I really enjoyed my lunch at Red Baron. I got 2 slices. The garlic sausage pizza was delicious. They make square pizzas. Good sauce & cheese Tasty ingredients. Especially the sausage and garlic. The owner was extremely friendly. I had a good conversation with him. The slices take 10-12 minutes since they are made to order, but that is not a bad thing. It is a very good thing to have hot and fresh food. Don't expect to walk in and get a slice in 2 minutes. Have a seat and enjoy the conversation. read more

See all

I always enjoy my visit heat! The staff is so friendly and you can tell they love what they do. The last time I visited I got my own small pizza (4 slices) with fries chicken, bacon, and sausage. A small pizza with only four slices doesn't sound like much. But this pizza filled me up with just two slices (and even that was pushing it)! If you decide to visit I recommend coming on Tuesday's to try their delicious broccoli and cheddar soup. read more

Red Baron Pizza - Menu (part) - Pizza Near Me - Fulton, New York

The pizza tasted like they used pre made dough from pillsbury and the wings were soggy.

Tradesmen beware: You don't have time to eat here. No, not even slices. They won't bother telling you it'll be 15 minutes for a slice either, just that they're made to order. Pretty on par for a town like Fulton though, absolute dog water. read more

worst pizza I have ever had in my life.!!! frozen dough canned sauce and expired cheese from Aldi. this resembled my experience. I believe I should have went to speedway....... service ok pizza was the size of a medium charged as much as a large. pepperoni was the only thing appetizin. if there was a no star rating that would have been my choice. read more

I love this place! We get delivery/takeout from here every Friday night. The chicken ceasar salad and the grilled chicken salad are the best. They are huge, and they are filled with the freshest ingredients. The subs are always piping hot and the staff is courteous. The owner is very generous and always does right by us if something is wrong with our order.(which hardly ever happens but when it does he replaces it for free and you keep the old one) I say this is the best in Fulton for pizza, wings, salads and subs. Keep up the good work guys! read more

Red Baron Pizza - Best grilled chicken salad in the area hands down! - Pizza Near Me - Fulton, New York

Beloved in Fulton as a longtime local fixture, as a product something that resembles a frozen mediocre pizza. Rednecks should stay out of the pizza business. read more

I ordered 15 mild chicken wings and they were nothing but grease and when I called to complain they told me that that's the amount of sauce that goes on the wings and there's nothing they can do about it and when put the manager on the phone she laughed at me and was absolutely rude the pizza was a veggie and it was uncooked and when I complained about that they told me I did not ask for it to be well done. read more

Snall gem in what would be a bland town. Glad co-workers ordered from here one day and offered to get me something. Usually order about once a week and food is consistently good, made to order. Staff is friendly. read more

Very small building. Slightly spendy prices. Very make your self at home kinda feel. 3 small two person tables. And a small bar that only fits four. Best pizza I have had in Fulton. We got a half cheese, half garlic. It was amazing. Cheese was thick. I think the crust is home made, but I am not sure. The price for the pizza could have been dropped a little, but other than that, it was pretty damn good! read more

Red Baron Pizza - sign for red baron pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fulton, New York

This is the best pizza in Fulton! The sauce is delish, the toppings and cheese are plentiful. Every time I come home to visit, we have to order pizza from here at least once. It may be pricier than other places around town, but it is totally worth it. Try it, you will not be disappointed!!! read more

Their wings are very good..... many choices..... Salads and sandwiches are OK.... Consistent food in Fulton.

Good pizza.The wings used to be my favorite but now they are terrible and the sauce is 90% grease that starts to harden once the air cools it. read more

I have read all the reviews and for the life of me I don't understand how anyone can say this is the best pizza in Fulton! The crust is a shell, it's not fresh dough but a pre-baked shell and for that reason I thought the pizza was horrible! The toppings were ok, the sauce and mozzarella was good but if you put all that stuff on a pre-baked shell then it is all just wasted! It's too bad because I watched the owner bust his butt to make and bake his pizzas, he's a hard working, friendly guy but that shell has to go! They were a little pricey and until they switch to fresh dough, I won't be going back. read more

Great customer service , the staff are all very friendly. The food is delicious! The subs and pizza are the best in the area!!!

Pizza is incredible, mozza sticks are delicious, pizza sub is the best! Definitely the best pizza in Fulton.

Ordered an antipasto got lettuce an 2 PIECES of meat 3 slices of tomato for 8.50 and 2.00 delivery change NEVER AGAIN

The pizza has a chewy thick crust and the toppings are great. I highly recommend this place for a sub or pizza! Yum

Tonight was the first time my husband and I ordered from Red Baron, we wanted to try someplace new. I generally do not complain, I just simply do not return if it is not good. BUT, IT WAS TERRIBLE! The bottom of the pizza was SOGGY and the center of the pizza was NOT COOKED THROUGH. We had several toppings on it that were ok but, the cheese was burnt. So we could not even continue cooking it in our oven because it would have burned the top further. I tried to put it in a pan to finish cooking but it was so soggy it just fell apart. Then we had 2 different kinds of wings and they were so overcooked they were hard and chewy. Looks like we will stick to our usual pizza place and not venture out again, this was a very expensive mistake! read more

Hands down, the best pizza in Fulton! It's a little pricier than the other available pizza options in town, but it's totally worth it!

I've only been ordering from here for a little over a year now but I highly recommend it. They have THE BEST WINGS and the ABSOLUTE BEST customer service. Doesn't matter who answers the phone or what time of day, always friendly and helpful. Delivery is quick and orders are correct. read more

I ordered two subs one cold and one hot from work for lunch after a hour I called to ask when the food would be delivered the man who answered the phone told me that it was going out the door now,then 15 minutes later the delivery girl called and said she was leaving now when the food came the cheeseburger sub was cold,probably will not order delivery from there again. It would have been nice of them to let me know it was going to be a while,and not send me a cold sub that should have been hot. read more

the pizza here is disgusting and expensive. beware it is not fresh homemade dough but some sort or parbaked shell they receive in the am!! the wings were greasy and not good either! worst 25 dollars I've ever spent the gas station has better pizza! read more