I used Rentright for 10 years. They are a very professional operation starting with Michael Yarnes. He was excellent to work with, and his follow-through was impeccable. It's obvious his standards trickled down to his support staff as every single person I worked with was excellent. Shout out to Amanda, Sharon, Jessica, and Nichole. The only reason I'm not using their services today is because I've listed my properties for sale (July 2026). Otherwise, I would continue to use them for another 10 years. read more

This company is the worst I have ever seen! After spotlessly cleaning the place, they still kept the entire deposit. Never ever use them, there are way too many places to rent. Upon moving in, the unit needed to be cleaned and i It was left better than received. Definitely a scam operation! read more

Sharon is my hero, I spent months looking for a place in my budget and rent right was very patient with me and made an effort to get me a place i could afford to live. they are professional and always very clear communicators! read more

My husband and I tried for nearly three weeks to get in contact with someone so they could represent our rental. Each time, the receptionist said they would leave a note for the person who handles rentals to give us a call back as she "just stepped out", or was on a phone call, in a meeting, etc. No one ever called us back. Not sure what's going on, but we finally took the hint that they do not have time to manage our property. read more

Don't plan on your whole deposit coming back to you!! When we moved in the house was filthy. We had it professionally cleaned. The master shower leaked out into the bathroom the entire time we lived there. couldn't get it approved to be fixed so I bought caulking and cut out the old and recaulked the shower my self. settling cracks through out the entire home. When we moved out we had all the pin holes from pictures filled textured and painted the whole place landscaped and cleaned. The place was in way better shape then we got it and they still charged us $1500 for cleaning, painting, landscaping, and repairs. Bunch of crooks! Horrible company to work with! read more

Rent Right included a "nondisparagement" clause in the lease they wanted me to sign saying that I would not write a negative online review of them. This ended up being a dealbreaker for me so I never signed a lease with them. Mike the owner says that there was also a "nondisparagement" clause in the application that I made online and that I am still bound by that, but I can't verify since the online application system only showed the application agreement electronically, ephemerally, and I will never submit another application with them. When I noted to Mike that such clauses are illegal under federal law, his response was that law is complicated and his lawyer approved it so he doesn't see any problem. I printed out a copy of the FTC website on the Consumer Review Fairness Act where it clearly says "the Act makes it illegal for a company to use a contract provision that ... bars or restricts the ability of a person who is a party to that contract to review a company's products, services, or conduct". When I attempted to give this to my Rent Right representative, they seemed to already understand the contradiction between the federal law and their contracts, because they refused to even look at the FTC info I was trying to provide. That was when our deal fell apart; the application fees we paid were supposed to give 48 hours to make a decision, and I wanted to sleep on it before the 48 hours ended in the middle of the next day, but Rent Right said I had to make a decision in just a few hours or they will release the property to other people interested. There were other contradictions in what Rent Right said: During the first walkthrough, Rent Right said I could have visitors (yes plural) who park in the visitor parking. During the second walkthrough another Rent Right rep said that visitor parking requires a tag and this unit did not come with any tags so no visitors could park there. During the first walkthrough, we asked if we could add a third roommate without going through approval (subletting) and Rent Right said yes. When I later pointed out that the lease says approval is required, Rent Right said we would indeed need approval and could not sublet. They wanted me to sign a lease saying I had received the CC&R document, when they did not have that available. I had a dispute with my prior landlord who said I owed some charges that I didn't actually owe. When I initially explained the situation to Rent Right they agreed with me that I didn't owe those charges and that would not stop them from renting to me. But after I had paid the application fee, and even after they told me I was approved, they said they would not rent to me unless I paid those bogus charges to my previous landlord. Because we wanted the Rent Right unit so much, we decided to write a check for those charges (over $1000) just to get the Rent Right unit. I would still have that money if I hadn't gotten involved with Rent Right. read more

Rent Right Home Right - Non-Disparagement clause from Rent Right lease - Property Management Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Mostly okay experience. Easy if you have no other choice. Unfortunately, moving out will cost you with their way of inspections. If you don't plan on hanging anything on the walls and live alone to keep the place better than received.. you might be okay. Quality of service was actually great and staff was kind. Just disappointed on how much was charged, overall. Biggest advice, don't do your own repairs with this company or leave anything behind like dust or spackling pinholes. They'll charge you. read more

I am not one to usually write reviews but Rent Right definitely deserves a 5 star. I have been a tenant in one of their properties for 9 months now. We've had a few very minor maintenance issues that have all been solved quickly and efficiently. Tonight (4th of July) we came home at 11pm and our AC unit had stopped working while we were gone. I put in a maintenance request and within minutes got a text from Hunter and he offered to get us a unit in the morning. If we were to ever have an emergency that needed to be dealt with immediately, I know for a fact that someone would reach out to us within minutes to get us the help we need. This gives us peace of mind knowing that they always have our backs if an unexpected situation does occur. This company (especially Hunter) truly cares about their tenants and always go above and beyond to make sure we are happy and comfortable. I would confidently and proudly recommend Rent Right to anyone who is looking to rent in the Prescott area. To the owner/manager of Rent Right: Please recognize Hunter for his hard work and dedication to your clients. He has gone above and beyond on multiple occasions and deserves to be recognized. read more

Absolute scum. The properties are not kept up well and very dirty upon move-in. The move-out "inspections" are a complete joke and only serve to line RR's pockets with your security deposit funds. What kind of idiot pays someone $200 to clean an oven or $60 to "remove debris" (the "debris" was a single highlighter pen and a plastic cup accidentally left in a cabinet) plus a 10% "oversight fee"? They will also mail whatever is left of your security deposit on the latest day possible within the AZ law (14 business days) - not because it takes that long to process, but just because these people hold such a small amount of power within their own pathetic personal lives and this is the only way they can obtain that feeling. I hope their lives improve so that they can stop taking out these feelings of inferiority on good tenants. read more

We rented a small home in Chino Valley from them for one year. We kept the place up incredibly well, fixed home issues ourselves, bought all kinds of supplies to make sure the trees and lawns were kept watered and healthy (they were not when we moved in) and paid our rent on time every month. When we moved in we did not get a mailbox key for almost a month, had to clean a lot of garbage up under the porch and in the yard, but never complained. When we moved out and got the check for return of our deposit, they charged us $170 to clean the oven, $250 for debris removal and a 10% "oversight" fee on top. I expected some charges but this was ridiculous. read more

I haven't rented a home in a very long time so I was nervous about the $3,000 deposit I put down renting a home from Rent Right. Maintenance requests were handled promptly by this company, the payment portal was easy to use, and they even sent us and our kids birthday cards in the mail, hand signed by the staff. They kept some money for the landscaping in the backyard, which was absolutely necessary, but I would recommend this company. They have been friendly and easy to deal with and were very fair in what was returned out of our deposit. read more

Our first experience with a management company was the best! We have used them for 2 1/2 years and had the best experience. Very professional and great to work with all the time. Renters seemed happy with them also. Would recommend them every day! read more

I have been involved with property managers for many years, both as tenant and landlord. I recently finished my lease, renting a hose that was managed by Rent Right ( I bought a home). I have never dealt with a more competent, honest, and fair property manager. I recommend them highly. read more

Thank you Rent Right! We have been renters for 2 years now. Rent Right has been diligent in taking care of any repairs that have been needed. Their semi-annual property inspection also assures the owner his property is being well maintained. We are happy to be renting through them. read more

Even though we've been clients of Rent Right Property Management for several years, the prompt for this review came today when I learned that Michael Yarnes was the ONLY Prescott Property Manager present at the Prescott City Council meeting when a planned discussion took place that would affect ALL rental property owners in Prescott, not just those owners who employ Rent Right to manage their properties. We are the owners of 4 rentals in Prescott and are very happy with our choice to have Rent Right manage the rentals for us. We live in NJ so it's imperative to have a team of professionals that we can trust and rely on. We're confident and comfortable with the way Rent Right handles our rentals from vetting potential renters, maintaining contractual agreements, basic collection of rental income to the huge responsibility of routine as well as emergency building maintenance and ongoing renter relations they consistently go above and beyond. Communication is a key component for business relationships to remain successful and I can attest that the team members at Rent Right are quick to return texts, emails or phone calls and never seem to be to busy to answer questions or explain a situation and even make recommendations. Michael Yarnes, the owner of Rent Right and his team of professionals are trustworthy and set a standard of honesty and professionalism that many other property managers could aspire to. read more

I just cannot even begin to express my disappointment and overall disgust with this establishment. We have been renters for 6 years and have lived in three different properties during that time. This was our first experience with rent right and we have never been screwed over this badly. Our first rental company took a whole $100 out of our deposit, the second, a whopping $175. Seeing a trend here? Yeah, we take care of our stuff. Now here's where things get fun. We received our deposit back from rent right today, or what was left of it. They took off over $1,000 dollars!!!! Doesn't these seem a little fishy based off of our history? Yeah, I think so too. There are a few charges on there that I agree with, such as the yard. I don't want whine about how my mother in law was in the ICU out of state for over a month and nearly died, but she was and it was stressful and costly and the last thing on our minds were the weeds. We still managed to spend an entire 9 hour day cleaning this residence to make sure it was in tip top shape when we turned our keys in. Yet we have a charge for $400 for 8 hours of cleaning. Not only that, they charged us to clean the carpets when we moved and then again when we left. Total scam, based off of us having to pay when we moved in, shouldn't it be the new tenants responsibility to pay for that? I even seriously doubt that they are doing it that often. Guess that's where they make their money. They also charged us $95 for 2 filters, which are about $20 each at most. The funny part is we received a reminder to change our filters via email and responded that we had and then were still charged for it less than a month later. Please do not use this company, you probably work very hard for your money like I do, and will not appreciate being robbed of it. read more

Rent Right charged an undisclosed $100.00 "Hold Utillities Fee" (not in lease contract) in addition to the contract written 750.00 lease break fee. Renters beware! We left all Utillities on as required and still were billed. Good company I imagine, if you are an owner, bad if you're the renter. Thought this company would be more honest than the other local property management companies in Prescott. Not so sure at this point. Will update if I get a response. -EJ read more

Their customer service needs some work. Robin would give me no information regarding a specific property over the phone, informed me I had to view the property online then call back. Called back within 5 minutes and was then informed by Robin that the home had applications that were going to be approved. Rent Right should improve their quality of customer service, and attempt to avoid potential renters' time. read more

Great company to work for! Would recommend to anyone who needs to rent a property or have a property managed.

Another undeserved star since "0" isn't an option. Stay as far away from Michael Yarnes and Jamie Nixon as possible. Jamie now has a new PM company called Top Notch Property Management. RR took complete advantage of us last year. Knowing that we were in a desperate situation, they proceeded to rent our home on our behalf to a business specializing in rehabilitation of Sevetely Mentally Ill adults WITHOUT OUR KNOWLEDGE OR CONSENT. Stuck in a lease (which, by the way was drawn on the incorrect form for a commercial lease) with a tenant we would never have leased to (due to the amount of wear and tear 8+ adults would (and did) do to our home) as well as being completely exposed to massive personal liability we were forced to deal with the tenants directly after being let go conveniently by RR. When I reminded them that they had a fiduciary duty to protect our assets, they fired US! They routinely billed us for the same work, on multiple occasions when THEY TENANTS HADN'T EVEN MOVED IN YET, claiming the tenants had requested this work (which they hadn't). When I proved this, they refunded some--but not all--of the fraudulent charges. We are out almost $10,000 due to their choice of tenants and the damage they did to our home. If Rent Right's goal is to permanently destroy your view on being a landlord, well they really are Top Notch at that. Jamie had the personality of a honey badger. Michael it appears is just dishonest. STAY AWAY FROM ANYONE ASSOCIATED WITH RENT RIGHT OR TOP NOTCH REALTY. read more

Its been about a year since I moved out of the property I rented from RR, and to be honest I had finally just forgotten all of my frustrations with this company until Jamie Nixon requested to be my connection on LinkedIn and all of the terrible memories came flooding back from the nightmare experience we had with this horrible company. If there is a way for them to take your money and get away with it, believe me they will. I've never had problems with landlords before and they found every way possible to impose every imaginary fine they could. A lot of it felt like it bordered on the line of being illegal. If I could go back, I would have rather lived in a soaking wet cardboard box for a year than gone through dealing with this company ever again. If I could give them negative stars I would. read more

I have had nothing but great experiences with Rent Right, the owner Michael and Tony, who handles all repairs. Also, the inspections have always gone great. We just had a plumbing issue with the garbage disposal. Rich, my hubby, put a request in thru the portal on Monday. We got a call from Tony the next day letting us know that Franklin Plumbing would be calling us. They called the same day and made an appt for the very next day. We came home to a new garbage disposal and now I can run the dishwasher! (Running right now!) Thank you Michael for building a great business! Thank you Tony for being on top of our plumbing issue! Thanks for having Franklin Plumbing as your plumber! Great communication from both Tony and Mike at Franklin! Happy tenant! read more

The move in-process was quick and easy. A care package was left in the apartment with basic essentials, making move-in a little more special. All associates answer emails and calls quickly. All initial fees are laid out clearly and are easy to understand. As long as I remain a renter, I hope to keep doing business with Rent Right! read more

I was lucky enough to choose Rent Right as my management team when I lived in Prescott last year. It's truly a gamble when it comes to renting if you don't do your research on the company first. Rent Right was professional, timely, and always had my best interest at heart. Their maintenance team is top notch and there was never any issue they couldn't handle. I miss living in Prescott a lot and am thankful to have had a good experience in my rental while I was there. If I come back (which I hope I will!) then I'm only searching for properties with Rent Right! read more

We have used Rent Right for almost a year to manage our rental at the Prescott Country Club in Dewey, AZ. Our prior property management company went out of business and we had long term tenants. We have decided to sell the property and Rent Right was so very helpful while managing the property, helping us vacate the property and completing needed clean up and repairs. We live in California and knowing that we could count on them for help relieved a lot of stress. Matt, Lacey and Amanda answered all of our questions and made the process work for us. They are the very BEST. Thank you again. read more

They are the worst!! Horrible experience do not get back with you in timely manner. Waited 5 days just for them to say needed CO signer, but did not have one. We make 4 times the rent so we went to CMA property management next day after rent right denied us and got approved in less than 24 hours! read more

Easy to deal with. Saw a house up for rent called Rent Right to get some information on that house and explained to them, that we were from out of town and we needed to see the house that day.We met an agent at the house that day and we ended up renting it! Thank you Rent Right for such excellent customer service! read more

I only gave this place one star because I had to, the NO star option is not available!! Stay away from this rental company!!!! Jamie N could be the rudest person I have ever had to deal with on any level. We rent a place on Cortez in Prescott. After one week of moving in the entire apartment complex had to be sprayed for bedbugs because the apartments were infested! I had to go out and buy extra mattress and pillow cases to prevent bedbugs from getting into our beds! Our apartment also has roaches. When we asked for our place to be sprayed we were told they will only do outside. I'm now trying to get out of my lease because the bugs are so bad. Jamie has been nothing but rude in helping me get out of my lease for the place being so unsanitary. She has continued to speak to me in a very unprofessional manor. I'm also a landlord of many properties in the Phoenix area and have a real estate attorney on retainer that will be sending a letter to break our lease. I will also look up the owners of this property and let them know personally how horrible and unsanitary this apartment complex has been taken care of by this company. DO NOT RENT HERE!!! read more

I was looking for a place to rent honestly this was the worst experience I had was going threw them horrible at getting back to you very rude not helpful worst rental company I went through i do not suggest them to anyone who is looking for a place to rent. read more

This company took over our lease when our building sold and have been so wonderful and accommodating since day one. Robin has been my point of contact for all things and if she doesn't handle it personally she will get me in touch with the right person. She is an absolute delight! When our lease was almost up and we wanted to upgrade to a new place. We found another one through rent right and it was perfect! Robin stepped in and helped us secure it that same day and with how quickly places get scooped up here I don't have to tell you how huge of a help that was. We are officially moved in and couldn't be happier. Thank you Rent Right and Robin!!! read more

This is hands down the worst people to rent from in Arizona, I pay a lot of money to live in a "nice apartment" and it's horrible living conditions. No fire alarms, the AC unit is full of mold and makes the apartment smell and I become sick if I am in the apartment more than a few hours. Shower doesn't work, the apartment is infested with spiders, ants and ear wigs. The outside is not maintained... I have been fighting with rent right for over a year now and they have fixed absolutely nothing. The owners of rent right are extremely rude and virtually impossible to work with. DO NOT USE this company they will screw you over.... read more

I agree with Trisha... Jamie is by far the most rude person I've ever met. Several times during our lease they attempted to invade our privacy nose into everything we were doing. We paid our rent on time we took care of the place. They put a clause that we were responsible for keeping the yard up. Had no idea that this thing turned in the weeds everywhere and they charged us just $800 by the time we get out of there the total fees that they were $1876 they took from our deposit. This was a $3000 per month rental charges $90 to clean spots at FedEx trucks and UPS guys did we had expensive new cars that don't leak. They nitpick everything. Can't tell you the number of rude emails and conversations I had with Jamie do not do business with these people.We have been out of there for three months they just had the nerve to send me another bill for 85 bucks to replace lights that were run over by UPS trucks or whatever they were solar lights is just crazy that they think I'm actually going to pay that. Stay away from this company.....! read more

Jamie is a fraud! They stole our $2,000 security deposit and tried to justify it with a bunch of bogus charges after we moved out. Stay away from Rent Right. We left the house super clean and in perfect condition only to have Jamie and her team come up with absurd lies to try and justify stealing our security deposit. This is how small, unregulated property management companies make extra money folks! Jamie was very rude to us throughout the entire 1 year lease period as well. Even after taking video and pictures of the house left in perfect condition and returning the keys, she still had the nerve to steal our deposit. They will be nice to you so be careful of this small, shady company. Worst property management leasing experience I have ever had. Don't be fooled by Michael, the owner, Jamie also owns this company and after you move out they will come up with all kinds of cleaning, trash, hauling and other bogus fee's to ensure that you get little if any of your security deposit back! read more