I was in Babylon, and the navigation app messed up badly when I tried to walk from a 1hr parking space to a main street, so I said the hell with it, and drove to Savers. I need large wooden picture frames. There were NONE. But I did find some books, a few gnomes, a vase, and some crystal glasses. I still intensely dislike the sticks on the carts, and the self-checkout. An older cashier was yakking with another woman, and her register was closed. I asked if there was someone else who could help. She told me, rudely, to use self-checkout. I said that I don't like it. She ordered another woman to help me, and that woman ordered someone ELSE. Well, at least she (the third one, younger) was pleasant. I wandered all around the store. It appears clean, and was organized. I accidentally found a Tory Burch black leather shoulder bag for $8.99, so naturally I bought it. Most of the bags were vinyl. The Burch needed conditioning and cleaning, but that's fine. It's very nice leather. Prices are okay. There were several sets of china, but nothing worth donating a set that I currently own to make space. I don't think that I would necessarily drive here again, unless I had to go to Babylon for something else. But who knows. Would have been four stars, but...rude cashiers and sticks on the carts. Book selection was pretty good, but more paperbacks than hardcover. read more

I had donated a lot of stuff from my house because we were selling it and moving to a smaller place. Accidentally some of the items that were donated were my grandmother's. I called the store and asked if there was any way I could get them back. The manager was quite rude and said no and hung up on me. He didn't make any effort to help me in anyway. I will not be donating any more stuff to your store now and in the future. read more

Overpriced and over used stuff. Tons of clothes. You could get lost in the clothing rackscfor days. You can hunt for a hidden treasure but you won't find it here. This is the land of one only of each item. Definitely skip Savers and shop at garage sales where you'll get better prices. read more

I love that there is a savers closer to me! Before this location opened up, the closest savers were a half an hr away farther into Suffolk. I always leave with a few things from here and I love it. The most I've spent was $50 on clothes. I love coming here and seeing what new things they've gotten read more

Savers - Thrift Stores Near Me - West Islip, New York

Would've given it 5 stars because I like this thrift store, the only downside is they don't have wifi and barely cell phone connection (we use Verizon), to see if you found the Holy Grail! That's half the fun of thrifting for me. Over time I've learned what name brands to look for, especially in jeans. They don't have a try on room, so you're able to return clothing I believe for 3 days after purchase? Not 100% sure. Service - everyone who works there is friendly, good selection in every category and the value is decent. They must have wifi and internet connection available to them because you can tell if you find a good brand if the price is inflated, donate and go on Tuesdays for 20-30% off. Over the year my family and I have found a few amazing deals at a few Savers. read more

Discovered this little gem after moving to the area looking for a place to donate my items. The store is well organized and clean. There are plenty of aproachable employees working the floor. Prices are fair definitely more affordable than Goodwill. They also give you a 20% off coupon if you donate. I also received a $3 off $10 for joining the Savers rewards program. I'm looking forward to more finds and to donating more items as I settle in to my new place. read more

Nothings labeled properly. You can't try clothing on and they don't allow you to use the restrooms. Walked out. No point

I had a wonderful experience here and wanted to recognize a few outstanding employees. Jason, who handles donations and helps test electronic items, is truly exceptional. He is always friendly, extremely polite, and goes out of his way to be helpful. His interpersonal skills really stand out and make every interaction pleasant and easy. Michael, front end manager, is also fantastic--welcoming, efficient, and always ready to assist with a positive attitude. Arlene, Fran, everyone!!! The store is kept very clean, very well organized, and very upbeat. Overall, the entire team is incredibly helpful and kind. The store always has excellent items for sale, including beautiful fabric, unique odds and ends, and some really exciting clothing finds. It's a great place to browse and shop, and the staff make the experience even better. Highly recommend! read more

Went there for the first time. Its huge, clean, organized, and there's room to walk around in the aisles. I found lots of great stuff for a middle of the week/afternoon. read more

Way overpriced as you can see by this product. It retails for 1.25 at the store, they are charging 2.49... But of course it's all donations so they get it for FREE. It's the cleanest savers since it's the NEWEST Also the staff is really great at this location so I'm giving it two stars , it would be a 1 without them. Either way they charge way too much. 25 dollars for a dented box of Legos. 25 for a small bag of Legos. Is this a thrift store or a collectibles reseller? Overall disappointed. read more

Savers - Retails at 1.25, they charge 2.49, they get it for free since everything in the store is DONATED. - Thrift Stores Near Me - West Islip, New York

Used stained and often times damaged prices that cost more than Walmart. These are donated items at retail prices which is absurd. You want smell clothes that have stains or holes and chipped and scratched used garbage donated come here ! read more

Started off as the best one around and slowly dwindled down. They have began to let people stand and wait for items to leave the distribution area and fight over it like animals. There's one guy with a mask that stands there all day long and snatches items right off the cart as the employees are pushing it out of the doorway. I have never in my life seen two grown individuals fight over a piece of glass until I went to this place. Savers needs to put an end to this it's disgusting. read more

Savers - Thrift Stores Near Me - West Islip, New York

The prices are good on home related items. The staff aren't overly friendly and if you need help, sometimes it seems like an inconvenience to them. There are a few very good staff members so I don't want to label the whole staff there though. The store is well stocked and well organized. read more

I'm confused by the low stars this thrift store is hands down the nicest I've been to on Long Island. There's a million people working there, it's clean, organized and doesn't even smell like a thrift store. 10/10 I got such cute stuff there. read more

Well I finally went to check out "SAVERS" first off prices suck and in many cases are actually at or above full retail for used stuff. Second they don't seem to have any open cash registers. Only employment deprival devices. There are local kids who need jobs. How about hire them and get rid of the employment deprival devices. And the whole place smells like a dusty old attic. Needless to say I'm never going back in there. read more

The new store is very clean, organized & has a nice selection of merchandise. Better than some of the other Savers on the Island. (We'll see how long that lasts.) That's the pros. Now for cons - the pricing seems to have followed in to this new location. Books, VHS Tapes, clothing, toys, art, etc. are overpriced. I have been going to different Savers for years. I could Reme a time when VHS tapes used to be .99¢, DVDS used to be $1.99, kids books used to be $1.29 no matter how big or small. Artwork used to be $5-$10. Now VHS tapes are $1.49-$3.49, DVDS are now $2.99 - $5.99 depending on which title. And kids books that are torn and ripped up now range from $1.49-$4.99. I will go down the street to the library and get books for .50¢-$1.00. DVDs for $1. Clothing is stained ripped and comparable to regular retail stores. Bric-a-brac section is plentiful but prices are a little high for a thrift store. Another thing I will say is that the parking lot is small! I'm not sure how it's going to do during senior Tuesdays as every Savers on the island during senior Tuesdays is packed! The resellers are getting a little much too. I partly blame them for prices being so high - the employees have caught on and are now pricing items that reflect eBay prices. Not everyone going in is a reseller. Some of us are collectors, some of us are a little tight on money at the moment. 3 stars. Wish I could give it more. I was extremely excited for this location but left a little bit disappointed. read more