preparing everything fresh to order. The menu changes frequently so check their Facebook for the latest. All of the food is made fresh and they do run out. Book early in the evening if there is something you have your heart set on.

We came in from out of town to celebrate my cousin's graduation. A total of three tables were…read moreoccupied. My aunt called on two separate occasions to make reservations for our larger group. We walked in on the night of my cousin's graduation to celebrate a huge milestone. We walked in and the hostess stated she didn't have our reservation, another lady who was either the owner or manager came up hot and bothered and was EXTREMELY rude. On a hospitality level I give her a -50. She very rudely stated she didn't have our reservation and continued to be awful as we tried to clarify that we had made a reservation. Even if she could have been nice and apologetic about the reservation misunderstanding, I wouldn't have stayed to eat here and support this business. People need to learn how to treat other humans nicely. This lady was NOT nice, one of the rudest restaurant encounters I've ever had.

Photos
Sebree's Restaurant - Pennies in the floor

Pennies in the floor

Sebree's Restaurant
Sebree's Restaurant - Onion Ring and Prime Rib dip

See all

Onion Ring and Prime Rib dip

Orchard Green - Fried Oysters

Orchard Green

4.4(269 reviews)
63.4 mi
•$$$

Before I came to Iowa City for a conference? i researched places to eat. This was one I wanted to…read morego to. They're well reviewed on Yelp, which I value. My friend from work and I came here tonight. Wow. They have an informal lounge downstairs and a more formal dining room upstairs. The lounge has the same menu plus a lounge menu. So we chose more choice. The lounge was kinda dark and it's not fancy. But it's clean and open. It's fine. The server was terrific. Ash accommodated our need for separate checks (for us each to bill for our meal). She was attentive and pleasant. I asked her what she liked better between a couple of things and she gave me an honest answer. I followed her recommendation, The beet salad was lovely. the dressing had some goat cheese in it and was delicious. The fresh beets on the side really worked with the dressing. My friend got the cheese platter to start and there was lots of cheese. He loved it. He got the lounge version of the salmon, which he thought was great. I got the Artic Char, which was delicate and phenomenal. It was topped with pieces of lobster and caviar like eggs. The fish was delicate and the sauce rich, but not overpowering. It was delightful. We both loved our meals and highly recommend Orchard Green.

Food is incredible. I had the ribeye. Ah-mazing. My friend got scallops and had 7 HUGE scallops.read more

Photos
Orchard Green - Bar downstairs

Bar downstairs

Orchard Green - Lobster Butternut Squash Bisque

Lobster Butternut Squash Bisque

Orchard Green - Lounge downstairs

See all

Lounge downstairs

Shakin' Shellfish - seafood - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...