I've been a loyal Art's customer since it was owned by Art (the original building was so small you…read morehad to go outside to change your mind and the floor was on a tilt). The Gordon years were great as well. These new owners have finally turned me off. 3 times in the past month I've stopped for rye bread and all 3 times they've been out and have said they won't be making any more soon. Wouldn't you think if you sell out you'd put it on the schedule to make more. I also purchased a dozen chocolate chip cookies and discovered 2 were half pieces (essentially i got 11 cookies). They also seemed to quit carrying local products (i.e. maple syrup). Such a shame a local institution has declined so significantly.

Sorry folks. Wanted to say that Arts is the place. But. Went twice. First time. Cookie tasted off…read more Next time. The bread didn't have that fresh taste. Real dry

My first time having pepperoni balls, a food unique to Erie! I was skeptical, as I'm not a huge fan…read moreof WV-style pepperoni rolls. I was immediately won over, though: they're squishy in such a way that the dough absorbs the pepperoni grease just perfectly. Pepperoni bread is also pretty good but not as special as the balls.

As a lifetime Erie resident I'm not going to lie, I gave it an extra star for nostalgia. Like most…read morepeople said, they're not the friendliest bunch, but not necessarily rude. The bread is amazing. Cannolis, best in town. Pizza so good. Keep in mind, the earlier you go the better selection and quality. I mentioned being a lifetime resident and have enjoyed their food since I was a child. My grandfather used to go every weekend when I was growing up. As soon as they opened without fail. Without giving my age, it's been decades and their quality has been consistent. I'd definitely recommend it, but can see how some can be turned off by the experience.

They did our wedding cake and it was nothing short of stunning! Absolutely gorgeous, like something…read moreout of a magazine. And it wasn't just breathtaking, it was delicious too. Absolutely cannot recommend them enough!

Wendy and Mark did an amazing job with our wedding cake. It looked exactly as we had…read moreenvisioned--simple and classy, yet stunning! Each tier had a different flavor, and each one was absolutely delicious. The frosting was hands down the best part--light, tasty, and truly unique to anything else in the Erie area!

Sontheimer's Country Bakery is a family-owned and -operated business that opened in 1920…read more It sells baked goods such as breads (e.g., French, pumpernickel, rye, croissants, hamburger, and hotdog), desserts (e.g., turnovers, cheesecake, eclairs, cream puffs, brownies, ladylocks, jelly rolls, and cupcakes), cakes (e.g., devil's food chocolate, lady baltimore white, and white-chocolate), kukas (e.g., almond, apple, cinnamon, maple, pecan, and raspberry), pies (e.g., apple, blackberry, cherry, peach, and strawberry rhubarb), cookies (e.g., cherry-nut, lemon, oatmeal raisin, peanut butter, and pecan shortbread), danishes (e.g., apricot, cheese, and pineapple), sweet rolls (e.g., bear claw, cinnamon raisin, coconut, delmar, and honey almond), etcetera! My husband and I have been customers here two times. Here are my ratings for what we bought: Chocolate-chip cookies - 5 stars - These chocolate-chip cookies tasted very buttery and really good. My husband described them as "the best." We purchased these cookies during both of our visits. Cherry danish - 3 stars - My husband ate this danish, and he described it as "average." Someday we will have to return and try more baked goods! Please note that the website says that the bakery accepts only cash and checks.

I was in the area for work and someone brought sweets to share from Sontheimers Bakery! I have a…read morebit of a sweet tooth so I was excited for the sweet treats. Cookies and a variety of danishes were presented. I'm not much of a danish person so I tried a chocolate chip and peanut butter cookie. I thought both were just ok a little on the hard side for my liking. The peanut butter didn't have a rich flavor. I would try this bakery again in the future so I could try some of their other specialties

This place is first a bakery serving up beautifully well done items with a wide variety. Coffee…read morehowever, is pretty standard and clearly not their specialty. Overall, I feel this establishment is a nice addition to to the downtown Erie scene.

Very popular bakery that offers sweet and savory breakfast and lunch items and beautiful pastries…read morein the window. Over a few weeks, I tried their avocado toast, croissants, savory croissant, strawberry matcha cruffin, baklava, and berry cinnamon roll! It was all tasty, but make sure it's microwaved at home as they can get pretty firm. Service is quite kind and will bring out your dish to you when you're seated inside. It's a lively cafe with most people chatting and some working/studying.

We started with the chicken soup and it was super fabulous. Our daughter had the pizza rolls, we…read morealso tried them and they were really tasty. The super highlight was a carrot cake. I only regret we only bought one piece to share, if we knew it was that good we would've bought a whole cake. !!! the cake was moist and tasty, and the frosting was the very best we had ever tried on a carrot cake. It took us over five hours to get there, but on future trips, they can be sure we will see them again!! The young man that waited on us was very courteous and accommodating ! We told him that we were returning from St. Vincent's hospital and my husband was in the car. He even said we could drive right up to the porch. If that would help I thought that was very gracious. I hope they remember us when we come again. Joy, John and Kathyjoy

classic Erie location that everyone should visit , a staple in the community and loved by all, try…read morethe Cider, duh

Russ & Cheryl are the absolute sweetest! Their shop is adorable and baked goods are delicious…read more They welcomed us in with open arms, allowed us to taste some of their favorites and we left not only with scrumptious treats but also new friends! Whether an Erie local or visiting like us, be sure to stop by!

If you're looking for pastries and bakery items, this is the place to come. EVERYTIME I've been…read morehere, I've left super happy because it's just that good! I have no complaints or criticisms! Another must try in Erie!