First time was better than the second time. Today's brisket sandwich tasted like it was sitting in…read moreau jus too long or it was reheated from yesterday. Maybe both? The texture and cut were also completely different than previously. Mac n cheese not good today. Tasted like a watered down stouffers frozen dinner without the yummy burnt edges. I may give this a third try at some point, like when it's busier or later in the day when the meat is fresh. $14 for the sandwich and side wasn't terrible for the portion size, which was larger today as well. Maybe they were moving out the old stuff. Who knows? Better luck next time.

Skimpy, mislabeled, and dry. I got the chicken platter with collard greens. Actually, though you…read morecouldn't tell from the menu, the platter is just the sandwich but instead of chips it comes with a small side and a drink. The sandwich, which I got with Carolina sauce, was still dry and had way more bread than bbq. The collards had good flavor. Overall, I was disappointed with the quantity and the quality. I've heard the Mac and cheese bowl is way more food but similarly mediocre. Don't think I'd go here again. If I did, it definitely wouldn't be for a "platter"

What a amazing place to get great food and everyone there is super friendly ! I will be back soonread more

Great local butcher shop! Plenty of fresh meats and homemade sausage, the made to order sub was…read morereally good. Great selection of hot foods as well. They have a few tables to eat inside and the staff was friendly.

Excellent meat and service . They will vacuum pack all steaks , etc . For a nominal fee .read more

Everything is local, super fresh and delicious. A classic family run meat market. I had marinated…read morestew meat and sausages ( green pepper and onion) best I've ever had.

Well organized and wide selection…read more And a great source for a Thanksgiving smoked turkey (order in advance). The scrapple and smoked Ham hocks are also very good. The staff is helpful.

It's already April and my wife and I's little getaway to Pennsylvania back in February continues to…read morepop into my head. Mostly it's where we stayed (shoutout to Airbnb), but also it was the fun and different experiences/places we visited around the Intercourse/Lancaster area like Stoltzfus Meats. This store doubles as a place to eat at as well as a spot to get plenty of (I bet you can guess) meats to cook up in the privacy of your own home. Normally, a place like Stoltzfus might have been somewhere we may not have even ventured into, but wanting to spend as much time in that aforementioned Airbnb, we saw the great Yelp score of this spot and what it offered in the way of food to cook, and so Stoltzfus was visited with a meaty mission in hand. What does Stoltzfus offer (beyond just saying meat)? Well they really do have a massive selection of different types of steak, pork, chicken, and even some non-meat meals (pizzas, mac and cheese, etc.). Some items come frozen which would have worked well for us had we been staying longer than a couple of days, but we decided to hit up the counter and get some fresh uncooked items that we could make for dinner (and breakfast). Once being helped (which was quick as there were many people working) the staff member was friendly (albeit we had a little confusion about the amount of sausage types we could buy) and we were able to purchase a few different flavored-sausages, some macaroni salad, and some breakfast sausages to make the next morning. After grabbing these we looked at some of the prepackaged meats and found some marinated chicken strips to get as well. Once back at the Airbnb, we cooked everything up and the meats definitely were tender and flavorful. The macaroni salad was also pretty solid. Though nothing blew me away, the meal we made was great for the price we spent. Best item was probably the breakfast sausages we had the next morning. They were a maple apple flavor and dang were they delicious. Overall, Stoltzfus Meats did the trick for our little Airbnb getaway. Perhaps not a place we would have ventured to if not staying in a location that warranted some potential cooking, I am still glad we got to experience Stoltzfus and would definitely return if we did end up back in that part of the Pennsylvania state with the need to make a meal. Even if I physically don't come back, I know my mind will at least continue to return here!

I love this butcher shop! Super quality of meats and cheeses, great selection and great service…read more I'm about an hour away, but will make the trip because I can't get that quality near me.

Always quality and good prices. My favorite butcher. Highly recommend. Best in e townread more

the best meat shop in the area a great selection of meats and homemade treats and side dishes, it…read moreis a little more expensive than shopping for meats at a commercial grocery stor, however the extra cost is worth it as their quality is top notch and is so much better than what you can get at an ordinary grocery store. would highly recommend!

Best ham loaf in the WORLD!!! The Wenger's are some of the…read morekindest, generous, top notch people in Elizabethtown. The quality and variety is above a little mom and pop butchers that it is. I would recommend you shop here!

They always have the freshest meat they always courtesy and friendly…read more I don't know what I would do if I couldn't shop there. Love them so much It's a country Deli butcher shop great variety and they always have specials.

Godfrey Brothers is a superb local butcher. The service is always great with friendly knowledgeable…read morestaff who will recommend the best cut for the meal you want to make if you ask. Quality of their meats is far superior than the grocery store. They also carry gulf shrimp and their sourdough bread partner just started providing sliced loaves of bread.