Small "hole in the wall" pet shop that I've blown by thousands of times on the main road without even an after thought. Well I decided to stop in after stopping at the smoke shop that used to be next door and in search of some premium dog food for our dog. Boy was I shocked at not only at the selection of quality dog foods they had and prices but the customer service that I received. I can count on my hand the number of times I have stepped into a pet shop and received the kind of customer service I received during my visit at this shop. Customer service is top notch!! An employee helped me select the right food for my dog, even providing me samples to try before I committed to a large bag of dog food that my dog might not otherwise like. They have a surprisingly large selection of foods, treats and other goodies in a very small store front. This small shop gives new meaning to, "good things come in small packages." read more

Positively Pets - Pet Stores Near Me - New Windsor, New York

Best pet store in the area! They have everything you need at very competitive in prices!

I am a regular shopper of positively pets - my golden absolutely loves coming in here, she gets very spoiled. This store always has what im looking for. I mostly come for treats you cant find at big name stores like elk jerky and fairly sourced deer antlers. The associates are always willing to talk and help. Always a positive experience. read more

I've been meaning to write something great about this place for a while now. If you're looking for a pet food shop equivalent of a health food store instead of your run of the mill chains (think Nature's Pantry vs Petco) then this is the right spot for you. Positively Pets carries higher end/healthier brands for your pets for reasonable prices. For example we feed our dog Earthborn Hollistic, I still have yet to find that in A local Petco/Pet Smart. They've been carrying grain free dog and cat food since before it became popular to feed your pet grain free food What really sets them apart is the knowledge of the two guys that are usually working there. They are friendly, can answer literally anything (hope I'm not setting the bar too high for these guys) and are eager to help. On a recent trip I wanted to change the flavor of food (my dog seemed to be getting bored). They told me to try it out for a few days and if he didn't like it, I could bring it back and exchange it. Who does that? I thought that was awesome of them for sure. They also gave me some sample packs of different flavors to try too. Definitely a cool gesture They keep track of the pet food you buy just Incase you forget or a relative/friend has to go in and buy for you. Every 10th bag of large for is free too. Can't beat that Forget the chain/mega-mart pet stores, give these guys a look read more

I have two big dogs and this is where I buy all of their food, supplements and treats from. I know the owner really cares about pet health - it's evident from the types of food stocked here. There's also a great selection of dog accessories - again high quality. With two large dogs its nice to find decent options for them in collars, leashes, toys, dog beds and bowls. So much stuff nowadays is geared towards toy dogs but here I can find a selection of good things for my gals. The smoke shop next door moved out and now the store is expanded and its feels great! read more

If you are anywhere within a reasonable drive of Positively Pets, you want this to be your pet store. This owner is wonderful and warm and incredibly encyclopedic in her knowledge of dogs, which is my only experience because I don't own cats. The staff is also very nice to deal with and very educated on animals. Their products are great quality. Their prices are very reasonable. (Reasonable for what you're getting). I have begun looking online for the products that I buy from them because I am moving to a very isolated community. I thought maybe I would save money but by the time I pay shipping I'm not saving any money. I have been shopping at Positively Pets for six years. They have walked with me through my dog's various challenges with her becoming very elderly and frail and have been a really great resource and support. They helped me to figure out how I'm going to drive across the United States with my incontinent beloved old girl. It's been a great relationship and I will miss them. read more

Been coming here since 2005 and the selection, prices and expertise of staff is very good. Judy always knows everything there is to know about nutrition, health and recommends the best products for your "kids". She will be greatly missed. The staff at Positively Pets take pride in the shop and it definitely shows! read more

See all

Was great store until the unfortunate passing of the stores owner Judy. She built up a great business and helped many pet owners when it came to nutritional needs for there pets. read more

I don't have enough good things to say about this place. TRUST ME when I say you need to visit. "Aunt Judy" is beyond helpful. She helped us with our dog, Daisy when noone else could. The staff are VERY friendly and always helpful. If they don't know an answer which is extremely rare they find out for you. GO THERE! :) read more

Staff is very knowledgeable and helpful! Only the best brands for your pet are sold here!

I have been shopping at Positively Pets ever since the first Iams and Eukanuba scare.Which was when my Frenchbo was about 3.My Frenchbo has food allergies and Judy had recommended me try feeding her limited ingredient,foods.The prices are as low as you can get.I searched even Amazon and the food is more than here.I would recommend you try here especially if you care about your 4 legged family member. read more

I have been shopping here for quite a while now and can only say good things about the store. Supplies and quality are great. The staff is fantastic...I have never met any of them that hasn't gone above and beyond to help. Even the other customers that have been there at the same time as I have, all are friendly and we share information. Whenever there is any kind of recall or problem about a product, we will immediately get sent an e-mail and update. Love this place!!!! Lola K. read more

Amazing. Super knowledgeable staff 100% recommend. My dog is a bit picky and they gave him samples of a bunch of different foods until we found one he liked. Also, they have a buy back program where you can actually return opened bags, used toys etc. read more

Great store. I have done much reading and tons of research and Eric (and the other guy there) are extermely knowledgable in a Pet food industry that is out of control. They sell top of the line foods and if, by chance, they don't have what you need - they will order it for you. They are patient and exactly what you would want in a store owner. They have the best treats, toys etc. I recommend highly. read more

I've been ordering online where my brands Fromm's & Taste of the Wild has always been lower than the local stores including free shipping & no tax! I too, have driven by 100's of times so decided to check them out just to see what they had & if their prices were decent for being a local small business. Boy, was I pleasantly surprised! My Fromm's was actually less $ than both online stores I shop at even with tax included (both online have free shipping & one with no tax). Was I ever so happy. But they didn't carry my large breed puppy but they were willing to order it - even just one bag. Small price increase that I missed by one week but still less!! They do have a large selection of quality brands so one can not go wrong & their prices are very competitive if not lower, again pleasantly surprised! I still get my treats online or at Petsmart when they run their promotionss - but if you need any quality food related brands they will have it or can get it for you! & yes, the customer service is impeccable! very nice homey neighborly feeling. A lot of regulars go there I can tell! Highly recommend to the discerning pet owner! & it's only 5min. from home & next to Chase so I can pay for my purchases!! ) Treat your pets here, they will enjoy what you get them!! ) read more

One of the best pet stores around! The staff members are friendly and very well-versed in their product knowledge. The owner reviews all of their suppliers before passing the product on to you, to make sure that everything they sell is the best for your pets. The food selection is enormous, and the toys and treats are safe and healthy as well. Our Akita-Malamute mix is always treated well when visiting and loves to see the staff and customers. I will never use another pet store. read more

Very knowledgable people. They Have everything for a healthy pet with lots of grain free foods and prices better than Petsmart! I would highly recommend Positively Pets to anyone who loves their pet and wants the best for them! read more