great pizza - great service. Love the cozy dine-in option. best pizza in the area. we always stop for pizza on our way thru.

One of the best pizza parlors in the area. Great desserts also. Our go to is the meat lovers pie with extra cheese. It never disappoints. read more

We just called and picked up our pizzas, so I did not get any pics. It is definitely small inside, so I think takeout is their main attraction. It is cute inside but small. They have some seating inside and a few picnic tables outside. It is in the middle of a fork in the road, so parking is very minimal! There is a small lot nearby that you could park if needed. The pizza is delicious!! There were 6 of us, so we got 2 pizzas, one pepperoni, and one The Big A,both were fabulous with plenty of toppings! read more

Rusty’s Pizza And Pie - The Big A - Pizza Near Me - Cambridge, Vermont

See all

When I visit my parents' house in Underhill, this is the go to pizza place. Their pies are good, but it's their Key Lime Pie that's an unexpected treat! It is really good! I always have to get a few slices to go with the pizza order. The staff is friendly, and they have these tiny video games that are miniature versions of the arcade game staples that all the pizza places seemed to have when I was growing up. It makes the wait enjoyable. It's a tiny building, so most of their business is take out, but there are few smaller tables and a counter. Don't plan on eating here if you are claustrophobic! read more

Great stop for a slice, a beer or soda, and friendly conversation. We'll stop in again next time we're driving through. Highly recommend!

Great pizza and friendly service. Super busy takeout, because their food is great and prices are reasonable. Only 1 table and counter for eating in; some outside tables as well; we were lucky enough to get the table. Always have some tasty dessert specials as well. Highly recommend. read more

Rusty’s Pizza And Pie - Rusty's - Pizza Near Me - Cambridge, Vermont

We get food to go a couple times a month. Both the service and food are great! Especially love the maple ginger salad! Best pizza for miles.

Great pizza, great quality and ability to modify pizza to customer needs. The service is cordial and the new remodel is just an added benefit. read more

Pizza was pretty good. Thicker crust than we are used to, but the crust tasted great. Unexpectedly, when hubby came back to the condo with the pizza he also brought 2 of the pie of the day. Wow. Strawberry Blueberry Pie that was so thick and tasty that everyone needs to get it. Wow. The crust of the pie is perfect. Wish I took a picture for you. read more

Just did the fabulous ropes course nearby and I had three hungry kids. This place is adorable and the food is top notch. We got two large meatball wedges on soft delicious crunchy fresh rolls with big yummy meatballs and great sauce. And then one lovely calzone. Kids devoured it. Then got fresh baked multi berry pie and chocolate mousse for dessert. The ambiance is so nice with a long real wood counter and the folks who work there couldn't be nicer. Highly highly recommend for a nice quick and yummy lunch or dinner. read more

Rusty’s Pizza And Pie - Yummy fresh pie. - Pizza Near Me - Cambridge, Vermont

Good food!!!! Clean!!!!! Fast,quick!!!!! Decorative!!!!! Good vibe!!!!! Nice people!!!!! Would recommend!!!!!!

best pizza around and awesome staff , wonderful assortment of ingredients high quality well made

Most people would hit the accelerator when they see this place. It's in a 1920s building that is painted in Italian colors. There is a tiny parking lot that is barely large enough for four cars. If you ignore your gut feeling and stop for food, you will be rewarded for that decision. We have been there many times for their lasagna that is really good. Today, we ordered a pizza and both of us felt it deserved five stars. The crust was thin and very tasty. The tomato sauce had a nice balance of tomato and spices. All of the veggies on top were fresh and very tasty. We ordered the pizza and had it delivered to our car. Then we went across from the street and ate it in the church parking lot across the street. It was a very nice experience. We chose not to bring home any lasagna since we were many hours from home. read more

Good people. Good pizza. Highly recommend this place. Yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

I gave this rating only a 1-star because the owner was very unprofessional, as she was hollering at one of her cooks in front of myself, girlfriend and kids, using the f-bomb for a mistake that she had made on our ticket order. She was also quite rude when we had asked a legitimate question about a food menu item and she got offended for no good reason. The food was good, but I personally wouldn't go back simply because the owner couldn't seem to control her temper. I feel bad for her staff! read more

We love Angelinas! Let's be real, you're not gonna find some NY thin crust or Chicago deep dish around these parts that even comes close, but with the plethora of wood-fired thin crust options around, many of them delicious, Angelinas comes through with a solid standard pizza offering, nothing fancy. Haven't ventured too far outside pizza on the menu, so I can't speak to anything else, but definitely 2 thumbs up from this pizza loving household. read more

Stopped on our way home from the NEK. Order a large mushroom/half and pineapple ham/half. The crust is not thin but not to thick. The ingredients were fresh and the flavor was delicious. While paying I was eyeing the great looking cupcakes. I asked the owner (I think), who made the cupcakes. He said "My wife" and describe them in detail, so I bought two. The combo was banana & pineapple with a brown butter frosting. They were a "10". YUM!! The flavor was amazing. Well done wifey!! We will be stopping again. We love supporting our local businesses. read more

We've been here twice now on our way home from a day skiing at Smuggs. My husband officially says this is the best calzone he's had (he's had many). Don't let the small size fool you, he was stuffed after finishing this and was raving about it. We each had a blood orange IPA from Bent hill brewery, recommended by the man taking our order (possibly the owner?)... SO good. I had the tomato soup and grilled cheese... exceptional. I then had the key lime pie - generous portion, the most amazing crust and overall flavor and the fresh blueberries on top were a perfect addition. I was so surprised. It's a small place with one 4 top table and 8 bar seats. We went once with our kids and once the two of us - service was great both times. Awesome place to stop on the way home from skiing or we may have to take a special trip even outside of ski season. read more

Rusty’s Pizza And Pie - Pizza Near Me - Cambridge, Vermont

I eat allot of pizza. I can't say this was bad but it just wasn't my style. Very doughy crust. The crust was thick and chewy and not that much flavor. The sauce had a strong taste of herbs which isn't too bad but takes away from all the other tastes. The cheese was great. They add plenty of cheese and it's not oily at all. I don't think I will return read more

Amazing pizza at decent prices, friendly efficient staff, clean & cozy seating inside as well as out, great homemade desserts, & a bar to order a brew while you wait if you are taking it home. What's not to love? This is literally our go to place for when we don't feel like cooking. They make consistently delicious perfect pizza every time. We were big fans when it was Angelina's but even more so now with the new name & renovations. read more

$17 for a 15" pizza. It was just ok. It wasn't bad ... I'd say it was smaller than most and a little light on the toppings ... especially for the price. Very thin pepperoni didn't add much flavor. Really was expecting more based on reviews. read more

Hot, crusty and delicious pizza and warm, friendly and efficient service even though the place was super busy. We ate in the restaurant (one table and some bar stools) and my son loved it as he could play with the mini video games they had on the counter. Really satisfying dinner and a great place for kids!! read more

We stopped by here after a long road trip to New Hampshire! We got two calzones, some cheesy garlic bread and a strawberry and vanilla shake. Service was friendly and comfortable, not stiflingly uptight. Feels like home! The calzones were huge and filling, the milkshakes I enjoyed mine but my SO said it was too "milky" for him, the cheesy bread was hot and very cheesy! We will stop here again for sure! read more

Rusty’s Pizza And Pie - The view out the window! - Pizza Near Me - Cambridge, Vermont

BLTerrible! I just received the worst BLT I've ever had. It was made with bacon bits! Seriously? What happened to crispy strip of bacon in a BLT? Just like the bagged bits you buy at the grocery. There was probably a tablespoon of diced tomato and the same of lettuce. Huge blob of white bread with no substance inside. Never again! read more

Rusty’s Pizza And Pie - My BLTerrible! - Pizza Near Me - Cambridge, Vermont

I think of reviews with places that I travel to mostly but I feel the need to express my thoughts on this place in particular. I'm a local, which means if I'm ordering out then I get a few selections as far as variety. It's a place I frequent for myself and my kids- pizza is delicious if you prefer a thicker crust that is crunchy and soft; the pesto Mac n cheese is perfectly gooey with an amazing pesto, crumb topping; my go to has been the quiche and salad which is the perfect balance of savory and creamy- even better that it comes with a side salad (balsamic dressing always). I won't get started on the desserts but you won't get the full experience if you don't try at least one on the list! I'm grateful to have this place in my backyard and will continue to support them and their hard work to keep this gem in our community! read more

It was absolutely INCREDIBLE!! The staff were the sweetest people ever and the food was incredible! I came with my family and the place was perfect to sit and eat. We ordered vegetable and cheese pizza, garlic bread, and French fries, and I am not exaggerating when I say it was one of the best food I've had in a long time. Of of the staff members, Serena, was just absolutely incredible. It's heartwarming to see such an amazing place with such amazing people and it would be a big mistake if you didn't eat here on your trip to the great state of Vermont. Loved it so so much read more

If you're staying in the area, this a "must" for pizza!! We got a large bacon & pepperoni, a cookie, and cheesecake. Customer service was so nice!! I loved talking on the phone with the employee who took our order and he was equally as friendly in person. Clearly, this is a popular place at dinner time. Our pizza was good; our desserts were great. However, we are hardcore pizza critics :) regardless, this spot should satisfy your pizza needs! read more

We really didn't care for the pizza. Crust had more of a bread texture and sauce had too much of an herby flavor. Overall, the pizza was lackluster. read more

Excellent food and service. Everything I have ever ordered here I have loved. Great Spaghetti, steak & cheese subs and pizza. Will always be my go to for great food. read more

Preferred Pizza in the area. The pizza crust and sub rolls are fantastic. try the hot relish for the cold/Hot subs. might not be for people who hate spicey food, tasty for the rest of us! Steak Bomb subs are amazing as is the Meatball subs,and hamburgers are great. only complaint is the cost for extra meat in subs cost as much as buying an additional sub!! Will be back as often as I can. read more

Ordered a large onion and pepperoni pizza and a side of original wings on a recent trip to Smuggs. The wings weren't great and seemed to lack any real flavor. The pizza was OK, not the best and not the worst. Next time I'm in the area I'll look at other options for a pizza night. read more

A very cozy roadside Italian food and burger stand. I always get the spaghetti with meatballs. Comes with yummiest garlic bread. Cannolis are very good. Looking forward to trying pizza and fries. Very friendly, very small. read more

Ran into this place while antiquing around Smuggler's Notch. Great calzones, small and cozy atmosphere. read more

See all

Excellent small local spot to get a bite to eat. You really must try the Steak & Cheese Bomb. It is AMAZING!! And get the large, it's just a dollar more than the small but twice the size. So delicious. read more

Love this place! Never disappointed when I go there. If you love calzones try their "deep fried" calzone. It sounds odd but is so good! Staff is always friendly and they have the best prices around. The only thing I'd say is missing is they don't offer a buffalo chicken pizza, which has been one of my favorites in other restaurants. Still giving 5 stars for quality and price. read more

Rusty’s Pizza And Pie - Pizza Near Me - Cambridge, Vermont

We come here every Monday for half priced pizza since November 2015. Everyone's friendly for the most part and the food is pretty good. Cons: Dropping the ball on putting our ticket through and telling us it'll be out in a minute - then we watch you put our pizza in the oven and wait 15 min... Sometimes the staff talks loudly about their problems which is a negative atmosphere for the customer - time and a place for everything! read more

Glory be... ecstasy! Maybe the best calzone I've ever had. Right here in rural dairy land. They have 2 varieties - baked nicely crisp, and FRIED. Since the Weds nite special is $5 calzone I got both. Amazing! Glorious! Only bummer - no free refills on soda. I paid for two and called it rounding error on the calzone special. Oh, and yes - I did eat both calzones. The fried was unique - the dough seemed a tad sweet. The baked was extremely crispy and mmm! This may be pizza heaven on earth. read more

See all

My friend and I came here on a Tuesday night they had 5 dollar calzones!So yummy and the lady behind the counter was very friendly can't wait to try more things from here :) read more

Stopped here after reading great reviews on our way out of Smugg's. Read about the meatballs being homemade but wanted pizza. Asked if I could get a side of meatballs. They were able to accomodate us at .50 a meatball. Not bad! And they meatballs were really good! Had them as an appetizer. Then ordred a large half pepperoni pie. Crust was really good. Very light and airy. Sauce was just okay but had a good bit of cheese. Not NY style in any way but still pretty good. If in Smugg's again would probalby pick up a pie to go and a meatball sandwich. and with 2 soda's the bill was only 20.00! they also have homemade cheesecake and canolli's for cheap but we were too full to try them. They do only have a few small tables inside and you order at the counter. they do bring it to you but not full wait service. But still good. read more

We are so lucky to have this amazing pizza in our town. It's super delicious. Last year my (then) 2 year old quickly figured out this is where the "good" pizza comes from and every time we drive by she asks to stop. What can I say, she knows a good thing when she eats it! read more