They remodeled this candy store and it's so cute now. Cute atmosphere. Lots of candy options. They serve really good ice cream. read more

Rustic Candy Shop - Candy Stores Near Me - West Yellowstone, Montana

BUT.... This candy store/ice cream shop is PERMANENTLY closed. Don't be fooled by the new very cheesy candy store. The owner of the new place forced the generational, family owned candy store out & put this awful store in. No local will EVER support this business. Go to Ernie's for some of the former family's candy. The new candy store that took over this location is NOT associated with the former owners at all. read more

This is a must-stop destination if you're in the area. The candy store is charming, with affordable prices. It's clean, and the customer service is great. read more

See all

No complaints :) The interior was inviting: full of color and great presentations. The service was friendly and helpful. The fudge itself was great. It was creamy, had interesting flavors, and was very enjoyable. The fudge was also not too sweet which was nice. Overall a great experience! read more

Best candy shop in town with a small town feel. They roll and wrap their own salt water taffy in the store which could use just a tad more flavor but were soft and sweet. Great assortment of specialty candy and chocolate as well. In house Carmel's we're delicious. Staff was very friendly and helpful offering taffy samples to customers. Only street parking is available. read more

Terrific selection of in-house made fudge and candies, as well as tons of fam favorites. Be aware the standard ice cream waffle cone comes with four generous scoops--worth the price and delicious, Montana-classic ice cream, but also a lot post-dinner! read more

Rustic Candy Shop - Moose Moss and Cookies'n'Cream ice cream waffle cone. - Candy Stores Near Me - West Yellowstone, Montana

Cutest little candy store I ever did see! This was probably our favorite stop out of all the window shopping we did. The store owner is taking all COVID precautions, including everyone who walks in must put on plastic gloves and use tongs for collecting candy. Very well done. At the beginning of the store, there is a refrigerator full of fancy-shmancy sodas, like Raspberry Coke (delightful btw). Then you hit the taffy wall-- it's was so pretty with all the vibrant colors! Unfortunately, though the color was abundant, the flavors were not. They each lacked a punch of whatever flavor it claimed to be. Would like to see that improved before my next trip. After the taffy, it's the regular candy wall, then as you come around the corner, you hit the fudge. So many flavors of fudge! It'll be hard for you to pick just one. Last, is the chocolate: my favorite part. I took home dark choco pb cups, dark choco salted caramels, and dark choco creams. Each chocolate comes in milk or dark chocolate as well as sugar-free options. It was a pretty epic store and it was also attached to a gift shop of cute trinkets and shirts. read more

See all

On our last day we stopped by here to grab a huckleberry shake. The gentleman helping us wasn't mean by any means, but wasn't the friendliest. We weren't even acknowledged when entering the shop. I say this because EVERY other business we visited in Gardiner, YNP and West Yellowstone was very friendly and polite. While there I saw a sign that said they were closing. Maybe the not so friendly attitude has something to do with it? While the shake was yummy I probably wouldn't come back. There are plenty of other stores where I could grab a shake. read more

The fudge is my weakness and also the homemade candy plus it's easy to find right on Main Street- it's a small shop but it has everything I need; I think it's the only candy shop in town. read more

As the name suggests- I stopped at this cute candy shop on a whim after visiting the Wolf and Grizzly Discovery Center before heading back into Yellowstone. I was NOT disappointed. The atmosphere was cute, and cozy. The smell AMAZING. There was a man behind the counter freshly dipping "almond joys" in their chocolate coating. He was incredibly friendly and watching him was so fun! I got a dark chocolate seafoam, a dark chocolate huckleberry (truffle? I'm unsure of what the name was exactly) and one of his freshly made "almond joys." He also gave me a sample of something not yet named. The chocolate melted in my mouth, it was rich but not overtly sweet. I wish I had more opportunities to come in and support this shop! 12/10 would recommend. Thanks for a delicious midday treat! read more

Num nummy this place has the best taffy I think I have ever had. No really I thought it was the best if you got it in a beach city but I was rough. read more

We absolutely love this place! It is one of our favorite places to go in all of West Yellowstone!! They have the most amazing fudge! We go crazy on it whenever we go to West Yellowstone. They have the most awesome staff too. Katie Olsen read more

The fudge and taffy were good but the sanitation practices here were alarming. The guy who scooped our ice cream kept rubbing his face with his gloves and then touching the cones. The woman who rung us up was using the same gloves to handle fudge as the cash register. read more

Old-fashioned candy store. They make their own fudge which is absolutely amazing. They have several different varieties of fudge and you will face a difficult decision narrowing down your choices. They have at least 100 different choices of candy that they sell bulk. So you can purchase your candy by the pound. Is there a better way? I can easily mix-and-match 10,000 cal of sugar here. Service is always good and they always have samples out. So no commitment on your part, just come into the store try a sample. read more

Rustic Candy Shop - Look for the candy sign - Candy Stores Near Me - West Yellowstone, Montana

First and foremost the quality of their confections are amazing. We got their fudge, carmel apples, chocolates and much more. Everything we tried was amazing. What takes this chocolate shop to the next level is service. The owners went above and beyond to surprise my wife on our anniversary trip, she couldn't be happier. read more

Being on a diet, I knew that as soon as I entered this establishment bad things would happen. They did. Wonderfully bad things. Unfortunately, I was only able to sample a small portion of their products - the fudge - however I can say that it tastes, feels, and smells as fresh as can be. The huckleberry & cream fudge was great, although the white chocolate flavor was slightly overpowering the fruitiness of the huckleberry. I also tried the milk chocolate & raspberry swirl - totally delectable, but add more raspberry! This store has all the normal candies you would expect to find - laffy taffy, big hunk, sour patch....you get the idea. They also have the fudge selection, a decent selection of chocolate (both sugar free and regular), and taffy. I would come again read more

I love this place! It is so cute and charming, and the owner is so nice. The fudge is AMAZING. We got milk chocolate and maple. It is the best fudge I've had in years. I highly recommend stopping by here for treats when you are in West Yellowstone. They have old fashioned candy and also ice cream. read more

I love what when I walk in, the girls are right there behind the counter making taffy. My kids love this too! I also like the ability to mix and match random candy and pay by the pound. They have so many kinds to choose from! I also love their fudge! So good and so many flavors to choose from! However, it is a bit pricey, but I suppose all fudge is. There is also a really cute store attached with adorable home decor! Overall, a fun stop when you're in the area. read more

Cute shop with a good selection of sweets. Offers a wide variety of fudge including low sugar. Sugar free candy options. Great friendly service. read more

Rustic Candy Shop - Candy Stores Near Me - West Yellowstone, Montana

The candy, most especially the fudge is great, but bad service really takes it down. They advertise buy 1lb of fudge and get 1/4lb free for $15, but purposefully cut the pieces huge and then tell you "well it's already cut" very rudely when you ask how their 15 dollar special turned in to 23 bucks. I tried to further the conversation, but she blatantly ignored me, already had my card and swiped it and never looked at me or said another word. read more

Has a small collection of candy that you cant find in most places. The taffy is hand made amd excellent! I'm not a huge fudge fan but i very highly recommend their fudge. The huckleberry cream that we tried was amazing! As well as the huckleberry ice cream They also have diabetic safe options as well. The staff is also great! I highly recommend stopping here! We did, twice! read more

What a wonderful little place! Girls were making watermelon taffy when we walked in. Offered us each a piece to try. So yummy! But the big hit was their fudge! Wow! We tried 4 different kinds and each one was some of the best we've ever had. The man behind the counter offered several taste-tests before we purchased, and was funny and friendly to boot. He did not rush us, even though there was quite a line. Darling place! We hope to return! read more

Best caramel candy. The lady misunderstood and gave me double my order which was a blessing in disguise.

Fun place to visit on your way into Yellowstone. You can load up on a bag of treats for the long drive around the park.

Fun environment! It's an old-fashioned candy store where you can watch taffy being pulled while you shop. The candy assortment is a mix of current and retro; I found candy I loved as a child, including pop-rocks, astro-pops, and cherry sours. Their fudge is amazing and worth the cost! I also love their ice cream - be sure to ask for a free test taste! read more

Great store with friendly employees and AMAZING candy. The chocolates are good, the fudge is good but the real star to me was the taffy!! Soft and chewy and flavorful, the best taffy I've ever eaten. read more