Great food and drinks outside patio is huge, Asher special is amazing pound of chunks and two…read moreorders of fries, ranch and your choice of sauce all in one pile

We ostes a retirement party in their back room! We served pizza and chicken chunks. The room was…read moreclean and well appointed with a private serving area, bar and lots of comfortable seating. Included were round tables which I particularly like for events. The food was excellent. The chicken chunks were all chucken, served with a variety of sauces and delicious! Pizza was great and kept warm in some nice warming tables. The server/bartender was attentive and did a nice job serving us all. Flexible with cash and credit card options. We were there in January but the outdoor venue looked very nice and I look forward to heading there this summer!

Great pizza, very clean dining area with super friendly staff. Generously built pizza. They have…read morewings that we will try next time. We will be back.

We like to support small business. This family run small business is a refreshing change from some…read morelocal chain store experiences. The people working here are truly kind and that makes a huge difference. The young man behind d the counter was courteous, kind and helpful. He offered to carry the pizzas to my car for me and although that was not necessary; it was a nice gesture. He did hold the door open for me and thank me for coming. The pizza was your average take out. I asked for light sauce which they did accommodate. It's nice to have a request honored. Toppings were adequate. The dill pickle pizza with ham was delicious cold the next day. The pepperoni, sausage and mushroom pizza was best hot out of the oven but reheated nicely in a pan on the stove. We love cold leftover pizza but this one was better reheated.

Food was amazing as well as service many good things this restaurant does well. Atmosphere is great…read morewith tvs,pool,darts and a comfortable feel

The kitchen staff knocked this pizza out of the park!!! They don't provide table service at this…read moreestablishment but that's fine, the kitchen staff always brings out the pizza, appetizers & are helpful and even bring extra plates when they are not busy. Had the pick 3 appetizer as well, enjoyed that it was out well before the pizza so we could snack on it as we were pretty hungry. Definitely took care of the kitchen in the tip! I can't really comment on the young lady bartender, she didn't really give friendly service when we came in & went up to get our drinks, told us several times rudely there was no table service. Yes, we acknowledged that when we walked in and weren't even there 30 seconds, live in the area and saw the signs. Just wrote it off to her having a bad day I guess (shrug), it was just odd as there were only about 8 customers there...all at the bar not sure why.

Last minute visit to see family. Everyplace was closed on Monday in this small town, but AJ's came…read moreto the rescue. Their pizza was hot a fresh. The service was great and they called to let me know my order was ready. Mostly a small to go place. Good place to save you in a food jam.

Everything was good. Delivery was earlier than we expected, pizza heavenly. The delivery guy was…read moregreat. But we didn't get his name.

The food was absolutely amazing and the wait staff were phenomenal. They were working short a…read moreserver and they were highly attentive and accurate. Recommend.

I've been there several times at all times of the year and they always seem to be busy..which is a…read moregood sign, I think. I really like their pizzas . I prefer them over any other in town. It can be a little noisy, but that is because people are there having a good time. Always had excellent service

We placed a delivery order for dinner today. I was not impressed and probably won't order again…read more Ordered a side salad and it wasn't fresh lettuce, a little wilted with brown pieces. The boneless chicken wings reminded me of a frozen bag of Walmart processed chicken meat. Was NOT real chicken. It also looked like they put the sauce in the bottom of the takeout container then dumped the wings on top. The pizza...the crust is really thick and wasn't very appealing. Family thought the pizza was ok so I increased my rating from 1 star to 2. Not sure how they have so many good reviews.

Ordered a pie with little to expectations as it's January in Marblehead. With that said, even…read moreduring busy season the local cuisine is suspect. I'm happy to report the medium pepperoni, banana peppers and onion was excellent anywhere. Pizza was fantastic. Crunchy crust, good sauce and little To no greasy. It's definitely the best pizza in the area. The women on my the phone was funny too. Great experience.

Have to have a Brick Oven Bistro pizza every time we are in or near Sandusky! Best service, food,…read moredrafts, and drinks in the area. The service is very family friendly-owned style, and the staff love working here-great indication of a top restaurant.

We enjoyed our meal, and note that the restaurant is busy. On a Thursday, we waited over 20 minutes…read morefor a table. Not sure if they take reservations. The waitress was really nice, and they have a very lengthy drink selection. I enjoyed the pizza and atmosphere. Portions are massive. You will have leftovers!

Food here is amazing!!!!!!!! Small little mom and pop shop, but the pizza is out of this world!…read moreSauce is tasty, crust is crisp, toppings out to the edges. Prices are great too. I would recommend this pizza place to anyone looking for a tasty meal.

A little pricey for pizza but great taste and awesome service. The subs are delicious and a very…read moregenerous amount of ingredients.

Very pleased with the new-to-me pizza spot at 5-14, I will most certainly be back. Wait wasn't bad,…read morefood was very good! Great cheese

Tasty. Clean. Courteous. Creative crusty creations. Popper pizza. Smokehouse pie. Pumpkin pie shake…read moreand most importantly Tofts soft serve used in all dairy treats. Vegan cheese is available to meet your needs. Intentional and innovative establishment in Smalltown Castalia =] Check it out for sure!!

After paddle boarding for 4 hours, my wife and I decided to stop in for a drink and a snack. The…read morestaff was very nice and Jim was awesome. Love the food and the service. Tacos are great. Enjoyed the food and the great view by the lake.

Just kinda of a blah kind of place. Yea it's on the water but there are plenty of bars on the water.read more