My husband walked in & requested a cheese slice with beef as we were leaving the fall carnival. Pros: Fast Friendly Service Easy to get 1 slice Less than 10 bucks Cons: Little Beef read more

Primo Pizza - Cheese pizza- added beef (Husband's pizza) - Pizza Near Me - Clayton, North Carolina

The pizza was good, a little softer of an under carriage than i like but still good! Quick service and well priced.

Went here with the family for dinner. This place is disgustingly dirty. The dust on the cash register alone you could write in. The girls went to use the ladies room and there was no toilet paper. Never again at this place. read more

Great pizza, Wonderful People! Wonderful food at a good price. This will definitely be my go to spot from now on!

Was doing Uber eat deliveries and had to stop here. Pizza right out the oven smoking out the box. Smelt good had to come back with the family and try. I had a meat lovers calzone very meaty. And you can't beat 2 cheese slices and a drink for $6.99 read more

Well I don't give 1 stars ever but. First wings were great no complaints, my wife liked the pizza and i will say it was ok. Daughter ordered a Caesar wrap she bit in a found middle of chicken raw pink, the cheese sticks were cooked in very old oil, you could tell before tasting. The cheesecake I got had a piece of plastic wrapper in it. So yeah..Do what you will with that info. read more

Service was quick and nice, the food was burnt but not terrible (I had Pizza and the Knots). The price was reasonable. Definitely not the worst or best experience read more

Primo Pizza is our go to pizza joint in Clayton! It's a small hole in the wall place in downtown but don't let that steer you away. The pizza here is delicious and the garlic knots deserve an honorary mention! It's super garlicky mmmm! read more

I've been here a couple of times, it's truly a hidden gem. I've had the Ny pizza and the pepperoni, both were very good and flavorful. Def will be back. Thank you read more

Delicious pizza and the ranch is good too! Very affordable. Love the pepperoni and also chicken/bacon

One of the worse experiences in my life. The staff was not friendly and were all out of sorts when we came to pick up our order. Every customer was waiting an exceptionally long time. When we gave them our name to pick up, it seems like they didn't even make our order and just started. We wasted an hour of our time just to receive one of the worse pizzas I have ever experienced. They clearly rushed and gave us food which I would classify as unacceptable. Children in third world countries wouldn't even accept this garbage. Never again! read more

Primo Pizza - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Clayton, North Carolina

Good NY style pizza for NC, so far one of the best spots. Great staff, very friendly. I will visit the shop again when I'm in town.

Mediocre pizza. Not pizza to 'write home about'. Did not order anything except pizza. Good customer service. Parking is easy. Quick service.

I'm Clayton they have some of the best pizza. I think we eat here every week almost. The pepperoni pizza is delicious. It's a quick taste of back home (NJ) and it's good if we don't want to drive all the way to Raleigh. read more

Excellent calzone. I purchase my favorite (Philly calzone and add peppers ). It is amazing !! My children enjoy the club sub with chips. Enjoy whenever you are in Clayton. You will not be disappointed. read more

Once again they did it right...Awesome pizza! One of my favorites in the Clayton area.

Small little joint. Pizza was delicious! The crust was a thinner style and the marinara was yummy. Really wanted to get a 2nd order of knots! So garlicky!!! read more

Primo Pizza - Meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Clayton, North Carolina

See all

What a great little place! Stopped in today for a quick lunch which was basically a quick two slice and a half/half iced tea. Walking in I was quickly greeted, placed the order for less than $6.00!!! Place reminds me of a little hole in the wall dig one would find in South Philadelphia, Newark, NJ or pick a place in Brooklyn. The slices did not miss. Three finger fold, crisp bottom and the right amount of cheese. Ok you don't have the water down here but remember it does say New York "Style". Will be back for sure! read more

Primo Pizza - menus and tables in a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Clayton, North Carolina

Wasn't expecting much but we were totally surprised. Pizza was fresh and amazing. I'm a nyc pizza snob and this was as good as anything I've had. Thin crust perfectly cooked, the ratio of cheese to sauce was ideal. This is our go to place for pizza now. Prices are very reasonable read more

Ordered a calzone! It was soggy and flat! It was a Togo order so I didnt see it until i was home. Next time, if there is a next time, I'll double check before leaving. Wasnt even edible! read more

See all

Lord never again. One word, roach. We ordered a large pie to go. We opened the box and there was a live roach on our pizza. Their solution? They'll make us another pie. Needless to say, we asked for a refund and have never returned. read more

I do not normally write reviews but I feel strongly enough to share my experience this time. I ordered 3 Stromboli and a pizza and expected the bill to be about $30 to $35. Instead, I was hit with a total of almost $50. When I said that was not in total on the website, I was told that it was not their site. Oddly, it listed their number, which is how I called the order in in the first place. It also occurred to me that no total for my order was given. This is not how I conduct myself in business, and I will not do business with companies that are ok with this. Order if you must, just be prepared for a surprize. read more

Pizza is decent, but the operation is bad. Paid an extreme price for one pizza and it's already been 1 1/2 hour wait! When I called the person on the phone made me wait over 5 minutes just to talk with him. Very poor customer service read more

Most disgusting pizza I've ever had. Under cooked. Cheese barely melted. Garlic knots burnt. First time customers and won't be back. We had 2 bites and had to throw it away: read more

I followed the NJ girls advice (Jen A) after her review. Although I have also relocated from NJ & had five other pizzas in Clayton within the last two months here, so far this place is the winner. We ordered an 18" pizza to have there with a spinach & mushroom calzone this evening. The calzone was really tasty as it was cooked to perfection & topped with garlic and oil. So it was like a garlic knot ( where I come from) stuffed . The only downfall was minimal, I mean minimal ricotta cheese, maybe 1/2-3/4 for my calzone which I must say disappointed me (see pic). The pizza was a wee bit salty which may be in the sauce. Now to be fair I do not salt really anything so take my comment in stride. I like my pizza thin & crispy but forgot to relay that when I ordered. However, the pizza was cooked right, tasty & very good for area. With 2 Soda's from fountain cost 23 beans. It is a Pizza place with booths & tables so dress is not an issue . I will go back & try the pizza thin & crispy! I was surprised not to see any menus around so I took pic of black board. I would not drive out of my way for the pizza, but if your here I think you would enjoy it. read more

See all

We ordered our pizza well done, it came barely cooked with raw dough in the center. We are a garlic loving family, we put garlic in everything. Oh my garlic...the penne Alfredo sauce was over powered by garlic, and the consistency of water. We also ordered the garlic cheese bread, it was inedible, because of the amount of garlic on it...it had so much garlic it burnt my mouth. I would definitely not order from them again. I wish I could give 0 stars, what a waste of money. read more

Primo Pizza - Barely cooked, raw dough in the middle. - Pizza Near Me - Clayton, North Carolina

I would give less stars. They don't know how to make a white sauce pizza when asked for it. struck out 3 times and then when they still got it wrong wouldn't give a refund or the right pizza. read more

A hole in the wall kind of place. Pits out a great pizza and the folks have all been nice. Pizza time is 15-20 minutes usually. Been going for years now and have had only one issue with one of our pizza. They replaced my order quickly and easily. Can't speak for the rest of the menu as I have not had anything but the pizzas read more

My husband and I just moved to the Clayton area. We have gotten pizza here three times already and it is absolutely delicious. However today I called to place an order for delivery and whoever answered the phone answered can you hold on a minute and I was on hold for over four minutes. I hung up and called again and the same man answered the phone and said hold on again. I waited and hung up and called back and he said the same thing. No hello or thanks for calling just hold on! I got mad because you don't answer a professional business where customers pay money for your food by saying hold on rudely! I asked for his name he refused to give me his name I asked for a manager he said that nobody would want to talk to me. He said if I wasn't going to place an order then he was going to hang up the phone. He hung up on me and I called back and requested to speak to a manager and he hung up on me again! I called back again and he yelled at me and said ma'am I don't have time for this right now! Then he said why are you so entitled!! I hope The manager sees this review and I would love to be contacted because this is unbelievable!!! I have never in my life been treated like this. This is not the way you should be treated by an employee who works in customer service and let alone takes orders over the phone and greets customers in such a horrendous way! He would not give me his name And said that I was weird for asking that but today is May 19th and I called at 5:40 PM in the afternoon. I don't care how good the food is! If this is how the manager allows his employees to treat customers like this then you've lost my business! read more

I am the pickiest of people when ordering out. The chicken alfredo pasta and cheese garlic bread was so so good! My son also enjoyed the meatballs. Would definitely recommend. read more

Primo needs GORDON RAMSEY!!!!! Pizza has no taste AT ALL. NO flavor in the dough!! & Sauceless!! Maybe if thy had sauce it wld add flavor!, My pizza was made wrong twice with the one item I DIDNT want with EXTRA!! Waist!! I don't throw away food but. It will be trashed!! If thr was a - 2STAR rating. Thy wld get that!! read more

Great NY pizza. I've had multiple pizza's here and they are great every time. The sub rolls here are what make each sub. Our go to subs would have to be the eggplant parmigiana and the Italian. The classic pepperoni pizza along with the vegetarian are our go to pies. read more

The pizza is good here but the prices are incorrect online by $2 plus for certain items. All they do is apologize that it's incorrect but don't change it. The staff isn't friendly the times I've been & my pizza crust is always burnt in places. I go because I don't always want the big chain store pizza but this is annoying. read more

We finally made it to Primo Pizza Friday night. They are located in downtown Clayton in the space formerly occupied by Lucky Chicken. They have about a dozen tables and it definitely has a old time pizzeria kinda vibe. For me, a take-out kinda place. The pizza was pretty good. Thin to medium crust, nice flavor to the sauce and they don't skimp on toppings. I'm not an authority on authentic NY style pizza but, I thought this was a pretty good pie. Service was friendly and efficient and our take out order was ready when promised. They have a pretty ambitious menu with most of the "Italian" standards. We'll definitely be back. read more

Go to spot for take out pizza. Always good and ready on time. The large is more than enough for a group of 4-5. Regular is good for the wife amd I and allows for leftovers. read more

Ordered dinner tonight 2 orders of bacon cheese fries - received 1 1 meatball sub with cheese and extra sauce - sub was bone dry, absolutely no sauce and over cooked meatballs Terrible. Quality has gone done progressively in the past 2-3 years. I try different days and times and it doesn't make a difference We won't be ordering from them anymore. read more

This is a small hole in the wall pizza, pasta place. The pizza as great and priced well. We will definitely be returning to try their various pastas and sandwiches! So happy to have tried this place out! read more

I ordered a pineapple slice with extra pineapple for myself and a pepperoni slice with extra pepperoni for my daughter and when we got it, it wasn't even heated. It was as if they just put cold pineapple and cold pepperoni on a slice and served it that way. And on top of that, the pineapple tasted old. I was very disappointed and had high expectations of the place since it had 4 stars. read more

Ordered a cheese pizza for the vegetarians in our office. Got it back to the office and there was pepperoni in the cuts.. and you could see the circles where they CLEARLY took pepperoni off of the pizza. When I called, the lady was rude stating that she wanted the pizza back, which we had already taken 1 slice out of. I drove the pizza back the restaurant, where she took it out of my hand, while I was trying to explain to her, she said "Whatever!" and walked away with the pizza to promptly THROW IT IN THE TRASH! She didnt even acknowledge me when she handed me the new pizza. This is the second time in two weeks our order has been wrong from Primo Pizza. We won't be going there again. read more

Visiting from Long Island, NY. Just had their regular slice and I must say this truly tastes like New York City pizza. Delish!