Just. Wow!!! First off - the food here is AWESOME! The first thing you will notice is "a new menu" with lowered pricing (they say) - but beware the portions and up charges - they are brutal Opinion - A diminished serving size on all time favorite appetizers will NEVER draw repeat customers (no matter the cost saving) Again, the food and atmosphere is on point (for flavor and pizza offerings) - and customer service is great! - But man, if you order wrong , you can definitely walk away hungry... read more

The pizza was short on sauce and toppings. It's been a while since I was this disappointed with a pizza. It's not a thin pizza and yet it comes with 2 big bread sticks. Instead they should put a salad with it. Sooo much bread. The servers were all working very had and very helpful. The best thing about this restaurant was the good local beers they have on tap. read more

See all

Unsuspectingly delicious!! Pizza is crisp, full of flavors, not too thick, not too thin. House salad was perfect. And the playlist was legit. Passing through but will remember this spot if I'm ever back out west read more

A real local small business...ambience is clean, casual, lots of warm wood, and a real local feel. It was pretty empty in here on a recent Tuesday night...just two other tables and my lonesome self at a bar table...despite that service was real slow to start to get a menu and get my order taken, but staff was friendly otherwise. I was curious about "Broasted" Chicken...and it turns out to be really good fried chicken! Broasted Chicken is deep fried twice...once in a high pressure cooker, and another in a traditional deep fryer...the end result is a very moist juicy chicken with a delightful crunchy thick battered skin, delicious! I got a 3 piece with breast, thigh, and wing, which also came with fries. $14 for all of this seemed reasonable enough. read more

See all

Went for lunch, got sat quickly, server was excellent. Food was great. Lots of toppings and they were fresh!! Look forward to going again.

Excellent pizza & broasted chicken restaurant in a historic building in downtown Sheridan . 1 block from the famous Buffalo Bill Cody's Sheridan Inn Hotel. Pizza is above average. It doesn't taste like any of the chains, a good thing. The broasted chicken is amazing but takes like 30 minutes to cook, worth the wait. In the summer, the service can be slow because of the crowds. It is a pretty big restaurant. It's very loud in there if that matters to you. Breadsticks are also stellar. read more

Service and food are good but prices are crazy. $18 mozzarella sticks, $18 for 8 chicken wings. 2 other people there for lunch on a Friday should tell you something. Pricing yourselves out read more

Rolled in Sheridan Wyoming after a long day on the road from Yellowstone. Powder River Pizza was recommended by the tour bus driver Greg and our tour director Eileen. A short walk from our hotel and we were on our way. We were greeted by Bailey and told we could sit where we liked. Bailey provided menus and took our drink order right away. Drinks were served right away and our order taken. Our salad order came first ( perfect!) Grrens were fresh and crisp and the dressing was a nice compliment. Each of our party of 4 ordered personal sized pizzas and each was done to perfection. Crust was delicious, sauce was great, not too sweet or acidic. Cheese and individual toppings were tasty as well. Bailey was attentive to our needs with additional drinks and take out orders. I highly recommend this establishment if you want a friendly, clean and comfortable place for lunch or dinner. If you are in the Sheridan Wyoming area , stop in . You will not be disappointed. read more

Powder River Pizza - Business signage. - Pizza Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

Pizza is good. The small arcade is a nice touch and entertaining enough for my toddler while we wait for pizza. Enough options to keep us coming back. read more

Phenomenal pizza. Get the signature crust. It may be a bit soft but the doughiness is awesome. The service was also great. Recommend highly

Good pizza! Great service! Very welcoming and authentic. The pizza was especially good, but the breadsticks were my favorite!!

My experience started off at roughly 7:00pm on the 27th of January 2026. I entered the restaurant and was "greeted" by... one of the friendliest servers I have ever met. I sat at the bar and he was quick to help me out. I asked what his favorite pizza was. With no hesitation he said the popper. His confidence was to outstanding to not believe him. So, I ordered it.. and holy smokes. It was... delicious. It was perfectly cooked and the service was top notch! I got my bill.. and realized it was appropriately priced for what I ordered. So I gave this guy.. a pretty decent tip and told him to have a good night! People like him... Will have me coming back! I'd honestly give this place five stars out of one. read more

Powder River Pizza was one of the few places open when we went searching for noms last night, so +1 for the hours of operation (apparently the rest of the businesses in Sheridan, Story, Buffalo, etc., all close by 7 pm on a Tuesday night...?). Happy we stopped there, it was a solid choice. The woman who took our order was very accommodating and attentive to our specifications. (Humoring all our mods ) Many pizza places are lazy, using cheese to carry the entire pie. Since Powder River doesn't have vegan cheese, we ordered one of their specials (the Greek) without. It was good! Heavy-handed with the veggies . Aaaaaand their signature crust is friggin' delicious. Def recommend for any wandering vegan tourists like me who torture waitstaff with questions (thanks again!) and anyone just wanting to grub on pizza. read more

The service hasn't been good the last year with take out or dining in, but calling in a take out order is the WORST!!! They charge your card over the phone, then when you get there to pick up the order... your order NEVER EXISTED! Every time this has happened, I don't know if its operator, the company, or their computers that are to blame but it's always happens! A cherry to top off this experience.... either you hear employees talking c**p or get food that you didn't order OR they replace missing ingredients with whatever they want that's the same color! But that's only if the servers don't ignore you half way through the meal. Food is decent but the process isn't worth it if they can't get an order right-the greek comes with peppers now days instead of spinach. Good Luck! read more

Powder River Pizza - Didn't know bell peppers and spinach were the same vegetables! - Pizza Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

A great date night! This was a classic pizza and beer joint; we stopped in after working all day and they were playing both games for the Stanley Cup Playoffs (which immediately won my heart!). But the Sampler pizza where you can get 4 types of their unique pizzas was perfect! I was able to try the pizzas I wanted and didn't have to share with my boyfriend just because i wanted one bite of everything - hehe. The waitress was incredibly helpful and got all of our extra requests correctly and made very helpful suggestions to 2 out of towners! We had enough leftover for 2.5 more meals so it was definitely worth our money! I would recommend this to anyone, single or family that wants quality food for a great price! read more

See all

It's a relaxed pizza place with a good selection of local beers. The food is above average and the service has always been friendly.

Called and called and was placed on eternal hold for 6+ minutes and would call back and immediately placed on hold. Seemed they then took the phone off the hook as it rang busy after that. If this is how they treat paying customers before they even place an order, no thanks. read more

My favorite pizza in Sheridan for 2024! I absolutely love the crust, and the taco pizza. Sweet BBQ was really good too. My husband likes their meatball sub. The kids meal was generously sized. Great spot to bring family & kids. read more

Had an amazing experience today at PRP! My wife and I took our two year old twins to lunch after a play date looking for a quick bite to eat, and the staff delivered! Our server brought hi-chairs over right away, and was honest about a possible delay for food from the kitchen due to a 20+ person party that had ordered just before us. We got our food in less than 15 minutes, our server checked on us at least 5 times, and brought our check out before we had a chance to ask. The food was great, the service was better, and we will back very soon! read more

Ambiance is family oriented, attracts locals. Service to ask for beer and food was quick and friendly. If you're looking for a dive place to eat with good quality, this is a good local place. Parking on a Friday evening was limited. read more

See all

We came here for dinner on a Tuesday night and started the whole affair very confused - we came in through what we thought was the main door but there was no greeter, so we just found a table and sat down. Fortunately someone saw us and brought over menus, but that was the last person we saw for a while. We did notice that there is an area where you walk up to the register and order, but couldn't tell if that was for to-go only. Eventually, we had a waiter come over, but all that to say the setup/layout confused out of towners like us! The pizzas we ordered were good, their 14" size could easily feed a family, and the dough was fluffy and delicious. Only other drawback here was that they have 2 separate game areas for the kiddos, so excited kids were running back and forth around us all night asking their parents for quarters to play the games. So, expect a family atmosphere like an elevated Cici's. read more

Powder River Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

Happened upon this place on a Friday at lunch time while passing through town. We needed to charge our car to continue our trip. Nice open dining area, mid to low light, clean. Food was good - the jalapeño popper pizza was recommended to me by the waiter. It was yummy and would have hit the spot if I was craving something nice and greasy, but I wish I'd stuck with my gut and ordered the Thai. Husband and kids split a build your own Hawaiian pizza and we had 3-4 slices left over. They were a little understaffed, which we appreciated being explained to us by our server, although several times we noticed he would take orders/fill drinks for the table next to us and not ask how we were doing. My husband had to go find plates himself once pizza was served. We weren't in a rush so it was ok, and it seems like there was a cowgirl/horse convention in town that weekend which may have made the place a little busier than usual for a Friday lunch. Would return for sure just to give another try because the pizza was so good, but not if I was in a rush. read more

Powder River Pizza - Jalapeño Popper 8" - Pizza Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

See all

Pizza delivery to our RV no problem, but the pizza is pricy..$32.00 for a 14" cowboy pizza. It was good though.

Been here many times and this place is not some run of the mill pizza joint, not even close. Never had a meal here that wasn't GREAT and the service is really top knotch. Bailey is especially awesome and deserves, not only a trophy, but a shrine. Really a spectacularly great server. Julia is also worthy of the shrine! read more

Powder River Pizza - Chicken enchilada pizza, but ALL their pizzas are my my favs - Pizza Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

Best f***in pizza I have ever had. Waitress was really friendly, the perfect balance between not seeing her at all and seeing her too much. If you want a nice relaxing evening with some delicious pizza, try it out. 10/10 recommend, and I'll be coming here every time I'm in Sheridan. read more

The staff was super attentive to us! We were a group of 40+ (youth hockey). I know we're not anyone's favorite group of people. Our drink never got below 1/4... our food was out all together and in a timely manner! It was truly wonderful! Our waitress had AWESOME BLUE HAIR AND EYEBROWS! 11/4/23 She was magnificent! As a GM OF A CUSTOMER SERVICE VENUE, I would love to have her on my staff! I'm so sorry, I didn't get your name. We need more people like her in the service industry. Please treasure her. Your staff right now is stellar! Fun for the kids and easy to find. read more

It took FOREVER to get our pizza! The server was very nice and comped our wine. Not sure what was going on, but our server said he finally made our pizza himself. read more

Got the Thai chicken salad tonight for carry out. I've had this before and it was very good. The good points are the lettuce is good (I'm picky about that)...but otherwise what made it Thai? It came with a balsamic vinaigrette. It usually came with a Thai peanut sauce. I think cooking 101 suggests that balsamic vinaigrette is not "Thai". But after picking it up I wasn't going to drive all the way back. Also it was mostly lettuce. Not a lot of anything else. Huge pieces of onions and green peppers and not a lot of chicken. read more

Powder River Pizza - A bunch of lettuce - Pizza Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

Followed the Yelp reviews and totally agree! Great service! Food was yummy!!!! If driving thru stop by, a MUST!!!

The food is always delicious here. The pizza crust & combinations are great as well as the appetizers & good service. This is one of our go to places to eat when we visit Sheridan. read more

Called in a pickup order for dinner, staff was friendly but I did get put on hold as soon as I called with no hello first. Pizza was good but the sauce could use more flavor, they have a great selection of toppings including greens yum. Fried pickles are my fav they had great flavor but way to much batter. Definitely fulfilled our pizza need but there is room for improvement. The cheesecake was definitely a must and so yummy. Would give it another try if we are ever in the area again. read more

See all

Really good pizza and excellent local beer selection. This is a must for us when we come to town from Washington state. I love the Polynesian pizza as a favorite, but I've tried others and I feel ya can't go wrong. read more

I love the food here. The prices are ridiculous. I was angry when the online prices were incorrect. Joe, the manager on duty took the time to talk to me, and made it right. I'll give it a five star, but I don't understand their business plan with such high prices. Maybe an occasional date night, but you'll go broke eating here regularly. The price with a coupon is still very high. Still prop's to the employees for doing things right. Thanks Joe. read more

See all

This place was awesome. We've been on a 2 week vacation and eaten a lot of pizza and this was hands down the BEST!

PRP makes a pretty good pizza. We were traveling through and needed dinner. We decided to try take out (since they closed in 20 minutes). The website wasn't loading right so we had no idea what pizzas they had to offer. We ended up just ordering pepperoni, sausage and mushroom as our toppings on a thin crust dough. The crust was a little thicker around the edges than we expected or desired but it was good. The pizza was cooked though but a bit on the floppy side. Having said that, the taste was nice. The toppings, sauce and cheeses were flavorful. All said and done, we were glad we tried PRP. The only true negative was not being able to load the webpage to see what they had to offer. read more

Delicious pizza. We had a personal greek and a personal let'er buck pizza. Also had a delicious local, draft, amber ale (cannot remember the name). Great service. read more

Awesome pizza!! Many options. Great gluten free options as well. We were looking for a local non-chain restaurant while we were in town, not particularly looking for pizza, but decided to go here. It was awesome! Great choice. read more

First time here and love their ambiance and great Wyoming pride in their decor. Ice cold local beer and delicious pizza. Ava, thank you for your excellent service! read more

See all

We are not locals but we are here 1-3 times a year visiting family. We were excited about this place but is has let us down. Prices are always going up and food is declining. This last visit was the worst. Ordered for pickup the prices were $10 above their website said. The response to the discrepancy was "Oh, Sorry" We got pizza and the crust was thick look like it was pushing toppings to the middle. In the picture that is not raised crust there were at least two rolls on that almost solid bread. We also got an eight piece chicken meal. The chicken was good and so were the sides. But for an eight piece meal the sides were single servings. Get the chicken meal at Ridley's or Albertsons tastes the same at half the price. Food is good but not worth the price. read more

Powder River Pizza - Potato Salad, Macaroni Salad, Coleslaw - Pizza Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

See all

Great place for a delicious, custom made pizza! This is a stopover pizza and beer place, as we are heading to DFW.