I've been stopping on Fridays to get a couple of slices for lunch. I have enjoyed them so much that today I decided to pickup a couple of their Brooklyn style crust pie to bring home for dinner. I'm really looking forward to getting them home for dinner! Stop by and give their diverse menu a try! read more

Decided to give a try as we've not yet ordered food from this spot. We got a Sicilian, cheese steak, a pasta dish, and a few apps. Across the board I would say that the food was good, but not great. Staff inside were warm and super friendly. Probably will give them another go at some point in the future but I'm not busting to get back. Not terrible, not amazing, a solid 3 stars. read more

We've gone three time for pizza and hands down they are the best in our area. They do not hold back in cheese or toppings. The pizzas themselves weigh a ton. They are super friendly and real Italians. True sign of a great pizza is the crust and theirs is delicious. read more

I don't know why this place has crappy reviews. Just got two slices. Crunchy. Good taste.

Great fortune to have found this spot RIGHT off Jersey Turnpike exit 7. Awesome pizza. Try the Sicilian and tomato pie. Delicious. Take a detour. It will make your day. read more

The BEST damn pizza we have EVER eaten!!! The crust was heavenly, the sauce and veggies were fresh and flavorful and the price was okay unbelievably reasonable!! We enjoyed chatting with the owner and the atmosphere was easy and relaxed. We can't wait read more

Great people! I really enjoy their Pizzq Margherita. Plenty of good pizza in Bordentown and this is my favorite.

We traveled here from Albany NY to go to 6 flags and decided to order some food to our hotel after a long day. We saw the reviews and thought what the heck... We got a turkey hoagie which came completely saturated.... With almost green tomatoes on it... We got a BLT panini that was completely dry with nothing on it and was not even grilled with almost rotten tomatoes on it.. the best part was the salad which half way through my husband found a sticker with a UPC from the apples on his fork. We also ordered a side of meatballs which only there was only 2 and they weren't even that great and were gray. Very disappointed glad we like the french fries or we would have totally had nothing to eat at all... We were 1st timers and last timers. It's sad that they would even serve anybody anything like we got tonight. Buyer beware. read more

Sfizio Pizza - Can't even take the UPC off the food before cutting it up... - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

See all

This pizza place is a super convenient location right on route 206 in Bordentown. They make some unique speciality pizzas that you can't get just anywhere. Sfizio "On a Whim" is the perfect place to go when everyone in your family wants something different. I've tried the gourmet pizza with arugula, prosciutto, and mozzarella. This was exactly what I was craving and really hit the spot. They also have so many "On a Whim" appetizer options like Macaroni and cheese balls, jalapeño poppers, cheesesteak bites, and taco sliders. There is a sampler option where you can pick four apps to try out, which seems perfect for a group. The inside wasn't too crowded when I went to pick up our pizza, so I think they mostly do take out and delivery! read more

Was in town and craving pizza. Stopped here and was not disappointed. Chicken bacon ranch pizza was delicious. Friendly staff and very clean. Will definitely be back read more

Sfizio Pizza - Chicken bacon ranch....so good - Pizza Near Me - Bordentown, New Jersey

I had great hopes for this place seeing only a few reviews, but most were raving about how good the food was. I was also happy to see one $ sign...... In short, we should have gone to WaWa. Worst pizza I've ever had. Two personal pizzas, buffalo and arugula mozzarella prosciutto, two sodas and an order of curly fries. $39 and some change. Not one dollar sign. Curly fries were great but that's not why we came. My pizza had cold mozzarella the pizza wasn't even hot, and I could not taste the prosciutto at all. My wife's buffalo chicken pizza, well that's why WaWa she commented that WaWa has a better tasting buffalo wrap that the pizza she had. My wife really wanted to go to Mannino's, I should have listened. There is a possibility I am bias but I enjoy good food, and this was not good. We won't be back and will warn our friends read more

They have THE BEST Stromboli! and if you order a large, you will definitely have enough left over for later ... or enough to share with 1-2 more people. Their cheesesteaks are really good, especially with a side of sweet potato fries! I also LOVE the Mint Truffle! Also, the delivery men are very friendly + polite, and they always arrive within a decent time frame after placing your order. read more

Person at the counter spit on me. Then called me a stupid armadillo and said I had a big nose.

Ehhhhh.... not bad, not great. Edible. Order has been goofed up twice. Convenient. Timely. So so.

If I could give this establishment a ZERO, I would!! ABSOLUTELY the WORST wings I have EVER eaten. Ordered garlic parmigiana; crispy. They were floating in 1/4" of grease with ABSOLUTELY NO flavor at all!! My friend got a chicken parmigiana sandwich and said, it too, was the worst she had ever eaten... NO flavor at all!! I never write bad reviews thinking everyone has a bad day or two but this was HORRIBLE!! read more

Moved to the area a couple months ago and ended up ordering pizza a lot during those moving days. Discovered this place then and have continued to come back since. The staff is always super friendly and you can get a variety of speciality pizzas here. Love the thin crust! read more

The people are nice and polite. Place is nice and clean but the food... Horrible. Worst pizza ever. Went with the family and my 11 year old who would literally eat anything called the food terrible.. order a Mear lovers personal pie and it tasted like lunch room pizza with lunchables meat on it. Stay away. Not worth it. read more

We are a local business who ordered lunch for several people one day. The order that was sent was incorrect. I called to straighten out the bill and the person on the other end of the phone was VERY RUDE and asked "How much do you want to pay?" I said we wanted to pay for what we ordered. He got very frustrated and said "Keep the food!" Then he hung up on me. I called back and said we did not want FREE FOOD, and would be happy to pay for what we ordered. AGAIN, he hung up on me. A few weeks later, we called back to order again and were told that "they would not deliver to us." I feel like we were treated terribly. The only reason I called back was because I felt bad about the prior experience and did not want FREE FOOD. Truthfully, the food is not that special, just convenient for us to have it delivered. This IS NO WAY TO RUN A BUSINESS IN MY OPINION. The person who I spoke to was HOT-HEADED and UNREASONABLE. If this is the owner, do not support his business. If it was an employee - FIRE him. I would never call them again and I hope you don't either!!! read more

Worst pizza ever No flavor at all So disappointed, make me mad Money wasted for nothing Few items were missing( ham, mushrooms) read more

Our go to free delivery spot! Awesome food!! Great prices!! I highly recommend this place!!! We order from here every time we stay in bordentown!! It's totally worth every penny!! read more

Saw this place on my yep. Had 4 stars so I decided to try them. Bad idea first time pizza had no flavor. Ordered one of there signature pizza arugula fresh mozzarella and bruschetta didn't taste like anything (weird ). Try it again today but ordered the works bad idea again. Onions were like shoe strings and for some reason they put huge green peppers . It was only ok when I re-heated it and drowned it with hot sauce. Very disappointed plus veggies tasted old. Sorry but think dominos is better and I don't even like them. read more

This ain't just any old quick and ready to go pizza parlor.This place has something for everybody, whether you're gluten-free, vegan, or vegetarian or just want a savory meal - they will accommodate you! Nobody makes a Margherita or Sicilian pie better than they do in fact. Period. Forget your old Mario and Frank's, forget Palermo's, SFIZIO has got it going on. Not only that, the Lubrano family that runs this place are a great gang of chummy people. I'm a total food snob and I've been ordering from them since I've moved into town and tried just about everything locally and these are my main go-to guys. Explore their menu, y'all and you shall not be disappointed! read more

Went in not knowing what to expect as this was our first time. I'll sum it up in a nutshell: This is a solid little pizza place. I had Sicilian and my wife had a turkey hoagie. Both were excellent. One can argue how can you mess up either, but we've all had our share of lousy pizza and mediocre sandwiches, and that was not the case here. Prices were reasonable and the staff was friendly. We'll done Sfizio's!! Only knock is the parking situation. You have to be a bit of an automobile contortionist to navigate the tight lot. read more

Standard suburban pizza joint. Not much else to say. Food was decent and as expected. Prices reasonable. They have an expanded menu, which is a perk. read more

Ordered here a couple times and the food never disappoints! Their prices are great considering most stuff isn't just premade from an outside source and fried. (Try the fried Mac and cheese) They also have quick delivery! Def one of my favorite pizza places to order from in bordentown! read more

WOW!! Sfizio's has been open less than a month, and I am impressed! From ordering to pickup or delivery, the experience has been great. The food is DELICIOUS! The pizza is hot and fresh and you can taste the authenticity in every bite. Ordering is easy, the menu is great, and I can't wait to try everything! Best pizza I've had in a long while. The flatbreads are fantastic! Thanks for coming to our little community! read more

I've had it with this place honestly. They are closest pizza joint near me so I try to use them and be loyal but damn. They have recently forgotten many items, say they will bring them and don't. Say they will "credit my account" and haven't. Tonight I order a simple veal parm sandwich and a caesar salad. The sandwich itself wasn't bad, but barely any meat at all. It was all roll. The caesar was a joke. No romaine or nice lettuce. All crushed up iceberg, white lettuce with about 5 croutons and 3 sliced pieces of parmesan. I've given this place alot of chances, but seems to get worse everytime. I'm sure there are better places in Bordentown. Sorry Sfizio's... I'll be looking elsewhere. read more

Order way too much from here, but that's because the food is good! Tiramisu is very good and one of my favs. Highly recommended

Probably the best chicken Parm Pie I have ever had. Crust is perfect! What a hidden gem this place is. I hope they hang around for a while..... read more

Fabulous flatbread!!! I had the Mediterranean and subbed mushrooms for the sausage.... omg... delish!!! Flatbread was brushed with olive oil, thin and crispy filled with flavor! Go try one!!! read more

Long day at work made me want to grab a pizza and head to my hotel, rather than dine out. Came across Sfizio's Pizza and glad I did. Super friendly people and my BBQ chicken pizza was very tasty. Perfect choice to end a busy day. read more

2ND time here..still amazing. Consistency is key to success. My new favorite pizza place. Well done

I got three different kinds of pizza for the first time here on Friday. They were delicious! My whole family loved it. Best of all, they were quick and the prices are totally reasonable. We will definitely be returning very soon!! read more

One of the best local pizzarias with the better prices with food quantities. I eat in with my kids and take out and I know the quality and service will be good. read more

Ordered a large mushroom pizza, chicken parm and potato soup online. Everything arrived in less than 60 min. The food was excellent! Will definitely be ordering again! read more

Sfizio Pizza opened in early April in the old location of Renna's on US 206 near Rte. 545. We picked up a Salad Verde @ $8.50: "cucumbers, cherry tomatoes, avocado, spring mix, green apples" - very good and plentiful salad, all ingredients very fresh and tasty. Also one of their large gourmet pizzas @ $19.00, Bruschetta: arugula, fresh diced mixture of tomatoes, red onion, red pepper & kalamata olives. Crust was fine, not remarkable and toppings quite good. The place is quite clean, with 8 or so tables if you want to eat in. Staff is friendly. Our favorite pizza in Bordentown is Palermo's but we'll come back here too. We got some 15% and 10% coupons in the mail which take off a little more from these prices. read more

We got hungry on the way from philly to new york and decided to stop for pizza on a whim (haha...that's their tagline). We were pleasantly surprised at how amazing the pizza was! I was a little ambivalent about the storefront and location, but I shouldn't have been--their NY style pizza was delicious and a perfect way to satiate our hunger. read more

I decided to give this place a try, as the few other reviews were rather positive. Unfortunately I was unimpressed with the food. I ordered a Plain Pizza and a Chicken California sub, of which I found both to be underwhelming. The pizza was particularly greasy and compared to other places in the area (i.e. Palermos, Villa Manninos, Empire) was sub-par. Similarly, the chicken sandwich was also sub-par and lacked a good amount of chicken. Empire and Villa Manninos have much better subs. If I had to state a positive regarding Sfizio, the ease of ordering and delivery time were acceptable. read more

We've ordered the brooklyn margarita many,many times since Szifio first opened. Over the last couple of months the once sweet delicious tomatoes changed to salty, metal tasting mess. We called & complained and were assured the special margarita canned tomatoes are the same ones they've always used, from California. They were kind enough to make us another pizza and delivered it really fast. Unfortunately the 2nd Pizza was no different in taste. Sad. Tonight we decided to give Sfizio another try, found an ad that stated large Pizza, 20 wings and 2 liter soda for $25. When we called to place order, we mentioned the ad - the girl even said we can pick which soda when we pick When we picked up our order, we were told that is only special for 2/4/18. Our mistake for not seeing the "fine" print on the ad, but we mentioned that we wanted special offer when we called in the order-- they knew we were referring to this advertisement-- she should have corrected us then. We excepted to pay $25 & ended up charged $30 with no 2 liter soda. Very disappointed that order taker didn't make us aware of offer error that we mentioned when placing order. A bit dishonest, in my opinion. The pizza was dry, not enough tomato sauce cheese not savory and crust too thick. The wings were over cooked and dry....not enough mild sauce. Almost like jerky. Very disappointed with Szifio. Next time will stickwith Mario & Franks II and buy a DELICIOUS Pizza, 20 wings & 2 liter for $19.99. And if you don't have the $19.99 coupon they sell it to you for the special price anyway...bye bye Sfizio. read more

Tonight my girlfriend and I both ordered an appetizer sampler and it was absolutely horrible. We got 7 different options from the "whims" section of the menu and almost everything we got was inedible. We are not that picky and we eat at Empire and Anthony's all the time and I would suggest you go to one of those options. The pizza could be good but I don't think I will be going back to find out. read more