Jim has been a professional in the Real Estate market on Martha's Vineyard. He has a wide variety…read moreof homes, commercial properties and rentals. He knows every part of the Island and has an extensive list of properties. I love that he has continued Bob Carroll's company. You'll never go wrong working with Jim. His office is a well known landmark on Main Street in Edgartown.

From the owner: All things real estate on Martha's Vineyard since 1954. Buying, selling, leasing, renting,…read moreresidential, commercial, land, houses for personal use or investments. Property management to winter care taking services as your home does not take care of itself when you are away.

Unprofessional. Crook. Unresponsive. You only get an answer when Skip Dostal needs something.read more

From the owner: Martha's Vineyard Real Estate has a well-deserved reputation for integrity, commitment and a strong…read moreworking knowledge of the island's real estate community. Unlike the larger agencies that often can treat a sale as just another transaction, our staff has chosen to keep the agency small in order to provide individual attention with each and every client and customer. Whether you are buying, selling or renting, our highly experienced professionals will make you feel comfortable as they guide you through the real estate process.

I had a truly disappointing experience with Edgartown Commons, specifically with the current…read moremanager, Julia. Our family has stayed here many times over the years, but after this recent interaction, we won't be coming back. We booked a stay for next year, received a confirmation email, and had a deposit withdrawn from our account -- only to have the deposit refunded days later without any communication whatsoever. When I called to find out what happened, Julia told me there was a "website issue" and that we never should've been able to book because next year's rates haven't been set yet. This directly contradicted the confirmation email, which clearly stated our rate was locked in. When I asked if they could honor the confirmed rate -- a basic standard in most reputable businesses -- Julia became defensive and irate. She told me, verbatim, that if I thought she was a terrible business owner, I probably shouldn't stay there. She was rude, condescending, and completely dismissive. Julia may claim the business has "integrity" and a long history on the island, but it's clear the current management does not reflect those values. This place might have had a good reputation in the past, but it's absolutely not the same under her leadership. A hospitality business with no regard for basic courtesy or professionalism is one to steer clear of.

Our first stay was July 2020-an unusual year b/c of COVID. Still we had a lovely time, location was…read morewonderful, unit was clean and big enough for 3 of us, plus felt homey. The unit was well stocked, everything was what we expected and more- easy to find. I can't say enough about centrally located it was to everything, we walked and biked from here to all. Great place for families or just as a getaway for 1!