Stopped after hiking and did it hit the spot! Their homemade ice cream flavors were quite…read moreextensive. The place was quaint in an old home with nice outdoor space. The milkshake was perfect. I had the brownie sundae which is something to die for!! Coming from Philly suburbs, the cost is so reasonable but the ice creams were so great. Our dog also had a pup ice.

Homemade ice cream that was delicious...what else do you really need? My almost 5 year old ordered…read morethe cookie monster ice cream and they even added candy cookie monster eyes to it! The service was fine ... the girls working the counter were all friendly. The ambiance is your typical ice cream shop. If you're in the area and looking for ice cream, look no further!

You know, it takes a lot of moxie to berate an ice cream parlor but some people just really love to…read moreact miserable and love to bring down others joy. This has been a longtime running decadent decadent homemade ice cream shoppe with a variety of flavors. It gets crowded easily, as it would be nifty if they had a fun, upbeat soundtrack playing or a few arcade games for children but the general ambience is so cozy and inviting already. You can't beat it on a sultry, summer evening!

I was actually pleasantly surprised by the ice cream. I wasn't sure what to expect when getting the…read moreice cream for one thing they don't allow you to taste the different flavors so for that, I was very skeptical but when I actually got the ice cream, I thought it tasted very good. It tasted very fresh very creamy. Specifically the mint one was into minty. It was just the right amount of mint and the chocolate one wasn't too sweet. The cherries actually provided a nice darkness that balanced out the chocolate. The chocolate itself had a decent amount of sweetness, but it wasn't overpowering so I felt like that was a nice balance. It definitely felt like a homemade fresh sort of ice cream and the cool part is at this place that the flavors end up changing I think every week so they have new flavors that they come out with so it's always a new experience. The only reason why he gave it four choices instead of five stars again because they don't provide that tasting service so that's just one thing that I thought that was kind of a miss.

It's Average for an ice cream shop. If your around town then yes stop in and have some. But I…read morewouldn't drive out of my way.

I will start by saying MOST ice cream places my girlfriend and I go to are unable to keep up with…read moredecent cross contamination policies (specifically for peanuts and tree nut allergies). It makes us limited to vanilla or chocolate soft serve which I am not knocking but there is only so much you can do with that. It immediately drops their value down to me no matter how good the ice cream might be. That is NOT the case with Fritz. In fact, it is quite the opposite. They handled themselves very well and my girlfriend was able to have her favorite, Cookies and Creme hard scooped ice cream. It was very rich and tasty! My tea berry was great as it always is and my dad's peach yogurt was also worth the stop. The service was quick and their commitment to making sure everyone can safely eat at their establishment meant a lot to us! No dessert treat is worth dying over.

Okay, so it's a long story on how I found myself seeking out Pecora's Creamery, which is a tiny…read morestore at the end of Pecora Road across from the old dairy. Inside is clean and quaint, with tasty breads, meats and cheeses from local farms. And while those are darn good- let's talk about the ice cream. This is the creamiest, most flavorful ice cream I have ever had in my life. No like seriously. This ice cream is small batch and it's AMAZING. I had the chocolate peanut butter egg (their Easter flavor), my husband had coffee, and my son had chocolate. Each was phenomenal in its own way. I don't know when I will be back in this area of Pennsylvania but if I'm anywhere remotely near, I will drive out of my way to have some more. Seriously folks, this ice cream is special.

The smoothest ice cream in a bucolic setting. The staff is friendly and the refrigerator cases are…read morefilled with a variety of products

Stopped by 3 days ago and had another amazing experience. Had a large "pumpkin pie arctic swirl"…read moreand it was to die for!!! Creamy pumpkin ice cream with big chunks of pumpkin pie mixed throughout, topped with whipped cream and sprinkled with cinnamon!! Yikes!

Their soft serve is magical, it's so damn tasty. I have to be careful. Get the coconut cream pie…read morearctic swirl and you won't be disappointed. Staff are friendly and courteous. Can't speak for ambiance it's a take out counter.

Do not go here expecting mix ins on a marble slate as their website lists, not only do they not…read morehave them they looked at us like we had ten heads when we asked. They had a number of flavors of ice cream but steer clear if you have a nut allergy as 9 of 20 flavors had some form of nuts in them. They were also out of hot fudge but it was close to closing time so I guess they get a pass for that. The staff was very nice about it but overall I wish I had gone to Jones Cones instead.

The people who work there are friendly and there is lots of choices of ice cream. They also have…read morefresh fruit and veggies for sell from local growers.

Needed a sweet treat. Ordered a small twist in a cup with chocolate sprinkles. Reasonably priced…read more Really good. Quick service. Loved the outdoor space.

Ice Shack is the perfect location for your soft serve and pretzel craving. With plenty of flavor…read moreoptions for both, you'll definitely want to come back. I enjoyed my soft serve vanilla with peanut buttercup and cinnamon & sugar pretzel. The pretzel has this amazing butter that works with the sweetness. We appreciate the sweet service and great pricing. Can't wait for my next visit before the season ends.

Found this place online and we had to make the 1+ hour drive to try it out. The kids were…read moredefinitely happy we did! The milkshakes are more of a sugary sweet work of art but the kids thoroughly enjoyed them! We (the adults) enjoyed browsing the huge array of candy from our childhood! The entire experience was great and the service was extremely friendly!

Bring your kids here and get them a super shake. It's very good. The people are nice, the place is…read morenice. The candy is great.

Perfect place to stop on the road! Best chocolate milkshake I've ever had, affordable prices,…read moreamazing views, and great service! Also ample places to sit outside and feed the goats!

Well, here I am at work waiting to get my trailer loaded, so I decided, why not use Uber Eats to…read moreget myself some ice cream? Luckily, the ice cream was from a local place. I was so excited to get this ice cream in Pennsylvania. My mouth started watering as if someone took a delicious peach pumpkin pie and set it right in front of my face--where I could smell all the peachy pumpkin and the crust, and feel the oozing heat coming right off of it. So that's the reason why I decided to get peach ice cream. Well, anyway, I ate two bites of this ice cream, and I suddenly got a headache. Now, this was no normal headache. I can definitely tell this was from the food now because this has happened to me a few times before. I know 100% it's the food. I don't recommend this ice cream based on the flavor, the feel, and of course, the headache that it gave me like a nagging wife--that's why I don't have one--or a husband who doesn't do anything, just complains all day, and watches football on Mondays, Thursdays, and Sundays. But I hope my review helps you pick where to get your ice cream next. If you like my reviews, check out my YouTube channel @brandenleebutler

Friendly and fun. Great service and great selection. Local owner…read more There is a large parking spot and outside tables to sit and eat. People also gathered around some of the cars and on the sidewalk in front of the restaurant. Flavor choices was vast - maybe 50 - with other options like frozen yogurt and ices and Milkshakes. They also serve hot dogs. It's well lit and easy to get to from Waverly, sayre, or Athens.

I ordered a large and a medium and they both came out the same size.... Why pay $5.00 when you can…read morepay $4.50 for the same thing...