This is where I go when I need something for a project at my cottage. I've been a customer for a…read morelong time, and they are always nice. I recognize some of the same people that have been helping me for years. This is a "real" hardware store where you can buy one (or a few) bolts, or that oddball plumbing part you simply must have to fix your leaky faucet. They go out of their way to answer your questions and help you solve your particular problem.

Wish there were more stores out there like this family owed and operated store they have everything…read moreyou need and will talk you though whatever they can i took a picture one time of something I was working on took it up there they knew just what i needed real awesome store i know alot of people that drive out of town for small things that they could have just got uptown just love this home town hardware i've been going there since I was a little kid and will continue to as long as there in this location thanks for the great one on one service

During Covid (12/23/20), my husband and I had to stop by the hardware to get some supplies for a…read morehome repair for grandparents that couldn't be put on hold. We've been into this hardware before and can generally find what we need. Prices are a bit above average and the staff is normally somewhat helpful. They have a sign on the door stating that face coverings are required, which was a relief as we have both battled and recovered from the virus. The 1 star is based on what we found in the store. After we had found most of what we needed, we counted several, mostly amish, wandering about chatting without masks on. One had the nerve to stand directly behind me hovering/coughing over my shoulder while we were trying to find the correct replacement part. Staff members WERE aware of the problem as they were even assisting the 'maskless' customers. This is unacceptable. Those of us who take precautions and want to stay healthy do not want to be exposed to those that can't even follow a county mandate. Upon checking out, I asked the younger dark haired girl about the mask rules and she basically rolled her eyes, shook her head and grunted something. Hopefully they get to experience the illness first hand so they can understand the importance of keeping themselves and their customers safe. If we need to run to the hardware for our elderly grandparents again, we will definitely go elsewhere. Just thankful that it was us and not them that walked into that virus nightmare.

This is a well stocked hometown store. They've got Stihl outdoor power equipment and a great grill…read moresection. The atmosphere is old timey hardware store. I bought a Traeger grill and they assembled and delivered the next day. Great service! Recommend Stickley hardware to anyone.

Been here twice at about 4:50 pm and they didn't let me in though they say there open till 5.read more

From the owner: Full line hardware store and building material supply serving Michiana since 1985. Offering: -…read moreLumber - Metal - Doors & Windows - Roofing & Siding - Overhead Doors - Exterior Decking - Siding - Shingles -Plumbing - Woodworker's Supply - Estimates/Prints - Truss - Vinyl - Power Tools - Etchwood - Paint - Home & Garden - Interior - Design Center - Delivery -Do it Best -Hardware - And More.

My dad loves this place, and it reminds me of my childhood, which is peculiar since I didn't grow…read moreup in Indiana and had no contact with Mennonites until I lived in Indiana as a grad student in 2001. I'm one of those dorks who adds goofs to IMDB. Most people add continuity issues, and I do too, but one of my IMDB-goof specialties is anachronisms. I just have an eye (and ear?) and a memory for phrases, speech patterns, and especially objects that are out of place in films and TV series set before the present, especially in the 1980s. Why am I bringing this up in a review of a hardware store in Shipshewana, Indiana? Why, because this place just reminds me of perusing a huge hardware store with my dad when I was a little kid and we were looking for supplies to build a doghouse for Buster (RIP), whom we hadn't acquired from the Downey pound yet. And further, when I walk around these aisles in 2023, nothing would be totally and completely out of place from those hardware-store visits in 1985. That is, although I'm sure there are objects and tools available here that were invented and patented long after 1985, there's very little that stands out as from the 1990s or 2000s or 2010s or 2020s. How cool is that? It's downright comforting, I tell you. Yes, the hardware is expensive. So what? Things used to be more expensive, relatively. And you know what? That was fine, because things being manufactured locally meant people had more money, because US manufacturing jobs used to pay well, so people could afford to buy well-made products at slightly higher prices, and doing so contributed to the local economy. All that cheapo crap you're buying from Walmart and Target just further enriches already obscenely wealthy people, and do you really need that many more T-shirts? Not that everything sold here is American made; but it does remind me of a much simpler and, yes, better time, at least economically. The people who work here are very friendly, and the selection of everything is ridiculous, especially when you consider how much smaller than a typical Home Depot it is. If you need it for your yard, garage, or farm, they probably have it here. If my parents lived closer to Indiana, I can guarantee you my dad would have bought many more things from here than he has the three or four times we've visited. If you ever find yourself in Northern Indiana with nothing to do, you should check out Yoder's Shipshewana Hardware, along with other businesses in the Yoder's empire (although Yoder is a fairly common surname among Anabaptists, so they might be owned by different Yoders, but those Yoders are all probably related not too far back).

First...and foremost the employees here make this store what it is…read more Excellent staff. Unfortunately, the owner...or the guy claiming to be is very disrespectful. Very. He sits in his office...overlooking the store...judging. Crazy? Continue to read. I bought a house in Shipshewana a year ago. It has required a ton of work. I have spent a lot of $$$$ in this store. I'm generally in there 2-4 times a week...sometimes several times a day. For a year...I have walked in...greeted people...they know me by name...grabbed a shopping cart...and a 20 cent Charleston chew. I joke with the cashier... "My shopping snack." Or... "I'll be back in a few!" Then...I shop. A lot. Then...I bring my purchases to the cashier...and my empty wrapper. I PAY FOR EVERYTHING...EVERY-TIME! This has been the routine for a year! Today...I picked up my special order...shopped...and ate a Charleston chew. As I was in the parking lot...almost to my car when the "owner" came out to chastise me and verbally assault me. I was so embarrassed and belittled. He said he wasn't accusing me of stealing the Charleston chew...but...there's a store policy about paying first. Okay. I can understand that. Not a problem. But why not just politely tell me...it's been a year!!! I said to him... "You realize I'm in this store every week?" He says... "Yea?" Not... T "Thank you for your loyalty." Just a dismissive..."Yea?" I'm a just a thief. That's fine. I would never chase a loyal customer out into the parking lot...never. If I had been asked politely.... "Can you pay for that before you shop?" Not a problem. Just not a hill to die on. Good luck yoders. You'll be successful because of your location and awesome employees. I pray that the owners heart is changed...and he will not judge people by assumptions. Or perhaps be less critical and more loving, kind. Sad face

Great place, LOCALLY owned, knowledgeable staff. Nice and helpful when you aren't exactly sure what…read moreyou need.

Everyone was very helpful! Andrea was especially helpful and easily led men through my issue. She…read moremade sure I was informed and had the correct information so i could complete my project.

More than a good hardware store. Joel and his employees are always welcoming and happy to help find…read morea product or offer help on a project.

Awful company!! Purchased two items from their E-bay site for a total of $7 which NEVER arrived…read more This company was absolutely NOT interested in making it right. They said they had a tracking # from USPS so tough luck for me. I assured them I was an honest person and suggested they check my E-bay profile so they could see my 100% Great Buyer status. Never dealt with such unconcerned people before. And never will again. They seem totally unconcerned about their reputation.

Ripoff place for propane. The will not charge by the gallon for tank refills and do not fill tanks…read moreto capacity. Go to Tractor Supply instead.]=

What a great store with great people. Friendly service and knowledgeable. Asked (Don?) I think…read morewas his name to help me just plug in a four way connector to motorhome as my knees make it impossible to kneel on the asphalt. He did it willingly and even helped me make sure my toe lights on my tow car were working properly. You have to shop here!

Truly the best hardware store around the Michiana area! They always have what I'm looking for. Top…read morenotch customer service! Staff is so friendly and helpful. Support local! These guys are amazing

From the owner: We specialize in Flint & Walling pumps, reconditioned pumps & pump repair. We are an authorized…read moreservice center and a local and online dealer for Saniflo uplifting toilets. We design and sell residential and commercial lawn irrigation systems. Hard to find items can be found at this local, hometown hardware store.

I went there to get a piece of lumber and some hinges. I arrived right before closing time. The…read morestaff was very helpful and friendly, with multiple people helping me find what I needed. I will definitely return when I need hardware or lumber. It looks like they had a great selection of tools and other items too. I wish I would've been able to stay longer to browse.

From the owner: Full line hardware store and building material supply serving Michiana since 1985. Offering: -…read moreLumber - Metal - Doors & Windows - Roofing & Siding - Overhead Doors - Exterior Decking - Siding - Shingles -Plumbing - Woodworker's Supply - Estimates/Prints - Truss - Vinyl - Power Tools - Etchwood - Paint - Home & Garden - Interior - Design Center - Delivery -Do it Best -Hardware - And More.