Service is wonderful. The menu is limited to prime rib on some days and filet mignon on others. The meal comes with a wedge salad, and sides. Potato and veggies. This might have been one of the best prime ribs I've ever had. It's a classic rustic vibe, the interior seems well made, it's built to last, and classy. Don't change a thing. The prices are really good. On the prime rib days I'd recommend getting the 16oz or bigger, it's a better cut of meat, less fat, and overall just better. I've been coming to this establishment for years, every time I'm in the area visiting family and friends we make a point to eat here and will continue to do so. read more

See all

Fantastic evening for dinner! Looking for a great steak house come here. It's a very cozy restaurant with an old style western feel to it. I got the 12oz prime rib cooked to medium rare, it was delicious. The meat was tender and flavorful! The service was amazing but wasn't bad. I'd definitely recommend this place and I will most certainly be coming back! read more

Quincys Steak & Spirits - Salad - Steakhouses Near Me - Monte Vista, Colorado

See all

Food is really good and great price. The menu is very simple... what size of steak and how do you want it cooked. It is served with a wedge of salad , the dressing is house dressing and is so good. Also served with a big loaded potato and bread. The service depends on the waitress. We've gotten one that was very attentive and one that was not. You do need a reservation, especially for a large group, and need to call the day before. They don't answer the phone before 4:00 and seating is limited. With our groups of 10-12. We were usually there for 2 hours. During our 4 week stay in Antonito, Co (45 minutes away), we usually eat here once a week. Sunday - Thursday is Filet Mignon (not sure it's a real filet mignon, but a good steak wrapped in bacon) Friday - Saturday is Prime Rib read more

Does no one in Monte Vista want to work? This establishment needs help. This evening we witnessed an amazing event. This restaurant which seats 80 people and was 3/4 full, had only 3 people working- a waitress and 2 cooks. Because of this, the wait for food was longer than usual, BUT THE WAITRESS DID A PHENOMENAL JOB of seating, serving, bartending , busing tables and seeing that everyone had a great meal. I hope she has tomorrow off because she is bone tired, I am sure. The food,by the way, was absolutely delicious and well worth the wait. read more

Wow! I haven't even had my filet morning and I am already inlove with this place! A great wedge salad and an amazing Ild Fashioned. The lady barkeep is super energetic and knows how to mix a great drink. I drove 933 miles from Cypress, TX today and I am drooling over some good dinner! Way to go Quincy! read more

Quincys Steak & Spirits - Steakhouses Near Me - Monte Vista, Colorado

I normally really like this restaurant. We went tonight with a table of 6. It was cold and snowy so it wasn't very busy. We saw the waitress three times. Once to get our drink order then the Dinner order and then to partially clean the table and the it was crickets! The steak was cold the baked potato was Luke warm. Keep in mind we're the only people in the restaurant. Quincy's you can do better! read more

We were a party of 6. Wait staff was well trained, drinks were excellent, food was served promptly and to our specifications. The price is right and we've been back. It's also very comfortable and pleasant. read more

You won't find a better deal for a good meal...pretty much anywhere! I don't know how they do it, but I got a 12 oz. bacon-wrapped filet mignon steak, with a salad wedge, and a loaded baked potato, for just $19.95! Wow! ...and you can get a smaller steak for less and up to a 15 oz steak for $22.95. Here's the deal. The ONLY thing on the menu Sunday-Thursday is filet mignon, and the ONLY thing on the menu Friday-Saturday is prime rib. That's all, plain and simple. I like it! We were there on a Monday at 6:30 PM and it was packed!! The other restaurant on the street was completely empty. Our server said during tourist season they are packed but not so much in the off-season. Beer and well drinks are also super cheap. Well drinks are only $3.25 and a call drink is $9.00. The filet mignon was cooked exactly as I ordered it. It wasn't the best I've ever had, but it was the best for the price I paid. My dad and I were both very pleased with our steaks. There were only three people working the entire place and they did a super job. You'll wait a bit for your food and drink, but it'll be worth it! Definitely bookmark this place for dinner if you're in the Monte Vista Area. read more

See all

The meal was ok, nothing special. We are all disappointed in the service provided. We felt that we were more of an inconvenience to the server. She never smiled or even said hi when she came to our table. She never even returned to the table to check on us or ask if we needed anything. Will not be returning and we are locals. read more

Terrific find in a small town. Filet was perfectly prepared, so delicious, even the baked potato tasted especially good. House ranch dressing is excellent. Mojito was delightfully minty and perfectly sweet. Cheesecake was scrumptious. Juliette served us, made the experience warm and welcoming. Highly recommended! read more

It was our first time to visit a Quincy's, nice atmosphere incredible service, we had the top sirloin, and to be honest in my four years of living in Colorado. It was the best steak I've had highly recommend. read more

Well it was 7:40 pm and me and my father and my sister wanted to give our money to this tiny business and they said they were closed yet it says on there website and walking in the door would not come here. read more

Although the menu is limited, the filet, baked potato and wedge salad were delicious! Filet was cooked exactly as ordered, the potato was locally farmed, and all was served efficiently and professionally. The restaurant is quite beautiful too. The only negative was a loud individual that arrived part way through our meal who definitely wasn't using his "inside voice"! read more

We were staying in Alamosa and looking for a place to eat that was unique and different. We read the reviews and decided to give Quincey's a try. What an absolutely amazing place!! We loved the charm of the building, but the food and drinks were also amazing!! The wedge salad was delicious. The dressing had us all trying to guess what type of dressing they used to make it so exceptional; after all, what can you do to make a wedge salad great? They really made it exceptional! Next was the drinks. We had 4 mixed drinks and two craft beers. They were all exceptional! Even the house Margaritas were really good!! We all had the filet (since we visited on a Tuesday, and that was our only option) and it was well-prepared and perfect. I cannot say enough about this restaurant. To make it even better, with 6 drinks and 4 filets, the ticket (with tip) was only $153.00!! Unbelievable!!! I wish we could visit more often!!! Don't pass up an option to try this great little gem of a restaurant if you are within 60 miles of Monta Vista CO!! read more

Quincys Steak & Spirits - Quincey's - Steakhouses Near Me - Monte Vista, Colorado

Yummy, very yummy and people not yummy but good service. And ambiance good too I think, I'm just giving 5 stars

Hidden Gem! My husband and I ordered the 9oz filets and they were amazing. Wedge salad had a unique dressing that we also enjoyed. The meals also came with bread and a baked potato. Overall super impressed and will definitely return next time we're in town. My only regret is not taking a picture of the meal to showcase the perfection. read more

An old school find. Fliet Mignon special,13.95! w/ baked potato, salad. Cocktails around 4$. Comfy chairs, good servers. A bit slow but worth it. read more

First date night in months. Partner and I ordered the exact same thing: same cut of meat. I should also add the restaurant has a 'limited menu' meaning they only serve one dish. That said, my partner received a beautifully seared THICK 12 oz cut of meat cooked perfectly 'medium rare'. I received a fatty, 8 oz, BLOOD RARE (did it even touch a flame for more than 6 secs?) piece of meat. The waitress forgot lemons for my water (I had to remind her), and brought my water with my partner's who's drink had arrived 5 mins earlier. Said partner also had to waive down waitress for my refills -- It's water... When the waitress brought my lemons, I also asked for extra salad dressing. Her response was 'Do you need anything else?' It was said in a not so nice manner. My partner is a White male. I am an African American woman. You connect the dots. read more

Great food and amazing prices. A must visit everything we come out to Fremont County.

This is the shining star of the entire San Luis Valley. If you find yourself within a 60 mile radius, make it a priority. The ranch/honey mustard blend is surprisingly amazing and the steaks are perfectly cooked. The horseradish completes the experience. Bravo, Quincy's!! read more

See all

2nd time I've eaten here and I just love the fact that there is one meal (basically) on the menu. Each time it's the 15 ounce filet for me. The salad is unique, but a change of pace. I rarely eat baked potatoes, but love the one here. Just fantastic people! Bravo to the kitchen! read more

Quincys Steak & Spirits - 15 oz filet (bacon wrapped), baked potato, and bread. - Steakhouses Near Me - Monte Vista, Colorado

Be warned. This review is in October 2023, but new ownership is coming in in November. Our visit was great. The restaurant is okay from the outside, but walk in and I found the Ambiance very appealing. It's beautiful and intimate and my wife and I felt very relaxed there. Our server Paris was TOP NOTCH, and why new ownership isn't offering any of the current staff positions is beyond me. I told Paris if the new owners don't beg her to stay, they are not being smart in their decision making already. The steaks were okay, but like other reviews, the consistency was lacking. My steak was fine, but my wife's was overcooked, and even though Paris had them remake it, it still was off. Overall, we did enjoy our experience, and we hope the staff there lands on their feet once they lose their jobs. read more

See all

This is the third time we've visited Quinceys and this will be the last! Med Rare steak looked and tasted more like it was cooked in the microwave but came out cold. I have not been impressed with this steak house! From the service to the food and water, this place I would not recommend ! Cold potato as well. For only having 1 item on the menu you would think they would have mastered their technique. read more

Quincys Steak & Spirits - Cold potato, Cold stake ! No bueno!!! - Steakhouses Near Me - Monte Vista, Colorado

This is an absolute must, we were passing thru and the food, atmosphere and service are always on point. read more

Quincys Steak & Spirits - The prime rib was absolutely delicious - Steakhouses Near Me - Monte Vista, Colorado

See all

Great food. Steaks cooked perfectly. Great staff. Fun ambiance--kind of Old West. Highly recommend this restaurant.

Service was not great. The steaks were beyond dry and tough! We all ordered medium rare, they came well done.

Prime Rib was cooked to perfection! This was my first meal in Colorado and it will certainly be tough to beat! read more

Quincys Steak & Spirits - Friday and Saturday - Prime Rib Dinner - Steakhouses Near Me - Monte Vista, Colorado

Very reasonable prices. Nice steak, baked potato, and salad. Very attentive wait staff. read more

Quincys Steak & Spirits - Beautiful old bar and restaurant - Steakhouses Near Me - Monte Vista, Colorado

Our front desk guy recommended this place, and given the town itself was super tiny, we decided to go with this place since the reviews were decent. The night we went was Prime Rib night and apparently, each night has a different meal, and only ONE meal. They have no menus for food or the bar. Pretty interesting concept, but I guess it works because the place was full when we walked in. We sat at the bar since it was empty. Food was pretty good and we were too stuffed for dessert. Price is reasonable too even though they said they raised it by a dollar due to the pandemic. Still worth it. read more

See all

Sometimes the best restaurants are tucked into small towns and this is one of those places. They serve just a couple of things and do it well. We had filet mignons and a wedge salad with wonderful homemade dressing. The venue is beautiful with stained glass, rich wood,and a cozy layout. The playlist (music) was awesome too-happy oldiesfrom60-70s. Staff was cheerful and attentive. We will be back. read more

Disappointing. Kindest description I can apply tonight. A week ago I checked out the food, service, bar and decided to get a group of friends together for a birthday dinner--about 10 of us have September or October b-days. That was a bad decision. Like everyone, they're understaffed. Tonight's service was glacially slow, especially bar service. The bar was also out of any rye whiskey. This was the case last week as well. Apparently nobody cares. I got bourbon as a substitute last week; tonight that was also out of stock. Drinks came a tray at a time with 15 minutes between trips. Food came a little more steadily once it started. All the comments I heard were about weak drinks (even my shot on the rocks had no flavor, and no effect, even though I hadn't eaten since 6:30 AM), half-baked potatoes and improperly done meat. My prime rib was far less tasteful than the same size and done-ness cut I got last week. I would advise against going as a group. One or two can eat at the bar, which is a better experience. Also, my group wanted to make a point about the service by shaving the tip. It was of course already added in. That's my last visit. It's said that new ownership takes effect next month. They should consider closing the place and trying to make their money back by selling the property and the fixtures and kitchen appliances. The star that I'm giving them reflects last week's experience (4) plus this week's (-3.5). read more

Unfortunately a bad experience. We had worked hard this week and wanted to celebrate with a nice steak and have not been to Quincy's in a while. We called at 16:30 and wanted to reserve a table for 6p. The hostess said they do not make reservations but would take my name and put me on the list... (?). Okay. We were able to get out of work early and get to the restaurant about 17:05 (5:05p). We told the hostess we were the ones who called in but were there now so please put us on the immediate waiting list. She motioned for us to wait outside and would be called. (Temps were about 90) Meanwhile others were walking in and while some came back out, many stayed in. The hostess came out every once in a while to ask for certain patrons - not us. After an hour - which was about 6p, I went back in to inquire and she said they had two different lists - ones for call ins and one for walk ins. Her "list" was scribbled and scratched through and in some areas, torn. I told her we should have been moved to "walk-in" and she said gruffly that's not how it works and we would probably be seated in the next 15 minutes. Meanwhile, customers who were seated at the bar just minutes after walking in were being served their "salad". After another 15 minutes of waiting we are finally seated and are attended. It was filet mignon night and I ordered the 9oz medium while my friend order the 6oz medium rare. The "salad" that I mentioned before was a iceberg lettuce wedge saturated in ranch dressing. I like ranch but wow. Their idea of a loaded baked potato is butter and sour cream and a pinch of cheese. I would have liked chives and bacon crisps. Disappointing. Finally, I get to cut into what I believe is the filet. It is not only tough but very well done and obviously dry. No moisture and little flavor. My friend's came out juicy and looked great. No issues on that side of the table. When the waitress came by to inquire how we were doing, I mentioned the steak was not exactly what I had ordered and showed her the cut. She asked what seemed rhetorical if I would like a new steak and I surprised myself and said, Yes". She seemed taken aback but said she would have to take my current cut back and I would have to wait another 30 minutes. By this time, we were passive and had nothing else to do. I knew others were waiting to be seated but in today's service industry, I wanted what I ordered - - a good tasty steak. However, the wait was minimal - only 7 minutes! Amazing! This filet was to my satisfaction and most of all, edible. However, I cannot honestly recommend this place to family or friends. There is a Japanese Steakhouse directly across the street with a better atmosphere, a friendly hostess and great food to include filet mignon. I don't blame the waitress. She was busy and doing the best she could. In my view, the business model is simple and effective. However, this restaurant would do better to fire the hostess or find someone who isn't the spawn of Seinfeld's "Soup Nazi and Joy Behar. AND simply take first come, first serve - no call aheads - no second list. Sorry Quincy's - you have to have much better to regain my business. I will not be recommending to anyone this is an establishment worth the visit. read more

There's only one thing on the menu, so if you don't want steak, don't come here. If you do want a reasonably priced steak, potato, and wedge salad, this is the place to go. The steak was nice and tender, the potato cooked to perfection, and cheesecake after, spot on. If I didn't live multiple states away, I would come here more than once a week. read more

Quincys Steak & Spirits - Sunday Thru Thursday - Filet Mignon Dinner - Steakhouses Near Me - Monte Vista, Colorado

See all

Came in with my old neighbor. He's a regular. If I lived there, I'd be a regular too. What size steak do you want and how do you want it cooked? We ate good that night. With prices being reasonable, of course you'd become a regular. Did I say the food was excellent? The drinks too? read more

See all

My sister-in-law had a bad steak, but I never have. It is a great atmosphere and good service.

We have been back at least six times since the previous review. Our steaks were cooked perfect every time. Great value for the money ..... Great service as well! read more

Ambiance is great, value is great. Mixed drinks are inexpensive and strong. However, the service and consistency of steaks are very inconsistent. Steaks are often undercooked, tough, and delivered to your table cold. Other times, steaks are hot, cooked to order, and tender. Last time I went with my family, we got seated and waited 45 minutes for service. No one ever came to our table. We left to eat at Eduardo's instead. I often stop in for cocktails in the afternoon before it gets busy. I'll stick to drinking there, but will rarely return for meal service. read more

This is the second time we made reservations for our family, no matter if you have reservations or Not they will sit people that are just walking in to accommodate them instead of theire reservations. We waited around an hour after our reservation time. Maybe we just need to try a different location, because the one in Monte vista is not it. read more

We had dinner while we were in Alamosa. They only do prime rib on Saturdays, but the meal was fine. The waitress could have been a little more friendly, but otherwise she did a good job. If we are the area again then we will definitely consider this restaurant again. read more

We had a reservation at 5:00 on a Sunday for a group of 6. They are somewhat limited on their setsing for groups and we arrived about 10 minutes early, so we had a 15 minute wait, which isn't bad. The drinks were good, the steak was very good (9oz) and the potato was very good also. Always a favorite. read more