We tried Tikka Masala for the first time as a party of 2 on a Friday night around 9pm. We chose…read morethis restaurant because they are on the inKind app which offers rewards that can be used at participating restaurants. There were 2 other tables when we entered and we were seated immediately and told to scan the QR code for the menu, which opened up to Toast Tab, which is not the ideal way to view a menu.
Within a minute, we were greeted by Louis (who handles the hospitality at Tikka Masala) and he asked if we wanted any drinks or were ready to order, but we needed a few minutes to look things over. He said to wave him over when we were ready, so I did and we decided to start with the Gunpowder Chicken appetizer medium spicy. He asked about entrees, but we told him we were still deciding.
After picking our entrees, I called him over again and he said, actually he would come back after our appetizer was dropped off. Shortly after, the appetizer came out and it looked great. A good portion size, nice presentation, and good spice level. We snapped a few photos, which caught the attention of Louis so he came over and encouraged us to enjoy the food and take lots of good photos for a review. I mentioned that we post on Yelp a lot, but he seemed concerned and said Google is much better as the community uses Google, so I let him know that we'd be happy to post to Google as well. He reminded us that his name is Louis and he handles the hospitality at Tikka Masala if we would like to mention him in our review.
As we neared the end of our appetizer, he came over for our main order. We chose Chicken 65 Biryani (spicy), Chicken Tikka Masala (mild), Chili Garlic Naan, Spicy Garlic Chutney, and a Mango Lassi. He read the order back, but did not mention the spice level on the Tikka, and I assumed that was because the default was mild, but it came out without any spice. Everything else sounded good, but we ended up with regular Chicken Biryani instead of Chicken 65. We were hungry and it was late, so didn't feel any need to correct this as we like both dishes equally. After all the dishes were dropped off, Louis reminded us to take lots of nice pictures for the review.
The Biryani portion was large and the spice level was on point. The Masala came in a large dish with lots of curry, but the amount of actual chicken was lackluster, so I did not feel the value in that dish at $21. Our usual Indian joint is $17 for chicken tikka masala and the amount of chicken is literally double and we always have leftovers. They did not have any Spicy Garlic Chutney, but Louis said Mango Chutney was available. We politely declined a couple times, but he urged us to try it, so said yes, and it was alright, but we wouldn't get it again. The Chili Garlic Naan is SPICY, so be warned! Literally stuffed with chili and will scorch you from the first bite! I was only able to handle one piece, as I usually stick with mild-medium spice.
As we finished our meals, Louis brought the check and reminded us each to leave a separate review on Google. We paid on inKind and took a few pictures of the place before heading for the door, where we were reminded again about the review. The inside is quite nice and clean with lots of seating at tables and booths and low-lighting.
Overall, the food was decent and we would consider trying some more dishes. Hopefully they can sort out the portion sizes as the appetizer and biryani were good, but the curry was small. Louis was an attentive and friendly server, but we could have went without all the review reminders. As I was writing this review, I heard a rustle in the bushes outside and I quickly went to the window where I thought I'd see Louis offering one final reminder, but it was just a pigeon.