Our overall experience was great! The atmosphere, bar, drinks and overall feel were perfect! We…read moreall agreed that the food was good, but not to the level we thought it would be at. Someone had compared this place to Delmonico's in Madison and this is definitely not nearly close. The service was amazing as well!Again, the food was good and our overall experience was great!

We attended an event catered by Pogy's and the food and the entire staff are amazing. The food was…read morehot and delicious, served on time, and the staff are friendly and attentive to everyone's needs. If you need an event catered, be sure and call Pogy's first.

Very accommodating to our needs. Great deal that they are easy to work with. Price is reasonable…read moreand they are always on time for the Chicken Q

Absolutely phenomenal service! Andy, the owner, was always available throughout our entire planning…read moreprocess of the wedding. Even when our venue created problems only weeks out from our date, Andy did everything in his power to make everything go smooth, and he delivered on every single promise! The day of our wedding couldn't have been better! His entire set up was perfectly on time, and there were absolutely no worries throughout the delivery of appetizers and entrees. He even threw in kids meals for the little ones in attendance. I cannot write enough good things about his entire service from prep, set-up and the actual meal service. Oh! And the food was amazing too! I had both beef tips and chicken, and they were both delicious! Thank you Andy for everything you did for us!

I would strongly recommend not ever using a check, I've paid with checks several times they often…read moretake well over a month to get deposited. My most recent encounter and cause for this review is I ordered and paid for chicken on October 15 2025 and he deposited the check March 11 2026. Seriously if I ever buy from you again, I'm going to write on the check, This is not valid after 30 days.

Our first experiences with this business was abousolty disgusting. My eight year old sister was…read morewalking home from school on Mormon Coulee Road and when she turned the other way to walk on the empty parking lot (where they were parked on the corner.) They proceeded to use a bull horn to yell at her to "get off their property." They do not in fact own that area, they ask the owner to park their business on it and use it to make their sales. My father went to talk to them about this, they denied scaring my sister. . Although that is not the first time this has happened. I was going on my daily bike ride and my first time around they simply moved out of the way to allow me through while I thanked them for doing so. But once it started to rain I raced home, and as I approached them they did not move out of the way this time so I rode a far distance around them in the parking lot where I was then yelled and catcalled. They said "nice ass" and then told me to stay off their property once again. I am a 13 year old child writing this out because of how mortified I am. Something I have observed was they only yell at children when they are alone and not in groups. I know this because whenever I have walked past them In a group of my friends they did not say a word to us. Only when we are alone. I hope others see this and do not let the children experience what me and my family have.

This spot basically checks all the boxes: good, reasonably priced sandwiches, great service and…read moresuper cute vibes. The interior is well designed, and the outdoor seating is pleasant. We ordered the BLTT and prosciutto parma. Both were solid, but we preferred the BLTT. The sandwiches are well constructed -- would be good picnic sandwiches! I enjoyed the bread -- it has integrity without being too hard to bite through. The BLTT is an elevated BLT with turkey, and the basil mayo and saba (which I believe adds a sweetness) are a nice touch. I loved that they didn't skimp on the prosciutto in the prosciutto parma, and the sharp tanginess from the slaw was a nice contrast to the fatty prosciutto and ricotta -- though some bites were just a bit too acidic, making the BLTT our preference. All the ingredients tasted high quality and well thought out. The BLTT was $12 and the prosciutto parma was $13, which might be on the higher end for sandwiches but not unreasonable for a meal, especially considering how good the ingredients are, in my opinion. I'd definitely return to try their other options, too!

Second time here and it blew us away even more!…read more We have gotten the BLTT, Prosciutto de Parma, and the Spicy Italian. All were some of best sandwiches I've had. The BLTT was our favorite of the three, but all blew us away! Scallion potato salad is great too. I love that the meat is local and so much of their sauces and everything are homemade which we always appreciate. Service is always friendly and restaurant is always clean. Fun to browse their unique and local grocery items while you're waiting for your food. They also have some good Happy Hour deals! For special dietary needs: they have gluten free bread and you can make any sandwich into a salad (for keto, gf, etc).